Man City punishment
#41
(09-14-2024, 07:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 11:36 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 10:59 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Man City haven't just bought success, Man Utd and Chelsea outspend them.

They bought in Pep Guardiola and built an entire club around him, that's what has made them invincible, it's boring, as boring as the football they play, and sorry, it is dull football, very, very effective, but dull.

Because other teams have been punished, now they have to be, but I don't take joy in that since I am vehemently against FFP, it doesn't protect clubs at all.

I have no love for City, or any of the biggest clubs at all, and never have done because they have always been bullies and made sure the game was rigged in their favour, nothing has changed, it's just Man City are better at it all than anyone else, in their limited credit, they don't do some of the more disgusting behaviours, they always buy youth products if they want one from another team, and rarely quibble over money, as we had with Morgan Rogers. Compare this to what Chelsea, Villa and Liverpool did when they wanted our youth players.

Someday football will eat itself, but it's not soon sadly.

Sorry but you have to tow the party line and hate Man city and ignore everything that went before them, and the facts I have already outline here before.

It's the modern age of fucking the facts to jump on the bandwagon and joining the witch hunt.

I don't give a flying fuck about city and still hate the money we wasted on Mills, but I am not thick enough to see what is really going on with FFP.

As such I have started a petition to burn Guardiola and his ex Barca minions like Trixi Bergenstein whose names I am too pissed to spell, on bonfire night.

Please sign the petition, as if we get to 100,000 parliament will massdebate it and it could happen, and it can be found at:

Thickcuntbelievesanyshitpeddled@gov.uk

Don’t drink and post fellow posters. 

I doubt anyone thinks FFP is fair to clubs with owners looking to invest but you are comparing Fred the Butchers investment in a football club in the 70s/80s with a club spending billions of money generated by an oil rich state. It has completely skewed football in this country and the idea we can all dream of another oil rich state or similar swooping in and spending obscene amounts of money on them is hardly the stuff of dreams it makes football secondary to billionaires vanity.

Simply the whole football ecosystem goes to shit at the very top of the game. 

Man City are the greatest example of this.

Defending their spend v other clubs is just a joke. Over the past 15 years or so since the Arabs bought them they’ve used brown envelopes, dodgy accounting and all manner of other tricks to gain an advantage. 

They have players worth multi millions who can’t get on the bench as their wealth is so vast.

I don’t know what kind of punishment is really fitting for them as all relegations will do is close down one promotion spot each season to teams run properly in the divisions below.

115 charges including 35 of not cooperating or compliance with the rules and some still think that’s ok!
Reply
#42
I've mentioned on here before about the guy I know that follows villa and got ejected from his long time seat for corporate interlopers. That situation has gone from bad to worse but is a typical example of what the hunger for success does to the genuine fans of these clubs. Disabled parking spaces at villa have now doubled in price, the stadium is falling to pieces apart from the "exclusive" parts. Unai Emery defends the increases saying difficult as it seems, they need the money to compete.
For me, the change could come in the form of a players wages cap. This is where almost all of the money goes. Some form of equitable wages ceiling coupled with limits on players signed, a better protection for Academy products and a genuine desire from the authorities to see a more sporting approach, should be the basis for change. I won't hold my breath.
Reply
#43
(09-14-2024, 10:26 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I've mentioned on here before about the guy I know that follows villa and got ejected from his long time seat for corporate interlopers. That situation has gone from bad to worse but is a typical example of what the hunger for success does to the genuine fans of these clubs. Disabled parking spaces at villa have now doubled in price, the stadium is falling to pieces apart from the "exclusive" parts. Unai Emery defends the increases saying difficult as it seems, they need the money to compete.
For me, the change could come in the form of a players wages cap. This is where almost all of the money goes. Some form of equitable wages ceiling coupled with limits on players signed, a better protection for Academy products and a genuine desire from the authorities to see a more sporting approach, should be the basis for change. I won't hold my breath.

Yes but did they give bad meat to their own players?
Reply
#44
(09-14-2024, 10:26 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I've mentioned on here before about the guy I know that follows villa and got ejected from his long time seat for corporate interlopers. That situation has gone from bad to worse but is a typical example of what the hunger for success does to the genuine fans of these clubs. Disabled parking spaces at villa have now doubled in price, the stadium is falling to pieces apart from the "exclusive" parts. Unai Emery defends the increases saying difficult as it seems, they need the money to compete.
For me, the change could come in the form of a players wages cap. This is where almost all of the money goes. Some form of equitable wages ceiling coupled with limits on players signed, a better protection for Academy products and a genuine desire from the authorities to see a more sporting approach, should be the basis for change. I won't hold my breath.

Good post TJ.

As has been said, the modern game has taken away the dreams of all supporters of clubs outside the chosen few, who are just global marketing brands.

As a kid in the 70s I dreamt of seeing Albion win the league and it was feasible. I dreamt of them winning the cup when it mattered.

Now a chosen few scoop up the trophies and clubs like us are left dreaming of becoming a top 8 club that might one day play Real Sociedad or Udinese on a Thursday night as the height of our possibilities.
Reply
#45
(09-14-2024, 10:33 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(09-14-2024, 10:26 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I've mentioned on here before about the guy I know that follows villa and got ejected from his long time seat for corporate interlopers. That situation has gone from bad to worse but is a typical example of what the hunger for success does to the genuine fans of these clubs. Disabled parking spaces at villa have now doubled in price, the stadium is falling to pieces apart from the "exclusive" parts. Unai Emery defends the increases saying difficult as it seems, they need the money to compete.
For me, the change could come in the form of a players wages cap. This is where almost all of the money goes. Some form of equitable wages ceiling coupled with limits on players signed, a better protection for Academy products and a genuine desire from the authorities to see a more sporting approach, should be the basis for change. I won't hold my breath.

Good post TJ.

As has been said, the modern game has taken away the dreams of all supporters of clubs outside the chosen few, who are just global marketing brands.

As a kid in the 70s I dreamt of seeing Albion win the league and it was feasible. I dreamt of them winning the cup when it mattered.

Now a chosen few scoop up the trophies and clubs like us are left dreaming of becoming a top 8 club that might one day play Real Sociedad or Udinese on a Thursday night as the height of our possibilities.

Agree with the above.

We used to have real hopes of a major cup or even Europe.
Now it’s virtually impossible and I won’t see it  again in my lifetime.
Reply
#46
I imagine Bologna fans thought the same 5 seasons ago
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#47
(09-14-2024, 10:29 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-14-2024, 10:26 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I've mentioned on here before about the guy I know that follows villa and got ejected from his long time seat for corporate interlopers. That situation has gone from bad to worse but is a typical example of what the hunger for success does to the genuine fans of these clubs. Disabled parking spaces at villa have now doubled in price, the stadium is falling to pieces apart from the "exclusive" parts. Unai Emery defends the increases saying difficult as it seems, they need the money to compete.
For me, the change could come in the form of a players wages cap. This is where almost all of the money goes. Some form of equitable wages ceiling coupled with limits on players signed, a better protection for Academy products and a genuine desire from the authorities to see a more sporting approach, should be the basis for change. I won't hold my breath.

Yes but did they give bad meat to their own players?
No, I hear they served up  cabbage for the manager once.
Reply
#48
(09-14-2024, 10:26 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I've mentioned on here before about the guy I know that follows villa and got ejected from his long time seat for corporate interlopers. That situation has gone from bad to worse but is a typical example of what the hunger for success does to the genuine fans of these clubs. Disabled parking spaces at villa have now doubled in price, the stadium is falling to pieces apart from the "exclusive" parts. Unai Emery defends the increases saying difficult as it seems, they need the money to compete.
For me, the change could come in the form of a players wages cap. This is where almost all of the money goes. Some form of equitable wages ceiling coupled with limits on players signed, a better protection for Academy products and a genuine desire from the authorities to see a more sporting approach, should be the basis for change. I won't hold my breath.
Excellent post. 
Unbridled capitalism gives us the current setup.
It's a "global brand" and all that glitter. It's taken the place of the old Italian/ Spanish hegemony. As such it's popular world wide and undoubtedly it's glamorous.
Is it just us old football farts who despise it? The modern fan is free to choose any club - even to change club. Odd to my generation, who are stuck with our club.
I suppose it won't change.
But you're right that it's the money that players get that makes all this happen.
Can you legally put a wage cap on "earnings"? 
How do the Bundesliga manage it? They keep attendance cheap and have excellent teams - though dominated by Bayern.
Anyway I hope Man city get what they deserve for what I see as cheating.
Some hope!
Reply
#49
I don’t know how accurate this is, but I’ve heard from the CEO/fellow shareholder of the business I run (the only thing I don’t like about him in fact is that he is a Chelsea fan) is that they’ve avoided the same kind-of major FFP investigation by utilising a loophole in the rules that allows you to offset major losses if you’ve made significant investments into hospitality and - in particular - hotel accommodation. If this is truly the case, the whole system stinks, because ultimately it will only benefit the best and most popular post-codes.

The King’s Road isn’t a bad place to stay. You’d have to pay me to stay near to the Etihad. What I disagree with most is the relevancy to turnover or rolling performance - it should be a level field once again. You could even introduce an exclusion from profit made via gate receipts and still have a fairer system than this.

Money ruins.
Reply
#50
(09-14-2024, 02:11 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I don’t know how accurate this is, but I’ve heard from the CEO/fellow shareholder of the business I run (the only thing I don’t like about him in fact is that he is a Chelsea fan) is that they’ve avoided the same kind-of major FFP investigation by utilising a loophole in the rules that allows you to offset major losses if you’ve made significant investments into hospitality and - in particular - hotel accommodation. If this is truly the case, the whole system stinks, because ultimately it will only benefit the best and most popular post-codes.

The King’s Road isn’t a bad place to stay. You’d have to pay me to stay near to the Etihad. What I disagree with most is the relevancy to turnover or rolling performance - it should be a level field once again. You could even introduce an exclusion from profit made via gate receipts and still have a fairer system than this.

Money ruins.

Cannot be true, could it?

The top clubs, having got into their dominant position, would never have added little loop holes to help them whilst FFP rules ensured they kept their seat at the top table.

Btw, from what I read I think it's a lot nicer around the Etihad area these days since the evil "oil money ruined everything" and the halcyon days of pools and russian gas money ruled the roost because they never spent big.

(09-14-2024, 02:59 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote:
(09-14-2024, 02:11 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I don’t know how accurate this is, but I’ve heard from the CEO/fellow shareholder of the business I run (the only thing I don’t like about him in fact is that he is a Chelsea fan) is that they’ve avoided the same kind-of major FFP investigation by utilising a loophole in the rules that allows you to offset major losses if you’ve made significant investments into hospitality and - in particular - hotel accommodation. If this is truly the case, the whole system stinks, because ultimately it will only benefit the best and most popular post-codes.

The King’s Road isn’t a bad place to stay. You’d have to pay me to stay near to the Etihad. What I disagree with most is the relevancy to turnover or rolling performance - it should be a level field once again. You could even introduce an exclusion from profit made via gate receipts and still have a fairer system than this.

Money ruins.

Cannot be true, could it?

The top clubs, having got into their dominant position, would never have added little loop holes to help them whilst FFP rules stifled competition and ensured they kept their seat at the top table.

Btw, from what I read I think it's a lot nicer around the Etihad area these days since the evil "oil money ruined everything" and the halcyon days of pools and russian gas money ruled the roost because they never spent big.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: