Southgate Resigned
#71
I've criticised Southgate, I've also highlighted some of the good he's done. No vitriol from me, it's more hyperbole from people simply disagreeing.

I was in Germany and didn't throw any beer at him or abuse him.

Highlighting he's just a bit short on tactical nous at this level and has made some strange decisions at Euro 24 in particular is ok.

I do believe we have a squad of players much closer in quality with the other nations than in the past too (bar maybe the wasted Sven years) and that has to be taken into account.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#72
(07-16-2024, 04:12 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I've criticised Southgate, I've also highlighted some of the good he's done.  No vitriol from me, it's more hyperbole from people simply disagreeing.

I was in Germany and didn't throw any beer at him or abuse him.

Highlighting he's just a bit short on tactical nous at this level and has made some strange decisions at Euro 24 in particular is ok.

I do believe we have a squad of players much closer in quality with the other nations than in the past too (bar maybe the wasted Sven years) and that has to be taken into account.

The only real way of determining the job Southgate has done is in comparison to his predecessor and the next managers record. The rest is just opinion.
Reply
#73
(07-16-2024, 04:15 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-16-2024, 04:12 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I've criticised Southgate, I've also highlighted some of the good he's done.  No vitriol from me, it's more hyperbole from people simply disagreeing.

I was in Germany and didn't throw any beer at him or abuse him.

Highlighting he's just a bit short on tactical nous at this level and has made some strange decisions at Euro 24 in particular is ok.

I do believe we have a squad of players much closer in quality with the other nations than in the past too (bar maybe the wasted Sven years) and that has to be taken into account.

The only real way of determining the job Southgate has done is in comparison to his predecessor and the next managers record. The rest is just opinion.

Agreed. The only other variables being the whole of the playing squad and the standard of the oppositions, I guess.
Reply
#74
(07-16-2024, 04:15 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-16-2024, 04:12 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I've criticised Southgate, I've also highlighted some of the good he's done.  No vitriol from me, it's more hyperbole from people simply disagreeing.

I was in Germany and didn't throw any beer at him or abuse him.

Highlighting he's just a bit short on tactical nous at this level and has made some strange decisions at Euro 24 in particular is ok.

I do believe we have a squad of players much closer in quality with the other nations than in the past too (bar maybe the wasted Sven years) and that has to be taken into account.

The only real way of determining the job Southgate has done is in comparison to his predecessor and the next managers record. The rest is just opinion.
Not sure about that comparison DH. A bit like saying I'll never know how good my Austin Allegro is until I've got that nice shiny Hillman Avenger...
We went into this tournament virtually all agreeing we have a plethora of attacking midfielders that will probably be let down by the defence. In the event, our defence looked solid. Just maybe we looked dull because our midfielders assisted the defence a lot. The new man will need to take all this into account before he delivers the death or glory football some of our fans want.
Reply
#75
Surely after six years of pragmatism we’ve reached the point in the cycle where people start screaming “PASSHUN!!!!”?

Who is the passhun candidate these days?
Reply
#76
For me Southgate has done a very good job in elevating us up to a level where we are consistently getting to semi's and finals and that is no mean feet to where we have been over the last 50 years. That said I really believe we have had the squad, and the opportunity, to really win something in his tenure and ultimately, when push comes to shove, he just hasn't got the tactical nous or verve to really go for the jugular.

I've felt in the last few years he's started to shoehorn his favourites in the starting 11 over the greater good of the side. Putting square pegs in round holes rather than looking at where these players play best for their clubs and working out a cohesive side. If that means leaving out some Stella players then so be it.

In summary he's a top bloke who I think has done a very good job but ultimately fell just short. Agree with others who think he's an International manager. Really don't see him cutting it in the prem. USA could do a lot worse than take him on.
Reply
#77
(07-16-2024, 04:49 PM)Fido Wrote:
(07-16-2024, 04:15 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-16-2024, 04:12 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I've criticised Southgate, I've also highlighted some of the good he's done.  No vitriol from me, it's more hyperbole from people simply disagreeing.

