Growth Watch
#91
Selective again KKC to suit your rightist agenda.
Was made wholly worse by Hunts NI election bribe, no?
Reply
#92
(10-24-2024, 03:23 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-24-2024, 03:16 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(10-24-2024, 02:40 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-24-2024, 01:50 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(10-24-2024, 09:41 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Most of the consumer related businesses that I'm dealing with are noticing a contraction in consumer demand. People are reluctant to commit to capital purchases until they have worked out what this Government means for them. The next month (Budget, BoE meeting, USA Elections) will be key in shaping the next couple of years.

Quite normal after a change in long term government and an only too real fear that someone is going to have to pay for the  recent huge events.

No, it's fear of being shafted by a Government that is going to tax the masses. We will find out next week if this is true.

We could be heading back into recession, once the tailwind of this Government catches up, the only thing to save it will be low energy prices which might keep inflation in check, leading to interest rate reductions.
Personally I think you are over-worrying. My view is they will make the first budget tough as,  A/ they have a screaming, yawning black hole to fill.....As we all know. And B/  they have 4 and a half years to then push things in what they perceive to be the right direction.  I am expecting a few things I don't like but I was fully expecting this anyway, regardless who won the election.

The "black hole" was identified by the IFS prior to the election, and was made wholly worse by the "without strings" above inflation pay settlements given to the union paymasters after the election. I'm fed up of hearing Ms Raynor answer every question at PMQs by blaming the Tories  for the last 14 years.

Good luck for the next 4.5 years.

It categorically was not. Conflating the number the IFS identified over a period of 5 years from the spring budget with respect to NI cuts with the spending gap for this year is intellectually dishonest.

The "black hole" relates to unaccounted departmental spending that had not been covered for by the last government for this year.

"But what about the fact that this appeared to be “unfunded”? It is not in the Home Office budget, a fact to which the home affairs select committee has repeatedly drawn attention. Instead, the expectation seems to have been that the cost would be covered from the Treasury “reserve” — the contingency left over from departmental allocations intended to cover unexpected and urgent demands. That is broadly where the money came from last year. Not that it should have done. Largely predictable costs like this should appear in departmental budgets. My guess is that the last government did not want them in the Home Office budget because that would have increased the spending “baseline” for future settlements, pushing up the Office for Budget Responsibility’s spending forecasts and making it even harder to claim to be staying within the fiscal rules.

Now this is where I do have sympathy for the new chancellor. Although the asylum bill was largely predictable, what wasn’t clear from the outside was that the reserve had already in effect been spent on a veritable hotchpotch of demands including support for the Northern Ireland executive, paying for various outrageously expensive public inquiries, and additional costs of running the railways. What was also not apparent from the outside was that a number of new initiatives announced by the Conservatives were in effect unfunded within departmental budgets."

From the horses mouth, Paul Johnson's article in the Times related to the "black hole". You can argue whether it's "truly" £22bn or actually £13bn but to say that the IFS were warning about it is false as they were on about something else entirely.
Reply
#93
The IFS was on about £19bn in spending cuts or tax rises baked into spending plans. They also laughed at Labour's claims of a "£22bn" black hole as much of that was entirely predictable (like above inflation pay rises to the public sector).
Reply
#94
(10-24-2024, 04:23 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Selective again KKC to suit your rightist agenda.
Was made wholly worse by Hunts NI election bribe, no?

Not selective at all. 

Labour should have put reversal of the NI bribe (which is what is was) into their manifesto. They would have still have won, and it would have given them a start in the game, rather than having to dance around their handbags on this "no tax increases for working people" rubbish, which wasn't deliverable by any party.

We now have FGK trying to define what is and what isn't a working person. Those who have saved all their lives to provide for their later years aren't working people, apparently.
Reply
#95
David Blunkett:

“If the government decides to increase employer national insurance contributions (NICs) it needs to be upfront about the fact that that this will impact working people, not just businesses. Creating a bigger NICs bill for employers could lead them to hire fewer people, limit pay rises, or even pay less pension contributions."
Reply
#96
(10-25-2024, 10:49 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-24-2024, 04:23 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Selective again KKC to suit your rightist agenda.
Was made wholly worse by Hunts NI election bribe, no?

Not selective at all. 

Labour should have put reversal of the NI bribe (which is what is was) into their manifesto. They would have still have won, and it would have given them a start in the game, rather than having to dance around their handbags on this "no tax increases for working people" rubbish, which wasn't deliverable by any party.

We now have FGK trying to define what is and what isn't a working person. Those who have saved all their lives to provide for their later years aren't working people, apparently.

So you admit Labour are having to clear up Hunts NI mess plus all the other shit from the last 14 years
Reply
#97
(10-25-2024, 01:01 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: So you admit Labour are having to clear up Hunts NI mess plus all the other shit from the last 14 years

The successive NI cut(s) were a Bear Trap for Labour. They should be reversed. In doing so you'd bring in almost all you need without introducing growth killing distortions and behavioural change to business and capital taxes. 

I hope I'm not right, but personally I expect to be fucked over completely next week. The minor saving grace may well be that changes won't take effect until next April, but I wouldn't put it past Labour to make immediate changes that would wreck investment plans made over years.
Reply
#98
It's been explained to you many times but by rising to the bait of Hunt and the shapeshifters it would have cost votes, and with the largest wafer thin majority ever could have cost Starmer dearly. We all know it was a piss take by Hunt but what choice dod Starmer have as every move he makes evokes a pavlov's dog reaction from your ilk of 'they will tax us to the hilt - run to the hills'
Reply
#99
What are they about to do FFS?

The utter stupidity of excluding the taxes that generate 75% of revenue from any RATE alteration means Labour can only to concentrate on the other 25% of taxes or mealy mouthed stealth fiscal drag and allowance alterations.

These other taxes are broadly more difficult to collect, easier to distort on the downside and will in all likelihood lead to substantial and enduring downside behavioral change. You only have to look at what's been announced so far - VAT on private schools will raise next to nothing in the medium term due to schools claiming relief on up to 10 years' worth of capital spend - it may even end up costing the Treasury.

Hopefully the Carried Interest and extension of the Tories daft Non Dom policies have already been dropped (fingers crossed), but the damage that could be done by NI on Employers Pension Contributions can't be overstated - every sentient commentator agrees that it's simply a tax on jobs and / or future wages, and for those engaged in salary sacrifice it'll simply be a direct income tax increase as firms withdraw the benefit. For people like me it'll wholly alter how I remunerate myself to mitigate the worst effects.

Like all the cretins after Lawson Reeves shows no intent to reform or simplify taxation - simply to increase the girth of the tax code once again leaving a trail of entirely foreseen consequences in her trail. And no big ideas on taxation measures like LVT that would not only raise money, but also give a huge boost to growth.

We have a cabinet comprised of second rate provincial local government officers in thrall to the civil service. The last time the civil service was in charge of the Budget was George Osborne's "Omnishambles" - Pasty Tax? Caravan Tax?
Reply
So you're suggesting that they should have either have risked losing the election because people like yourself would have screamed 'Usual Labour - taxing us til the pips squeak', or won the election on a difficult pledge and then gone back on it immediately for people like you to scream 'same old Labour - taxing us til the pips squeak, they lied to us'.

It really is people like you that have created this mess.

And the real question is 'What could they possibly do?', your own statement say that we are fucked either way. I'm not getting too hysterical at the 1st bend on a long journey.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)