£40bn Taxes & Spending Cuts in the Budget
#41
(10-17-2024, 02:20 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 01:39 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 01:29 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 12:05 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: At least I work in the public sector. So if I am going to be fucked, at least there might be some lube.

Biggest impact on the public sector will be if Labour cuts the tax free lump sum you can take from your pension.

As DB pensions are far more generous than private sector DC schemes there will be a vast amount of public sector workers approaching pensionable age looking to use their tax free lump sum to pay off their mortgage or other debts. If Labour reduces the lump sum they're able to take I'm not sure there'll be enough lube to go round.

And as usual, it looks like existing pensioners will come out of the budget scot free.

I think they are likely to reduce the ceiling rather than the percentage, Proth. 

There is a fair argument that if your contributions are tax free, then why should your withdrawal be tax free? It's a brave woman that does it, though. Labour could go down as the Government that fucked over the Uk's retired working classes.

Well it's not like they haven't got form from their last term in office fucking over pension funds is it?

You're right, it would be brave woman to screw with plans that individuals and families have made over decades - but I doubt they even consider the very real consequences.

Labour - the party that has fucked the working people who vote for them.
Reply
#42
(10-17-2024, 09:56 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 08:46 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No it wasn't, the OBR have already confirmed that it wasn't and they're the ultimate authority on that. The spending deficit within the fiscal rules (known) and the black hole for this year (not known) are not the same thing.

The "Black Hole" for this year - much of it completely predictable (like above inflation rises for NHS Staff) is a convenient distraction from the fact that the Tories ludicrous spending plans ALWAYS relied on either exceptionally deep cuts, huge tax rises or more borrowing - or most likely a combination of all three.

Anyone with aspirations to enter government would've known this, and it's plainly barking to suggest otherwise.

Like I said earlier - with Labour having take the cowards way in ruling out increases to taxes that actually raise money they're going to rely on creating all sorts of distortions in CGT, Employers NI and I dare say other areas that will simply drive behavioural change to the extent that "working people" will end up pay the cost anyway. They deserve all the brickbats that will come their way.  

If they're not careful on Employers NI they'll create huge disincentives for pension saving for both employer and employee. After Brown's assault on pensions to the long term detriment of everyone all those years ago you'd have thought Labour may have learned; clearly not. They're promising to be as fuckwitted with money as every other Labour government in history.

Or they weren't considering any of their responsibilities and were just throwing any shit at the wall in the hope it would stick and save their jobs.

Labour backed themselves in a corner on not doing away with the stupid, unfunded Tory tax cuts but that's the game they had to play. The NI cut was quite clearly done to trap Labour so they could create a scare story, I know this because on the final week of polling in my constituency I was speaking to people I'd canvassed who said they might vote Lib Dem and 90% of them said they were voting Tory now because they were shit scared of Labour taxing them to the hill and back as the Telegraph was saying they would and they didn't believe the Tories would do that. The fact is despite everything they only squeaked a third of the vote and were heavily reliant on tactical voting which includes a lot of middle class professionals who would have been put off from a more honest manifesto. And being a member of a party that broke one of it's key pledges on tuition fees and suffered immensely as a result despite the compromise being basically what said party had wanted with a de-facto graduate tax I think it's perfectly understandable why Labour are extremely reluctant to reverse the NICs cut (or up income tax by the 2%, which would be fairer and raise more money) even if it's the "right" thing to do.
Reply
#43
(10-17-2024, 01:39 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 01:29 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 12:05 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: At least I work in the public sector. So if I am going to be fucked, at least there might be some lube.

Biggest impact on the public sector will be if Labour cuts the tax free lump sum you can take from your pension.

As DB pensions are far more generous than private sector DC schemes there will be a vast amount of public sector workers approaching pensionable age looking to use their tax free lump sum to pay off their mortgage or other debts. If Labour reduces the lump sum they're able to take I'm not sure there'll be enough lube to go round.

And as usual, it looks like existing pensioners will come out of the budget scot free.

I think they are likely to reduce the ceiling rather than the percentage, Proth. 

There is a fair argument that if your contributions are tax free, then why should your withdrawal be tax free? It's a brave woman that does it, though. Labour could go down as the Government that fucked over the Uk's retired working classes.

Withdrawal  isn't tax free though, is it? I've got a pension paying out now and I'm taxed on both that and my wage. I pay into a SIPP which is tax incentivised but when I withdraw  it it will be taxed.
Reply
#44
(10-17-2024, 03:23 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 01:39 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 01:29 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 12:05 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: At least I work in the public sector. So if I am going to be fucked, at least there might be some lube.

Biggest impact on the public sector will be if Labour cuts the tax free lump sum you can take from your pension.

As DB pensions are far more generous than private sector DC schemes there will be a vast amount of public sector workers approaching pensionable age looking to use their tax free lump sum to pay off their mortgage or other debts. If Labour reduces the lump sum they're able to take I'm not sure there'll be enough lube to go round.

And as usual, it looks like existing pensioners will come out of the budget scot free.

I think they are likely to reduce the ceiling rather than the percentage, Proth. 

There is a fair argument that if your contributions are tax free, then why should your withdrawal be tax free? It's a brave woman that does it, though. Labour could go down as the Government that fucked over the Uk's retired working classes.

Withdrawal  isn't tax free though, is it? I've got a pension paying out now and I'm taxed on both that and my wage. I pay into a SIPP which is tax incentivised but when I withdraw  it it will be taxed.

You can take out up to 25% or £270k from your pension pot tax free at 55 (57 from April 2028).
Reply
#45
(10-17-2024, 03:30 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 03:23 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 01:39 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 01:29 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 12:05 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: At least I work in the public sector. So if I am going to be fucked, at least there might be some lube.

Biggest impact on the public sector will be if Labour cuts the tax free lump sum you can take from your pension.

As DB pensions are far more generous than private sector DC schemes there will be a vast amount of public sector workers approaching pensionable age looking to use their tax free lump sum to pay off their mortgage or other debts. If Labour reduces the lump sum they're able to take I'm not sure there'll be enough lube to go round.

And as usual, it looks like existing pensioners will come out of the budget scot free.

I think they are likely to reduce the ceiling rather than the percentage, Proth. 

There is a fair argument that if your contributions are tax free, then why should your withdrawal be tax free? It's a brave woman that does it, though. Labour could go down as the Government that fucked over the Uk's retired working classes.

Withdrawal  isn't tax free though, is it? I've got a pension paying out now and I'm taxed on both that and my wage. I pay into a SIPP which is tax incentivised but when I withdraw  it it will be taxed.

You can take out up to 25% or £270k from your pension pot tax free at 55 (57 from April 2028).

Remarkably, that's the point I agree with you on!
Reply
#46
(10-17-2024, 03:22 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 09:56 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 08:46 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No it wasn't, the OBR have already confirmed that it wasn't and they're the ultimate authority on that. The spending deficit within the fiscal rules (known) and the black hole for this year (not known) are not the same thing.

The "Black Hole" for this year - much of it completely predictable (like above inflation rises for NHS Staff) is a convenient distraction from the fact that the Tories ludicrous spending plans ALWAYS relied on either exceptionally deep cuts, huge tax rises or more borrowing - or most likely a combination of all three.

Anyone with aspirations to enter government would've known this, and it's plainly barking to suggest otherwise.

Like I said earlier - with Labour having take the cowards way in ruling out increases to taxes that actually raise money they're going to rely on creating all sorts of distortions in CGT, Employers NI and I dare say other areas that will simply drive behavioural change to the extent that "working people" will end up pay the cost anyway. They deserve all the brickbats that will come their way.  

If they're not careful on Employers NI they'll create huge disincentives for pension saving for both employer and employee. After Brown's assault on pensions to the long term detriment of everyone all those years ago you'd have thought Labour may have learned; clearly not. They're promising to be as fuckwitted with money as every other Labour government in history.

Or they weren't considering any of their responsibilities and were just throwing any shit at the wall in the hope it would stick and save their jobs.

Labour backed themselves in a corner on not doing away with the stupid, unfunded Tory tax cuts but that's the game they had to play. The NI cut was quite clearly done to trap Labour so they could create a scare story, I know this because on the final week of polling in my constituency I was speaking to people I'd canvassed who said they might vote Lib Dem and 90% of them said they were voting Tory now because they were shit scared of Labour taxing them to the hill and back as the Telegraph was saying they would and they didn't believe the Tories would do that. The fact is despite everything they only squeaked a third of the vote and were heavily reliant on tactical voting which includes a lot of middle class professionals who would have been put off from a more honest manifesto. And being a member of a party that broke one of it's key pledges on tuition fees and suffered immensely as a result despite the compromise being basically what said party had wanted with a de-facto graduate tax I think it's perfectly understandable why Labour are extremely reluctant to reverse the NICs cut (or up income tax by the 2%, which would be fairer and raise more money) even if it's the "right" thing to do.

Of course the Tories weren't considering any of their responsibilities.

A responsible Labour Party would've pointed out the £19bn in spending cuts that were baked into Tory plans. They didn't, in fact they refused to recognise the issue when repeatedly pressed which makes them just as bad as the Tories in pulling the wool over the eyes of the electorate.

As it is they're about to ride a coach and horses through their "fully costed" manifesto. That's not opinion. That's fact. 

And as for the policy prescriptions, the PwC Tax Accountant I was out with last night told me they've been working on behavioral wargaming since May.
Reply
#47
(10-17-2024, 04:36 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 03:22 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 09:56 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 08:46 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No it wasn't, the OBR have already confirmed that it wasn't and they're the ultimate authority on that. The spending deficit within the fiscal rules (known) and the black hole for this year (not known) are not the same thing.

The "Black Hole" for this year - much of it completely predictable (like above inflation rises for NHS Staff) is a convenient distraction from the fact that the Tories ludicrous spending plans ALWAYS relied on either exceptionally deep cuts, huge tax rises or more borrowing - or most likely a combination of all three.

Anyone with aspirations to enter government would've known this, and it's plainly barking to suggest otherwise.

Like I said earlier - with Labour having take the cowards way in ruling out increases to taxes that actually raise money they're going to rely on creating all sorts of distortions in CGT, Employers NI and I dare say other areas that will simply drive behavioural change to the extent that "working people" will end up pay the cost anyway. They deserve all the brickbats that will come their way.  

If they're not careful on Employers NI they'll create huge disincentives for pension saving for both employer and employee. After Brown's assault on pensions to the long term detriment of everyone all those years ago you'd have thought Labour may have learned; clearly not. They're promising to be as fuckwitted with money as every other Labour government in history.

Or they weren't considering any of their responsibilities and were just throwing any shit at the wall in the hope it would stick and save their jobs.

Labour backed themselves in a corner on not doing away with the stupid, unfunded Tory tax cuts but that's the game they had to play. The NI cut was quite clearly done to trap Labour so they could create a scare story, I know this because on the final week of polling in my constituency I was speaking to people I'd canvassed who said they might vote Lib Dem and 90% of them said they were voting Tory now because they were shit scared of Labour taxing them to the hill and back as the Telegraph was saying they would and they didn't believe the Tories would do that. The fact is despite everything they only squeaked a third of the vote and were heavily reliant on tactical voting which includes a lot of middle class professionals who would have been put off from a more honest manifesto. And being a member of a party that broke one of it's key pledges on tuition fees and suffered immensely as a result despite the compromise being basically what said party had wanted with a de-facto graduate tax I think it's perfectly understandable why Labour are extremely reluctant to reverse the NICs cut (or up income tax by the 2%, which would be fairer and raise more money) even if it's the "right" thing to do.

Of course the Tories weren't considering any of their responsibilities.

A responsible Labour Party would've pointed out the £19bn in spending cuts that were baked into Tory plans. They didn't, in fact they refused to recognise the issue when repeatedly pressed which makes them just as bad as the Tories in pulling the wool over the eyes of the electorate.

As it is they're about to ride a coach and horses through their "fully costed" manifesto. That's not opinion. That's fact. 

And as for the policy prescriptions, the PwC Tax Accountant I was out with last night told me they've been working on behavioral wargaming since May.

Because if it wasn't presented as "fully costed" the Tory client press (Telegraph, Mail, Spectator etc) would have hammered them on it as they've done in the past because that is what they always do. A responsible Labour party doesn't win elections anymore, that's the crux of the matter. They put through the most bland, milquetoast and shallow manifesto ever and only scraped a third of the vote because they knew that if they were more aggressive then the soft underbelly propping them up would collapse. And now they know - based on precedent - that if they do the "right thing" and reverse the NICs cut or up income tax by 2% then they are fucked for having broken a promise very early on (see: the Lib Dems and tuition fees, doing the "right thing" killed the party off for a decade).
Reply
#48
(10-17-2024, 01:29 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 12:05 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: At least I work in the public sector. So if I am going to be fucked, at least there might be some lube.

Biggest impact on the public sector will be if Labour cuts the tax free lump sum you can take from your pension.

As DB pensions are far more generous than private sector DC schemes there will be a vast amount of public sector workers approaching pensionable age looking to use their tax free lump sum to pay off their mortgage or other debts. If Labour reduces the lump sum they're able to take I'm not sure there'll be enough lube to go round.

And as usual, it looks like existing pensioners will come out of the budget scot free.

You can't have it both ways. Last week you were bemoaning the pensioner's loss of WFA. Now you are complaining they are getting away with something Scot Free.  Just stop stirring, you Moaning Minnie.
Reply
#49
(10-17-2024, 06:35 PM)Baggybenny Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 01:29 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-17-2024, 12:05 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: At least I work in the public sector. So if I am going to be fucked, at least there might be some lube.

Biggest impact on the public sector will be if Labour cuts the tax free lump sum you can take from your pension.

As DB pensions are far more generous than private sector DC schemes there will be a vast amount of public sector workers approaching pensionable age looking to use their tax free lump sum to pay off their mortgage or other debts. If Labour reduces the lump sum they're able to take I'm not sure there'll be enough lube to go round.

And as usual, it looks like existing pensioners will come out of the budget scot free.

You can't have it both ways. Last week you were bemoaning the pensioner's loss of WFA. Now you are complaining they are getting away with something Scot Free.  Just stop stirring, you Moaning Minnie.

Me bemoan the loss of the WFA? I think you must be confusing me with someone else. The WFA is the least of what should be lost by more affluent pensioners.
Reply
#50
Strong rumours that more FTBs will be dragged into paying Stamp Duty as Labour refuses to extend the Tories increase in thresholds , another stupid tax which simply distorts an already horribly distorted market. Expect another spike in house prices as buyers race to complete.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)