Posts: 641
Threads: 32
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
5
(07-14-2024, 10:28 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: (07-14-2024, 10:25 PM)Duffers Wrote: (07-14-2024, 10:23 PM)spudgun Wrote: I couldn't help wondering tonight whether a Pulis side could beat the Spanish by frustrating the crap out of them, denying them space and hitting the channels early to play for set pieces and long throws.
Would be awful to watch, but would it have worked if the players would buy in to it? (not that I think they would for a second!)
The one thing England sides have never been is streetwise. Knowing when to slow games down, draw fouls, deploy the “dark arts”, etc.
Agree.
Most of that stuff is usually carried out when we are ahead with the clock ticking. Would have been of little use in this tournament!
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
The key is getting somebody really tactically astute into the set up. Not Steve Holland.
How about Liam Rosenior?
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
07-15-2024, 08:40 AM
(This post was last modified: 07-15-2024, 08:42 AM by AnelkasBeard.)
I really really don't understand the vitriol directed at Southgate. We've had 2 semi finals in over 40 years before he came in. Enjoy the fact we're actually competing at the business end of tournaments.
"But he had easy draws" "He loses to the first good team we face" - Does no-one remember how BAD it was before the last 6 years?
Euro 2016 - We lost to fucking Iceland
WC 2014 - We went out in the groups to Costa fucking Rica.
Euro 2012 - lost to Italy in the first difficult game.
WC2010 - pretty crap in the groups, then we all know what happened, but still got destroyed by a good Germany team.
Euro 2008 - We didn't even qualify.
WC 2006 - we got an own goal to beat Paraguay, squeaked past Trinidad and Tobago in the last 10 minutes in the groups, then snuck past Ecuador 1-0 to lose to "the first good team we faced" in Portugal.
Euro 2004 was probably the last time we had a really good, potentially tournament winning team and we still lost to Portugal the first good ones we faced.
"Oh but Southgate had more talent" - the 00s England teams were called the "Golden Generation" ffs. Gerrard, Lampard, Scholes, Rooney, Owen, Terry, Cole, Beckham, Campbell, Ferdinand etc etc. All fantastic players.
It's okay to admit we were just beaten by the better team on the night, and we were underdogs. We could have played better, he has made mistakes, but Spain won it fair and square. Look at what we had to deal with for the previous 20 years, never mind all that went before that.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(07-15-2024, 05:44 AM)Duffers Wrote: (07-15-2024, 03:56 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Southgate was a failed club manager.
At international level you can’t just buy players you have to work with that you’ve got, it’s why I don’t really like comparing eras. Is Southgate a better manager than Terry Venables? Or Bobby Robson?
Nope - he’s just had the job at a time we’ve got better players in comparison.
What he has done well is make the international football team likeable again; that element will be tough act to follow. The next 2 competitions will show if he was a good coach too.
Do the tournaments that predecded him not count for anything?
We were going out in groups and losing to Iceland pre-Southgate. It got so bad they felt they had to give Fat Sam a job.
It did indeed. Much like Bruce at the Albion, it shows what a poisonous atmosphere can do. Gareth has lifted that and we’ve moved on. My point was more that all international managers are, to an extent, constrained by the quality of the players available and the expectations that go with that.
This tournament:
1. he had no LB cover and didn’t really cover the left side in general.
2. We have a forward in Kane who scores for fun and has all season. His career has been spent with pacy players narrow either side of him and he did well for England with Rashford and Sterling doing that. Why the change in formation?
3. Experimenting with TAA at the start? I’m not averse to trying TAA in that role, but I’d suggest the start of a major tournament isn’t the place to trial it. We had no settled plan, formation or style.
That’s just 3 major errors that haunted us through the competition and he never corrected them. Yes he dropped TAA but we still lacked cohesion or a pattern of play.
Southgate lifted us from our possibly our lowest ebb v Iceland and we’ve come on a long way but our win record against the top teams with him in charge isn’t great at all, way below par.
We started the Euros as the favourites, based on the squad, by the time we got to the final we were the underdog. Has Southgate’s England ever beaten a team that you didn’t expect to? He doesn’t really lose when not expected to either, that’s the bit he’s changed. That last step doesn’t appear to be in him and that’s where the good managers really show their ability.
I’ve seen our routes in completions be commented upon. There’s no denying we’ve had the better side on a couple of occasions, that’s not a stick to beat him with. For me it highlights we beat the teams we should and lose to the teams who are a match for us on paper.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(07-15-2024, 08:54 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: (07-15-2024, 05:44 AM)Duffers Wrote: (07-15-2024, 03:56 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Southgate was a failed club manager.
