Tonight’s boxing
#11
(10-13-2024, 03:27 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-13-2024, 10:42 AM)Cuzer Wrote: The 116-112 card against Bivol  was an absolute disgrace

A lot of pressure on Whittaker now as it certainly looks to all like he was after a way out

Cuzer

Not a disgrace. A stretch maybe. Lots of really close rounds. Beterbiev got given them.

Four factors in boxing scoring:
Clean punching (effect important)
Effective aggression
Ring generalship 
Defence

In those close rounds (there were a good number of them), it’s reasonable to give them
betwrbiev.

Thing is, when Bivol let rip, he outboxed Beterbiev. But in lots of the close rounds (and there were many of them), he only did it for say, three 15 second spurts. He circled the ring a lot.

Whereas Beterbiev would have been favoured in effective aggression, and ring control (as Yarde pointed out after in the studio).

Plus, in terms of clean and effective punching…. The stats were super close in terms of how many landed. So then we go to how effective… the judges have a better idea close up…. What clue do we have? Bivol’s face afterwards… so Beterbiev more effective too with his heavy hands.

Hard to separate in defence in the close rounds.

So I can easily see why he was given so many close rounds. Bivol needed to do more in a lot of those rounds. Bivol did the best looking work. But nowhere near enough of it taking all factors into account.

It was very close and both class acts. But 8-4 can easily happen in a close fight, for reasons above.

Hopefully we’ll see a best of 3!

There is no way, on gods green earth, Bivol only won four rounds in that fight

The card is a disgrace

Absolutely a tight fight, I had Bivol by only one round but to give him four rounds out of twelve, shoukd never work again

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#12
(10-13-2024, 10:50 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(10-13-2024, 03:27 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-13-2024, 10:42 AM)Cuzer Wrote: The 116-112 card against Bivol  was an absolute disgrace

A lot of pressure on Whittaker now as it certainly looks to all like he was after a way out

Cuzer

Not a disgrace. A stretch maybe. Lots of really close rounds. Beterbiev got given them.

Four factors in boxing scoring:
Clean punching (effect important)
Effective aggression
Ring generalship 
Defence

In those close rounds (there were a good number of them), it’s reasonable to give them
betwrbiev.

Thing is, when Bivol let rip, he outboxed Beterbiev. But in lots of the close rounds (and there were many of them), he only did it for say, three 15 second spurts. He circled the ring a lot.

Whereas Beterbiev would have been favoured in effective aggression, and ring control (as Yarde pointed out after in the studio).

Plus, in terms of clean and effective punching…. The stats were super close in terms of how many landed. So then we go to how effective… the judges have a better idea close up…. What clue do we have? Bivol’s face afterwards… so Beterbiev more effective too with his heavy hands.

Hard to separate in defence in the close rounds.

So I can easily see why he was given so many close rounds. Bivol needed to do more in a lot of those rounds. Bivol did the best looking work. But nowhere near enough of it taking all factors into account.

It was very close and both class acts. But 8-4 can easily happen in a close fight, for reasons above.

Hopefully we’ll see a best of 3!

There is no way, on gods green earth, Bivol only won four rounds in that fight

The card is a disgrace

Absolutely a tight fight, I had Bivol by only one round but to give him four rounds out of twelve, shoukd never work again

Cuzer

Way OTT that.

It was close. I had a draw but only a 2 round “swing” from a draw is 8-4.

1 judge had 7-5, and despite plenty seeing Bivol as winner, a number of viewers and pundits also edged towards Beterbiev 7-5, so is a one round swing from that really a “digrace”? nah. There were tons of close rounds and I’ve explained why judges could reasonably give plenty of those to Beterbiev.

Close fights can be 8-4, when the rounds are very very close individually. Rounds are hardly ever given as draws, so overall had to be a draw, 2 point, or 4 point deficit. It may “feel” wrong with the closeness of the fight overall, but the fact is rounds are scored individually, so you can rack up a lead by slightly edging a lot of close rounds. And one judge clearly didn’t like bivols intermittent work, however classy, and put more emphasis on effective aggression and controlling the ring to give him the close rounds.. of which there were plenty.
Reply
#13
(10-13-2024, 11:03 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-13-2024, 10:50 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(10-13-2024, 03:27 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-13-2024, 10:42 AM)Cuzer Wrote: The 116-112 card against Bivol  was an absolute disgrace

A lot of pressure on Whittaker now as it certainly looks to all like he was after a way out

Cuzer

Not a disgrace. A stretch maybe. Lots of really close rounds. Beterbiev got given them.

