REFEREE GRAHAM SCOTT
#21
In truth he got one decision massively wrong - the Holgate penalty was as clear a penalty as you will see.

Unfortunately so was the one that was given.

I have changed my mind on the Gayle second yellow booking, at the time and watching it in real time, thought it merited a yellow, having watched it back before the second leg, think Gayle was doing enough not to get the second yellow and he certainly wasn't helped by the antics of the Villa goalkeeper.

Gayle's throw in booking might be controversial, but he had been warned just a few minutes before. Not only that on this message board before a ball was kicked there was a thread on the officials for the play off semi final. It was mentioned that Scott was a stickler for time wasting, so I was aware that any scent of time wasting was going to be clamped down on by this ref.

Does make me think why the same ref doesn't get to officiate both games. If time wasting was Scott's eccentricity, then surely both teams as an away side should be subject to it.
Reply
#22
He'll get dog's abuse next time he refs us.

I won't condone that type of behaviour but I'll fucking well join in.
Reply
#23
(05-18-2019, 09:12 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: In truth he got one decision massively wrong - the Holgate penalty was as clear a penalty as you will see.

Unfortunately so was the one that was given.

I have changed my mind on the Gayle second yellow booking, at the time and watching it in real time, thought it merited a yellow, having watched it back before the second leg, think Gayle was doing enough not to get the second yellow and he certainly wasn't helped by the antics of the Villa goalkeeper.

Gayle's throw in booking might be controversial, but he had been warned just a few minutes before. Not only that on this message board before a ball was kicked there was a thread on the officials for the play off semi final. It was mentioned that Scott was a stickler for time wasting, so I was aware that any scent of time wasting was going to be clamped down on by this ref.

Does make me think why the same ref doesn't get to officiate both games. If time wasting was Scott's eccentricity, then surely both teams as an away side should be subject to it.

The problem was that he certainly didn’t treat both sides remotely equally which is unacceptable.
The linesman didn’t seem to help but there was also an unsavoury haste the way he made his decisions.
You mentioned time wasting but Villa had no punishment for their antics once they went in front.
He saw Grealish dive a couple of times yet just smiled and told him to get on with the game instead of booking for cheating.
One small example was the push in Gayle’s face - no foul and no booking.
Soon after Gibbs did similar to a Villa player - foul and booking resulted !!!
Reply
#24
(05-18-2019, 09:41 AM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote:
(05-18-2019, 09:12 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: In truth he got one decision massively wrong - the Holgate penalty was as clear a penalty as you will see.

Unfortunately so was the one that was given.

I have changed my mind on the Gayle second yellow booking, at the time and watching it in real time, thought it merited a yellow, having watched it back before the second leg, think Gayle was doing enough not to get the second yellow and he certainly wasn't helped by the antics of the Villa goalkeeper.

Gayle's throw in booking might be controversial, but he had been warned just a few minutes before. Not only that on this message board before a ball was kicked there was a thread on the officials for the play off semi final. It was mentioned that Scott was a stickler for time wasting, so I was aware that any scent of time wasting was going to be clamped down on by this ref.

Does make me think why the same ref doesn't get to officiate both games. If time wasting was Scott's eccentricity, then surely both teams as an away side should be subject to it.

The problem was that he certainly didn’t treat both sides remotely equally which is unacceptable.
The linesman didn’t seem to help but there was also an unsavoury haste the way he made his decisions.
You mentioned time wasting but Villa had no punishment for their antics once they went in front.
He saw Grealish dive a couple of times yet just smiled and told him to get on with the game instead of booking for cheating.
One small example was the push in Gayle’s face - no foul and no booking.
Soon after Gibbs did similar to a Villa player - foul and booking resulted !!!

The identical Gibbs/Gayle incidents really annoyed me.

However that doesn’t excuse Gibbs losing his head at the decision, getting himself all worked up to point where he’s booked for dissent and then goes flying into a challenge for the penalty seconds later.

He should have known better.
Reply
#25
(05-18-2019, 09:41 AM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote:
(05-18-2019, 09:12 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: In truth he got one decision massively wrong - the Holgate penalty was as clear a penalty as you will see.

Unfortunately so was the one that was given.

I have changed my mind on the Gayle second yellow booking, at the time and watching it in real time, thought it merited a yellow, having watched it back before the second leg, think Gayle was doing enough not to get the second yellow and he certainly wasn't helped by the antics of the Villa goalkeeper.

Gayle's throw in booking might be controversial, but he had been warned just a few minutes before. Not only that on this message board before a ball was kicked there was a thread on the officials for the play off semi final. It was mentioned that Scott was a stickler for time wasting, so I was aware that any scent of time wasting was going to be clamped down on by this ref.

Does make me think why the same ref doesn't get to officiate both games. If time wasting was Scott's eccentricity, then surely both teams as an away side should be subject to it.

The problem was that he certainly didn’t treat both sides remotely equally which is unacceptable.
The linesman didn’t seem to help but there was also an unsavoury haste the way he made his decisions.
You mentioned time wasting but Villa had no punishment for their antics once they went in front.
He saw Grealish dive a couple of times yet just smiled and told him to get on with the game instead of booking for cheating.
One small example was the push in Gayle’s face - no foul and no booking.
Soon after Gibbs did similar to a Villa player - foul and booking resulted !!!
Good examples. What also infuriated me was the haste with which he went for his cards in what was obviously a very highly charged game. Holgate was on a booking after about 10 minutes when McGinn went to ground easily while both were chasing the ball. If you replay all the bookings, there were Grealish and co surrounding him every time. I also noted we were awarded 3 fouls in the entire 90 minutes. When has that ever happened before?
Reply
#26
I'd be highly surprised if he ever ref's at the hawthorns. He will gets dogs abuse for 90 minutes and rightly so.
Reply
#27
(05-18-2019, 09:55 AM)albion_pigeon Wrote: I'd be highly surprised if he ever ref's at the hawthorns. He will gets dogs abuse for 90 minutes and rightly so.

Correct. He is an enemy of the club now. He completely lost it in that game and cost us dearly.

Contrast to the ref for Blues at home. He knew it was a physical match, both teams were up for it and he didn't impede.
Reply
#28
Made me snarl seeing him as fourth official at the Cup Final.

Cunt.
Reply
#29
(05-19-2019, 12:29 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: Made me snarl seeing him as fourth official at the Cup Final.

Cunt.

+1
Reply
#30
Just a quick reminder that Graham Scott is still a cunt.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: