Free Gear Keir & Victoria Sponge
#81
(09-26-2024, 02:26 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Don't change the subject. 

The subject, I believe is "Free Gear Keir & Victoria Sponge"

I'm sure you'll find another thread way back about someone who no longer matters at all, but could have made a very good PM.
Reply
#82
The fact that have decided to completely ignore the subject (note the comment I replied to you) is testament to your hypocrisy and the massive blind spot over your "former party" as you refer to them.

Have you thought about the fact that you're getting called out by someone who doesn't like the Labour Party or Starmer?

Like I've just pointed out that Javid took £225k in donations that he didn't give a reason for during a single Parliamentary session and you've decided to say he'd make a very good PM despite chastising Starmer for declaring donations but, unlike Javid, actually bothering to say what they're for. You clearly don't care about that, I don't particularly care much about it either, but you care massively about Starmer doing something less egregious to the point that you ignored the facts (not opinion, facts) about a specific donation in an attempt to link it to others.
Reply
#83
The discussion is not about me. I am not chastising Starmer for taking or declaring donations. Frankly, I don't care about Starmer being on the take however tawdry it is for someone who's already more wealthy than I'll ever be allowing a mate to buy him and his missus clothes and put his kid up in an £18m penthouse.

All I have stated is that should you set yourself up as a sanctimonious moral guardian (which he undoubtedly has) then you can't behave otherwise without expecting ridicule.

When he and Rachel Reeves are taking the shirt off my back on October 30th I will rest safe in the knowledge that I paid for that shirt. St Keir may not be able to say the same - and this should haunt him for a while yet.

My first comment in the this thread was "Maybe the conclusion we ought to draw is that the PM is woefully underpaid and shouldn't be relying on tawdry donations to clothe his wife?"

Which is hardly chastising, is it?
Reply
#84
(09-26-2024, 02:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The discussion is not about me. I am not chastising Starmer for taking or declaring donations. Frankly, I don't care about Starmer being on the take however tawdry it is for someone who's already more wealthy than I'll ever be allowing a mate to buy him and his missus clothes and put his kid up in an £18m penthouse.

All I have stated is that should you set yourself up as a sanctimonious moral guardian (which he undoubtedly has) then you can't behave otherwise without expecting ridicule.

When he and Rachel Reeves are taking the shirt off my back on October 30th I will rest safe in the knowledge that I paid for that shirt. St Keir may not be able to say the same - and this should haunt him for a while yet.

Are you completely ignorant over why I responded to you or something? Have you actually bothered to read anything I put? I wasn't on about Starmer, I was on about you trying to compare something benign (the usage of the flat) with more egregious things (the clothes and sunglasses) as though they're one and the same (they aren't). So yes, this discussion (what I'm on about) absolutely is about you. I haven't made one general statement on the issue as a whole. I don't disagree with the point that MPs and ministerial salaries are poor, but I've not once made any comment about that because that isn't what I'm discussing.

You're even still at it by bringing up the flat, it's completely benign. Apply the context and the facts, it's the most boring accusation.
Reply
#85
(09-26-2024, 02:26 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-26-2024, 01:21 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(09-26-2024, 11:57 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(09-26-2024, 10:22 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(09-25-2024, 03:50 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Exactly this, Proth.

Free Gear was elected on a mandate to rid UK politics of sleaze. He has made a fine start, and that's why they are tanking in the opinion polls. The only problem is that they are bomb-proof for almost 5 years, unless they tear themselves apart when the Left Wing pops its head up again.

I don't have a "lot", I've voted for both sides over the years. 

If you review my posts on this bored, you will see that I declare as "right of centre", and was critical of the last Government. What I don't have is an unjustifiable bias towards any particular side when things are wrong, and the country is just starting to realise that at the moment we have a level of hypocrisy in the present Government.

At the last GE, you voted to retain what was, objectively, the worst Conservative government in history.

And we now have the start of the worse Labour Government in history. 

What were the choices?? I would have happily voted for something/somebody that was electable - and that isn't Reform. The fact that Labour won a landslide with less votes than 2019 tells you all you need to know. The majority of the British public don't endorse any of the choices at present.

The Lib Dems, an independent candidate, spoiling your ballot?

Look at the absolute state of the Tory leadership contenders, what's the point? When the Lib Dems have significantly more qualified MPs and a front bench team that absolutely shits on the Tory benches I fail to see the point of the Conservative Party, all they've done since the general election is whinge about Labour wanting houses being built and pylons being put up. I'm no fan of Labour but the bar is so so low, do you remember the first actions of the Tories in 2015? Ban onshore wind, scale down social care, mothball the mental care act, cut schools funding, cut private pension incentives, sell off the GIB, tax renewable power generation, cut primary care spending and cut back on infrastructure spending. That was an outright stupid budget, not to mention the benefit cuts that didn't do anything to reduce the deficit. That's how low the bar is.

(09-26-2024, 02:16 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-26-2024, 09:25 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Is this the same Mike Wood that in 2015 submitted a nonsense elections return that significantly underreported electoral expenses undertaken?

And seeing as we're on the topic of donations, Javid is hardly clean if you got through his register of interests while he was in government. Free first class flights for him and his wife? £2k worth of free wine? £235,000 of cash or equivalent donations with zero disclosure of purpose in 2019 when he was Home Secretary or Home Secretary? Have you ever brought that up?

Like I've said all the way through this thread, St Keir set himself up as the clean skin. It's his issue to own. He brought it up. Not me. Not you. Him.

Don't change the subject. Have you ever brought up Javid's declared donations up with him?

I'm going to reason that you didn't because (despite being terrible practice because he's completely failed to actually declare what that massive amount of money was for let alone why he got it, yet he's bothered to declare the mundane stuff in the same Parliamentary session like community funding or local campaigning support) the only place this was ever mentioned was in a passing comment in an issue of Private Eye as, rather conveniently, the right-wing press that are going all on this now didn't care at the time.

And as I said at the time of the election I voted for Tory to prevent the election of a Labour candidate in Bromsgrove - there was no other credible alternative who could have won the seat. I did not want a Labour landslide (which is what happened. We saw what happened with a Conservative landslide), but I couldn't have foreseen the start they would make. 

Sunak should have hung on until November. He wouldn't have won, and the country needed change. The Conservatives would have held more seats though, and stood more chance of being an effective opposition.
Reply
#86
(09-26-2024, 03:10 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-26-2024, 02:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The discussion is not about me. I am not chastising Starmer for taking or declaring donations. Frankly, I don't care about Starmer being on the take however tawdry it is for someone who's already more wealthy than I'll ever be allowing a mate to buy him and his missus clothes and put his kid up in an £18m penthouse.

All I have stated is that should you set yourself up as a sanctimonious moral guardian (which he undoubtedly has) then you can't behave otherwise without expecting ridicule.

When he and Rachel Reeves are taking the shirt off my back on October 30th I will rest safe in the knowledge that I paid for that shirt. St Keir may not be able to say the same - and this should haunt him for a while yet.

Are you completely ignorant over why I responded to you or something? Have you actually bothered to read anything I put? I wasn't on about Starmer, I was on about you trying to compare something benign (the usage of the flat) with more egregious things (the clothes and sunglasses) as though they're one and the same (they aren't). So yes, this discussion (what I'm on about) absolutely is about you. I haven't made one general statement on the issue as a whole. I don't disagree with the point that MPs and ministerial salaries are poor, but I've not once made any comment about that because that isn't what I'm discussing.

You're even still at it by bringing up the flat, it's completely benign. Apply the context and the facts, it's the most boring accusation.

As I said above, that's your opinion which I don't share. Getting prissy with me on a message board is not going to change that BB.
Reply
#87
(09-26-2024, 03:42 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: And as I said at the time of the election I voted for Tory to prevent the election of a Labour candidate in Bromsgrove - there was no other credible alternative who could have won the seat. I did not want a Labour landslide (which is what happened. We saw what happened with a Conservative landslide), but I couldn't have foreseen the start they would make. 

Sunak should have hung on until November. He wouldn't have won, and the country needed change. The Conservatives would have held more seats though, and stood more chance of being an effective opposition.

And as I said before the election, due to the mechanics of FPTP and how the Lib Dems were campaigning there was always going to be a Labour landslide.

The Conservatives as a party needed to fuck off ASAP. They had no idea what to do, they were purely governing based on vibes instead of evidence, their flagship policy was never happening and they had scraped the barrel so much that talentless shysters like Badenoch, Cleverly, Atkins, Coutinho etc were senior ministers and they had to bring back David Cameron.

And if they'd waited until November they would have been destroyed even worse than they were. Nobody wants to campaign in the dark let alone for a party that knows it's going to lose, the party finances were in the gutter so redundancies were coming at CCHQ and they had lost the press a long while back. The Tory vote share was only going in one direction the closer to Christmas it got. The stupid thing was Sunak not going for an earlier election while Reform were irrelevant and the Lib Dems were unprepared.

(09-26-2024, 03:48 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-26-2024, 03:10 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-26-2024, 02:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The discussion is not about me. I am not chastising Starmer for taking or declaring donations. Frankly, I don't care about Starmer being on the take however tawdry it is for someone who's already more wealthy than I'll ever be allowing a mate to buy him and his missus clothes and put his kid up in an £18m penthouse.

All I have stated is that should you set yourself up as a sanctimonious moral guardian (which he undoubtedly has) then you can't behave otherwise without expecting ridicule.

When he and Rachel Reeves are taking the shirt off my back on October 30th I will rest safe in the knowledge that I paid for that shirt. St Keir may not be able to say the same - and this should haunt him for a while yet.

Are you completely ignorant over why I responded to you or something? Have you actually bothered to read anything I put? I wasn't on about Starmer, I was on about you trying to compare something benign (the usage of the flat) with more egregious things (the clothes and sunglasses) as though they're one and the same (they aren't). So yes, this discussion (what I'm on about) absolutely is about you. I haven't made one general statement on the issue as a whole. I don't disagree with the point that MPs and ministerial salaries are poor, but I've not once made any comment about that because that isn't what I'm discussing.

You're even still at it by bringing up the flat, it's completely benign. Apply the context and the facts, it's the most boring accusation.

As I said above, that's your opinion which I don't share. Getting prissy with me on a message board is not going to change that BB.

I'm not looking to change your opinion. I'm calling you out for ignoring facts.
Reply
#88
(09-26-2024, 04:00 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-26-2024, 03:42 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: And as I said at the time of the election I voted for Tory to prevent the election of a Labour candidate in Bromsgrove - there was no other credible alternative who could have won the seat. I did not want a Labour landslide (which is what happened. We saw what happened with a Conservative landslide), but I couldn't have foreseen the start they would make. 

Sunak should have hung on until November. He wouldn't have won, and the country needed change. The Conservatives would have held more seats though, and stood more chance of being an effective opposition.

And as I said before the election, due to the mechanics of FPTP and how the Lib Dems were campaigning there was always going to be a Labour landslide.

The Conservatives as a party needed to fuck off ASAP. They had no idea what to do, they were purely governing based on vibes instead of evidence, their flagship policy was never happening and they had scraped the barrel so much that talentless shysters like Badenoch, Cleverly, Atkins, Coutinho etc were senior ministers and they had to bring back David Cameron.

And if they'd waited until November they would have been destroyed even worse than they were. Nobody wants to campaign in the dark let alone for a party that knows it's going to lose, the party finances were in the gutter so redundancies were coming at CCHQ and they had lost the press a long while back. The Tory vote share was only going in one direction the closer to Christmas it got. The stupid thing was Sunak not going for an earlier election while Reform were irrelevant and the Lib Dems were unprepared.

(09-26-2024, 03:48 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-26-2024, 03:10 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-26-2024, 02:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The discussion is not about me. I am not chastising Starmer for taking or declaring donations. Frankly, I don't care about Starmer being on the take however tawdry it is for someone who's already more wealthy than I'll ever be allowing a mate to buy him and his missus clothes and put his kid up in an £18m penthouse.

All I have stated is that should you set yourself up as a sanctimonious moral guardian (which he undoubtedly has) then you can't behave otherwise without expecting ridicule.

When he and Rachel Reeves are taking the shirt off my back on October 30th I will rest safe in the knowledge that I paid for that shirt. St Keir may not be able to say the same - and this should haunt him for a while yet.

Are you completely ignorant over why I responded to you or something? Have you actually bothered to read anything I put? I wasn't on about Starmer, I was on about you trying to compare something benign (the usage of the flat) with more egregious things (the clothes and sunglasses) as though they're one and the same (they aren't). So yes, this discussion (what I'm on about) absolutely is about you. I haven't made one general statement on the issue as a whole. I don't disagree with the point that MPs and ministerial salaries are poor, but I've not once made any comment about that because that isn't what I'm discussing.

You're even still at it by bringing up the flat, it's completely benign. Apply the context and the facts, it's the most boring accusation.

As I said above, that's your opinion which I don't share. Getting prissy with me on a message board is not going to change that BB.

I'm not looking to change your opinion. I'm calling you out for ignoring facts.

"The Conservatives as a party needed to Fuck Off ASAP". That's the level of debate we have reached after less than 3 months of St Keir's Government.

It's going to be a long 5 years.
Reply
#89
You do realise that line doesn't work on me as I didn't vote for Labour, right?

And do you seriously think that a party that was going through the motions and had done so little were going to anything meaningful with an extra four months? They bet the house on Rwanda ffs, the complete shambles that was last years energy auction showed just how unserious they were.
Reply
#90
(09-26-2024, 04:24 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: "The Conservatives as a party needed to Fuck Off ASAP". That's the level of debate we have reached after less than 3 months of St Keir's Government.

It's going to be a long 5 years.

Arf.

(09-26-2024, 04:00 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I'm not looking to change your opinion. I'm calling you out for ignoring my opinion.

I've corrected that for you.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)