Israel
(09-28-2024, 02:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still labouring under the delusion you can bomb an ideology and beliefs into submission… it’s not going to work.

There are thousands of new Nasrallahs queuing up to replace him.
The Israeli approach is intellectually and morally bankrupt.
Reply
(09-28-2024, 02:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still labouring under the delusion you can bomb an ideology and beliefs into submission… it’s not going to work.

Or in the case of the Palestinians, it's more than ideology and beliefs, it's the dispossession and illegal occupation of their land.

Also, why are people firing rockets at Israel "murderous bastards", but when Israel bombs flats, schools and hospitals, it's some kind of peace-keeping mission? Despite the fact that the region is clearly no closer to being at peace?
Reply
(09-28-2024, 02:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still labouring under the delusion you can bomb an ideology and beliefs into submission… it’s not going to work.

When was I ever under that delusion Dekka, pray tell?

It's not about ideology. It's about power, influence and land. And it's being orchestrated by two powers who have no interest in jaw jaw.

(09-28-2024, 03:22 PM)Squid Wrote: Also, why are people firing rockets at Israel "murderous bastards"

How would you describe Hezbollah then? I'm curious.
Reply
(09-28-2024, 05:06 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-28-2024, 02:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still labouring under the delusion you can bomb an ideology and beliefs into submission… it’s not going to work.

When was I ever under that delusion Dekka, pray tell?

It's not about ideology. It's about power, influence and land. And it's being orchestrated by two powers who have no interest in jaw jaw.

(09-28-2024, 03:22 PM)Squid Wrote: Also, why are people firing rockets at Israel "murderous bastards"

How would you describe Hezbollah then? I'm curious.

That's not the question I was asking.
Reply
(09-28-2024, 05:12 PM)Squid Wrote:
(09-28-2024, 05:06 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-28-2024, 02:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still labouring under the delusion you can bomb an ideology and beliefs into submission… it’s not going to work.

When was I ever under that delusion Dekka, pray tell?

It's not about ideology. It's about power, influence and land. And it's being orchestrated by two powers who have no interest in jaw jaw.

(09-28-2024, 03:22 PM)Squid Wrote: Also, why are people firing rockets at Israel "murderous bastards"

How would you describe Hezbollah then? I'm curious.

That's not the question I was asking.

This the first time you've been selectively quoted by Proth?
Reply
(09-28-2024, 01:42 PM)Protheroe Wrote: So what is Israel to do then? Chat to the murderous bastards firing rockets at them?

That's my post in context Squid.

What would you call a militia in a failed state who have been firing rockets into Israel since October 7th?
Reply
(09-28-2024, 05:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-28-2024, 01:42 PM)Protheroe Wrote: So what is Israel to do then? Chat to the murderous bastards firing rockets at them?

That's my post in context Squid.

What would you call a militia in a failed state who have been firing rockets into Israel since October 7th?

This has been asked numerous time but what is the actual plan? What does success look like for Israel? You really think that this ends in peace and stability for Israel? There is no win here.
Reply
(09-28-2024, 05:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-28-2024, 01:42 PM)Protheroe Wrote: So what is Israel to do then? Chat to the murderous bastards firing rockets at them?

That's my post in context Squid.

What would you call a militia in a failed state who have been firing rockets into Israel since October 7th?

Bomb the fuckers into the Stone Age .Israel forever??
Reply
Matthew Syed has written a superb article in The Times today essentially about Who Do You Want To Win?

I suggest you all read it, then tell me who you want to win - and why.
Reply
(09-28-2024, 08:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Matthew Syed has written a superb article in The Times today essentially about Who Do You Want To Win?

I suggest you all read it, then tell me who you want to win - and why.

Ignoring the flaw in that article in relation to the fact that it makes one single mention to who I want to "win" (Lebanon, so it can start to transition back towards a democracy rather than be a country held hostage by a Iranian proxy militia) and even then in a geographic context rather than a national context (and given the topic of the article I find it quite bizarre that you'd avoid bringing up the country or the government), you could at least post the text or an excerpt of the article. The Times is a subscription newspaper, a lot of people don't pay for it so can't read it.

For the benefit of people using my MCW privilege of subscribing to The Times: 

One of the privileges of being a journalist is that you get to criticise. To dissect the decisions of others. To offer warnings from the comfort of one’s sofa (or, in my case, the local coffee shop). In this space, I have criticised the United States often, Israel also, as well as the UK, Germany, France, Italy, Australia and other nations that might traditionally be regarded as allies.

So perhaps you’ll forgive me for saying something that doesn’t get into the details of any single dispute, doesn’t opine on the precise logic of Israel’s killing of Hassan Nasrallah or its broader response to the October 7 attacks, doesn’t get into the weeds of western policy over Ukraine; instead, it makes a simpler but, I hope, not simplistic point. In the conflagration that is coming, I back Israel 100 per cent, the West 100 per cent, civilisation 100 per cent, progress 100 per cent.


Take a step back. Since the West rose to prominence, the world has witnessed growth of a kind that would astound any human being living in the previous 250,000 years. Living standards since the Second World War have risen 500 per cent, lifespans by over a decade, and child mortality has plummeted. While the Bolsheviks were murdering thousands in the gulags and Chairman Mao was masterminding the starvation of perhaps 50 million in China, the US-led West was more or less keeping the shipping lanes open and permitting free trade of a kind that transformed the fabric of the world.

This isn’t to say this rise in prosperity was entirely attributable to the West, nor to deny the errors and crimes committed by the alliance. They trip off the tongue, don’t they? Vietnam, the Iraq war, Abu Ghraib, Guantanamo Bay and more. The US, as the dominant power, has often displayed rank hypocrisy in the way it has interpreted and enforced the somewhat euphemistically named “rules-based order”. But compared with any remotely plausible alternative source of power, the western alliance has exerted the most benign influence the world has known, or perhaps will ever know.

In a world that has started to spin in ever faster geopolitical motion, I suggest we must keep this truth close to our hearts. All foreign policy decisions, all quasi-legal decisions by Foreign Office lawyers and international courts, all assessments of the legitimacy of any geopolitical action, can be made only against the backdrop of this bigger picture. How else to figure out what is wise or unwise, progressive or destructive, right or wrong, if one doesn’t glimpse the forces at play in a world moving closer to an inflection point, quite possibly (although I dearly hope not) involving global war?

And it is this logic, I fear, that we have lost sight of. Vladimir Putin’s forces are committing rape and mutilation in Ukraine, a sovereign nation whose energy infrastructure is being bombed to smithereens as you read these words. Who do we want to win? Again, the question may sound crude, but it is, I suggest, central to assessing the second-order questions of whether we provide more weapons and more aid, thereby sending a signal to Putin, who — like all bullies — understands only the language of strength.

Without a moral position that instils steel in one’s decisions, we will continue to falter, continue to equivocate, continue with the myopic policy of preventing Ukraine from using weaponry in Russian territory — thereby strengthening Putin’s conviction that he will ultimately get his way, dominate the Donbas and, in time, find a pretext for invading the Baltic states too. Our lack of clarity is increasing the risk of escalation, just as it did when we looked the other way as Russia decimated Grozny and invaded Crimea.

And what of Israel, beset on all sides by terrorist groups, each backed by Iran, a nation ruled by a millenarian cult that beats women for lifting the hijab and boasts about expunging Israel from the map and perhaps history itself. I am no fan of Binyamin Netanyahu or right-wing elements in his cabinet, nor the indefensible settlements in the West Bank, but I see in Israel a nation that has given much to civilisation and incubated remarkable prosperity despite its precarious position, while Hamas has spent billions in aid on tunnels, weapons, hotel suites for its leaders and indoctrination camps that turn the next generation of children into fanatics who crave death rather than life, annihilation rather than hope. If you doubt this, watch the documentary Surviving October 7th: We Will Dance Again, a classic of the genre, despite film-makers excising the description of Hamas as terrorists at the behest of the BBC.

Who do you want to win? As you ponder, I invite you to consider what is unfolding around you as China — an ancient and impressive civilisation now run by a totalitarian clique — knits together an axis antithetical to the forces of openness and liberty we so foolishly take for granted. Look at the connective tissue between these revisionist powers as Beijing provides Putin with dual-use weapons and Iran provides drones, as North Korea absorbs new nuclear secrets and Russia provides assistance to the Houthis, whose raison d’être is to disrupt the shipping that embodies the free exchange eulogised by Enlightenment thinkers. Even now, global shipping faces vastly increased insurance costs while detouring around the Cape of Good Hope to avoid Yemen — a deadweight loss to the whole world.

Advertisement

And yet still we invite China to infiltrate our institutions, we look the other way as our politicians take their cash: business as usual. Can we not see that these tyrants are projecting their power ever more boldly (look at the Wagner Group in the Sahel, China’s Belt and Road initiative, Taiwan’s precariousness) precisely because they see us as decadent. How do you think China feels when the UK bans weapons to Israel during a hot war, when President Biden can’t bring himself to call Putin’s bluff, when the multilateral institutions created by the West have been so thoroughly infiltrated they are interpreting laws in ways that represent an inversion of their founding logic?

When the US congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez tweets that the brilliantly targeted attack on pagers by the Israel Defence Forces is a war crime, despite a stunningly low attritional ratio of innocents to combatants, while failing to condemn the thousands of rockets fired from southern Lebanon into Israel, I hope you see my point. She has drunk the propaganda, titrated into western consciousness from bots across the autocratic world, that the US is evil, Israel a colonialist oppressor, and their actions are inherently tainted. By this estimate, the Normandy landings were a violation of international humanitarian law, since innocent people died, never mind that the operation was central to the defeat of Nazism — a secular fanaticism whose psychological contours are not so very different from the fundamentalism of Hamas, Hezbollah and Isis.

Again, you might feel the division of the world into two forces is binary, even Manichaean, but I suggest there are hinge moments in history where simplicity is an asset. There are obviously legitimate tactical considerations in the Middle East, Ukraine and Taiwan (perhaps the most strategically important theatre of all due to its role in the production of advanced semiconductors). But let us remember Churchill’s words: “It is where the balance quivers, and the proportions are veiled in mist, that the opportunity for world-saving decisions presents itself.”

The mists are lifting, and with them, I hope, our sense of purpose. We should stand with freedom. With democracy. With hope. Not just for ourselves but for the future of humanity.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)