Israel
It rather depends what prism you choose to view the world through.
Reply
The realistic one rather than the “you’re nasty for telling the truth” one
Reply
I'm sure that'll come as great comfort to my Jewish friends.
Reply
(10-22-2024, 07:48 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Sobbing about the reality of Israel’s global image, and the consequences of that, won’t make it any less true fellas. What I or you believe has no relationship with that being the truth.

The truth is that no intervention will happen until after the American election. Too many American-Jewish votes at stake in a knifedge election
Reply
(10-22-2024, 10:20 AM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm sure that'll come as great comfort to my Jewish friends.

No doubt it won’t be. The original point (before you turned it into something it never was) was exactly about them suffering for actions that are (mis)represented in their name and image. It’s not good and it’s not the way it should be, but it’s the reality.
Reply
(10-21-2024, 07:50 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Lebanon like Syria has done a pretty good job of destroying itself over the last 50 years.

(10-21-2024, 07:45 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(10-21-2024, 07:04 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-21-2024, 06:31 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: When you listen to the arrogance and superiority complex of the Israeli politicians, it’s impossible not to conclude it likely that many ordinary Israelis will find in the coming years they have few places that they find welcoming or understanding in the wider world. It’s a huge process of isolation they are being subjected to, probably without fully understanding it.

Do you really judge a nations' people by the behaviour of its leaders? Or is it just the Jooz?

What a nasty comment.

Ahhh the old anti semitism bollocks for those genocide lovers to trot out. Yawn. You not got at least a second like of piffle to trot out. Please try harder.

OK. Get all your dirty washing out then. Which other countries inhabitants do you judge by their leaders?

Spitting Image had this little ditty back in the 80s:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9dmoT9A...nTheTosser

Much of the world will view Israelis in the same way that they viewed white South Africans: as racist upholders of an apartheid state. It is no coincidence that South Africa has led the ICJ case against Israel. Just look at the "democratically elected" Israeli politicians on show here: https://www.channel4.com/news/hardline-i...gaza-strip
Reply
Did YOU view white South Africans in the UK "as racist upholders of an apartheid state"? Do YOU view Israelis in the UK "as racist upholders of an apartheid state"?

There's a pretty thick line here which I think some are in danger of crossing.

If "people" can apply these sorts of tropes to South Africans or Israelis resident in the UK, how can they then complain about "people" applying tropes to other ethnic groups or nationalities in the UK? What a slippery slope that is.
Reply
You’re still struggling to stop changing the original point. So I’ll pop it below for you again.

People shouldn’t end up holding or espousing those views. But they do.

You don’t half flit between a tough world view and a sugar coated one when it suits whatever the Proth narrative of the day is.
Reply
(10-22-2024, 10:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Did YOU view white South Africans in the UK "as racist upholders of an apartheid state"? Do YOU view Israelis in the UK "as racist upholders of an apartheid state"?

There's a pretty thick line here which I think some are in danger of crossing.

If "people" can apply these sorts of tropes to South Africans or Israelis resident in the UK, how can they then complain about "people" applying tropes to other ethnic groups or nationalities in the UK? What a slippery slope that is.

Why now have you changed things to focus on people in the UK? One hundred people killed in Gaza and Lebanon in past 24 hours, but the real victims here are Proth's friends.

Israel is a state which to many people in the world is clearly committing genocide, with the open approval of the majority of the politicians, media and public. We know Not All Israelis (for example the new clip I linked took pains to point out that there was a protest outside the meeting by families), just like Not All White South Africans (even the song pointed out Breyten Breytenbach), but the fact is that Israel will now be viewed as a pariah state by many.
Reply
(10-22-2024, 11:14 AM)Squid Wrote:
(10-22-2024, 10:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Did YOU view white South Africans in the UK "as racist upholders of an apartheid state"?  Do YOU view Israelis in the UK "as racist upholders of an apartheid state"?

There's a pretty thick line here which I think some are in danger of crossing. 

If "people" can apply these sorts of tropes to South Africans or Israelis resident in the UK, how can they then complain about "people" applying tropes to other ethnic groups or nationalities in the UK? What a slippery slope that is.

Why now have you changed things to focus on people in the UK? One hundred people killed in Gaza and Lebanon in past 24 hours, but the real victims here are Proth's friends.

Israel is a state which to many people in the world is clearly committing genocide, with the open approval of the majority of the politicians, media and public. We know Not All Israelis (for example the new clip I linked took pains to point out that there was a protest outside the meeting by families), just like Not All White South Africans (even the song pointed out Breyten Breytenbach), but the fact is that Israel will now be viewed as a pariah state by many.

That is what I am responding to:

"When you listen to the arrogance and superiority complex of the Israeli politicians, it’s impossible not to conclude it likely that many ordinary Israelis will find in the coming years they have few places that they find welcoming or understanding in the wider world. It’s a huge process of isolation they are being subjected to, probably without fully understanding it."

And you haven't answered my questions either.

(10-22-2024, 10:59 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: People shouldn’t end up holding or espousing those views. But they do.

WHO does? Come on spit it out?

Because you're both claiming that you don't / won't. So who does? Who are "they"?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)