Things can only get crapper!
#21
How's the "don't have children until you can afford it" preaching working out? I literally just posted a report saying that the child benefit cap has not done that, ergo those kids are being born with reduced opportunities making them more likely to be reliant on welfare provisions over their lifetime. Capping child benefit isn't working on reducing the number of kids being born to parents who can't afford them so all it's contributing is making those children more reliant on state welfare for a longer period of their lives.
Reply
#22
(09-11-2024, 11:34 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-11-2024, 11:33 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-11-2024, 11:22 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: It's prettyy much peak Protheroe to wail about short termism in government and yet suggest kids should be kept in poverty due to their parents' circumstances.  He'll be asking the NHS to sort out preventative healthcare next, obliviously.

Who's keeping kids in poverty? And how will just £17 per week make all the difference?

£17 a week is the difference between a child eating three meals per day instead of two or less.

I can recommend a series, on Channel 5 I think, called "Rich House, Poor House" where "Top 1%" families trade houses, for just a week, with the bottom 10% earners of society.

The first thing that most people get is empathy, alongside a realisation that £17 does actually make a fuck load of difference to that group.  £17 to me is not the same as £17 to them.  

Then I started to become a bit Tory about it all and wonder why they weren't working (often structural disincentives) or had lots of kids and, in a LOT of instances, why they had multiple pets despite being impovershed.  Conversely, most of the poor parents worked a damn sight more hours that the rich folk - but that all links back to book which inspired the title for the series.  I digress...

And then, slowly admittedly, the little nuggets of conversations start to connect and you start to identify trends why people find themselves in bad situations.  And, yes, some of it is bad decision making.  But none of us are infallibale, it's just that some of us have a shorter distance to fall.

As far as Poverty Porn goes, it's well done.  The follow up series, where just the teenage kids swap houses, is a good window into how our own children might turn out if you perpetuate the myth that poverty is self inflicted and their own wealth is seen as a barometer of self worth, skill or status.  I'd say 7/10 of them are cunts.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#23
My point was Labour need to offer a clear and more positive message to the country. It’s all well and good politics nerds understand the situation the previous government put us in, but that won’t give them any slack when the next election rolls around. They were elected because they weren’t the previous tosspots not because they currently offer any positive hope for the future. Pragmatism is fine but we have an electorate that voted for Boris Johnson the idea that doom and gloom messages are sustainable is a naive position to take if Labour want to see in a second term.
Reply
#24
(09-11-2024, 01:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: My point was Labour need to offer a clear and more positive message to the country. It’s all well and good politics nerds understand the situation the previous government put us in, but that won’t give them any slack when the next election rolls around. They were elected because they weren’t the previous tosspots not because they currently offer any positive hope for the future. Pragmatism is fine but we have an electorate that voted for Boris Johnson the idea that doom and gloom messages are sustainable is a naive position to take if Labour want to see in a second term.

Would you like them lie instead then?
Reply
#25
(09-11-2024, 05:50 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-11-2024, 01:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: My point was Labour need to offer a clear and more positive message to the country. It’s all well and good politics nerds understand the situation the previous government put us in, but that won’t give them any slack when the next election rolls around. They were elected because they weren’t the previous tosspots not because they currently offer any positive hope for the future. Pragmatism is fine but we have an electorate that voted for Boris Johnson the idea that doom and gloom messages are sustainable is a naive position to take if Labour want to see in a second term.

Would you like them lie instead then?

I will leave that to the masters in your former party. No I expect them to give a positive vision and plan of where the country is going, unless of course the country is so broken by 14yrs with the most awful xxxxs in charge it’s beyond repair. If that’s what you’re saying and there is nothing to be positive about then what a ringing endorsement of your former party and fiends and colleagues..
Reply
#26
(09-11-2024, 01:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: My point was Labour need to offer a clear and more positive message to the country. It’s all well and good politics nerds understand the situation the previous government put us in, but that won’t give them any slack when the next election rolls around. They were elected because they weren’t the previous tosspots not because they currently offer any positive hope for the future. Pragmatism is fine but we have an electorate that voted for Boris Johnson the idea that doom and gloom messages are sustainable is a naive position to take if Labour want to see in a second term.
True but what do you think would happen?  They have inherited a country that is well and truly broken.  Pretty much everything a civilised nation needs has been cut, abandoned or sold to benefit the few.  Even dyed in the wool tories concede the last lot were beyond the pale and there will be a price to pay. Personally I don't want my kids paying any more than they absolutely have to towards the shambles. I don't agree with everything being done but I still get the feeling there is, at last, someone willing to behave responsibly. I say that as someone that would soon have been getting a winter fuel allowance but now is not! I think they would have done better by cutting it for all bar the lower council tax bands and I think it will be forever thrown back at them.
Reply
#27
(09-11-2024, 06:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-11-2024, 05:50 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-11-2024, 01:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: My point was Labour need to offer a clear and more positive message to the country. It’s all well and good politics nerds understand the situation the previous government put us in, but that won’t give them any slack when the next election rolls around. They were elected because they weren’t the previous tosspots not because they currently offer any positive hope for the future. Pragmatism is fine but we have an electorate that voted for Boris Johnson the idea that doom and gloom messages are sustainable is a naive position to take if Labour want to see in a second term.

Would you like them lie instead then?

I will leave that to the masters in your former party. No I expect them to give a positive vision and plan of where the country is going, unless of course the country is so broken by 14yrs with the most awful xxxxs in charge it’s beyond repair. If that’s what you’re saying and there is nothing to be positive about then what a ringing endorsement of your former party and fiends and colleagues..

I’ve been telling you, and them that there’s been very little to be positive about for 16 years.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)