At international level you can’t just buy players you have to work with that you’ve got, it’s why I don’t really like comparing eras. Is Southgate a better manager than Terry Venables? Or Bobby Robson?
Nope - he’s just had the job at a time we’ve got better players in comparison.
What he has done well is make the international football team likeable again; that element will be tough act to follow. The next 2 competitions will show if he was a good coach too.
Do the tournaments that predecded him not count for anything?
We were going out in groups and losing to Iceland pre-Southgate. It got so bad they felt they had to give Fat Sam a job.
It did indeed. Much like Bruce at the Albion, it shows what a poisonous atmosphere can do. Gareth has lifted that and we’ve moved on. My point was more that all international managers are, to an extent, constrained by the quality of the players available and the expectations that go with that.
This tournament:
1. he had no LB cover and didn’t really cover the left side in general.
2. We have a forward in Kane who scores for fun and has all season. His career has been spent with pacy players narrow either side of him and he did well for England with Rashford and Sterling doing that. Why the change in formation?
3. Experimenting with TAA at the start? I’m not averse to trying TAA in that role, but I’d suggest the start of a major tournament isn’t the place to trial it. We had no settled plan, formation or style.
That’s just 3 major errors that haunted us through the competition and he never corrected them. Yes he dropped TAA but we still lacked cohesion or a pattern of play.
Southgate lifted us from our possibly our lowest ebb v Iceland and we’ve come on a long way but our win record against the top teams with him in charge isn’t great at all, way below par.
We started the Euros as the favourites, based on the squad, by the time we got to the final we were the underdog. Has Southgate’s England ever beaten a team that you didn’t expect to? He doesn’t really lose when not expected to either, that’s the bit he’s changed. That last step doesn’t appear to be in him and that’s where the good managers really show their ability.
I’ve seen our routes in completions be commented upon. There’s no denying we’ve had the better side on a couple of occasions, that’s not a stick to beat him with. For me it highlights we beat the teams we should and lose to the teams who are a match for us on paper.
This was my reasoning for listing out what we've done previously - we never beat the big Nations, and quite often lost to the smaller nations we should beat. This isn't a stick to beat Southgate with - it's simply what England always do. And we've come a darn site closer to beating those big teams under him than anyone else.
Posts: 27,981
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
When people say "lucky routes" they also fail to take into account that we often get "easier" runs through knockouts because other big nations fuck up their own draws. We usually do our bit by winning the group, not sure it's luck that other sides don't do theirs.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(07-15-2024, 08:26 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The key is getting somebody really tactically astute into the set up. Not Steve Holland.
How about Liam Rosenior?
This is probably my biggest criticism of Southgate - that he's had 4 tournaments now and failed to address the tactical weaknesses he and his team have. Just having somebody in the stands relaying ideas to the bench would have been beneficial in the bigger games.
Posts: 4,668
Threads: 183
Joined: Nov 2022
Reputation:
14
(07-15-2024, 09:12 AM)Duffers Wrote: When people say "lucky routes" they also fail to take into account that we often get "easier" runs through knockouts because other big nations fuck up their own draws. We usually do our bit by winning the group, not sure it's luck that other sides don't do theirs.
Fair point.
But it's also fair to point out Southgate has had good fortune in coming up against nations we should be beating in knockouts. That's not his fault, of course, but it's a fact that draws have opened up favourably for him like no other England manager.
Unfortunately he is tactically unaware and can't get the job done against a competitive nation. That's also a fact. 5 wins in 26 games against the top nations tells you that.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
As ever this seems to be a playing out that if you don't think Southgate is up to taking us any further then you must think he's shit and vice versa.
I recognise he's done good with the England squad. I also recognise he's had a better squad to work with than some before him. If the praise is that he didn't do as shit as Capello or Hodgson, then that is really a poor argument. He's brought a togetherness to the squad where there was previously club factions and won the games he should (on paper) against the opposition we should win. He's shown a poor return against the bigger nations. If i was picking a squad on paper from last night, prior to the tournament, you'd choose England's. Yet we never quite played as a team and the Spaniards did. Individual skill, such as Bellingham's bicycle kick, will only take you so far. The extra bit comes from the coaching, the plan, the detail of subtle tweaks that make a difference. I've not seen that from him, as an example you'll see CC slightly change things in game and the pattern of play changes. I can't recall that happening with Southgate.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 11,922
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
07-15-2024, 10:07 AM
(This post was last modified: 07-15-2024, 10:07 AM by CarlosCorbewrong.)
Fuck it, whilst we're spacegoating - has Pickford ever made a save, for England, that you didn't expect him to be able to make?
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
|