Let's hope for a mild winter then
#31
(07-30-2024, 10:24 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-30-2024, 09:59 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(07-29-2024, 06:51 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-29-2024, 05:21 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The divisions are clear to see already.

We are in for 5 years of Government that 'wasn't the Tories".

It's going to be a tough ride, and Labour need 10 years to see if they are right.

£12K single income pensioners now lose their winter fuel benefits whilst Junior Doctors start on c£35K on day 1.

The £12k single income pensioners pay no tax (or student loans) on that £12k and their expenditure is significantly lower as they are the demographic least likely to have kids and need to rent, plus they get subsidised travel and other concessions and those eligible for pension credit (most "working class" pensioners who only paid NICs, not those middle class ones in receipt of other pension incomes) will keep the allowance payments. What the hell is this bullshit comparison? Do you honestly think people should put the interests of pensioners above children, students and working age adults or something?

Please don't be rude.

Yes I do think we should put the interests of some pensioners above those of some adults. They created the wealth that allows these young people to make their choices. I agree that middle class pensioners should not be able to claim the allowance (and should pay TV licence) but there are many that don't qualify for benefits and are living on the edge.

These are people that Labour should be protecting. Start increasing CGT, IHT and Pension Tax if we need to balance the books. Don't hit those who can't hit back. Wait till next year when the Doctors come back for another 22% - I don't expect them to meekly take 3% inflation related rise next year. That's when the fun will start, after all other public sector workers hang out for similar increases.

What wealth?! Not housing wealth, this patronising narrative acting as though the first generation to be worse off than their predecessors should owe the generation that made them worse off is ridiculous. Heating allowance tying to pension credit eligibility is perfectly fair given the increases to the state pension

More and more of my money is going towards propping the wealthiest generation ever while I can't even afford to live where I grew up unless I save up a 25% deposit, and I doubt the state pension will exist by the time I'm 70 so I'm also maxing out my workplace pension.

And I hope your workplace pension tax is increased to support those that gave you the chances in life. A single retired person cannot live on £13K a year. 

You are lucky you can make the choices to invest in your retirement. In post-war Britain they couldn't.
Reply
#32
(07-30-2024, 10:28 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(07-30-2024, 10:24 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-30-2024, 09:59 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(07-29-2024, 06:51 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-29-2024, 05:21 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The divisions are clear to see already.

We are in for 5 years of Government that 'wasn't the Tories".

It's going to be a tough ride, and Labour need 10 years to see if they are right.

£12K single income pensioners now lose their winter fuel benefits whilst Junior Doctors start on c£35K on day 1.

The £12k single income pensioners pay no tax (or student loans) on that £12k and their expenditure is significantly lower as they are the demographic least likely to have kids and need to rent, plus they get subsidised travel and other concessions and those eligible for pension credit (most "working class" pensioners who only paid NICs, not those middle class ones in receipt of other pension incomes) will keep the allowance payments. What the hell is this bullshit comparison? Do you honestly think people should put the interests of pensioners above children, students and working age adults or something?

Please don't be rude.

Yes I do think we should put the interests of some pensioners above those of some adults. They created the wealth that allows these young people to make their choices. I agree that middle class pensioners should not be able to claim the allowance (and should pay TV licence) but there are many that don't qualify for benefits and are living on the edge.

These are people that Labour should be protecting. Start increasing CGT, IHT and Pension Tax if we need to balance the books. Don't hit those who can't hit back. Wait till next year when the Doctors come back for another 22% - I don't expect them to meekly take 3% inflation related rise next year. That's when the fun will start, after all other public sector workers hang out for similar increases.

What wealth?! Not housing wealth, this patronising narrative acting as though the first generation to be worse off than their predecessors should owe the generation that made them worse off is ridiculous. Heating allowance tying to pension credit eligibility is perfectly fair given the increases to the state pension

More and more of my money is going towards propping the wealthiest generation ever while I can't even afford to live where I grew up unless I save up a 25% deposit, and I doubt the state pension will exist by the time I'm 70 so I'm also maxing out my workplace pension.

And I hope your workplace pension tax is increased to support those that gave you the chances in life. A single retired person cannot live on £13K a year. 

You are lucky you can make the choices to invest in your retirement. In post-war Britain they couldn't.

Do you think most state pensioners are 100 years old or something? My generation is the first one to be economically worse off than our parents, and I'm unlikely to be entitled a state pension in anywhere near the capacity that exists currently. I'm not grateful for that, I'm not grateful to the generation that exploited the boom of the 1980s and 1990s while preparing to leave my generation worse off. Not to mention benefitting from defined benefit pension schemes that simply don't exist nowadays unless they've been grandfathered in.

Your solution to tax working people more, especially on things designed to reduce the necessary tax burden in 50 years time like private pensions, ignoring the already massive tax burden on working people to support generous benefits to baby boomers that their parents weren't entitled to is nonsensical. Effectively forcing a generation who's already going to be worse off to sacrifice even more so the generation that has benefitted the most can be insulated from the fallout of their choices. All the while wanting to make it as difficult to have children as possible and simultaneously opposing any level of immigration making the burden even harder to support with a diminished tax base.
Reply
#33
(07-30-2024, 10:45 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-30-2024, 10:28 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(07-30-2024, 10:24 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-30-2024, 09:59 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(07-29-2024, 06:51 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The £12k single income pensioners pay no tax (or student loans) on that £12k and their expenditure is significantly lower as they are the demographic least likely to have kids and need to rent, plus they get subsidised travel and other concessions and those eligible for pension credit (most "working class" pensioners who only paid NICs, not those middle class ones in receipt of other pension incomes) will keep the allowance payments. What the hell is this bullshit comparison? Do you honestly think people should put the interests of pensioners above children, students and working age adults or something?

Please don't be rude.

Yes I do think we should put the interests of some pensioners above those of some adults. They created the wealth that allows these young people to make their choices. I agree that middle class pensioners should not be able to claim the allowance (and should pay TV licence) but there are many that don't qualify for benefits and are living on the edge.

These are people that Labour should be protecting. Start increasing CGT, IHT and Pension Tax if we need to balance the books. Don't hit those who can't hit back. Wait till next year when the Doctors come back for another 22% - I don't expect them to meekly take 3% inflation related rise next year. That's when the fun will start, after all other public sector workers hang out for similar increases.

What wealth?! Not housing wealth, this patronising narrative acting as though the first generation to be worse off than their predecessors should owe the generation that made them worse off is ridiculous. Heating allowance tying to pension credit eligibility is perfectly fair given the increases to the state pension

More and more of my money is going towards propping the wealthiest generation ever while I can't even afford to live where I grew up unless I save up a 25% deposit, and I doubt the state pension will exist by the time I'm 70 so I'm also maxing out my workplace pension.

And I hope your workplace pension tax is increased to support those that gave you the chances in life. A single retired person cannot live on £13K a year. 

You are lucky you can make the choices to invest in your retirement. In post-war Britain they couldn't.

Do you think most state pensioners are 100 years old or something? My generation is the first one to be economically worse off than our parents, and I'm unlikely to be entitled a state pension in anywhere near the capacity that exists currently. I'm not grateful for that, I'm not grateful to the generation that exploited the boom of the 1980s and 1990s while preparing to leave my generation worse off. Not to mention benefitting from defined benefit pension schemes that simply don't exist nowadays unless they've been grandfathered in.

Your solution to tax working people more, especially on things designed to reduce the necessary tax burden in 50 years time like private pensions, ignoring the already massive tax burden on working people to support generous benefits to baby boomers that their parents weren't entitled to is nonsensical. Effectively forcing a generation who's already going to be worse off to sacrifice even more so the generation that has benefitted the most can be insulated from the fallout of their choices. All the while wanting to make it as difficult to have children as possible and simultaneously opposing any level of immigration making the burden even harder to support with a diminished tax base.


And breath.

The tax base has to increase. Charge those that can afford it, not pensioners who can't earn any more.
Reply
#34
(07-30-2024, 10:45 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Do you think most state pensioners are 100 years old or something? My generation is the first one to be economically worse off than our parents, and I'm unlikely to be entitled a state pension in anywhere near the capacity that exists currently. I'm not grateful for that, I'm not grateful to the generation that exploited the boom of the 1980s and 1990s while preparing to leave my generation worse off. Not to mention benefitting from defined benefit pension schemes that simply don't exist nowadays unless they've been grandfathered in.

Your solution to tax working people more, especially on things designed to reduce the necessary tax burden in 50 years time like private pensions, ignoring the already massive tax burden on working people to support generous benefits to baby boomers that their parents weren't entitled to is nonsensical. Effectively forcing a generation who's already going to be worse off to sacrifice even more so the generation that has benefitted the most can be insulated from the fallout of their choices. All the while wanting to make it as difficult to have children as possible and simultaneously opposing any level of immigration making the burden even harder to support with a diminished tax base.