I was in Germany and didn't throw any beer at him or abuse him.

Highlighting he's just a bit short on tactical nous at this level and has made some strange decisions at Euro 24 in particular is ok.

I do believe we have a squad of players much closer in quality with the other nations than in the past too (bar maybe the wasted Sven years) and that has to be taken into account.

The only real way of determining the job Southgate has done is in comparison to his predecessor and the next managers record. The rest is just opinion.

Agreed. The only other variables being the whole of the playing squad and the standard of the oppositions, I guess.

… and we are judging him against what criteria otherwise? His record reads as follows two Euros runners-up medals, a World Cup semi-final and a quarter-final.
Reply
#78
He has the same World Cup record as Bobby Robson, arguably Bobby’s was better. Lost in ‘86 by a hand ball goal to the eventual winners and lost on penalties in ‘90, again to the eventual winners.

This current team has more quality than the ‘90 squad. We’re playing in European club competitions and have players abroad, alongside a far higher standard domestic league with players from all over the world.
The pool of players is smaller but the quality is much better. Up to Italia ‘90 we’d been banned for 5 years and our domestic game really suffered.

In ‘98 we lost on pens to Argentina with 10 men or we got knocked out in the 2nd Round if you want to see it that way. We ended up against Argentina because we failed to win the group. That’s what Southgate has stopped. We may well have lost to Croatia in the 2nd Round instead or Germany in the QF we’ll never know.

Yes Southgate has massively dragged us up from a low ebb, he’s brought a togetherness and a love from fans for the national side again. He’s also produced a consistency of results, we rarely trip up against lesser nations which is an improvement on many before him, sadly we rarely beat the higher ranking ones as previously happened. IMO I believe we have the squad capable of doing so now and that’s the difference. We can’t be default say Southgate did a good job just because Sven or Capello underperformed with the supposed golden generation.

Yes Southgate has done a good job in many aspects, but he’s not shown us that’s he’s a top tactical coach.

The next man (or woman) doesn’t have to have a great club record, Redknapp would have been a fucking disaster, they need to have the tactical wherewithal against the other countries top managers.

That’s not vitriolic (I haven’t seen a single vitriolic post on here despite most football fans being like that ffs).
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#79
Right decision for him and the country I think.

Problem is who replaces him?
Reply
#80
(07-16-2024, 07:40 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: He has the same World Cup record as Bobby Robson, arguably Bobby’s was better.  Lost in ‘86 by a hand ball goal to the eventual winners and lost on penalties in ‘90, again to the eventual winners. 

This current team has more quality than the ‘90 squad.  We’re playing in European club competitions and have players abroad, alongside a far higher standard domestic league with players from all over the world.
The pool of players is smaller but the quality is much better.  Up to Italia ‘90 we’d been banned for 5 years and our domestic game really suffered.

In ‘98 we lost on pens to Argentina with 10 men or we got knocked out in the 2nd Round if you want to see it that way.  We ended up against Argentina because we failed to win the group.  That’s what Southgate has stopped.  We may well have lost to Croatia in the 2nd Round instead or Germany in the QF we’ll never know.

Yes Southgate has massively dragged us up from a low ebb, he’s brought a togetherness and a love from fans for the national side again.  He’s also produced a consistency of results, we rarely trip up against lesser nations which is an improvement on many before him, sadly we rarely beat the higher ranking ones as previously happened.  IMO I believe we have the squad capable of doing so now and that’s the difference.  We can’t be default say Southgate did a good job just because Sven or Capello underperformed with the supposed golden generation.

Yes Southgate has done a good job in many aspects, but he’s not shown us that’s he’s a top tactical coach.

The next man (or woman) doesn’t have to have a great club record, Redknapp would have been a fucking disaster, they need to have the tactical wherewithal against the other countries top managers.

That’s not vitriolic (I haven’t seen a single vitriolic post on here despite most football fans being like that ffs).

To do better the next manager will have to win the Euros and get to a World Cup final. Not a lot of wriggle room being set by those who think Southgate has reached his limit.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)