Israel
(09-28-2024, 09:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I know it terrifies you Dekka to admit that liberalism is far superior to totalitarianism. I clocked that during Covid.

Proth I respect your opinions as much as you respect mine.
Reply
Your decadent opinions are derived from your experience in a wonderfully free and safe island country largely surrounded by other free and safe countries. I dare say you may have different opinions if you lived in Estonia, Poland, Taiwan, Burma or Israel.
Reply
(09-28-2024, 09:29 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Can you provide an actual source quote from me that simply says what Israel is doing is “fine”?

Let me be crystal clear, I wish nothing but total defeat for Iran and its proxies. The Iranian regime offers nothing positive for this world whatsoever. Israel is not to blame for Hamas or Hezbollah. Iran simply cannot abide the prospect of a successful liberal state in its midst that offers freedom for all - but particularly for women and sexual minorities - and heaven forbid peace with its neighbours.

As long as Iran is sponsoring savagery on Israel’s doorstep there can be no peace. 

Both Hamas and Hezbollah were formed as a direct response to Israeli actions. Hamas in the wake of the First Intifada, Hezbollah in response to Israel's brutal invasion of Lebanon, which included the Sabra and Shatila massacre. 

If Israel was not illegally occupying Palestinian land (something they've been doing many decades before the existence of the current Iranian state), or invading neighbouring countries, neither Hamas or Hezbollah would exist. Wheras Palestinian resistance to Israel would still exist even if the current Iranian regime did not.

Israel is not "a successful liberal state". It is a genocidal ethnostate that has killed more civilians than Hamas ever could. As for claiming it offers "freedom for women", what freedom is there for the Palestinian women it slaughters? 

"Lebanon does not want Hezbollah. Egypt has washed its hands of Gaza. Both countries know exactly what is occurring yet a few thousand miles away in free and liberal Europe plenty deny the truth."

What does this even mean? The Egyptian government is dependent on US aid and so will do what the US wants. A big section of Lebanon may hate Hezbollah, but that doesn't mean they don't hate the Israeli state and it's treatment of the Palestinian people.

Iran could disappear from the face of the earth tomorrow, it would make no difference to how people in the surrounding countries feel about the Israeli state. Jordan has had a peace treaty with Israel for decades. Ask the average Jordanian how they feel about Israel. They will not say "Ooh, it's a successful liberal state". Those countries having a front row seat to Israel engaging in the mass execution of Palestinians, unsurprisingly hasn't generated many feelings of warmth. A state saying "But October 7th" isn't a very compelling argument when that state has now killed 20,000 times as many people and shows no sign of stopping.

There will never be peace until there is justice for the Palestinian people.

Thinking genocide is wrong is not a "decadent opinion".
Reply
(09-28-2024, 09:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-28-2024, 08:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Matthew Syed has written a superb article in The Times today essentially about Who Do You Want To Win?

I suggest you all read it, then tell me who you want to win - and why.

This isn’t fugging Star Wars no one ‘wins’ no one is ‘winning’ you won’t bomb, kidnap, kill or flatten entire cities into peace, submission or a solution. The best you might achieve is a pause in the violence. What a childish way of looking at this situation.

It is superb as Mr P says. If you'd read the piece, you may not have written that. 
I want Israel to win, I am fully behind them as most Israelis are too.  I am ashamed of the Labour Party's position on supplying arms to Israel. I want Ukraine to win and Taiwan. I shall keep asking the question to all the anti zionists, antisemites and pacifists on here. What would you do?
Reply
Accusing someone of decadence because they don’t believe a solution can be found at the end of gun with regards to the Israel, Palestine and wider Middle East problems is privileged position to take. Particularly given they are making these statements without any significant consequences to them or presumably their families, whilst living in relative luxury thousands of miles away from the unfolding conflict(s). I know which position taken is more ‘decadent’.
Reply
(09-29-2024, 05:39 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(09-28-2024, 09:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-28-2024, 08:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Matthew Syed has written a superb article in The Times today essentially about Who Do You Want To Win?

I suggest you all read it, then tell me who you want to win - and why.

