Israel
(07-16-2024, 02:37 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-16-2024, 02:10 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: They don't need to be popular, fact is it's either the PA or Hamas.

So you expect the PA to be able to negotiate an enduring two-state solution when they haven't had a democratic mandate for two decades and two-fifths of the population of the West Bank would prefer a terrorist regime?

And you expect the Israelis to be interested in parle with an illegitimate, weak, self-serving and corrupt cadre in the pursuit of a two-state solution? 

Good luck with that.

No I wouldn't expect Israel to be interested in that.

If Israel had been genuinely interested in pursuing a two state solution, they wouldn't have deliberately gone about undermining the authority of the PA.
Reply
I expect that the PA will gladly sign an agreement with Israel with respect to establishing a two-state solution on the condition of Israel first getting a government that wants it and second withdraws from the illegal settlements in the West Bank. I also expect that on an agreement being signed to do just that the international community will support the implementation of a two-state solution and help guarantee political stability, much as they've done in other regions (Northern Ireland, Kosovo, central America, Indonesia, Cambodia, Germany). The barrier to actually starting that process lies within in Israel and is currently running the country.

The fact is, despite your aversion to accepting it, that the only entity that can displace Hamas in Gaza is the PA. Israel cannot permanently occupy Gaza without committing a genocide, Hamas need to be displaced by an entity (and there's only one entity, the PA) otherwise they will continue to come back in one form or another.
Reply
(07-16-2024, 03:02 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I expect that the PA will gladly sign an agreement with Israel with respect to establishing a two-state solution on the condition of Israel first getting a government that wants it and second withdraws from the illegal settlements in the West Bank. I also expect that on an agreement being signed to do just that the international community will support the implementation of a two-state solution and help guarantee political stability, much as they've done in other regions (Northern Ireland, Kosovo, central America, Indonesia, Cambodia, Germany). The barrier to actually starting that process lies within in Israel and is currently running the country.

The fact is, despite your aversion to accepting it, that the only entity that can displace Hamas in Gaza is the PA. Israel cannot permanently occupy Gaza without committing a genocide, Hamas need to be displaced by an entity (and there's only one entity, the PA) otherwise they will continue to come back in one form or another.

I commend your faith in the wholly illegitimate and corrupt PA. I'm afraid I don't share it.

(07-16-2024, 02:57 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: If Israel had been genuinely interested in pursuing a two state solution, they wouldn't have deliberately gone about undermining the authority of the PA.

Well quite, Israel is not interested in pursuing a two state solution.
Reply
It's not faith in the PA, it's the acknowledgement that the PA are infinitely better than Hamas and the only political entity that can displace Hamas from Gaza through international support.
Reply
(07-16-2024, 03:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It's not faith in the PA, it's the acknowledgement that the PA are infinitely better than Hamas and the only political entity that can displace Hamas from Gaza through international support.

Oh. OK.

The problem that they're a venal, corrupt and illegitimate entity with little popular support from Palestinians doesn't worry you?

#LeastWorst, maybe?
Reply
The problems with the Israeli government and Hamas worry me significantly more.
Reply
(07-16-2024, 03:37 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-16-2024, 03:02 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I expect that the PA will gladly sign an agreement with Israel with respect to establishing a two-state solution on the condition of Israel first getting a government that wants it and second withdraws from the illegal settlements in the West Bank. I also expect that on an agreement being signed to do just that the international community will support the implementation of a two-state solution and help guarantee political stability, much as they've done in other regions (Northern Ireland, Kosovo, central America, Indonesia, Cambodia, Germany). The barrier to actually starting that process lies within in Israel and is currently running the country.

The fact is, despite your aversion to accepting it, that the only entity that can displace Hamas in Gaza is the PA. Israel cannot permanently occupy Gaza without committing a genocide, Hamas need to be displaced by an entity (and there's only one entity, the PA) otherwise they will continue to come back in one form or another.

I commend your faith in the wholly illegitimate and corrupt PA. I'm afraid I don't share it.

(07-16-2024, 02:57 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: If Israel had been genuinely interested in pursuing a two state solution, they wouldn't have deliberately gone about undermining the authority of the PA.

Well quite, Israel is not interested in pursuing a two state solution.

Well yes I think we all know this to be true.

Makes you wonder why friends of Israel, such as the USA, still pretend this is a viable option and the one they are pursuing.
Israel have many so called friends who are happy to turn a blind eye to much egregious behaviour by the IsraeliGovt, but little in the way of true friends who are prepared to tell them some home truths.
Reply
(07-16-2024, 04:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The problems with the Israeli government and Hamas worry me significantly more.

Quite. As I said #LeastWorst.

(07-16-2024, 04:33 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Israel have many so called friends who are happy to turn a blind eye to much egregious behaviour by the IsraeliGovt, but little in the way of true friends who are prepared to tell them some home truths.

It's one thing telling Israel some home truths. Quite another crafting a lasting solution in the crucible of the Middle East.

In Bibi's shoes that would be my question to the free world.
Reply
https://x.com/abierkhatib/status/1813558...73690?s=46

More facts for the weak minded on here to reject

https://x.com/kahlissee/status/1813331536626020492?s=46
Someone could have been killed
Reply
The Knesset has voted to reject the two-state solution.

https://www.timesofisrael.com/knesset-vo...s-us-trip/

Yet more Bantustans for thee, democracy for me.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)