The state of the criminal justice system
#31
Tax credits were well intended and had a very positive impact on reducing child poverty. However, as with PIP, after a time people adapt their choices and the intention became a perverse incentive
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#32
Here are the realities of austerity… austerity was necessary for those with the least

This is where the Libertarians pick and choose when they care about the most vulnerable.
Reply
#33
(07-15-2024, 09:33 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Tax credits were well intended and had a very positive impact on reducing child poverty. However, as with PIP, after a time people adapt their choices and the intention became a perverse incentive

Precisely. And better not to take money off people in the first place, then create a massive bureaucracy to give it back - unless you're doing that for votes, which is what happened.

(07-16-2024, 06:26 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Here are the realities of austerity… austerity was necessary for those with the least

This is where the Libertarians pick and choose when they care about the most vulnerable.

Austerity, such as it was, ended in 2015. Life is likely to be a struggle for the poorest under any government. Why? Because they're poor.

You can just spell out the inequality in tax treatment you'd like to introduce to move towards greater income equality. Go on. Who pays more?

And how does that effect their behaviour? https://www.ft.com/content/a61b6b66-1048...121b4fcb1e
Reply
#34
I don’t fully agree with you about not redistributing, tax credits just needed to evolve and be tapered better but they went from float to anchor in the space of five years
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#35
(07-15-2024, 12:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Yes, yes, yes only if you believe in Keynesianism which served this country so badly up to 1979. Krugman, like Keynes would pay people to dig ditches and fill them back in.

At the time I said that we'd all have to accept being a little bit poorer and paying more tax. As it is no-one accepted they needed to be poorer for the sake of our kids and grandkids, and the coalition largely avoided tax increases (quite the opposite for the lowest paid). Instead choosing to kick the can down the road on debt (as I also said ad infinitum 2010-15).

Add in Covid and Energy Price Support and this is the reckoning.

With virtual full employment the only thing a Keynesian boom would have done then or do now is revive inflation. Which would force interest rates on government debt up. There is a reason Labour, the Tories, the BoE and the bond markets all supported a degree of austerity in 2010. #LeastWorst, you could say.

Hayek's libertarianism and his loathing of Socialism gave birth to your fundamental beliefs and everything you think flows from it.  You just read the wrong book.
Reply
#36
I'm not sure what's wrong with economic and social freedom from coercion. Maybe you can provide the counter argument?

And I'm not sure what relevance your comment has to the post you quoted. What do you disagree with there?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)