It's that time of year again: Edinburgh's best joke award
#41
(08-20-2024, 11:59 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(08-20-2024, 11:54 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(08-20-2024, 11:43 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(08-20-2024, 11:25 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(08-19-2024, 12:54 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: I suspect 90% of standup jokes would seem shit when seen in writing with no context, buildup or delivery.

1000% this. These lists remove almost everything that a comedian does to make the lines funny.

Also a "jokes list" is likely to include mostly dad jokes or puns, as the more observational style comedy just won't fit in to these lists.

I totally disagree, Tim Vine, Gary Delaney, Milton Jones to name just three, all rattle off gags and make you laugh, and you don't need their version of a long winding twisty anecdote to get to the punchline and laugh. Sure some comedians are best in the full on story mode, like our Frank, but for this list of jokes, you don't need all the background and context.

This year's jokes are just rather crap.

You're wilfully ignoring one of the categories Chamonix said, delivery. The people you list have excellent delivery of their one liners. Some people don't, and some people are god awful at delivering jokes.

Also the bold bit, how do you know? You haven't seen their whole set. It could be that they've had jokes littered through the set that allude to the same topic, so the more and more jokes they utter about it, the funnier it gets. Some people have completely different styles of comedy, and how they present themsevles during sets.

You've also misunderstood my point regarding the style of joke on the list. A 5 minute story about a fridge (John Bishop always comes to mind with this), is never going to make this list, but it could be the funniest thing you've ever heard. But it won't make a list of "best joke" because it's too long, will likely have many jokes contained within it, etc etc.

It's also worth stating that comedy is obviously subjective, so you aren't wrong in your opinion. It's just simply not possible to judge these jokes somewhat objectively, properly, without seeing it.

A few years back (pretty much when Tim Vine would win) the jokes were funny, presented just as a list, exactly the same as this one... Jokes back then were funny in their own right, you are really over thinking this... Nobody made excuses for a list of jokes containing a few duds, nowadays apparently we need context, delivery, back story or what have you to make a list of jokes funny... that in itself tells me that i won't find the list of jokes funny.

I happen to find most of those jokes amusing. I think in a stand up setting, I would find them a lot funnier. You don't, and that's fine.

My overall point is that this list is kind of pointless, because it's always going to appear less funny regardless of who's on it, or what joke they're making, because it's not the intended medium.
Reply
#42
We were with Mark Simmons on the day of the Euro Final. 

He's a really affable chap. Very funny. 

In his one liner genre I think that Tim still has the edge. That "x factor".

I'd suggest that the Fringe has a lot to worry about and the quality of the jokes is not at the top of the list of issues.
Reply
#43
(08-20-2024, 12:01 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(08-20-2024, 11:59 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(08-20-2024, 11:54 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(08-20-2024, 11:43 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(08-20-2024, 11:25 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: 1000% this. These lists remove almost everything that a comedian does to make the lines funny.

Also a "jokes list" is likely to include mostly dad jokes or puns, as the more observational style comedy just won't fit in to these lists.

I totally disagree, Tim Vine, Gary Delaney, Milton Jones to name just three, all rattle off gags and make you laugh, and you don't need their version of a long winding twisty anecdote to get to the punchline and laugh. Sure some comedians are best in the full on story mode, like our Frank, but for this list of jokes, you don't need all the background and context.

This year's jokes are just rather crap.

You're wilfully ignoring one of the categories Chamonix said, delivery. The people you list have excellent delivery of their one liners. Some people don't, and some people are god awful at delivering jokes.

Also the bold bit, how do you know? You haven't seen their whole set. It could be that they've had jokes littered through the set that allude to the same topic, so the more and more jokes they utter about it, the funnier it gets. Some people have completely different styles of comedy, and how they present themsevles during sets.

You've also misunderstood my point regarding the style of joke on the list. A 5 minute story about a fridge (John Bishop always comes to mind with this), is never going to make this list, but it could be the funniest thing you've ever heard. But it won't make a list of "best joke" because it's too long, will likely have many jokes contained within it, etc etc.

It's also worth stating that comedy is obviously subjective, so you aren't wrong in your opinion. It's just simply not possible to judge these jokes somewhat objectively, properly, without seeing it.

A few years back (pretty much when Tim Vine would win) the jokes were funny, presented just as a list, exactly the same as this one... Jokes back then were funny in their own right, you are really over thinking this... Nobody made excuses for a list of jokes containing a few duds, nowadays apparently we need context, delivery, back story or what have you to make a list of jokes funny... that in itself tells me that i won't find the list of jokes funny.

I happen to find most of those jokes amusing. I think in a stand up setting, I would find them a lot funnier. You don't, and that's fine.

My overall point is that this list is kind of pointless, because it's always going to appear less funny regardless of who's on it, or what joke they're making, because it's not the intended medium.

Which is fine and dandy, but they've done these lists for years, in this format, and they used to be a lot funnier over all. According to the majority, who'd comment on here.
Reply
#44
Aaah..... Now I understand!
Reply
#45
(08-20-2024, 11:31 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(08-20-2024, 09:34 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote:
(08-19-2024, 04:11 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cy0nk9241z8o

It's like all those winning jokes are for children and were chosen by children, on the level that the most entertaining joke my son can come out with is "Daddy you're a fat Cow and smell of Strawberries..." which either means he has a promising comedy career in waiting or the winning jokes need to be so PC, comedy becomes irrelevant.

Or he thinks you're fat and smell of strawberries of course  Big Grin .

'From the mouths of babies........'

More than likely... Wink

I thought me nan was typing to me from beyond the grave then reading that olde saying.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)