Israel
(09-30-2024, 08:09 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-30-2024, 07:48 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What does ‘winning’ actually look like? The most decadent opinions are from those who are treating the deaths of hundreds, thousands of people like General Haig in Blackadder Goes Fourth, just something to sweep up and pop in the bin. Whilst they live safely thousands of miles away and think not being able to afford private school is a sacrifice.

Good question. The ultimate answer is Israel not being permanently under existential threat. The more likely answer is denuding the military capability and prestige of Iran and it's proxies enough to bring another temporary period of peace. Given that Hezbollah is most likely now being run by people who two weeks ago weren't trusted with a pager I sense that's progress.

As for your latter point... see another thread.

You haven't answered the question because you've completely removed the Palestinian people from your answer. Has Dekka said, just people to sweep up and put in the bin.

Again, you overlook that the Palestinian resistance movement predated any Iranian movement. You also overlook that even before 7th October, over 240 Palestinians had been killed on the West Bank, including 9 people killed by settlers:

https://reliefweb.int/report/occupied-pa...ear-record

There will be no peace until there a just settlement for the Palestinian people. The Israeli state thought they had defanged the PLO and PFLP, instead Hamas and Hezbollah were created instead.
Reply
"There will be no peace until there a just settlement for the Palestinian people."

Exactly. Everyone knows it. Even Netanyahu.
Reply
Can I just ask what you believe a ”just settlement” for the Palestinians is?
Reply
(09-30-2024, 08:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Can I just ask what you believe a ”just settlement” for the Palestinians is?

Israel is demonstrating that it will never surrender to the "idea" described on here that they should not exist. As William Hague says in the Times this morning "in the last fortnight they have shown that an up-to-the-minute combination of data analytics, AI, cyber-penetration and conventional weapons can be utterly devastating" This is how you win, or at least make the other side lose slowly. Overwhelming strength. The West must support Israel as they do Ukraine. What other options are there? How can violent, homophobic, misogynistic, antisemitic, fundamentalist, tyrannical men be allowed to win? I can’t imagine a peace (just settlement) with Nazis
Reply
(09-30-2024, 08:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Can I just ask what you believe a ”just settlement” for the Palestinians is?

Ultimately that's for the Palestinian people to decide, but an independent state with full control of its own borders. If right of return is not possible, then the Israeli state needs to pay reparations. There's enough evidence of the land and housing that they stole from Palestinians to make that a calculable figure.

There has always been and always will be a Jewish population in the Levant, but Zionism as an ideology has only lead to discrimination, misery and death so needs to go the way of baasskap.

This short video by the Jordanian foreign minister yesterday is worth watching:

https://x.com/carlbildt/status/184085598...tLZ9A&s=19

Pont - The Israelis have been boasting of their overwhelming strength for over 70 years and yet Palestinian resistance still exists. Comparing Palestinians with Nazis is grotesque. You write as though the world can't see what is happening in Gaza and the West Bank. Who are the people who have been killing children every day for the past year? Not Palestinians..
Reply
(10-01-2024, 08:20 AM)Squid Wrote:
(09-30-2024, 08:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Can I just ask what you believe a ”just settlement” for the Palestinians is?

Ultimately that's for the Palestinian people to decide, but an independent state with full control of its own borders. If right of return is not possible, then the Israeli state needs to pay reparations. There's enough evidence of the land and housing that they stole from Palestinians to make that a calculable figure.

I wonder what makes you believe that is possible when the issues are so intractable and thousands of years in the making?

If they can't come a lasting settlement in Cyprus, where there's been peace from 50 years - then how on Earth do you think it's possible in the Middle East? A region chock-full of bad actors?
Reply
(10-01-2024, 08:49 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-01-2024, 08:20 AM)Squid Wrote:
(09-30-2024, 08:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Can I just ask what you believe a ”just settlement” for the Palestinians is?

Ultimately that's for the Palestinian people to decide, but an independent state with full control of its own borders. If right of return is not possible, then the Israeli state needs to pay reparations. There's enough evidence of the land and housing that they stole from Palestinians to make that a calculable figure.

I wonder what makes you believe that is possible when the issues are so intractable and thousands of years in the making?

If they can't come a lasting settlement in Cyprus, where there's been peace from 50 years - then how on Earth do you think it's possible in the Middle East? A region chock-full of bad actors?

While Cyprus is divided, at least it is not in active conflict and both halves are able to function. Ditto Bosnia Herzegovina and indeed Northern Ireland.

I wouldn't say the issues are thousands of years in the making either. If we got in a time machine to Jerusalem 1824, we'd find a functioning multi-ethnic, multi-faith city.
Reply
(10-01-2024, 08:57 AM)Squid Wrote:
(10-01-2024, 08:49 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-01-2024, 08:20 AM)Squid Wrote:
(09-30-2024, 08:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Can I just ask what you believe a ”just settlement” for the Palestinians is?

Ultimately that's for the Palestinian people to decide, but an independent state with full control of its own borders. If right of return is not possible, then the Israeli state needs to pay reparations. There's enough evidence of the land and housing that they stole from Palestinians to make that a calculable figure.

I wonder what makes you believe that is possible when the issues are so intractable and thousands of years in the making?

If they can't come a lasting settlement in Cyprus, where there's been peace from 50 years - then how on Earth do you think it's possible in the Middle East? A region chock-full of bad actors?

While Cyprus is divided, at least it is not in active conflict and both halves are able to function. Ditto Bosnia Herzegovina and indeed Northern Ireland.

I wouldn't say the issues are thousands of years in the making either. If we got in a time machine to Jerusalem 1824, we'd find a functioning multi-ethnic, multi-faith city.

Because Cyprus, Bosnia and Northern Ireland aren't surrounded by influential bad actors.

When I say thousands of years I'm talking about Egyptian bondage, the conflagration of the Temple, the Persian bondage etc. Not 200 years ago under the jackboot of the Ottomans.
Reply
Bosnia?! Not surrounded by bad actors? It shares a land border with a state that committed genocide against it!

Depending on which side of Cyprus you sit, there will also be varying opinions upon Turkey and Greece as bad actors.

Bringing up biblical history is completely irrelevant to the existence of modern national states, especially when the rest of the Middle East has to abide by a pencil wielded during Sykes-Picot.

Why on earth does a modern-day Palestinian deserve to suffer because of "Egyptian bondage, the conflagration of the Temple, the Persian bondage"? I hope you are this vocal about reparations for the victims of the far more recent trans-Atlantic slave trade, but I suspect not.
Reply
(10-01-2024, 11:04 AM)Squid Wrote: Bosnia?! Not surrounded by bad actors? It shares a land border with a state that committed genocide against it!

Depending on which side of Cyprus you sit, there will also be varying opinions upon Turkey and Greece as bad actors.

Bringing up biblical history is completely irrelevant to the existence of modern national states, especially when the rest of the Middle East has to abide by a pencil wielded during Sykes-Picot.

Why on earth does a modern-day Palestinian deserve to suffer because of "Egyptian bondage, the conflagration of the Temple, the Persian bondage"? I hope you are this vocal about reparations for the victims of the far more recent trans-Atlantic slave trade, but I suspect not.

Bosnia is not under permanent existential threat from forces on its borders or further afield. Would you consider either the Serbs or the Croats to be bad actors now? 

There is no absolutely no prospect of internecine warfare in Cyprus whilst Greece & Turkey are NATO members.

Where did I suggest Palestinians "deserve to suffer"? All I am pointing out is that tribal conflict, conquest, defeat and reconquest have an exceptionally long history in that part of the world.

Having spent August in the southern states I don't need a lecture about the slave trade or Jim Crow laws ta. As with Israel & Palestine any solutions are exceptionally complex and I doubt there'll be a resolution that provides what you consider to be justice.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)