Israel/Hezzbolah
(09-20-2024, 05:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-20-2024, 02:29 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote: Muslims all over the world rise as one at the injustice they perceive and that is why it's a tinderbox in that region. 

Have they risen as one against the injustice against Uyghurs?

Do they not perceive injustice to be occurring in Afghanistan, Syria, Egypt, Iran, Somalia?

It seems to me that the only injustices Muslims all over the world rise as one for are those they accuse Israel of, the US and to a lesser extent the rest of the liberal western world.

If Muslims are truly concerned about injustice everywhere it exists, then I suggest a little self reflection may be in order.

Not this whataboutery again.

As has been explained several times on here, Muslims and and others in the West are on the streets protesting, because our government's are actively funding and arming the Israeli state.

Of the countries you have listed

1)Muslim states took in more Syrian refugees then anywhere else: https://www.statista.com/statistics/7402...20refugees.

2)As bad as all those other countries are in terms of human rights, they haven't slaughtered 40,000 people in the last 11 months. Israel has and it shows no signs of stopping the slaughter any time soon.

3)I find it very peculiar to demonising Muslims in particular, when the vast majority of UN member states have condemned the Israeli occupation of Palestine, becusse to them it seems like little more than a 21st century version of an apartheid state:
https://news.un.org/en/story/2024/09/1154391


4)As always, if you really, really cared about the wellbeing about the Israeli state as you claim to do, you would be more focused on the increasingly deranged people in positions of power there:

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/israel-hama...e-protest/
Reply
(09-20-2024, 05:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-20-2024, 02:29 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote: Muslims all over the world rise as one at the injustice they perceive and that is why it's a tinderbox in that region. 

Have they risen as one against the injustice against Uyghurs?

Do they not perceive injustice to be occurring in Afghanistan, Syria, Egypt, Iran, Somalia?

It seems to me that the only injustices Muslims all over the world rise as one for are those they accuse Israel of, the US and to a lesser extent the rest of the liberal western world.

If Muslims are truly concerned about injustice everywhere it exists, then I suggest a little self reflection may be in order.

(09-20-2024, 06:28 PM)Squid Wrote:
(09-20-2024, 05:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-20-2024, 02:29 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote: Muslims all over the world rise as one at the injustice they perceive and that is why it's a tinderbox in that region. 

Have they risen as one against the injustice against Uyghurs?

Do they not perceive injustice to be occurring in Afghanistan, Syria, Egypt, Iran, Somalia?

It seems to me that the only injustices Muslims all over the world rise as one for are those they accuse Israel of, the US and to a lesser extent the rest of the liberal western world.

If Muslims are truly concerned about injustice everywhere it exists, then I suggest a little self reflection may be in order.

Not this whataboutery again.

As has been explained several times on here, Muslims and and others in the West are on the streets protesting, because our government's are actively funding and arming the Israeli state.

Of the countries you have listed

1)Muslim states took in more Syrian refugees then anywhere else: https://www.statista.com/statistics/7402...20refugees.

2)As bad as all those other countries are in terms of human rights, they haven't slaughtered 40,000 people in the last 11 months. Israel has and it shows no signs of stopping the slaughter any time soon.

3)I find it very peculiar to demonising Muslims in particular,  when the vast majority of UN member states have condemned the Israeli occupation of Palestine, becusse to them it seems like little more than a 21st century version of an apartheid state:
https://news.un.org/en/story/2024/09/1154391


4)As always, if you really, really cared about the wellbeing about the Israeli state as you claim to do, you would be more focused on the increasingly deranged people in positions of power there:

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/israel-hama...e-protest/
They haven't because it hardly gets any mainstream media attention.

If it had they would have protested.

4) I don't know why it's been said on here that I support Israel, because I don't support either side. I said that the politicians in Israel are doing it to stay in power and actually mentioned Netanyahu.com and Ben-Gvir, both evil scumbags imo. They are driven by the religious zealots, and if they weren't doing what they were doing they would lose power.

Again it is religion.

Like I have said, many times on here, I feel sorry for the innocent loss of life and anyone who wouldn't is feel like that is a disgrace of a human being.

I think people are easily manipulated by the likes of Tommy Robinson and that hook handed guy Abu Hamza I think, and the internet and social media helps to fuel the hate. 

Those being manipulated by the Islamic fundamentalists are told to hate anyone who isn't Muslim.

If you think all the protests about Gaza here are about targeting the likes of Barclays, you are gravely mistaken.

They feel their brothers and sisters are being persecuted, and the more radicalised are actually going over to fight for them.
Reply
(09-20-2024, 06:28 PM)Squid Wrote: Not this whataboutery again.

Hmm. Injustice is injustice wherever it occurs. Wouldn't you agree?

I suppose one of the reasons Muslims don't protest about injustice in their own countries is simply because they'll be jailed, or much much worse.

And please don't accuse me of demonising Muslims. I'm happily guilty of demonising Islamist regimes who channel perceived injustices against Muslims for their own ends, but that's very different.

Let's be honest, what's kicked off in Israel and the occupied territories was initially a reaction to the enlightened self interest of those Arab states willing to make peace with Israel. Iran can't have that now, can it? What has followed is appalling bloodshed, for everyone apart from the very regimes who stirred the pot.

And the peaceniks reckon it can be solved by talking about a two state solution when neither Iran nor Israel has the slightest interest in that outcome.

Also Squid, it's worth noting that Turkey is a secular state, not Islamic and definitely not Islamist - even if for the time being it does have a Sultan in charge.
Reply
(09-20-2024, 07:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-20-2024, 06:28 PM)Squid Wrote: Not this whataboutery again.

Hmm. Injustice is injustice wherever it occurs. Wouldn't you agree?

I suppose one of the reasons Muslims don't protest about injustice in their own countries is simply because they'll be jailed, or much much worse.

And please don't accuse me of demonising Muslims. I'm happily guilty of demonising Islamist regimes who channel perceived injustices against Muslims for their own ends, but that's very different.

Let's be honest, what's kicked off in Israel and the occupied territories was initially a reaction to the enlightened self interest of those Arab states willing to make peace with Israel. Iran can't have that now, can it? What has followed is appalling bloodshed, for everyone apart from the very regimes who stirred the pot.

And the peaceniks reckon it can be solved by talking about a two state solution when neither Iran nor Israel has the slightest interest in that outcome.

Also Squid, it's worth noting that Turkey is a secular state, not Islamic and definitely not Islamist - even if for the time being it does have a Sultan in charge.

Whilst those who support the conflict think you can bomb your way to peace… ffs
Reply
It's a bugger, ay it Dekka.
Reply
(09-20-2024, 07:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-20-2024, 06:28 PM)Squid Wrote: Not this whataboutery again.

Hmm. Injustice is injustice wherever it occurs. Wouldn't you agree?

I suppose one of the reasons Muslims don't protest about injustice in their own countries is simply because they'll be jailed, or much much worse.

And please don't accuse me of demonising Muslims. I'm happily guilty of demonising Islamist regimes who channel perceived injustices against Muslims for their own ends, but that's very different.

Let's be honest, what's kicked off in Israel and the occupied territories was initially a reaction to the enlightened self interest of those Arab states willing to make peace with Israel. Iran can't have that now, can it? What has followed is appalling bloodshed, for everyone apart from the very regimes who stirred the pot.

And the peaceniks reckon it can be solved by talking about a two state solution when neither Iran nor Israel has the slightest interest in that outcome.

Also Squid, it's worth noting that Turkey is a secular state , not Islamic and definitely not Islamist - even if for the time being it does have a Sultan in charge.

Erdogan is slowly trying to change that, though.
Reply
(09-20-2024, 07:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-20-2024, 06:28 PM)Squid Wrote: Not this whataboutery again.

Hmm. Injustice is injustice wherever it occurs. Wouldn't you agree?

I suppose one of the reasons Muslims don't protest about injustice in their own countries is simply because they'll be jailed, or much much worse.

And please don't accuse me of demonising Muslims. I'm happily guilty of demonising Islamist regimes who channel perceived injustices against Muslims for their own ends, but that's very different.

Let's be honest, what's kicked off in Israel and the occupied territories was initially a reaction to the enlightened self interest of those Arab states willing to make peace with Israel. Iran can't have that now, can it? What has followed is appalling bloodshed, for everyone apart from the very regimes who stirred the pot.

And the peaceniks reckon it can be solved by talking about a two state solution when neither Iran nor Israel has the slightest interest in that outcome.

Also Squid, it's worth noting that Turkey is a secular state, not Islamic and definitely not Islamist - even if for the time being it does have a Sultan in charge.

You seem to  be completely skirting around the issue of Israel illegally occupying Palestinian territory and comittting endless human rights abuses, which has been taking place long before 7th October, which is not a sustainable situation.
Only this week, a bunch of Israeli settlers attacked two primary schools in the West Bank: 
https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-eas...024-09-17/

The despots du jour can "normalise" as they wish*, they don't speak for their populations and until there is a just settlement for the Palestinian people, there will never be peace.

And again, I'm old enough (just) to remember the excuses people made for Apartheid era South Africa. It was the only democracy in the region, what a well-functioning country, that the Black population wasn't capable of government and were violent terrorists, that people unfairly focused on South Africa, instead of all the suffering elsewhere. Those arguments have aged very poorly, just as those supporting Israel's actions have. 

It's very depressing to watch this clip and realise it's over 35 years old:  
https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x31a50a
*There won't be any further normalisation for the foreseeable future, btw the public backlash would be too great.
Reply
(09-20-2024, 09:53 PM)Squid Wrote:
(09-20-2024, 07:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-20-2024, 06:28 PM)Squid Wrote: Not this whataboutery again.

Hmm. Injustice is injustice wherever it occurs. Wouldn't you agree?

I suppose one of the reasons Muslims don't protest about injustice in their own countries is simply because they'll be jailed, or much much worse.

And please don't accuse me of demonising Muslims. I'm happily guilty of demonising Islamist regimes who channel perceived injustices against Muslims for their own ends, but that's very different.

Let's be honest, what's kicked off in Israel and the occupied territories was initially a reaction to the enlightened self interest of those Arab states willing to make peace with Israel. Iran can't have that now, can it? What has followed is appalling bloodshed, for everyone apart from the very regimes who stirred the pot.

And the peaceniks reckon it can be solved by talking about a two state solution when neither Iran nor Israel has the slightest interest in that outcome.

Also Squid, it's worth noting that Turkey is a secular state, not Islamic and definitely not Islamist - even if for the time being it does have a Sultan in charge.

You seem to  be completely skirting around the issue of Israel illegally occupying Palestinian territory and comittting endless human rights abuses, which has been taking place long before 7th October, which is not a sustainable situation.
Only this week, a bunch of Israeli settlers attacked two primary schools in the West Bank: 
https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-eas...024-09-17/

The despots du jour can "normalise" as they wish*, they don't speak for their populations and until there is a just settlement for the Palestinian people, there will never be peace.

And again, I'm old enough (just) to remember the excuses people made for Apartheid era South Africa. It was the only democracy in the region, what a well-functioning country, that the Black population wasn't capable of government and were violent terrorists, that people unfairly focused on South Africa, instead of all the suffering elsewhere. Those arguments have aged very poorly, just as those supporting Israel's actions have. 

It's very depressing to watch this clip and realise it's over 35 years old:  
https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x31a50a
*There won't be any further normalisation for the foreseeable future, btw the public backlash would be too great.

I'm not skirting around anything, I'm just at a loss to suggest what anyone can practically do about it when the leaders of both sides are fully invested in eternal conflict and endless abuses. If you have an idea I'd be pleased to hear it.

I don't recall any serious excuses for Apartheid as I was growing up. Though the ANC has shown itself to be thoroughly unfit for government and non-tourist South Africa is a barely functioning and violent experience for most black South Africans, whereas its leaders have grown fat off typical African governance based on corruption and political patronage. Echoes of the PA in the West Bank, perhaps.
Reply
(09-21-2024, 11:57 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-20-2024, 09:53 PM)Squid Wrote:
(09-20-2024, 07:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-20-2024, 06:28 PM)Squid Wrote: Not this whataboutery again.

Hmm. Injustice is injustice wherever it occurs. Wouldn't you agree?

I suppose one of the reasons Muslims don't protest about injustice in their own countries is simply because they'll be jailed, or much much worse.

And please don't accuse me of demonising Muslims. I'm happily guilty of demonising Islamist regimes who channel perceived injustices against Muslims for their own ends, but that's very different.

Let's be honest, what's kicked off in Israel and the occupied territories was initially a reaction to the enlightened self interest of those Arab states willing to make peace with Israel. Iran can't have that now, can it? What has followed is appalling bloodshed, for everyone apart from the very regimes who stirred the pot.

And the peaceniks reckon it can be solved by talking about a two state solution when neither Iran nor Israel has the slightest interest in that outcome.

Also Squid, it's worth noting that Turkey is a secular state, not Islamic and definitely not Islamist - even if for the time being it does have a Sultan in charge.

You seem to  be completely skirting around the issue of Israel illegally occupying Palestinian territory and comittting endless human rights abuses, which has been taking place long before 7th October, which is not a sustainable situation.
Only this week, a bunch of Israeli settlers attacked two primary schools in the West Bank: 
https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-eas...024-09-17/

The despots du jour can "normalise" as they wish*, they don't speak for their populations and until there is a just settlement for the Palestinian people, there will never be peace.

And again, I'm old enough (just) to remember the excuses people made for Apartheid era South Africa. It was the only democracy in the region, what a well-functioning country, that the Black population wasn't capable of government and were violent terrorists, that people unfairly focused on South Africa, instead of all the suffering elsewhere. Those arguments have aged very poorly, just as those supporting Israel's actions have. 

It's very depressing to watch this clip and realise it's over 35 years old:  
https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x31a50a
*There won't be any further normalisation for the foreseeable future, btw the public backlash would be too great.

I'm not skirting around anything, I'm just at a loss to suggest what anyone can practically do about it when the leaders of both sides are fully invested in eternal conflict and endless abuses. If you have an idea I'd be pleased to hear it.

I don't recall any serious excuses for Apartheid as I was growing up. Though the ANC has shown itself to be thoroughly unfit for government and non-tourist South Africa is a barely functioning and violent experience for most black South Africans, whereas its leaders have grown fat off typical African governance based on corruption and political patronage. Echoes of the PA in the West Bank, perhaps.

Living under Israeli occupation in West Bank is absolutely nothing like living in South Africa. Freedom House agrees which is why the West Bank has a score of 22/100 and is rated Not Free and South Africa has a score of 79/100 and is rated Free.

See for yourself:

https://freedomhouse.org/country/west-bank

https://freedomhouse.org/country/south-a...world/2024
Reply
(09-21-2024, 12:44 PM)Squid Wrote: Living under Israeli occupation in West Bank is absolutely nothing like living in South Africa.

Where did I say that it was? I implied the PA was similar to the corrupt ANC.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)