Four factors in boxing scoring:
Clean punching (effect important)
Effective aggression
Ring generalship 
Defence

In those close rounds (there were a good number of them), it’s reasonable to give them
betwrbiev.

Thing is, when Bivol let rip, he outboxed Beterbiev. But in lots of the close rounds (and there were many of them), he only did it for say, three 15 second spurts. He circled the ring a lot.

Whereas Beterbiev would have been favoured in effective aggression, and ring control (as Yarde pointed out after in the studio).

Plus, in terms of clean and effective punching…. The stats were super close in terms of how many landed. So then we go to how effective… the judges have a better idea close up…. What clue do we have? Bivol’s face afterwards… so Beterbiev more effective too with his heavy hands.

Hard to separate in defence in the close rounds.

So I can easily see why he was given so many close rounds. Bivol needed to do more in a lot of those rounds. Bivol did the best looking work. But nowhere near enough of it taking all factors into account.

It was very close and both class acts. But 8-4 can easily happen in a close fight, for reasons above.

Hopefully we’ll see a best of 3!

There is no way, on gods green earth, Bivol only won four rounds in that fight

The card is a disgrace

Absolutely a tight fight, I had Bivol by only one round but to give him four rounds out of twelve, shoukd never work again

Cuzer

Way OTT that.

It was close. I had a draw but only a 2 round “swing” from a draw is 8-4.

1 judge had 7-5, and despite plenty seeing Bivol as winner,  a number of viewers and pundits also edged towards Beterbiev 7-5, so is a one round swing from that really a “digrace”? nah. There were tons of close rounds and I’ve explained why judges could reasonably give plenty of those to Beterbiev.

Close fights can be 8-4, when the rounds are very very close individually. Rounds are hardly ever given as draws, so overall had to be a draw, 2 point, or 4 point deficit. It may “feel” wrong with the closeness of the fight overall, but the fact is rounds are scored individually, so you can rack up a lead by slightly edging a lot of close rounds. And one judge clearly didn’t like bivols intermittent work, however classy, and put more emphasis on effective aggression and controlling the ring to give him the close rounds.. of which there were plenty.

Good explanation, Backside. 

It's how I saw it. I prefer technical boxing, as a preference, so probably gave more of the tight rounds to Bivol. But as I said above, can't argue with Beterbiev getting the nod.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#14
Ta.

I thought the sky commentators went OTT about Bivol too. Whereas those in the studio could see why Beterbiev won.

I also watched Gareth A Davis’s YouTube vlog yesterday, and he had it 8-4 Beterbiev on the night, watching from ringside (7-5 when watched it back). I think he’s a good boxing pundit. I think the effectiveness of punches from Beterbiev also swayed the judges (who are close up), and this doesn’t come across on tv.

But there’s so much misunderstanding of boxing scoring. How many even know the four factors I listed above? (The tv should make this clear, and they don’t, although Yarde mentioned it in the studio). 8-4 can be a super close fight when 6-8 of the rounds are close. This is what people don’t get. Judges score them each round. They don’t take a block of 4 rounds and say “they were all close, better give them 2 each”. Four close rounds can be 4-0. Likewise, 12 close rounds can easily be 8-4.
Reply
#15
As soon as the announcer said 116-112 all commentators and those at ringside automatically thought Bivol won, no way could Betibiev have won tbe fight by that margin, that was the general feeling from all there and commentating on the night

And then he did….

I’ve followed boxing all my life and been to numerous top level events all over the world so I’m hardly a casual fan, you make valid points and as I say it was a close fight for sure but that card stunk the house out for me

I’ve seen some shocking decisions over the years, absolute robberies, this wasn’t one of them but that card needs some explaining on the judges part IMO…and a few others it seems

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#16
(10-13-2024, 10:42 AM)Cuzer Wrote: The 116-112 card against Bivol was an absolute disgrace

A lot of pressure on Whittaker now as it certainly looks to all like he was after a way out

Cuzer

Completely agree, there is simply no way Beterbiev won that fight 8 rounds to 4. No way. I had the first 3 rounds going to Bivol, the next 3 to Beterbiev, then the next 3 to Bivol again, although I could see a 2-1 there instead. So 6-3/5-4 after 9. Then you could argue a 3-0 Beterbiev in the final 3 rounds, I personally had it as 2-1. So for me, 7-5 Bivol but absolutely could see a 6-6 or a 7-5 to Beterbiev, if you preferred him hitting Bivol's gloves the whole fight. 8-4 is just too lopsided for what a close spectacle it was.

The problem with the scoring system and how subjective it is, is that what most people are talking about is the scorecard and the judges. Not the actual boxing. It's the problem boxing has had for years, and just doesn't get out of it's own way with shit like this.
Reply
#17
(10-14-2024, 10:49 AM)Cuzer Wrote: As soon as the announcer said 116-112 all commentators and those at ringside automatically thought Bivol won, no way could Betibiev have won tbe fight by that margin, that was the general feeling from all there and commentating on the night

And then he did….

I’ve followed boxing all my life and been to numerous top level events all over the world so I’m hardly a casual fan, you make valid points and as I say it was a close fight for sure but that card stunk the house out for me

I’ve seen some shocking decisions over the years, absolute robberies, this wasn’t one of them but that card needs some explaining on the judges part IMO…and a few others it seems

Cuzer

The sky commentators yes. Yet the radio commentators at ringside were not in the slightest shocked, and had Beterbiev 8-4 or 7-5. So it wasn’t the general feeling by all that were there.

As you say, this wasn’t a shocking decision, hence the “never work again” thing is daft. It was reasonable. 7-5 was a completely reasonable score. 8-4 is one round different. Taking into account how pro boxing is scored, with ring generalship and effective aggression crucial, plus punching effect, and most importantly the fact close fights can be 8-4, there’s literally nothing wrong with the decision.

I had 6-6, but at least 2 rounds I gave Bivol were very very close And could have gone the other way easily. That makes it 8-4. Id be interested to know how you got more than 4 rounds “clearly” to Bivol. So many were close. And Beterbiev got the close ones by a judge who is yards away. It’s really no issue.close fights can be 8-4. Nothing needs explaining, the cards are online, 10 rounds had complete agreement by the judges (6-4 Beterbiev). Only 4 and 7 were scored differently. One gave Beterbiev both, one gave Bivol both, one gave one each. Fuss about nothing. Effective aggression and ring generalship favoured by the 8-4 judge.
Reply
#18
(10-14-2024, 11:21 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(10-13-2024, 10:42 AM)Cuzer Wrote: The 116-112 card against Bivol  was an absolute disgrace

A lot of pressure on Whittaker now as it certainly looks to all like he was after a way out

Cuzer

Completely agree, there is simply no way Beterbiev won that fight 8 rounds to 4. No way. I had the first 3 rounds going to Bivol, the next 3 to Beterbiev, then the next 3 to Bivol again, although I could see a 2-1 there instead. So 6-3/5-4 after 9. Then you could argue a 3-0 Beterbiev in the final 3 rounds, I personally had it as 2-1. So for me, 7-5 Bivol but absolutely could see a 6-6 or a 7-5 to Beterbiev, if you preferred him hitting Bivol's gloves the whole fight. 8-4 is just too lopsided for what a close spectacle it was.

The problem with the scoring system and how subjective it is, is that what most people are talking about is the scorecard and the judges. Not the actual boxing. It's the problem boxing has had for years, and just doesn't get out of it's own way with shit like this.

So much wrong there.

Beterbiev didn’t hit the gloves the whole night. The clean punch stats were very similar. Beterbiev won close rounds on ring generalship and effective aggression. Bivols superior technical boxing was too intermittent to win the close rounds in the judges eyes… he circled the ring too much, and 10 second flurries three times in a round didn’t cut it.

8-4 isn’t too lobsided as boxing scoring is round by round, as I keep explaining. You admit 7-5 is reasonable, yet one round difference to that is a disgrace? lol.

You’ve even answered your own question, by saying judging is subjective… which it is! Hence, taking into account the four factors they judge each round on, the subjectivity literally means there will be variation on the weight put on those factors. Nothing disgraceful about putting more weight into effective aggression and ring control. It’s part of the scoring in EACH round.

Good article by Bunce in the independent agreeing with the decision. The sky commentators bias has duped people IMO. That and people not understanding 8-4 can be a close fight.
Reply
#19
For balance, TNT sports were spaffing their load over Beterbiev well over the top. Making it sounds like his completely dominated.

As has been said. The fight was really close, but the extra aggression is always likely to win over better quality technique when it comes down to it.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#20
(10-14-2024, 01:55 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: For balance, TNT sports were spaffing their load over Beterbiev well over the top. Making it sounds like his completely dominated.

As has been said. The fight was really close, but the extra aggression is always likely to win over better quality technique when it comes down to it.

Yeah the radio also had Beterbiev ahead.

As I’ve said, I agree it was really really close. But folk don’t get how scoring works if they think that automatically means it’ll be 7-5 or 6-6. You can have lots of very close rounds go to one fighter. Looking at the fight as an overall 36 minutes and scoring it like that just isn’t how it works.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: