Great player, rubbish manager
#51
Gary O'Neil did a good job at Bournemouth, and now doing a good job at the Dingles. He was a solid player and had a good career. I'm not sure you can lump him in the list, mind.
Reply
#52
(08-12-2024, 02:52 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Gary O'Neil did a good job at Bournemouth, and now doing a good job at the Dingles. He was a solid player and had a good career. I'm not sure you can lump him in the list, mind.

I meant Martin O'Neil.
Reply
#53
(08-12-2024, 02:30 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote: Some great/very good players who been great/very good managers:

Beckenbauer
Zidane
Deschamps
B.Clough
A.Ferguson
Dalglish
Souness
M.O'Neil
Koeman
Cruyff
Rijkaard
Hoddle
Keegan
Zoff
Arteta
Pep
Kendall
Simeone
Mancini
Del Bosque
Pochettino

Pretty sure there are plenty more.

Given that this is supposed to be an Albion bored, Sir Bobby Robson. 

A great bloke, player and manager.
Reply
#54
(08-12-2024, 02:55 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote:
(08-12-2024, 02:52 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Gary O'Neil did a good job at Bournemouth, and now doing a good job at the Dingles. He was a solid player and had a good career. I'm not sure you can lump him in the list, mind.

I meant Martin O'Neil.
I guessed! I was adding the name, sort of, and not arguing against anyone!
Reply
#55
(08-12-2024, 10:36 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(08-12-2024, 10:24 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: The season after the great escape was weird. Until February we looked safe and sound, Robson went to a coaching seminar, one I have seen since all about the use of the sole striker as Jose Mourinho was doing with Drogba at Chelsea.

Robson decided he wanted to emulated it, and did so, with Kevin Campbell who age had finally caught up with.

We then just slept until we got relegated, Robson confused why his new idea wasn't working, after all, at the seminar they said it worked.

He also rested key players at the wrong time.

People forget that we were bottom and adrift at Christmas. You have to give Robson credit for that. It doesn't make him a managerial legend, but it means he can't be categorised as a good player who was a shit manager in my view. He said the Great Escape was his finest achievement in football, FFS.

But we weren't 'bottom and adrift' when he took over.

Fergies decision to play a weakened team in the penultimate game was more instrumental than anything alecan did.
Reply
#56
(08-12-2024, 03:00 PM)baggiebloke Wrote:
(08-12-2024, 02:30 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote: Some great/very good players who been great/very good managers:

Beckenbauer
Zidane
Deschamps
B.Clough
A.Ferguson
Dalglish
Souness
M.O'Neil
Koeman
Cruyff
Rijkaard
Hoddle
Keegan
Zoff
Arteta
Pep
Kendall
Simeone
Mancini
Del Bosque
Pochettino

Pretty sure there are plenty more.

Given that this is supposed to be an Albion bored, Sir Bobby Robson. 

A great bloke, player and manager.

Ronnie Allen was a decent manager too. Don Howe on t'other 'ond
Reply
#57
(08-12-2024, 05:38 PM)Bristol Baggie Wrote:
(08-12-2024, 10:36 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(08-12-2024, 10:24 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: The season after the great escape was weird. Until February we looked safe and sound, Robson went to a coaching seminar, one I have seen since all about the use of the sole striker as Jose Mourinho was doing with Drogba at Chelsea.

Robson decided he wanted to emulated it, and did so, with Kevin Campbell who age had finally caught up with.

We then just slept until we got relegated, Robson confused why his new idea wasn't working, after all, at the seminar they said it worked.

He also rested key players at the wrong time.

People forget that we were bottom and adrift at Christmas. You have to give Robson credit for that. It doesn't make him a managerial legend, but it means he can't be categorised as a good player who was a shit manager in my view. He said the Great Escape was his finest achievement in football, FFS.

But we weren't 'bottom and adrift' when he took over.

Fergies decision to play a weakened team in the penultimate game was more instrumental than anything alecan did.

That game was only 1 point out of 34. Sometimes management goes beyond the touchline
Reply
#58
Clough was very much a second division player, so i don't think he counts as a great player and a great manager, more a moderate player who became a great manager.
Reply
#59
(08-12-2024, 02:55 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote:
(08-12-2024, 02:52 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Gary O'Neil did a good job at Bournemouth, and now doing a good job at the Dingles. He was a solid player and had a good career. I'm not sure you can lump him in the list, mind.

I meant Martin O'Neil.

There’s some very strange posts on this thread and this is right up there. O’Neill had astounding success with Wycombe and Leicester- possiblyLeicester’s greatest manager, until the Ranieri miracle.
He also had a few very decent seasons with Villa, although financially backed.
Only after Villa did his managerial career go downhill.
That happens with many managers who then lose the plot and eventually give it up. 
To be a rubbish manager you really have to be rubbish right from the start with limited success, before packing it in.
Incidentally I always thought John Wile would have had a good managerial career, but it never happened.
Reply
#60
(08-12-2024, 08:21 PM)MrBater Wrote: Clough was very much a second division player, so i don't think he counts as a great player and a great manager, more a moderate player who became a great manager.

Alex Ferguson was similar. One of the greatest ever Managers, but I don't think even Fergie would claim he was a great player.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)