Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(10-01-2024, 09:50 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Though be careful, you've criticises Fellows and fans don't like that. True though, last two games have shown he still has a lot to learn, teams expect him now, he's not an unknown quantity.
Yeh he is untouchable in some eyes and I get it. But that's not the case. He's a developing player who will have quiet games and spells. He will need taking out and resting for the odd game. He will also need the odd spell out the team whilst they work on things.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 7,711
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(10-01-2024, 09:53 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (10-01-2024, 09:50 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Though be careful, you've criticises Fellows and fans don't like that. True though, last two games have shown he still has a lot to learn, teams expect him now, he's not an unknown quantity.
Yeh he is untouchable in some eyes and I get it. But that's not the case. He's a developing player who will have quiet games and spells. He will need taking out and resting for the odd game. He will also need the odd spell out the team whilst they work on things.
Got the same marks from me, issue is his replacement is finished at this level.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
I like Lurker's marks, but everytime I looked at Swift he seemed to be miss-hitting things or not making the sensible pass.
As for Fellows FWIW, the Brummie were on their feet way more once he came on. No, he's not perfect, but I make a concerted effort to enjoy him as much as possible as he's the most gifted player we've had sincer Pereira and he probably won't be with us next season.
Posts: 2,007
Threads: 113
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
4
Some harsh comments here. I think Wallace played cos Carlos thought he could cut inside an break lines - he did this twice and both times the pass he received was too heavy and prevented him from going 1 on 1. I think he’s being judged on him not being Fellows.
We played a decent side tonight and they nicked it 1-0, could easily have been 0-0 or 1-0 to us with a bit of luck.
People complain too much after a defeat. Every player puts in a shift, knows their job and the manager gets all he can out of them. Get behind them cos at times tonight it was quiet for a team that was top going into the game.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
10-01-2024, 11:16 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-01-2024, 11:16 PM by SW4Baggie.)
(10-01-2024, 09:47 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Palmer - 8 - Some great saves. Nowt he could do bout the goals.
Furlong - 6 - Another quiet one with some wasteful passes. Defended well though.
Ajayi - 7 - Solid
Bartley - 7 - Solid
Heggem - 7 - 8 first half, 6 start of the second. First half was as good as I've seen him.
Racic - 6 - Yeh, not bad. Lacking sharpness. But think it will come.
Mowatt - 8 - Best we've got.
Wallace - 5 - Great shift as always, but squandered our 2 best chances. Not good night at the office offensively.
Swift - 7 - Anything good goes through him. We faded when he went off.
Grant - 7 - Such a humongous amount of graft and some really clever passes and runs. Needs to threaten the goal more.
Maja - 5 - Poor tonight.
Subs:
Molumby - 7 - Added some drive and broke lines well. Lacked end product.
Fellows - 6 - Beat his man and got him self half a yard a couple of times. Poor delivery. Really poor touch when set away in the break second half. Needs to work on his first touch when moving at pace. He should have been in 1-1. They should just show him Walcott/Salah videos on repeat.
MJ - 6 - Tried things, tried to commit them in right areas but he's just not quite at it right now. Will come though.
Bobbins - 5 - Trying to remain rational. But I think he's just a bit shit.
Styles - 6 - Good cameo. Brilliant pass, some good tackles. Looks promising.
CC - Think he's got it wrong 2 games in a row now in terms of his subs. Which is not like him. Swift needed to stay on, and MJ was wasted centrally in what was a compacted area of the pitch.
Agree with your comments, but I think some of the scores are a bit generous in attack lad.
Palmer 8
Furlong 7
Bartley 7
Ajayi 7
Heggem 7
Racic 5
Mowatt 8
Wallace 4
Swift 6
Grant 6
Maja 5
Molumby 7
Styles 7 - really improved us
Fellows 6
Dobbin 4 - his best cameo so far
MJ 3 - woeful
Posts: 27,980
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(10-01-2024, 09:13 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Oh look, repeated comments, agenda against certain players, silly nicknames for players he doesn't like. Some idea he's the lone voice in the world against all others.
Reminds me of someone.
The phrase “saying it as I see it” is a dead giveaway.
Although TBF Johnstone was dire when he came on last night.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(10-01-2024, 11:14 PM)aj21 Wrote: Some harsh comments here. I think Wallace played cos Carlos thought he could cut inside an break lines - he did this twice and both times the pass he received was too heavy and prevented him from going 1 on 1. I think he’s being judged on him not being Fellows.
We played a decent side tonight and they nicked it 1-0, could easily have been 0-0 or 1-0 to us with a bit of luck.
People complain too much after a defeat. Every player puts in a shift, knows their job and the manager gets all he can out of them. Get behind them cos at times tonight it was quiet for a team that was top going into the game.
Agree with this.
Wallace getting unnecessary stick. We are lucky to have both him and Fellows.
I think Boro deserved to win, but it could have been 1-0 to us, it was a tight game.
Posts: 1,960
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(10-01-2024, 09:13 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Oh look, repeated comments, agenda against certain players, silly nicknames for players he doesn't like. Some idea he's the lone voice in the world against all others.
Reminds me of someone.
Highley likely you're right Birdy.
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(10-01-2024, 09:38 PM)MrBater Wrote: (10-01-2024, 09:34 PM)Jacko Wrote: Palmer 8 - superb save from LL and otherwise didn't put a foot wrong
Furlong 6 - bang average but did nothing wrong
Ajayi 5 - caught out of position several times including getting under the ball for LL's big chance
Bartley 6 - slightly better than Sunday but not really up against much with LL pulling onto Ajayi at every opportunity
Heggem 6 - Got beat by Doak a couple of times but otherwise played well and won other duels with him
Racic 6 - I thought he linked play well without really hurting Middlesbrough
Mowatt 7.5 - Ran the game as usual, but didn't do anything outstanding
Grant 5 - He's not a goal threat and can't link up play, the only reason people weren't howling for his removal on SM is because:
Wallace 3 - I genuinely think this guy is done, or as close to as it makes no matter, shouldn't start another game
Swift 4 - Another poor game and a massive shame Diangana has picked up another injury, a luxury player in an otherwise ridiculously hard working team
Maja 6.5 - never had a chance created for him, linked play well and should have had an assist for the dreadful Wallace effort, abysmal attempted pass that would have put Jed clean through though I had zero confidence he would score in any case
Fellows 6 - never really got in the game, Boro did a job on him
Johnston 6.5 - looked lively when he came on, unlucky on a couple of occasions
Molumby 6 - added energy but not much else a red line sub if ever I saw one
Dobbin NA - did he touch the ball?
Styles NA - where was he meant to be playing, presumably left back but he's a midfielder all day long imo
These are much closer to how I saw it. Apart from Grant who would get a 6.
I quite liked Racic, seemed to be all over the place at times.
These marks made me laugh. But not unexpected Grant 5 Johnston 6.5 Grant put a shift in and 3 or 4 decent crosses also beat his man, not his fault nobody got on the end of his crosses. Johnston never beat a man lost the ball numerous times and his crosses went into row Z. I like Johnston but at present not up to his last season standard. As for Styles he had a very good cameo at left back the ball for Maja was excellent. Ah well me and Jacko will never agree on Grant this season. So after this post I will leave Jacko to get on with his unfair criticism and keep ignoring his threads for the time being.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(10-02-2024, 10:05 AM)wba13 Wrote: (10-01-2024, 09:38 PM)MrBater Wrote: (10-01-2024, 09:34 PM)Jacko Wrote: Palmer 8 - superb save from LL and otherwise didn't put a foot wrong
Furlong 6 - bang average but did nothing wrong
Ajayi 5 - caught out of position several times including getting under the ball for LL's big chance
Bartley 6 - slightly better than Sunday but not really up against much with LL pulling onto Ajayi at every opportunity
Heggem 6 - Got beat by Doak a couple of times but otherwise played well and won other duels with him
Racic 6 - I thought he linked play well without really hurting Middlesbrough
Mowatt 7.5 - Ran the game as usual, but didn't do anything outstanding
Grant 5 - He's not a goal threat and can't link up play, the only reason people weren't howling for his removal on SM is because:
Wallace 3 - I genuinely think this guy is done, or as close to as it makes no matter, shouldn't start another game
Swift 4 - Another poor game and a massive shame Diangana has picked up another injury, a luxury player in an otherwise ridiculously hard working team
Maja 6.5 - never had a chance created for him, linked play well and should have had an assist for the dreadful Wallace effort, abysmal attempted pass that would have put Jed clean through though I had zero confidence he would score in any case
Fellows 6 - never really got in the game, Boro did a job on him
Johnston 6.5 - looked lively when he came on, unlucky on a couple of occasions
Molumby 6 - added energy but not much else a red line sub if ever I saw one
Dobbin NA - did he touch the ball?
Styles NA - where was he meant to be playing, presumably left back but he's a midfielder all day long imo
These are much closer to how I saw it. Apart from Grant who would get a 6.
I quite liked Racic, seemed to be all over the place at times.
These marks made me laugh. But not unexpected Grant 5 Johnston 6.5 Grant put a shift in and 3 or 4 decent crosses also beat his man, not his fault nobody got on the end of his crosses. Johnston never beat a man lost the ball numerous times and his crosses went into row Z. I like Johnston but at present not up to his last season standard. As for Styles he had a very good cameo at left back the ball for Maja was excellent. Ah well me and Jacko will never agree on Grant this season. So after this post I will leave Jacko to get on with his unfair criticism and keep ignoring his threads for the time being. Nailed it, 13. Styles at least, gave us something to think about as we wait for Saturday.
|