Private Education
#1
I'm beginning to wonder whether Labour's changes will actually net any money at all for the Treasury. Perhaps it is just vindictive red meat for the base after all.

From my good friend Johnny Webber.
https://www.colliers.com/en-gb/news/27-0...te-schools
Reply
#2
So, your opposition of state subsidy (via working tax credits) to business - an issue that we agree on btw- doesn't apply to the businesses that are private schools?

What happened to "if they can't stand on their own too feet they shouldn't be operating"?

Or are you cherry picking to suit your own rightist agenda again?
Reply
#3
(09-30-2024, 08:12 AM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm beginning to wonder whether Labour's changes will actually net any money at all for the Treasury. Perhaps it is just vindictive red meat for the base after all.

From my good friend Johnny Webber.
https://www.colliers.com/en-gb/news/27-0...te-schools

I'm Labour through & through and I have no objection to VAT on school fees or the withdrawal of charitable status. If it's a matter of principle it should be tapered and phased in over many years. Otherwise it's precisely what you say it is and will close private schools and make the remaining even more elite. I don't believe it is moderate policy and i'm a mod.
Reply
#4
Are we saying private schools should be subsidised by the state via dubious ‘charitable’ status but children’s hospices such as Acorns should rely solely on the generosity of those who give to charity? I seem to recall certain posters thought that hospices should not receive government grants and should be self sufficient, should a private school not have to be?

It’s amazing how much airtime and effort is put into highlighting the ‘plight’ of the struggling private schools and the children and parents who attend them by right wing papers and politicians and yet barely any column inches or airtime generated for the real plight of local hospices who genuinely do look after children and parents with genuine needs of support from the state.
Reply
#5
But the point is that the policy is likely to rise very little if anything at all. Probably even less than cancelling the Winter Fuel Allowance. So what' the point?
Reply
#6
Surely if parents cant afford to send kids to private schools due to VAT

Wont it just put more pressure on state schools that are struggling
Reply
#7
Which is one of the reasons the policy is unlikely to net anything significant for the Treasury.
Reply
#8
(10-01-2024, 01:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Which is one of the reasons the policy is unlikely to net anything significant for the Treasury.

Just like the change in Non-Dom tax, which is going to net very little.

It's ok changing the rules, because "they aren't fair", but when you have costed a hike in Treasury income that fails to materialise then you either have to "row back", or start charging even more tax to the working people (or take more off the Pensioners. Perhaps Labour can start charging them National Insurance, that would rake in a few quid).
Reply
#9
The Non-Dom changes could actually cost the Treasury. It doesn't really surprise me that neither the government (this or last) nor the Treasury get this as I don't believe they have the first idea of just how mobile finance is these days.
Reply
#10
You can use similar arguments when it comes to unpaid carers and hospices but oddly that doesn’t cut much ice with right wingers. If every unpaid carer dumped their loved one on the state to look after the care system would collapse, similarly if charity hospices didn’t exist then that would put even more strain on the care and health system.

They apparently shouldn’t receive help from the state or at the very best should be means tested into poverty even though they save the country million of pounds a week. It’s like there is one set of financial and moral rules for one group of people and a completely different set of rules for the other. There are some very skewed values on display in this thread.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)