Starmer to talk sense?
#21
(10-28-2024, 05:31 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 04:26 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Can someone draw me a diagram of how "raising taxes is going to prevent austerity"?

He's just made it more expensive for the working people to get to work in raising bus fares, and if you tax me more, I'm going to have less to spend and be more thrifty and frugal, thus not contributing to the economy.

It is austerity, they're just being dishonest in defining it.

Austerity is the raising of taxes and/or (emphasis on the or) cutting of spending for the purpose of reducing the deficit.

Ah, someone else has noticed then.

(10-28-2024, 07:07 PM)Everything Zin Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 04:26 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Can someone draw me a diagram of how "raising taxes is going to prevent austerity"?

He's just made it more expensive for the working people to get to work in raising bus fares, and if you tax me more, I'm going to have less to spend and be more thrifty and frugal, thus not contributing to the economy.

Starmer's just creating another economic miracle to match Brown's "elimination of boom and bust". To be fair, when he talked about growth pre-election, he never actually said what was going to grow. People assumed he meant the economy rather than tax, unemployment, business closures.....

Akin to Barry Fry's promise to take Blues out of the Championship...
Reply
#22
(10-28-2024, 05:14 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 05:03 PM)baggy1 Wrote: BB has explained to you enough times and the OBR will be spelling it out this week, the basis for the manifesto was flawed because Hunt simply lied about the black hole. They’ve got that used to lying that they think they could just keep doing it without consequence.

Yet the IFS highlighted that £19bn tax increases / spending cuts baked into the Tories published spending plans to anyone who'd listen over and over again. Neither party engaged with this at all during the election campaign - Labour were asked time after time on Radio 4 about this.

Of the Hunt Black Hole we've already done this to death FFS. I have no issue with paying £9.4bn in pay rises / back pay if you secure something in return, yet the table is bare. It's an insult to the employers you're going to lean on to be more efficient to load the public sectors' mouths with gold when productivity in the public sector has been flatlining for years (and plunging in the NHS). 

Labour will crow about the latter in an attempt to cover up their duplicity in the former. We all knew about the former (apart from you apparently) so there's no debate about it. It amply demonstrates the Manifesto was a work of fiction.

When you’ve created a situation where there is a massive shortage of Doctor’s because you’ve a) cut off the supply withdrawing freedom of movement, b) cut off the incentive by paying below market rates in a global market, and c) worsened the work environment by having a decade and a half of cuts you don’t have much room to negotiate that they do more - you’re lucky they are around to do anything. 

And if £9.4Bn is unfunded then that means that it wasn’t included in the Hunt budget, which would then make it part of this black hole you deny is there.
Reply
#23
(10-28-2024, 09:21 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 05:14 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 05:03 PM)baggy1 Wrote: BB has explained to you enough times and the OBR will be spelling it out this week, the basis for the manifesto was flawed because Hunt simply lied about the black hole. They’ve got that used to lying that they think they could just keep doing it without consequence.

Yet the IFS highlighted that £19bn tax increases / spending cuts baked into the Tories published spending plans to anyone who'd listen over and over again. Neither party engaged with this at all during the election campaign - Labour were asked time after time on Radio 4 about this.

Of the Hunt Black Hole we've already done this to death FFS. I have no issue with paying £9.4bn in pay rises / back pay if you secure something in return, yet the table is bare. It's an insult to the employers you're going to lean on to be more efficient to load the public sectors' mouths with gold when productivity in the public sector has been flatlining for years (and plunging in the NHS). 

Labour will crow about the latter in an attempt to cover up their duplicity in the former. We all knew about the former (apart from you apparently) so there's no debate about it. It amply demonstrates the Manifesto was a work of fiction.

When you’ve created a situation where there is a massive shortage of Doctor’s because you’ve a) cut off the supply withdrawing freedom of movement, b) cut off the incentive by paying below market rates in a global market, and c) worsened the work environment by having a decade and a half of cuts you don’t have much room to negotiate that they do more - you’re lucky they are around to do anything. 

And if £9.4Bn is unfunded then that means that it wasn’t included in the Hunt budget, which would then make it part of this black hole you deny is there.

Hunt refused to pay £9.4bn - that was Labour s choice.
Reply
#24
The point being that the Tories would have had to pay something as the pay rise had to happen at some level (they were offering something like 11%). This means that either £9.4bn was partially funded in Hunt’s budget, therefore it isn’t ‘unfunded’ or it is unfunded because Hunt didn’t include that in his budget, which would create a black hole (the one that doesn’t exist apparently).
Reply
#25
B1 - I will make the point one last time as it doesn’t seem to be cutting through. Labour made the choice to pay £9.4bn in wage settlements WITHOUT STRINGS. It’s not the amount of money, it’s the sheer stupidity of that act.
Reply
#26
(10-29-2024, 08:34 AM)Protheroe Wrote: B1 - I will make the point one last time as it doesn’t seem to be cutting through. Labour made the choice to pay £9.4bn in wage settlements WITHOUT STRINGS. It’s not the amount of money, it’s the sheer stupidity of that act.

Mate, you negotiate leases with upward-only rent reviews and shit break out clauses.  I'm not sure you're the one to be lecturing on how to negotiate terms... Big Grin
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#27
(10-29-2024, 08:34 AM)Protheroe Wrote: B1 - I will make the point one last time as it doesn’t seem to be cutting through. Labour made the choice to pay £9.4bn in wage settlements WITHOUT STRINGS. It’s not the amount of money, it’s the sheer stupidity of that act.

And I’ve made the point many times as well, because of the lack of doctors after years of underinvestment and worsening conditions the government were in no position to dictate terms. It’s fantasy that you think they could.
Reply
#28
(10-29-2024, 07:38 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The point being that the Tories would have had to pay something as the pay rise had to happen at some level (they were offering something like 11%). This means that either £9.4bn was partially funded in Hunt’s budget, therefore it isn’t ‘unfunded’ or it is unfunded because Hunt didn’t include that in his budget, which would create a black hole (the one that doesn’t exist apparently).

And if my Auntie had a cock she would be my Uncle.

The Tories had closed negotiations, and wanted a change in working practices. Labour rolled over. How do you think this will play out in the NHS which is in massive need of reform? As soon as the unions put pressure on Labour they will crumble again.

(10-29-2024, 09:40 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 08:34 AM)Protheroe Wrote: B1 - I will make the point one last time as it doesn’t seem to be cutting through. Labour made the choice to pay £9.4bn in wage settlements WITHOUT STRINGS. It’s not the amount of money, it’s the sheer stupidity of that act.

And I’ve made the point many times as well, because of the lack of doctors after years of underinvestment and worsening conditions the government were in no position to dictate terms. It’s fantasy that you think they could.

That's why many work 3 days for the NHS, and 3 days as Locum's IN THE SAME HOSPITAL charging 3x as much. 

This is the kind of stupidity that has to stop. Pay them more for 6 days NHS, rather than paying 3x as much to exploit the NHS.
Reply
#29
I think you’re missing the point - if it was in Hunts budget it isn’t all unfunded, and if it wasn’t it should have been as you can’t make a budget without including all upcoming expenses. If you ignore some upcoming costs then you inevitably create a black hole that doesn’t allow proper budgeting.
Reply
#30
(10-29-2024, 11:34 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I think you’re missing the point - if it was in Hunts budget it isn’t all unfunded, and if it wasn’t it should have been as you can’t make a budget without including all upcoming expenses. If you ignore some upcoming costs then you inevitably create a black hole that doesn’t allow proper budgeting.

Hunt didn't budget anything because the talks were concluded. You don't offer the solution before you negotiate it (or in Labour's case give it away). 

Where was it costed in Labour's manifesto? I don't remember a line saying we will give Train Drivers 22%, Junior Doctors 16% with no strings - and it is all fully costed.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)