Montero and Murphy
#11
(05-16-2019, 09:35 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(05-16-2019, 09:24 AM)Duffers Wrote: Easy to say with the benefit of hindsight but what a colossal waste of time those two were.

Would Burke have offered anything less than either of them?

To be honest, I think there have been some silly, strange, bewildering even, signings this season. Sako comes in, plays about twice, after being `not fit` for weeks, then goes back to where he came from. Was Big Dave, Jones or Dowling responsible?
Montero joins on loan, never plays,  36 year old Hoolahan, hardly plays, but contract extended till the end of the season.
Came within minutes of signing Oviedo, a rank average fullback who can`t get in Sunderlands team.

This is about the arrogance/self belief of managers and coaches - they seem to have a belief that even if someone has under-performed or not lived up to their potential somewhere else that they will be able to bring out the best in them because they are an amazing coach/manager.

How often this actually works out tells you everything you need to know!
Reply
#12
we signed some shit and hardly played them but it kept the youth away from the first team which annoys me.

we've got some talent but if we're only throwing them on when we're in a problem situation that ain't fair on them or giving them a chance.  they need a run in the team.

Leko came on against an experienced team with their tales up on Tuesday and was supposed to run them down up front all on his own, no chance, he's hardly played all season.

I hope we get rid of some of these "experienced" players who are blocking the bench and give our youth a chance.  a 16 year old played in the premier in May and not the first I believe.

strange how the youth didn't really get involved as big Dave and Shan were both heavily involved in their development.
Reply
#13
I believe that Montero would have made an impact and a contribution had he been given the opportunity.
Reply
#14
(05-16-2019, 09:56 AM)Hopalong Wrote: I believe that Montero would have made an impact and a contribution had he been given the opportunity.

This 100%
Reply
#15
(05-16-2019, 09:48 AM)Jamin03 why change it? Wrote: we signed some shit and hardly played them but it kept the youth away from the first team which annoys me.

we've got some talent but if we're only throwing them on when we're in a problem situation that ain't fair on them or giving them a chance.  they need a run in the team.

Leko came on against an experienced team with their tales up on Tuesday and was supposed to run them down up front all on his own, no chance, he's hardly played all season.

I hope we get rid of some of these "experienced" players who are blocking the bench and give our youth a chance.  a 16 year old played in the premier in May and not the first I believe.

strange how the youth didn't really get involved as big Dave and Shan were both heavily involved in their development.

they didn't get involved because the stakes were so high, simple as that.
Reply
#16
(05-16-2019, 09:48 AM)Jamin03 why change it? Wrote: we signed some shit and hardly played them but it kept the youth away from the first team which annoys me.

we've got some talent but if we're only throwing them on when we're in a problem situation that ain't fair on them or giving them a chance.  they need a run in the team.

Leko came on against an experienced team with their tales up on Tuesday and was supposed to run them down up front all on his own, no chance, he's hardly played all season.

I hope we get rid of some of these "experienced" players who are blocking the bench and give our youth a chance.  a 16 year old played in the premier in May and not the first I believe.

strange how the youth didn't really get involved as big Dave and Shan were both heavily involved in their development.
One thing that surprises me is, whenever a youth / under 21`s coach, who tells anyone who will listen, what great kids are coming through etc, gets to take charge of the first team, they ` have to trust experienced pro`s`,or `can`t take a chance with young lads` etc.
Reply
#17
(05-16-2019, 09:26 AM)billybassett Wrote: Murphy was absolutely awful across both semi final legs...

I was genuinely pleased when we signed him, given his record wth Norwich in this division previously.

After his time with us, I have absolutely no idea what his strengths are. He's brought nothing to the table, and has been a complete waste of space. Bizzare that Edwards was binned after doing more in one half than Murphy did over his entire loan spell.

Is Murphy another example of a young player that has earned more money that he needs already, and is just going through the motions? Will be interesting to see what happens with him next season.
Reply
#18
I can assume that Montero had some sort of fitness problem or was colossally shite in training.

Murphy on the other hand, cant see why Benetiez spent £10m+ on him.
Reply
#19
(05-16-2019, 09:57 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(05-16-2019, 09:56 AM)Hopalong Wrote: I believe that Montero would have made an impact and a contribution had he been given the opportunity.

This 100%

Absolutely. Leko was worse than useless when he came on. No reading of the game. No anticipation at all. On 2 or 3 occasions the ball dropped into an area where a striker on the move could have got there. He is stood looking at it. The only good thing he had a chance with he had to hand ball it to get it under control.
Montero could not possibly have been worse and although equally useless neither could Burke.
Reply
#20
(05-16-2019, 10:08 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote:
(05-16-2019, 09:26 AM)billybassett Wrote: Murphy was absolutely awful across both semi final legs...

I was genuinely pleased when we signed him, given his record wth Norwich in this division previously.

After his time with us, I have absolutely no idea what his strengths are. He's brought nothing to the table, and has been a complete waste of space. Bizzare that Edwards was binned after doing more in one half than Murphy did over his entire loan spell.

Is Murphy another example of a young player that has earned more money that he needs already, and is just going through the motions? Will be interesting to see what happens with him next season.

Like you pleased. Spoke to a couple of Norwich fans at Xmas, they did not rate either of the Murphys and were glad to see them go. They had a different take on Maddison

I trust you do not see us paying £10 million for him Big Grin
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)