This isn’t fugging Star Wars no one ‘wins’ no one is ‘winning’ you won’t bomb, kidnap, kill or flatten entire cities into peace, submission or a solution. The best you might achieve is a pause in the violence. What a childish way of looking at this situation.

It is superb as Mr P says. If you'd read the piece, you may not have written that. 
I want Israel to win, I am fully behind them as most Israelis are too.  I am ashamed of the Labour Party's position on supplying arms to Israel. I want Ukraine to win and Taiwan. I shall keep asking the question to all the anti zionists, antisemites and pacifists on here. What would you do?

Out of interest, as an Islamophobe, what do you think the solution is?
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
(09-29-2024, 08:43 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(09-29-2024, 05:39 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(09-28-2024, 09:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-28-2024, 08:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Matthew Syed has written a superb article in The Times today essentially about Who Do You Want To Win?

I suggest you all read it, then tell me who you want to win - and why.

This isn’t fugging Star Wars no one ‘wins’ no one is ‘winning’ you won’t bomb, kidnap, kill or flatten entire cities into peace, submission or a solution. The best you might achieve is a pause in the violence. What a childish way of looking at this situation.

It is superb as Mr P says. If you'd read the piece, you may not have written that. 
I want Israel to win, I am fully behind them as most Israelis are too.  I am ashamed of the Labour Party's position on supplying arms to Israel. I want Ukraine to win and Taiwan. I shall keep asking the question to all the anti zionists, antisemites and pacifists on here. What would you do?

Out of interest, as an Islamophobe, what do you think the solution is?

If you mean by that I oppose the homophobic, misogynistic, antisemitic, oppressive, fundamentalist terrorist groups and states that surround israel I'm gonna have to hold my hands up. Now answer the fucking question. 
I see Bibi's poll ratings are up
Reply
(09-28-2024, 11:18 PM)Squid Wrote:
(09-28-2024, 09:29 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Can you provide an actual source quote from me that simply says what Israel is doing is “fine”?

Let me be crystal clear, I wish nothing but total defeat for Iran and its proxies. The Iranian regime offers nothing positive for this world whatsoever. Israel is not to blame for Hamas or Hezbollah. Iran simply cannot abide the prospect of a successful liberal state in its midst that offers freedom for all - but particularly for women and sexual minorities - and heaven forbid peace with its neighbours.

As long as Iran is sponsoring savagery on Israel’s doorstep there can be no peace. 

Both Hamas and Hezbollah were formed as a direct response to Israeli actions. Hamas in the wake of the First Intifada, Hezbollah in response to Israel's brutal invasion of Lebanon, which included the Sabra and Shatila massacre. 

If Israel was not illegally occupying Palestinian land (something they've been doing many decades before the existence of the current Iranian state), or invading neighbouring countries, neither Hamas or Hezbollah would exist. Wheras Palestinian resistance to Israel would still exist even if the current Iranian regime did not.

Israel is not "a successful liberal state". It is a genocidal ethnostate that has killed more civilians than Hamas ever could. As for claiming it offers "freedom for women", what freedom is there for the Palestinian women it slaughters? 

"Lebanon does not want Hezbollah. Egypt has washed its hands of Gaza. Both countries know exactly what is occurring yet a few thousand miles away in free and liberal Europe plenty deny the truth."

What does this even mean? The Egyptian government is dependent on US aid and so will do what the US wants. A big section of Lebanon may hate Hezbollah, but that doesn't mean they don't hate the Israeli state and it's treatment of the Palestinian people.

Iran could disappear from the face of the earth tomorrow, it would make no difference to how people in the surrounding countries feel about the Israeli state. Jordan has had a peace treaty with Israel for decades. Ask the average Jordanian how they feel about Israel. They will not say "Ooh, it's a successful liberal state". Those countries having a front row seat to Israel engaging in the mass execution of Palestinians, unsurprisingly hasn't generated many feelings of warmth. A state saying "But October 7th" isn't a very compelling argument when that state has now killed 20,000 times as many people and shows no sign of stopping.

There will never be peace until there is justice for the Palestinian people.

Thinking genocide is wrong is not a "decadent opinion".

And that's why your opinion is so decadent. Modern Israel has been under existential threat since the creation of the State; Iran, Hezbollah, Hamas don't want "justice for the Palestinian people" - they want the complete destruction of the Israeli state. Without Iran, would those proxies exist? Even if they did they'd be far less of a threat to Israel.

