Posts: 880
Threads: 30
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
2
08-12-2024, 09:42 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-12-2024, 09:50 PM by BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine.)
(08-12-2024, 11:48 AM)Bristol Baggie Wrote: (08-12-2024, 09:07 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (08-12-2024, 03:38 AM)Slowpoke Gonzalez Wrote: (08-11-2024, 10:59 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Billy Wright. From the dark side but undoubtedly one of England's finest players, managed Arsenal into nowhereland. Bryan Robson, most influential player I've ever seen, seemed to have little if any idea. Hoddle (I wasn't a fan, the poncey flat pitch bully), terrible manager. And of course, Steve Bruce, great player but a lazy destructive influence as manager.
Hoddle had enough player testimonies to suggest that he was a good manager at a time. He was lauded for his coaching work at least.
Bruce was past it by the time he got to us, but he wasn't always a terrible manager. He'd been successful at a few different clubs.
These two weren't out of their depth in the way that some of the other names on here were.
Bruce had gone by the time he got to us, but 4 promotions from the second tier suggests a successful past as a manager.
The Great Escape confirms for a period, Robbo was a successful manager.
The Great Escape confirms nothing of the sort. Robbo took us to the bottom of the table and a freak set of results kept us up. Awful manager (world class player though)
He had reasonable success at Middlesbrough though, two promotions and two cup finals?
(08-12-2024, 08:21 PM)MrBater Wrote: Clough was very much a second division player, so i don't think he counts as a great player and a great manager, more a moderate player who became a great manager.
I agree, but did caveat my post with 'great/very good' player. Clough's goalscoring record, division 2 or not, is remarkable and would mark him as a very good player. His career was also cut short by injury, else he would almost certainly have had many years playing in the top flight.
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
Fair enough, but the thread says great player, rubbish manager.
Lots of names being mentioned weren't great players, merely just good ones.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
08-13-2024, 09:46 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-13-2024, 09:47 AM by Spandaubaggie.)
Most managers who have any kind of career have had success at some point so dismissing managers as rubbish surely means players who had a go and it didn't work out and they faded into obscurity. Wayne Rooney looks like being spectacularly bad.
There's some good players who started off as good managers, but then lost their way. Roy Keane and Mark Hughes spring to mind.
Always recall Peter Reid as a good manager, but then lost the plot too.
Trouble is getting managers when they become journeymen and have lost their way. That happened to us with Bruce and in the 90s with the likes of Denis Smith and Brian Little.
Posts: 3,808
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(08-12-2024, 03:00 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: (08-12-2024, 02:30 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote: Some great/very good players who been great/very good managers:
Beckenbauer
Zidane
Deschamps
B.Clough
A.Ferguson
Dalglish
Souness
M.O'Neil
Koeman
Cruyff
Rijkaard
Hoddle
Keegan
Zoff
Arteta
Pep
Kendall
Simeone
Mancini
Del Bosque
Pochettino
Pretty sure there are plenty more.
Given that this is supposed to be an Albion bored, Sir Bobby Robson.
A great bloke, player and manager.
Never thought of Keegan as a good manager, (I'd love it,just love it meltdown ).
George Graham, good player, good manager, bit of a crook though.
Posts: 3,652
Threads: 119
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
7
Fillipo Inzagi - good player - bad manager
Simeone Inzagi - bad player - good manager
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(08-13-2024, 11:07 AM)MGalea Wrote: Fillipo Inzagi - good player - bad manager
Simeone Inzagi - bad player - good manager
Wasn't Simeone decent at Lazio (obviously not as good as Pippo but still)
Posts: 3,853
Threads: 97
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
7
(08-12-2024, 10:06 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (08-12-2024, 09:07 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (08-12-2024, 03:38 AM)Slowpoke Gonzalez Wrote: (08-11-2024, 10:59 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Billy Wright. From the dark side but undoubtedly one of England's finest players, managed Arsenal into nowhereland. Bryan Robson, most influential player I've ever seen, seemed to have little if any idea. Hoddle (I wasn't a fan, the poncey flat pitch bully), terrible manager. And of course, Steve Bruce, great player but a lazy destructive influence as manager.
Hoddle had enough player testimonies to suggest that he was a good manager at a time. He was lauded for his coaching work at least.
Bruce was past it by the time he got to us, but he wasn't always a terrible manager. He'd been successful at a few different clubs.
These two weren't out of their depth in the way that some of the other names on here were.
Bruce had gone by the time he got to us, but 4 promotions from the second tier suggests a successful past as a manager.
The Great Escape confirms for a period, Robbo was a successful manager.
I'm not sure amassing 34 points, at the time the fewest total of points needed to avoid relegation (Is this still the case?) and surviving because other teams bottled their chance to stay up should be seen as a success.
It was a fantastic occasion, and I'll never forget that day and how it unfolded, but for the last hand full of games, where we actually looked a decent outfit, it was an abysmal season. The following season and then the beginning of the 2006/7 season were equally abysmal.
Exactly, we were down and out at full time. Then in the other game Palace equalised to keep us up.
Posts: 409
Threads: 65
Joined: Jan 2024
(08-12-2024, 06:29 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (08-12-2024, 05:38 PM)Bristol Baggie Wrote: (08-12-2024, 10:36 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (08-12-2024, 10:24 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: The season after the great escape was weird. Until February we looked safe and sound, Robson went to a coaching seminar, one I have seen since all about the use of the sole striker as Jose Mourinho was doing with Drogba at Chelsea.
Robson decided he wanted to emulated it, and did so, with Kevin Campbell who age had finally caught up with.
We then just slept until we got relegated, Robson confused why his new idea wasn't working, after all, at the seminar they said it worked.
He also rested key players at the wrong time.
People forget that we were bottom and adrift at Christmas. You have to give Robson credit for that. It doesn't make him a managerial legend, but it means he can't be categorised as a good player who was a shit manager in my view. He said the Great Escape was his finest achievement in football, FFS.
But we weren't 'bottom and adrift' when he took over.
Fergies decision to play a weakened team in the penultimate game was more instrumental than anything alecan did.
That game was only 1 point out of 34. Sometimes management goes beyond the touchline
Bollocks.
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
08-13-2024, 12:36 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-13-2024, 12:36 PM by AnelkasBeard.)
(08-13-2024, 11:38 AM)HugeHons Wrote: (08-12-2024, 10:06 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (08-12-2024, 09:07 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (08-12-2024, 03:38 AM)Slowpoke Gonzalez Wrote: (08-11-2024, 10:59 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Billy Wright. From the dark side but undoubtedly one of England's finest players, managed Arsenal into nowhereland. Bryan Robson, most influential player I've ever seen, seemed to have little if any idea. Hoddle (I wasn't a fan, the poncey flat pitch bully), terrible manager. And of course, Steve Bruce, great player but a lazy destructive influence as manager.
Hoddle had enough player testimonies to suggest that he was a good manager at a time. He was lauded for his coaching work at least.
Bruce was past it by the time he got to us, but he wasn't always a terrible manager. He'd been successful at a few different clubs.
These two weren't out of their depth in the way that some of the other names on here were.
Bruce had gone by the time he got to us, but 4 promotions from the second tier suggests a successful past as a manager.
The Great Escape confirms for a period, Robbo was a successful manager.
I'm not sure amassing 34 points, at the time the fewest total of points needed to avoid relegation (Is this still the case?) and surviving because other teams bottled their chance to stay up should be seen as a success.
It was a fantastic occasion, and I'll never forget that day and how it unfolded, but for the last hand full of games, where we actually looked a decent outfit, it was an abysmal season. The following season and then the beginning of the 2006/7 season were equally abysmal.
Exactly, we were down and out at full time. Then in the other game Palace equalised to keep us up.
We weren't down at full time, Charlton equalised in the 80th minute I think. Norwich got blasted by Fulham, Soton losing 2-1 to United from about the 60th minute.
When The Horse scored, we were staying up, but Palace equalised then scored a penalty I think, so when Richardson scored for 2-0 at 75 minutes, we were down. But I'm sure like 5 minutes later, the news filtered round that Charlton had scored, and we had 10-12 minutes of praying things stayed the same.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(08-13-2024, 12:36 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (08-13-2024, 11:38 AM)HugeHons Wrote: (08-12-2024, 10:06 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (08-12-2024, 09:07 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (08-12-2024, 03:38 AM)Slowpoke Gonzalez Wrote: Hoddle had enough player testimonies to suggest that he was a good manager at a time. He was lauded for his coaching work at least.
Bruce was past it by the time he got to us, but he wasn't always a terrible manager. He'd been successful at a few different clubs.
These two weren't out of their depth in the way that some of the other names on here were.
Bruce had gone by the time he got to us, but 4 promotions from the second tier suggests a successful past as a manager.
The Great Escape confirms for a period, Robbo was a successful manager.
I'm not sure amassing 34 points, at the time the fewest total of points needed to avoid relegation (Is this still the case?) and surviving because other teams bottled their chance to stay up should be seen as a success.
It was a fantastic occasion, and I'll never forget that day and how it unfolded, but for the last hand full of games, where we actually looked a decent outfit, it was an abysmal season. The following season and then the beginning of the 2006/7 season were equally abysmal.
Exactly, we were down and out at full time. Then in the other game Palace equalised to keep us up.
We weren't down at full time, Charlton equalised in the 80th minute I think. Norwich got blasted by Fulham, Soton losing 2-1 to United from about the 60th minute.
When The Horse scored, we were staying up, but Palace equalised then scored a penalty I think, so when Richardson scored for 2-0 at 75 minutes, we were down. But I'm sure like 5 minutes later, the news filtered round that Charlton had scored, and we had 10-12 minutes of praying things stayed the same.
Correct.
The most useful contribution Robson made to that escape was getting his mate Fergie to go full strength at Southampton despite it being meaningless for United. Worth remembering we weren’t in the bottom 3 when Robson was appointed, it was only his appalling form in his first 10 games that left us bottom.
Any other season we’d have been relegated long before the last few games, but the incompetence of those around us and a few favours from Sir Alex kept us up!
Remember there being a rumour floating round the ground Palace had another penalty at 2-2 with a few mins to go…
|