Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(09-20-2024, 09:52 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (09-20-2024, 09:42 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (09-20-2024, 09:27 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (09-20-2024, 09:13 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (09-20-2024, 09:12 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: This needs a proper impact assessment
No it doesn't. The evidence is already available from other major economies around the world.
"This needs a proper impact assessment to ascertain the negative effects and determine the actual effects and" the scale of the tiered system required and how best to manage the trade offs"
I know it inconveniences you to actually address the point people are making but can you at least not selectively quote me? Just because other countries do it does not mean that there won't be negative effects were we to do it and as a result if we do it we need to know how best to manage implementing it to prevent things bank charges being hiked up massively overnight on customers.
I think you ought to explain exactly what you mean by the "tiered system" required, as I'm not sure we're talking about the same thing.
Tiered reserves remuneration is the exact system that the BoJ and ECB have (and the BoE used to have) to separate the policy rate from interest serving costs for the government. Currently we do not have a tiered system.
Was this not what you were on about? Because it's what RefUK were on about.
You'll have to explain why that would have any effect on bank charges?
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(09-20-2024, 10:35 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (09-20-2024, 09:52 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (09-20-2024, 09:42 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (09-20-2024, 09:27 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (09-20-2024, 09:13 AM)Protheroe Wrote: No it doesn't. The evidence is already available from other major economies around the world.
"This needs a proper impact assessment to ascertain the negative effects and determine the actual effects and" the scale of the tiered system required and how best to manage the trade offs"
I know it inconveniences you to actually address the point people are making but can you at least not selectively quote me? Just because other countries do it does not mean that there won't be negative effects were we to do it and as a result if we do it we need to know how best to manage implementing it to prevent things bank charges being hiked up massively overnight on customers.
I think you ought to explain exactly what you mean by the "tiered system" required, as I'm not sure we're talking about the same thing.
Tiered reserves remuneration is the exact system that the BoJ and ECB have (and the BoE used to have) to separate the policy rate from interest serving costs for the government. Currently we do not have a tiered system.
Was this not what you were on about? Because it's what RefUK were on about.
You'll have to explain why that would have any effect on bank charges?
So not only do you not know the name of what you were advocating but the effects of it? Seriously? Do you even know how it works?
The losses have to be made up somewhere, they don't just disappear. The losses will be made up by the commercial banks losing their effective subsidy and it's very unlikely they'll just eat them up especially at that scale - so they'll up charges on customers to make up at least some of the difference. Hence why I said there needs to be an impact assessment to know how best to manage that, such as phasing in the renumeration rate change and the reserve requirement - you don't just set the rate at 0% and the reserve requirement at 10% overnight. There's lots of variables that you need to model the impact of to set targets and timescales, just because other countries do it (note, those other countries and the ECB have differing rates and reserves requirements) doesn't mean you can switch it on and off like a switch - you need to transition.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
09-20-2024, 11:25 AM
(This post was last modified: 09-20-2024, 11:26 AM by Protheroe.)
This is the whole point BB. Why is the BoE subsidising commercial banks by paying the base rate on reserve deposits? Your beloved ECB doesn't, and actually applied negative interest rates on excess reserves. The impact on the general public and businesses will be so broadly based as to be minuscule - at most a modest broadening of the margin between savings and loan rates.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
My beloved ECB? What the hell are you on about? I'm not a Eurofederalist and I never advocated joining the Euro.
I've not once disputed the principal of adoption a tiered system, what I said (if you'd bothered to read what I've said which you clearly haven't) is we need to do it properly and we need an impact assessment to establish a strategy. The SNB, BoJ and ECB all have a tiered system but it's not the same (for example, ECB has a 1% reserve requirement and the SNB have a 2.5% reserve requirement), and not gradually bringing it in will have a much bigger effect on how commercial banks handle it compared to if it's done gradually and sensibly.
And forgive me for not trusting the word of someone who doesn't even know the name of the thing they're advocating on the impact of it, even the NEF (who have published several reports in favour of doing it) have said there will be a substantial effect on bank charges to make up for lost subsidy. Your "at most" assumption is a complete guess with zero evidential basis especially as it doesn't factor in variances between rates and reserves as well as timeframes.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(09-20-2024, 11:25 AM)Protheroe Wrote: This is the whole point BB. Why is the BoE subsidising commercial banks by paying the base rate on reserve deposits? Your beloved ECB doesn't, and actually applied negative interest rates on excess reserves. The impact on the general public and businesses will be so broadly based as to be minuscule - at most a modest broadening of the margin between savings and loan rates.
Sounds like Basle II all over again.
Just read the headlines in the FT - haven't they found her an additional £10bn? Wonder which Public Servants that will go to.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
09-20-2024, 12:18 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-20-2024, 12:18 PM by Protheroe.)
(09-20-2024, 11:38 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: And forgive me for not trusting the word of someone who doesn't even know the name of the thing they're advocating on the impact of it, even the NEF (who have published several reports in favour of doing it) have said there will be a substantial effect on bank charges to make up for lost subsidy. Your "at most" assumption is a complete guess with zero evidential basis especially as it doesn't factor in variances between rates and reserves as well as timeframes.
Personally I'd prefer the poorest weren't subsiding bank profits, but that's just me. There is competition (not enough) that'll keep a lid on charges.
(09-20-2024, 11:44 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Just read the headlines in the FT - haven't they found her an additional £10bn? Wonder which Public Servants that will go to.
They're currently forming a disorderly queue.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
09-20-2024, 12:27 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-20-2024, 12:28 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(09-20-2024, 12:18 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (09-20-2024, 11:38 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: And forgive me for not trusting the word of someone who doesn't even know the name of the thing they're advocating on the impact of it, even the NEF (who have published several reports in favour of doing it) have said there will be a substantial effect on bank charges to make up for lost subsidy. Your "at most" assumption is a complete guess with zero evidential basis especially as it doesn't factor in variances between rates and reserves as well as timeframes.
Personally I'd prefer the poorest weren't subsiding bank profits, but that's just me. There is competition (not enough) that'll keep a lid on charges.
If every single bank applies charges due to the effective subsidy winding down too quickly for them to adjust it won't. Things don't operate in a vacuum. When the people who have been pushing for this have explained that charges will go up to cover at least some extent of the loss of effective subsidy then it's a pretty confident assertion that they will go up. Which is why you need an impact assessment to mitigate against that and provide the best strategy to enable competition instead of a shock to the system.
I think it's pretty telling that you have no answer for this and you are trying to justify your position by pretending that I'm against this just because I want it to be done reasonably instead of reading what I have said or even any of the NEF's policy papers on it (they're available publicly if you want to educate yourself). The people who actually know what they're talking about expect bank customers to make up some extent of the difference and that extent depends on how botched or not implementation is. Also very telling that you've decided to not quote anything from my second paragraph so you can attempt to ignore it.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
Did the NEF have anything to say about LDIs before they blew up in everyone's face? Anything about Yenmaggedon? The ditching of bank subsidies is far more predictable then either, and the effect is likely to be modest and more on lending margins than charges.
There is not a cartel in banking (albeit Brown & Osborne's stupidity means we still have too few and too big banks) - so the CMA could ensure cartel behaviour does not ensue on charges.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
You have zero evidence base for your assumption, you are basing your assumption based on RefUK's flawed interpretation of NEF's own report and now you're attacking the NEF for bothering to model the thing you're arguing for in their attempt to justify that it is something we should do on the basis that they are saying it needs to be done properly to manage the fallout on bank customers which you disagree with despite having zero evidence basis for to challenge their numbers or even having read their report (evidenced by the fact that you didn't even know the name of the thing you were arguing for which the NEF uses in their report), just a hunch and a hope.
You clearly haven't thought this through well enough. What's the % we should go for regarding the reserve requirement? 1%? 2.5%? 5%? 10%? And what should the rate be set at? 1%? 0.5%? 0%? And how quickly should we set that rate from the current rate?
And there doesn't need to be a cartel for a sudden shock to cause identical behaviours across the market, and the markets can stabilise and mitigate those costs through a gradual implementation.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(09-20-2024, 03:30 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: You clearly haven't thought this through well enough. What's the % we should go for regarding the reserve requirement? 1%? 2.5%? 5%? 10%? And what should the rate be set at? 1%? 0.5%? 0%? And how quickly should we set that rate from the current rate?
Well I'm not the Chancellor am I? I have a day job.
The point stands, at the moment all taxpayers are on the hook subsidising bank profits. I wonder how many of them appreciate that?
|