It's no coincidence that October 7th followed years of rapprochement between Israel and other Middle Eastern states. Iran can't have that.

What does "justice for the Palestianian people" look like? After October 7th you can't realistically believe the Israelis would come to the negotiating table?
Reply
(09-30-2024, 07:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-28-2024, 11:18 PM)Squid Wrote:
(09-28-2024, 09:29 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Can you provide an actual source quote from me that simply says what Israel is doing is “fine”?

Let me be crystal clear, I wish nothing but total defeat for Iran and its proxies. The Iranian regime offers nothing positive for this world whatsoever. Israel is not to blame for Hamas or Hezbollah. Iran simply cannot abide the prospect of a successful liberal state in its midst that offers freedom for all - but particularly for women and sexual minorities - and heaven forbid peace with its neighbours.

As long as Iran is sponsoring savagery on Israel’s doorstep there can be no peace. 

Both Hamas and Hezbollah were formed as a direct response to Israeli actions. Hamas in the wake of the First Intifada, Hezbollah in response to Israel's brutal invasion of Lebanon, which included the Sabra and Shatila massacre. 

If Israel was not illegally occupying Palestinian land (something they've been doing many decades before the existence of the current Iranian state), or invading neighbouring countries, neither Hamas or Hezbollah would exist. Wheras Palestinian resistance to Israel would still exist even if the current Iranian regime did not.

Israel is not "a successful liberal state". It is a genocidal ethnostate that has killed more civilians than Hamas ever could. As for claiming it offers "freedom for women", what freedom is there for the Palestinian women it slaughters? 

"Lebanon does not want Hezbollah. Egypt has washed its hands of Gaza. Both countries know exactly what is occurring yet a few thousand miles away in free and liberal Europe plenty deny the truth."

What does this even mean? The Egyptian government is dependent on US aid and so will do what the US wants. A big section of Lebanon may hate Hezbollah, but that doesn't mean they don't hate the Israeli state and it's treatment of the Palestinian people.

Iran could disappear from the face of the earth tomorrow, it would make no difference to how people in the surrounding countries feel about the Israeli state. Jordan has had a peace treaty with Israel for decades. Ask the average Jordanian how they feel about Israel. They will not say "Ooh, it's a successful liberal state". Those countries having a front row seat to Israel engaging in the mass execution of Palestinians, unsurprisingly hasn't generated many feelings of warmth. A state saying "But October 7th" isn't a very compelling argument when that state has now killed 20,000 times as many people and shows no sign of stopping.

There will never be peace until there is justice for the Palestinian people.

Thinking genocide is wrong is not a "decadent opinion".

And that's why your opinion is so decadent. Modern Israel has been under existential threat since the creation of the State; Iran, Hezbollah, Hamas don't want "justice for the Palestinian people" - they want the complete destruction of the Israeli state. Without Iran, would those proxies exist? Even if they did they'd be far less of a threat to Israel.

It's no coincidence that October 7th followed years of rapprochement between Israel and other Middle Eastern states. Iran can't have that.

What does "justice for the Palestianian people" look like? After October 7th you can't realistically believe the Israelis would come to the negotiating table?

What does ‘winning’ actually look like? The most decadent opinions are from those who are treating the deaths of hundreds, thousands of people like General Haig in Blackadder Goes Fourth, just something to sweep up and pop in the bin. Whilst they live safely thousands of miles away and think not being able to afford private school is a sacrifice.
Reply
(09-30-2024, 07:48 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What does ‘winning’ actually look like? The most decadent opinions are from those who are treating the deaths of hundreds, thousands of people like General Haig in Blackadder Goes Fourth, just something to sweep up and pop in the bin. Whilst they live safely thousands of miles away and think not being able to afford private school is a sacrifice.

Good question. The ultimate answer is Israel not being permanently under existential threat. The more likely answer is denuding the military capability and prestige of Iran and it's proxies enough to bring another temporary period of peace. Given that Hezbollah is most likely now being run by people who two weeks ago weren't trusted with a pager I sense that's progress.

As for your latter point... see another thread.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)