Let's hope for a mild winter then
#21
(07-30-2024, 08:45 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-30-2024, 08:36 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Benefits should be means tested with few exceptions, state pension for example, so long as you have paid in for long enough.

Can we stop with this conceit about "paying in"?

NI is just tax, it goes on current spending. There is no pot with your name on it.

As I posted on the "Surprise" thread:
The OBR's long-term projections (from 2022) show debt rising to over 100 per cent of GDP by 2052-53 and reaching 267 per cent of GDP in 50 years if upward pressures on health, pensions and social care spending, and the loss of motoring taxes, are accommodated. Bringing debt back to 75 per cent of GDP – the level at which it stabilised in the Government’s pre-pandemic March 2020 Budget – would need taxes to rise, spending to fall, or a combination of both, amounting to a 1.5 per cent of GDP additional tightening (£37 billion a year in today’s terms) at the beginning of each decade over the next 50 years. [OBR's words - not mine]

The State Pension will become increasingly unaffordable, so anyone under 30 had better start making some serious preparations for it not to exist in it's current form. As well as trying to buy a house, earn enough to raise kids, have any sort of lifestyle etc.

Oh I know, was being a little flippant, more that's how imo the system should work. 

I fully expect state pension to end in time, not even sure I'll get it tbh. 

Your post is far too accurate though, there is no hope for the younger generations, nothing. I'm thankful my son is exceptionally gifted in maths because that's a path to a STEM career which has some modicum of hope, if he wasn't I'd be very, very worried about what his future holds. 

At some point this world, and the economy model the west uses is going to collapse on itself, it's already starting, I don't know what comes next, but until it does it's going to be a very painful few years, maybe decades until it does come along.

I'm not anti-capitalist, I believe capitalism has had it's advantages, and still does, however we've gone into the stage beyond capitalism, into cronyism, and socialism for the ones who have won capitalism, as we've both said when the government bailed out the banks.

I've said for a long time, we're fucked, there is no way out now, no government is going to make anything better, too many bad decisions made for too long, all anyone can do is make sure they are as protected as possible from what is going to happen.

Sorry for the nihilism
Reply
#22
(07-30-2024, 09:17 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm not anti-capitalist, I believe capitalism has had it's advantages, and still does, however we've gone into the stage beyond capitalism, into cronyism, and socialism for the ones who have won capitalism, as we've both said when the government bailed out the banks.

Markets have provided us all with riches beyond the wildest dreams of our grandparents. But you're right, crony capitalism and corporate welfare epitomised by the bank bailouts, suppressed interest rates and Covid "support" have put us on the road to ruin. You can trace virtually everything bad back to 2008, and how successive governments globally have dealt with the aftermath.
Reply
#23
Nope. It’s enriched some people at the expense of others and given a few generations a decent party with the later generations nursing the hangover. I’m not anti or pro it, it’s just how it is and has been. Deluding yourself about what it constitutes is exactly that - a delusion - and nothing else. Trying to we write the universal laws of equal and opposite reactions to everything is comedy.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#24
(07-29-2024, 06:51 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-29-2024, 05:21 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The divisions are clear to see already.

We are in for 5 years of Government that 'wasn't the Tories".

It's going to be a tough ride, and Labour need 10 years to see if they are right.

£12K single income pensioners now lose their winter fuel benefits whilst Junior Doctors start on c£35K on day 1.

The £12k single income pensioners pay no tax (or student loans) on that £12k and their expenditure is significantly lower as they are the demographic least likely to have kids and need to rent, plus they get subsidised travel and other concessions and those eligible for pension credit (most "working class" pensioners who only paid NICs, not those middle class ones in receipt of other pension incomes) will keep the allowance payments. What the hell is this bullshit comparison? Do you honestly think people should put the interests of pensioners above children, students and working age adults or something?

Please don't be rude.

Yes I do think we should put the interests of some pensioners above those of some adults. They created the wealth that allows these young people to make their choices. I agree that middle class pensioners should not be able to claim the allowance (and should pay TV licence) but there are many that don't qualify for benefits and are living on the edge.

These are people that Labour should be protecting. Start increasing CGT, IHT and Pension Tax if we need to balance the books. Don't hit those who can't hit back. Wait till next year when the Doctors come back for another 22% - I don't expect them to meekly take 3% inflation related rise next year. That's when the fun will start, after all other public sector workers hang out for similar increases.
Reply
#25
They won’t be coming back next year as it’s a 2 year deal.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#26
(07-30-2024, 10:01 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: They won’t be coming back next year as it’s a 2 year deal.

A backdated 2 year deal to 2023.
Reply
#27
I will say means testing pensioners who get what £11k as a pension seems all very Tory… who are Labour representing now? Labour should remember they won because the Tories were appalling not because people liked what Labour had to offer. I’d have voted Lib Dem if they had a chance of winning in my area.
Reply
#28
(07-30-2024, 10:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I will say means testing pensioners who get what £11k as a pension seems all very Tory… who are Labour representing now? Labour should remember they won because the Tories were appalling not because people liked what Labour had to offer. I’d have voted Lib Dem if they had a chance of winning in my area.

I don't disagree with you Derek (for a change!!).
Reply
#29
(07-30-2024, 10:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I will say means testing pensioners who get what £11k as a pension seems all very Tory… who are Labour representing now? Labour should remember they won because the Tories were appalling not because people liked what Labour had to offer. I’d have voted Lib Dem if they had a chance of winning in my area.

Means testing is not bad thing. My parents do not need a heating allowance, by their own admission, they don't need to worry about it, so take it from there, there is more in the pot to help those that do need it.
Reply
#30
(07-30-2024, 09:59 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(07-29-2024, 06:51 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-29-2024, 05:21 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The divisions are clear to see already.

We are in for 5 years of Government that 'wasn't the Tories".

It's going to be a tough ride, and Labour need 10 years to see if they are right.

£12K single income pensioners now lose their winter fuel benefits whilst Junior Doctors start on c£35K on day 1.

The £12k single income pensioners pay no tax (or student loans) on that £12k and their expenditure is significantly lower as they are the demographic least likely to have kids and need to rent, plus they get subsidised travel and other concessions and those eligible for pension credit (most "working class" pensioners who only paid NICs, not those middle class ones in receipt of other pension incomes) will keep the allowance payments. What the hell is this bullshit comparison? Do you honestly think people should put the interests of pensioners above children, students and working age adults or something?

Please don't be rude.

Yes I do think we should put the interests of some pensioners above those of some adults. They created the wealth that allows these young people to make their choices. I agree that middle class pensioners should not be able to claim the allowance (and should pay TV licence) but there are many that don't qualify for benefits and are living on the edge.

These are people that Labour should be protecting. Start increasing CGT, IHT and Pension Tax if we need to balance the books. Don't hit those who can't hit back. Wait till next year when the Doctors come back for another 22% - I don't expect them to meekly take 3% inflation related rise next year. That's when the fun will start, after all other public sector workers hang out for similar increases.

What wealth?! Not housing wealth, this patronising narrative acting as though the first generation to be worse off than their predecessors should owe the generation that made them worse off is ridiculous. Heating allowance tying to pension credit eligibility is perfectly fair given the increases to the state pension

More and more of my money is going towards propping the wealthiest generation ever while I can't even afford to live where I grew up unless I save up a 25% deposit, and I doubt the state pension will exist by the time I'm 70 so I'm also maxing out my workplace pension.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)