There is something about the Chris Cornell - Nothing compares to you interpretation of the original that really captivates me when I listen to it.
https://youtu.be/kxEcc2AiddQ?si=LUFxAEKCaNshiitA
Personally, I love remixes, edits, bootlegs of original pieces of music. I'm in my early 40s and have been into the election music scene since a teenager.
I still DJ (for fun as opposed to being a regular gigging DJ) and I love the way the numerous genres of dance music are constantly evolving but at the same time retaining the key feelings/musical elements that make that genre what it is. This allows someone in their 40s to still be able to connect with brand new music in a genre they love and understand, whilst at the same time as a 20 year old who is into the same thing.
A great example of this is Drum & Bass music. If you go to big festival and look at the crowd in the Drum & Bass tent you will find 18 - 50 years olds alongside each other. In my experience, there is an acknowledgement and mutual respect between all of those age groups. I believe that is rooted in the way a genre is influenced and therefore progressed by the younger generation of music producers, coupled with the need for the older person on the dance floor in a club or at a festival is clearly seen as a veteran of that genre/music scene in the eyes of the younger people in that scenario.
Anyway, my original point of writing this is to say that I don't necessarily think a cover, remix, re-edit of a song needs to be classified as better or worse.
All of the various versions can live alongside each other, as long as they are all well produced pieces of music and that the bits they copy from the original are reused in an interesting way.
A quick example of an original song being reworked in very different ways but at the same time, you can hear that all of the versions retain some of the same musical elements, as well as invoking similar feelings but by going about things in a different way.
One of my favourite songs ever is Roy Ayres - Everybody Loves The Sunshine.
This original version was released in 1976 -
https://youtu.be/nC9dQOnUyao?si=b6LfELFKEkepHuOu
Here is a Drum & Bass version released in 2020 -
https://youtu.be/4kN1xkQ4lcI?si=blZ8XfnEvYcDPTYA
This is a chilled out Hip Hop version released in 2018 -
https://youtu.be/U_PQxFJvet0?si=czKuuy8eKIfwtN82
The biggest issue blocking new versions of original songs is copyright when using audio samples. However, in the current electronic dance music scene, there is a thriving movement referred to as bootlegs.
These are unofficial due to the use of unpaid for audio samples from the original songs. However, the producers of these bootlegs will often release them for free online as .mp3 files, typically for the use of DJs or to be enjoyed and appreciated by the people who understand whatever genre the bootleg fits into.
I think this is a great thing and makes a lot of sense.
All of us were in some way influenced by the music we heard when we were younger. From what our parents were into, what we heard on TV etc. For me, I think it is a bit ridiculous for a record label to try to charge some young, semi amateur music producer because they sampled a part of a song they love and turned it into something entirely different musically.
I think the to bootlegs of the original I've linked above a good way for me to explain what I'm talking about.
Obviously, when it comes to a major worldwide music star ripping off a previously unknown independent band and almost directly copying the essence of one of their songs, it is a very different matter.
Especially if they are selling it and making huge sums of money from it and not crediting the original creators in any way.