Trump
The reason why people have voted Tory is because of a lack of credible alternative.

Republicans have the same issue. They won't vote Dem, but can't vote Trump
Reply
(10-14-2024, 09:13 AM)Mr Nimbus Wrote:
(10-14-2024, 08:46 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: I’ve been trying to get my head around how decent people can vote for Trump. My only conclusion is an extremely liberal Democratic Party are seen by some as more repulsive.
If you are conservative by nature, accepting change slowly the anything goes attitude of liberalism without stigma can appear seedy I guess.
After all we live in an era where homosexuality is very much publicised on TV and there is a very open and highly publicised debate on gender ideology that appears to get too much airplay and is seen as extremely strange to many people.
I guess that mixed in with a fear of mass immigration is a pretty good stick to beat liberal values with.
I’d like to say I’m only guessing. Those aren’t my views being quite liberal myself.

Interesting point made on a pod yesterday.

"One of the biggest problems that Labour strategists have is that they just can't understand why anyone would vote Tory in the first place"

Same rules apply I guess.  Baffling to me and thee but of course which is why we can only presume it's because these people are a combination of misogynistic, xenophobic and racist, and generally not too bright.  

But it cant be that simple?
Half of America = Good
Half = Bad. 

Its just so much seems counterintuitive.  I mean the link between Trump and Fundamentalist Christian's ffs, how do they square that circle.
The problem is if you label people racist or xenophobic etc straight away you've lost the footing to debate.

Throwing around those words just gets people's backs up.

Here's an example. I live by some nice lakes in Warwickshire. In recent years there's been more undesirables around the lakes such as East European poachers and, predominantly Asian, young lads who have been seen doing drug deals and driving around menacingly in very expensive sports cars. We now see police patrolling more as the issue has got so bad.

Last week I spoke to a neighbour who's parents live by these lakes. The parents are moving as they don't feel safe any more.

I don't like seeing these shifty people around there. Does that make me racist? I think not. I just don't like crooks and criminals regardless of colour.

Equally if you are in a neighbourhood that has completely changed due to a huge influx of immigration and you miss how it used to be does that make you racist?

I'm not so sure. I think the inability to debate these differences and the issues and just shouting names are driving people to the likes of Farage.

It's worrying times as we can't seem to have level headed discussions any more.

As I've said. I'm playing devil's advocate. I just happen to know people more angry and intolerant of change who have voiced this. Some of these are very decent people just fed up as they feel things have changed for the worse.
Reply
(10-14-2024, 08:58 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(10-14-2024, 06:26 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: At least they arrested this guy before he could get anywhere near Trump.
You sound disappointed. The sooner Trump is off the scene the better for all.

Putin should be first.
Reply
(10-14-2024, 09:59 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(10-14-2024, 09:13 AM)Mr Nimbus Wrote:
(10-14-2024, 08:46 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: I’ve been trying to get my head around how decent people can vote for Trump. My only conclusion is an extremely liberal Democratic Party are seen by some as more repulsive.
If you are conservative by nature, accepting change slowly the anything goes attitude of liberalism without stigma can appear seedy I guess.
After all we live in an era where homosexuality is very much publicised on TV and there is a very open and highly publicised debate on gender ideology that appears to get too much airplay and is seen as extremely strange to many people.
I guess that mixed in with a fear of mass immigration is a pretty good stick to beat liberal values with.
I’d like to say I’m only guessing. Those aren’t my views being quite liberal myself.

Interesting point made on a pod yesterday.

"One of the biggest problems that Labour strategists have is that they just can't understand why anyone would vote Tory in the first place"

Same rules apply I guess.  Baffling to me and thee but of course which is why we can only presume it's because these people are a combination of misogynistic, xenophobic and racist, and generally not too bright.  

But it cant be that simple?
Half of America = Good
Half = Bad. 

Its just so much seems counterintuitive.  I mean the link between Trump and Fundamentalist Christian's ffs, how do they square that circle.
The problem is if you label people racist or xenophobic etc straight away you've lost the footing to debate.

Throwing around those words just gets people's backs up.

Here's an example. I live by some nice lakes in Warwickshire. In recent years there's been more undesirables around the lakes such as East European poachers and, predominantly Asian, young lads who have been seen doing drug deals and driving around menacingly in very expensive sports cars. We now see police patrolling more as the issue has got so bad.

Last week I spoke to a neighbour who's parents live by these lakes. The parents are moving as they don't feel safe any more.

I don't like seeing these shifty people around there. Does that make me racist? I think not. I just don't like crooks and criminals regardless of colour.

Equally if you are in a neighbourhood that has completely changed due to a huge influx of immigration and you miss how it used to be does that make you racist?

I'm not so sure. I think the inability to debate these differences and the issues and just shouting names are driving people to the likes of Farage.

It's worrying times as we can't seem to have level headed discussions any more.

As I've said. I'm playing devil's advocate. I just happen to know people more angry and intolerant of change who have voiced this. Some of these are very decent people just fed up as they feel things have changed for the worse.