As you know, I have a lot of sympathy with what young people face in this country. But, let's not fall into the trap of suggesting that government policies and individuals' actions of the 1980s and 1990s are the main driver of intergenerational inequality though; they're not. 

The cause of so much intergenerational inequality is rampant asset price inflation since 2008. And you can't blame those with equity failing to look a gift horse in the mouth when offered free money conjured out of thin air can you? 

Suppressed interest rates since 2008 also put the final nail in the coffin of DB pension provision (after Gordon Brown murdered them) - most schemes were in deficit until Feb 2024 when interest rates returned to some sort of normal level. So yes, you have a right to feel bitter and yes, you're certainly on the button saying no more tax hikes to pay for benefits you'll never see. But if we hadn't had 14 years of zero interest rates you'd already have a bigger house and much greater onotological security.

Let me tell you what low interest rates have done to asset price inflation with an easy example. Last week we put a 2-bed house up for rent in Cradley at £850 pcm. After the first viewing the new tenants offered £900 pcm to take it off the market. This is a two bed terrace, in Cradley.
Reply
#35
(07-30-2024, 11:22 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-30-2024, 10:45 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Do you think most state pensioners are 100 years old or something? My generation is the first one to be economically worse off than our parents, and I'm unlikely to be entitled a state pension in anywhere near the capacity that exists currently. I'm not grateful for that, I'm not grateful to the generation that exploited the boom of the 1980s and 1990s while preparing to leave my generation worse off. Not to mention benefitting from defined benefit pension schemes that simply don't exist nowadays unless they've been grandfathered in.

Your solution to tax working people more, especially on things designed to reduce the necessary tax burden in 50 years time like private pensions, ignoring the already massive tax burden on working people to support generous benefits to baby boomers that their parents weren't entitled to is nonsensical. Effectively forcing a generation who's already going to be worse off to sacrifice even more so the generation that has benefitted the most can be insulated from the fallout of their choices. All the while wanting to make it as difficult to have children as possible and simultaneously opposing any level of immigration making the burden even harder to support with a diminished tax base.

As you know, I have a lot of sympathy with what young people face in this country. But, let's not fall into the trap of suggesting that government policies and individuals' actions of the 1980s and 1990s are the main driver of intergenerational inequality though; they're not. 

The cause of so much intergenerational inequality is rampant asset price inflation since 2008. And you can't blame those with equity failing to look a gift horse in the mouth when offered free money conjured out of thin air can you? 

Suppressed interest rates since 2008 also put the final nail in the coffin of DB pension provision (after Gordon Brown murdered them) - most schemes were in deficit until Feb 2024 when interest rates returned to some sort of normal level. So yes, you have a right to feel bitter and yes, you're certainly on the button saying no more tax hikes to pay for benefits you'll never see. But if we hadn't had 14 years of zero interest rates you'd already have a bigger house and much greater onotological security.

Let me tell you what low interest rates have done to asset price inflation with an easy example. Last week we put a 2-bed house up for rent in Cradley at £850 pcm. After the first viewing the new tenants offered £900 pcm to take it off the market. This is a two bed terrace, in Cradley.

The infrastructure deficit we currently have is as a result of decisions made in the 1980s. Things like new nuclear, railways, reservoirs, heat networks, light railways, telecoms etc. were not actioned in those two decades despite them being central to sustained economic growth over the long term instead of just the medium and short term and being planned for. The growth we could have had if those things had happened would have been able to equalise opportunity. It's not just 2008.
Reply
#36
(07-29-2024, 05:21 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The divisions are clear to see already.

We are in for 5 years of Government that 'wasn't the Tories".

It's going to be a tough ride, and Labour need 10 years to see if they are right.

£12K single income pensioners now lose their winter fuel benefits whilst Junior Doctors start on c£35K on day 1.

35k for a junior doctor is fucking chicken feed.
Reply
#37
(07-30-2024, 11:32 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-30-2024, 11:22 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-30-2024, 10:45 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Do you think most state pensioners are 100 years old or something? My generation is the first one to be economically worse off than our parents, and I'm unlikely to be entitled a state pension in anywhere near the capacity that exists currently. I'm not grateful for that, I'm not grateful to the generation that exploited the boom of the 1980s and 1990s while preparing to leave my generation worse off. Not to mention benefitting from defined benefit pension schemes that simply don't exist nowadays unless they've been grandfathered in.

Your solution to tax working people more, especially on things designed to reduce the necessary tax burden in 50 years time like private pensions, ignoring the already massive tax burden on working people to support generous benefits to baby boomers that their parents weren't entitled to is nonsensical. Effectively forcing a generation who's already going to be worse off to sacrifice even more so the generation that has benefitted the most can be insulated from the fallout of their choices. All the while wanting to make it as difficult to have children as possible and simultaneously opposing any level of immigration making the burden even harder to support with a diminished tax base.

As you know, I have a lot of sympathy with what young people face in this country. But, let's not fall into the trap of suggesting that government policies and individuals' actions of the 1980s and 1990s are the main driver of intergenerational inequality though; they're not. 

The cause of so much intergenerational inequality is rampant asset price inflation since 2008. And you can't blame those with equity failing to look a gift horse in the mouth when offered free money conjured out of thin air can you? 

Suppressed interest rates since 2008 also put the final nail in the coffin of DB pension provision (after Gordon Brown murdered them) - most schemes were in deficit until Feb 2024 when interest rates returned to some sort of normal level. So yes, you have a right to feel bitter and yes, you're certainly on the button saying no more tax hikes to pay for benefits you'll never see. But if we hadn't had 14 years of zero interest rates you'd already have a bigger house and much greater onotological security.

Let me tell you what low interest rates have done to asset price inflation with an easy example. Last week we put a 2-bed house up for rent in Cradley at £850 pcm. After the first viewing the new tenants offered £900 pcm to take it off the market. This is a two bed terrace, in Cradley.

The infrastructure deficit we currently have is as a result of decisions made in the 1980s. Things like new nuclear, railways, reservoirs, heat networks, light railways, telecoms etc. were not actioned in those two decades despite them being central to sustained economic growth over the long term instead of just the medium and short term and being planned for. The growth we could have had if those things had happened would have been able to equalise opportunity. It's not just 2008.
 
It was called Privatisation. I know, I was lending to the privatised industries at the time. 

The alternative was for Scargill to lead these people into a year long strike they had no chance of winning.

Our country will work out what is correct over the next 5 years and vote accordingly. I'm open to the result. If Labour win it will because they have made the key calls correctly.
Reply
#38
It's relative. Me and Mrs H pick up our state pension this year which is £23K combined (I think when I get mine in November, she got her first payment this month). We also have 10 years of civil service pension each which takes us to about £32k. After paying off the mortgage nearly 4 years ago, and shovelling everything in to a SIPP and a generous NEST pension contribution for Mrs H as an employee, we will be OK. I am still working (hard) and earning decent money. Leaving that aside, there will be a lot of people akin to us if I retired.

I feel embarrassed about free stuff we get already - we don't need it. Direct where needed.
Reply
#39
(07-30-2024, 11:02 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: And breath.

The tax base has to increase. Charge those that can afford it, not pensioners who can't earn any more.

How long am I supposed to defer being able to buy a house or have children for because I can apparently "afford" extra taxes?

Sustainably increasing the tax base is contingent on productivity increases, immigration and higher birth rates. Not encouraging skilled emigration, making it as difficult as possible to justify having children and cutting capital spending to support poorly targeted welfare entitlements.

There's an £18bn shortfall that needs to be made up thanks to the last Tory government committing spending without disclosing it or funding it (because apparently Rwanda would save the day according to Jeremy Hunt and alone remove £6.4 billion, my arse), removing the entitlement to benefits that people don't need is the ideal option to limit the amount of tax that needs to be raised and cuts that need to be made up. There's already plenty of other areas where people need support, like unpaid carers, but aren't provided it.
Reply
#40
(07-30-2024, 11:41 AM)Hudds1 Wrote: It's relative.  Me and Mrs H pick up our state pension this year which is £23K combined (I think when I get mine in November, she got her first payment this month).  We also have 10 years of civil service pension each which takes us to about £32k.  After paying off the mortgage nearly 4 years ago, and shovelling  everything in to a SIPP and a generous NEST pension contribution for Mrs H as an employee, we will be OK.  I am still working (hard) and earning decent money.  Leaving that aside, there will be a lot of people akin to us if I retired.

I feel embarrassed about free stuff we get already  - we don't need it.  Direct where needed.

I take your point, Hudds, and agree with your logic.

Loads of people aren't quite there, though, and rely on this allowance.

I'm pleased you have provided for your future   Wink Wink
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: