09-16-2024, 07:10 AM
Arresting people for expressing opinions online belongs in a Kafka tale not a liberal democracy
Tomiwa Owolade
Monday September 16 2024, 12.01am, The Times
I don’t like being told what to think. It makes me feel trapped. This is why I am amused whenever I am called a coon. Or a house negro. Or an Uncle Tom. Or a coconut. Terms which imply I am acting out of subservience to a “white establishment” or controlled like a puppet; nothing could be further from the truth. I think what I think on matters of race because I have independently come to my conclusions.
But I am sometimes described as a race traitor because I think racism is not the only factor that explains inequality in society. That we shouldn’t reduce anyone to their racial identity. I am a moral universalist. And I think the term anti-racist, which should be a noble one, has been tarnished by many who claim to embody its principles.
Consider the case of Marieha Hussain. In November 2023 the schoolteacher from High Wycombe was attending a pro-Palestine rally and carrying a placard that showed images of Rishi Sunak (then prime minister) and Suella Braverman (then home secretary) imposed on coconuts beneath a palm tree.
A coconut is brown on the outside and white on the inside. To describe a black or brown person as a coconut is to suggest that they have betrayed their race: that their allegiance is to white people rather than other brown people. No amount of sophistry can excuse the fact that this is a racial slur. It is abusing someone based on their race instead of their intelligence or character or any other aspect of their individual personality.
Hussain was charged in May this year with committing a racially aggravated public order offence. She was acquitted last week at Westminster magistrates’ court. Outside the court, she said: “The damage done to my reputation and image can never be undone.” She added: “This ordeal has been agonising for my family and I. Instead of enjoying my pregnancy I’ve been vilified by the media, I’ve lost my career, I’ve been dragged through the court system.”
Her defence of the placard was that she was engaged in political satire. She wasn’t being racist against Sunak and Braverman, she was merely mocking them for pursuing racist immigration policies while being the children of immigrants. This defence is nonsense. The meaning of the term “coconut” in the context in which Hussain was using it is clear to anyone.
Kehinde Andrews does not claim to be satirical when he describes black or brown people as race traitors. He is the first professor of black studies in the UK. For him, racism is a fundamental aspect of British society. Any account of inequality in Britain, or in the West more generally, which doesn’t see race as the essential aspect of it is worthless. His latest book is entitled The Psychosis of Whiteness.
Andrews was invited by the Metropolitan Police in April to be an expert in a Crown Prosecution Service review into whether Hussain’s placard was a racist slur. Unsurprisingly, he didn’t think it was. According to Andrews, terms like “coon” and “house negro”, “Uncle Tom” and “coconut” are not racial slurs but “vital expressions of black political thought that should be celebrated and not policed”. And Andrews is himself facing a criminal investigation for calling the right-wing commentator Calvin Robinson a “house negro”.
Earlier this month, three police officers came to Andrews’s house in Birmingham after Robinson filed a complaint. West Midlands police told The Independent: “We’ve received a report of racist comments being posted online and we’re carrying out inquiries. There is no place for hate crime and we’ll investigate any reports we receive.”
But what is even more shameful than describing black and brown people as race traitors is being criminalised for doing so. It is scandalous that the police are coming into the homes of people for opinions they have expressed online: this is a scenario more befitting a fable by Franz Kafka than a society that claims to be a liberal democracy.
Hussain and Andrews should not be punished by the law. Freedom of speech is the foundation of all the other freedoms — to think, to dispute, to discover, to be. Hate speech laws are abused so often that they now perform the same role as blasphemy laws did in the past: what constitutes hateful is often to the person charged with such an offence a legitimate moral or political point of view.
Hate speech laws should be scrapped for written or published remarks. Expressions that are offensive should not fall under the jurisdiction of the law but should, as far as they are genuinely offensive, be condemned by wider society.
Disliking being told what to think — my guiding principle — also means rejecting the prosecution of speech I or anyone else may consider offensive. We need to be stricter about what kinds of views should be scrutinised by the law. Five years ago a police officer called Harry Miller was investigated and visited by the police for committing a “non-crime hate incident” because he retweeted an allegedly transphobic song.
Andrews once reviewed my book This is Not America and described me as “tap dancing for white people”. If someone reported him to the police for his review, I would be even more offended than by the racist insult he directed against me. What gives me dignity is the freedom to express my views, and that freedom is only meaningful if it is universally extended.
It serves no one to criminalise the speech of Andrews and his ilk. A more powerful way of undercutting their arguments is through contrary speech: emphasising that the only way to reach a genuinely anti-racist place is not through bitterness and division but by affirming a common humanity.
Tomiwa Owolade
Monday September 16 2024, 12.01am, The Times
I don’t like being told what to think. It makes me feel trapped. This is why I am amused whenever I am called a coon. Or a house negro. Or an Uncle Tom. Or a coconut. Terms which imply I am acting out of subservience to a “white establishment” or controlled like a puppet; nothing could be further from the truth. I think what I think on matters of race because I have independently come to my conclusions.
But I am sometimes described as a race traitor because I think racism is not the only factor that explains inequality in society. That we shouldn’t reduce anyone to their racial identity. I am a moral universalist. And I think the term anti-racist, which should be a noble one, has been tarnished by many who claim to embody its principles.
Consider the case of Marieha Hussain. In November 2023 the schoolteacher from High Wycombe was attending a pro-Palestine rally and carrying a placard that showed images of Rishi Sunak (then prime minister) and Suella Braverman (then home secretary) imposed on coconuts beneath a palm tree.
A coconut is brown on the outside and white on the inside. To describe a black or brown person as a coconut is to suggest that they have betrayed their race: that their allegiance is to white people rather than other brown people. No amount of sophistry can excuse the fact that this is a racial slur. It is abusing someone based on their race instead of their intelligence or character or any other aspect of their individual personality.
Hussain was charged in May this year with committing a racially aggravated public order offence. She was acquitted last week at Westminster magistrates’ court. Outside the court, she said: “The damage done to my reputation and image can never be undone.” She added: “This ordeal has been agonising for my family and I. Instead of enjoying my pregnancy I’ve been vilified by the media, I’ve lost my career, I’ve been dragged through the court system.”
Her defence of the placard was that she was engaged in political satire. She wasn’t being racist against Sunak and Braverman, she was merely mocking them for pursuing racist immigration policies while being the children of immigrants. This defence is nonsense. The meaning of the term “coconut” in the context in which Hussain was using it is clear to anyone.
Kehinde Andrews does not claim to be satirical when he describes black or brown people as race traitors. He is the first professor of black studies in the UK. For him, racism is a fundamental aspect of British society. Any account of inequality in Britain, or in the West more generally, which doesn’t see race as the essential aspect of it is worthless. His latest book is entitled The Psychosis of Whiteness.
Andrews was invited by the Metropolitan Police in April to be an expert in a Crown Prosecution Service review into whether Hussain’s placard was a racist slur. Unsurprisingly, he didn’t think it was. According to Andrews, terms like “coon” and “house negro”, “Uncle Tom” and “coconut” are not racial slurs but “vital expressions of black political thought that should be celebrated and not policed”. And Andrews is himself facing a criminal investigation for calling the right-wing commentator Calvin Robinson a “house negro”.
Earlier this month, three police officers came to Andrews’s house in Birmingham after Robinson filed a complaint. West Midlands police told The Independent: “We’ve received a report of racist comments being posted online and we’re carrying out inquiries. There is no place for hate crime and we’ll investigate any reports we receive.”
But what is even more shameful than describing black and brown people as race traitors is being criminalised for doing so. It is scandalous that the police are coming into the homes of people for opinions they have expressed online: this is a scenario more befitting a fable by Franz Kafka than a society that claims to be a liberal democracy.
Hussain and Andrews should not be punished by the law. Freedom of speech is the foundation of all the other freedoms — to think, to dispute, to discover, to be. Hate speech laws are abused so often that they now perform the same role as blasphemy laws did in the past: what constitutes hateful is often to the person charged with such an offence a legitimate moral or political point of view.
Hate speech laws should be scrapped for written or published remarks. Expressions that are offensive should not fall under the jurisdiction of the law but should, as far as they are genuinely offensive, be condemned by wider society.
Disliking being told what to think — my guiding principle — also means rejecting the prosecution of speech I or anyone else may consider offensive. We need to be stricter about what kinds of views should be scrutinised by the law. Five years ago a police officer called Harry Miller was investigated and visited by the police for committing a “non-crime hate incident” because he retweeted an allegedly transphobic song.
Andrews once reviewed my book This is Not America and described me as “tap dancing for white people”. If someone reported him to the police for his review, I would be even more offended than by the racist insult he directed against me. What gives me dignity is the freedom to express my views, and that freedom is only meaningful if it is universally extended.
It serves no one to criminalise the speech of Andrews and his ilk. A more powerful way of undercutting their arguments is through contrary speech: emphasising that the only way to reach a genuinely anti-racist place is not through bitterness and division but by affirming a common humanity.