What a load of complete and utter common sense.
Reply
(10-14-2024, 08:46 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: I’ve been trying to get my head around how decent people can vote for Trump. My only conclusion is an extremely liberal Democratic Party are seen by some as more repulsive.
If you are conservative by nature, accepting change slowly the anything goes attitude of liberalism without stigma can appear seedy I guess.
After all we live in an era where homosexuality is very much publicised on TV and there is a very open and highly publicised debate on gender ideology that appears to get too much airplay and is seen as extremely strange to many people.
I guess that mixed in with a fear of mass immigration is a pretty good stick to beat liberal values with.
I’d like to say I’m only guessing. Those aren’t my views being quite liberal myself.

Amongst all the disgraceful fear-mongering that he uses, this statement should lead any sane person to immediately rule him out of obtaining any high office.

'You'll send your son to school and he'll come back as a girl'. 

 How on earth he can still be a strong candidate for the presidency after coming out with unadulterated garbage like that is beyond me. But then, I did spend some time in Iowa, way back and an awful lot of the people looked as if they'd walked off the set of 'Deliverance', so I shouldn't really be surprised.
Reply
(10-14-2024, 10:18 AM)Tiptonmon Wrote:
(10-14-2024, 08:46 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: I’ve been trying to get my head around how decent people can vote for Trump. My only conclusion is an extremely liberal Democratic Party are seen by some as more repulsive.
If you are conservative by nature, accepting change slowly the anything goes attitude of liberalism without stigma can appear seedy I guess.
After all we live in an era where homosexuality is very much publicised on TV and there is a very open and highly publicised debate on gender ideology that appears to get too much airplay and is seen as extremely strange to many people.
I guess that mixed in with a fear of mass immigration is a pretty good stick to beat liberal values with.
I’d like to say I’m only guessing. Those aren’t my views being quite liberal myself.

Amongst all the disgraceful fear-mongering that he uses, this statement should lead any sane person to immediately rule him out of obtaining any high office.

'You'll send your son to school and he'll come back as a girl'. 

 How on earth he can still be a strong candidate for the presidency after coming out with unadulterated garbage like that is beyond me. But then, I did spend some time in Iowa, way back and an awful lot of the people looked as if they'd walked off the set of 'Deliverance', so I shouldn't really be surprised.

It's the pigs around there that get my sympathy.
Reply
(10-14-2024, 08:46 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: I’ve been trying to get my head around how decent people can vote for Trump. My only conclusion is an extremely liberal Democratic Party are seen by some as more repulsive.
If you are conservative by nature, accepting change slowly the anything goes attitude of liberalism without stigma can appear seedy I guess.
After all we live in an era where homosexuality is very much publicised on TV and there is a very open and highly publicised debate on gender ideology that appears to get too much airplay and is seen as extremely strange to many people.
I guess that mixed in with a fear of mass immigration is a pretty good stick to beat liberal values with.
I’d like to say I’m only guessing. Those aren’t my views being quite liberal myself.

I've a lot of family in the states, typically card carrying democrats, but some are either not voting or voting trump, 4 reasons

1) inflation, "gas" prices have gone up by about 50% I was paying $3.00 - $3.50 when I was there in the summer, I had for years been paying $2.00 - $2.50.  FWIW worth the price of a pint has increased from the $5 - $7 I was paying to $8 - $9.00
2) immigration, running at about 3M a year "undocumented " under Biden, that's the equivalent of about 500k people arriving on small boats here. People have been losing their minds here over 50k per annum in small boats, imagine if it was 10 times that number.  In Northern, Coastal, and Mid-west "sanctuary" states and cities it's now having an impact.
3) Police reform act, post George Floyd.  Objective to make the police "more accountable" but the Dems have effectively lost the Police
4 ) Afghan withdrawal, dead soldiers and billions worth of kit left behind.  The Dems never really banked on the military but they have lost them completely.

If you've lost the Police and the military, illegal immigration is considered to be out of control and gas prices have risen by >50% frankly you hope and pray you're opposition is a lunatic like Donald Trump.  If the Dems were fighting literally anyone else they would get crushed in the election.  As it happens the Dems got lucky, they could have been up against Nikki Haley, and its just too close to call.
Reply
(10-14-2024, 09:59 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(10-14-2024, 09:13 AM)Mr Nimbus Wrote:
(10-14-2024, 08:46 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: I’ve been trying to get my head around how decent people can vote for Trump. My only conclusion is an extremely liberal Democratic Party are seen by some as more repulsive.
If you are conservative by nature, accepting change slowly the anything goes attitude of liberalism without stigma can appear seedy I guess.
After all we live in an era where homosexuality is very much publicised on TV and there is a very open and highly publicised debate on gender ideology that appears to get too much airplay and is seen as extremely strange to many people.
I guess that mixed in with a fear of mass immigration is a pretty good stick to beat liberal values with.
I’d like to say I’m only guessing. Those aren’t my views being quite liberal myself.

Interesting point made on a pod yesterday.

"One of the biggest problems that Labour strategists have is that they just can't understand why anyone would vote Tory in the first place"

Same rules apply I guess.  Baffling to me and thee but of course which is why we can only presume it's because these people are a combination of misogynistic, xenophobic and racist, and generally not too bright.  

But it cant be that simple?
Half of America = Good
Half = Bad. 

Its just so much seems counterintuitive.  I mean the link between Trump and Fundamentalist Christian's ffs, how do they square that circle.
The problem is if you label people racist or xenophobic etc straight away you've lost the footing to debate.

Throwing around those words just gets people's backs up.

Here's an example. I live by some nice lakes in Warwickshire. In recent years there's been more undesirables around the lakes such as East European poachers and, predominantly Asian, young lads who have been seen doing drug deals and driving around menacingly in very expensive sports cars. We now see police patrolling more as the issue has got so bad.

Last week I spoke to a neighbour who's parents live by these lakes. The parents are moving as they don't feel safe any more.

I don't like seeing these shifty people around there. Does that make me racist? I think not. I just don't like crooks and criminals regardless of colour.

Equally if you are in a neighbourhood that has completely changed due to a huge influx of immigration and you miss how it used to be does that make you racist?

I'm not so sure. I think the inability to debate these differences and the issues and just shouting names are driving people to the likes of Farage.

It's worrying times as we can't seem to have level headed discussions any more.

As I've said. I'm playing d?evil's advocate. I just happen to know people more angry and intolerant of change who have voiced this. Some of these are very decent people just fed up as they feel things have changed for the worse.

I think that's the point I was trying to make, badly?

Because we have no understanding, we cannot empathise, and have to resort to these words for explanation.  

When you provide some context it does help.  As in the UK, there is a demographic who want their world to stay the same, if not return to some halcyon day.   This isn't possible, the change has allready happened, but snake oil salesmen like Trump and Farage will tell you a little dab of what they are selling will put it all right again.  They are selling time travel.

Unfortunately there is no doubt that both of these men ARE also misogynistic, racist and xenophobic (as well as being priviledged) so by association we conclude the same of their voters. Even though we know it's much more complex.

And even more unfortunately for their supporters these rich, privileged, narcissistic men genuinely couldnt give a fuck about their voters, they just love power and money.  It's to feed their fragile egos and fill their pockets.

Americans need to try and vote on a reality ticket, rather than the brutal fantasy trump is promising.  These are interesting times.
Reply
(10-14-2024, 10:27 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote:
(10-14-2024, 08:46 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: I’ve been trying to get my head around how decent people can vote for Trump. My only conclusion is an extremely liberal Democratic Party are seen by some as more repulsive.
If you are conservative by nature, accepting change slowly the anything goes attitude of liberalism without stigma can appear seedy I guess.
After all we live in an era where homosexuality is very much publicised on TV and there is a very open and highly publicised debate on gender ideology that appears to get too much airplay and is seen as extremely strange to many people.
I guess that mixed in with a fear of mass immigration is a pretty good stick to beat liberal values with.
I’d like to say I’m only guessing. Those aren’t my views being quite liberal myself.

I've a lot of family in the states, typically card carrying democrats, but some are either not voting or voting trump, 4 reasons

1) inflation, "gas" prices have gone up by about 50% I was paying $3.00 - $3.50 when I was there in the summer, I had for years been paying $2.00 - $2.50.  FWIW worth the price of a pint has increased from the $5 - $7 I was paying to $8 - $9.00
2) immigration, running at about 3M a year "undocumented " under Biden, that's the equivalent of about 500k people arriving on small boats here. People have been losing their minds here over 50k per annum in small boats, imagine if it was 10 times that number.  In Northern, Coastal, and Mid-west "sanctuary" states and cities it's now having an impact.
3) Police reform act, post George Floyd.  Objective to make the police "more accountable" but the Dems have effectively lost the Police
4 ) Afghan withdrawal, dead soldiers and billions worth of kit left behind.  The Dems never really banked on the military but they have lost them completely.

If you've lost the Police and the military, illegal immigration is considered to be out of control and gas prices have risen by >50% frankly you hope and pray you're opposition is a lunatic like Donald Trump.  If the Dems were fighting literally anyone else they would get crushed in the election.  As it happens the Dems got lucky, they could have been up against Nikki Haley, and its just too close to call.

I’d liken it to the Brexit vote here. Lots of people are dissatisfied with their current lifestyle and because of this they want change and Trump’s populism is offering simple answers to very difficult problems that he cannot solve. With striking similarity with Brexit, Trump will be worse than Harris, and those that vote for him will suffer more than those that don’t, but by the time they realise it’ll be too late, and Trump and his cronies will have by then blamed everyone else for holding back the MAGA revolution.
Reply
So, different country, similar problems... Go figure, pretty much the same across Europe too...
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)