OFWAT's the point, more like
#11
Re nationalisation is the only way to end this greed
They cant be trusted to deal with sewage
OFWAT & Environment Agency both as fucking useless as each other
Employing people on high paid salaries to justify the poor performance of these companies

Ive never agreed with privatisation of utility companies
The Water was never needed as never any competition
Reply
#12
It’s not far off privatising oxygen. It should never have happened, should be reversed and should never happen again
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#13
(07-12-2024, 10:53 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: It’s not far off privatising oxygen. It should never have happened, should be reversed and should never happen again

Agreed - same with utilities. Fucking disgrace.
Reply
#14
(07-12-2024, 10:53 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: It’s not far off privatising oxygen. It should never have happened, should be reversed and should never happen again

Nationalisation is not a panacea. I did surveying work for STW pre and post-privatisation, and I can tell you that the privatised firm was far more commercial / professional in in its dealings with me and my then firm. Welsh Water remains not-for-profit and suffers from similar outcomes to other water companies.

That is not to say that privatisation has been a "good thing", only to say that regulation of the sector (in common with the other utilities) has been toothless and largely reactive.
Reply
#15
Like with everything Proth, it needs doing properly whatever sphere it sits in. The bottom line is though, no one should be using such a fundamental human resource as water to issue profits to shareholders. The rest of the discussion should come after that, not alongside it
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#16
(07-12-2024, 11:59 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Like with everything Proth, it needs doing properly whatever sphere it sits in. The bottom line is though, no one should be using such a fundamental human resource as water to issue profits to shareholders. The rest of the discussion should come after that, not alongside it

They'd be perfectly entitled to issue profits to shareholders if water supply was clean and uninterrupted, and the sewage system wasn't a Victorian relic. How the regulator hasn't spotted this anomaly is beyond me tbh. The true picture of sewage has only become clear since widespread monitoring has been implemented, so it's not a new thing - however the sheer scale of the problem ought to have elicited regulatory and government action. It didn't, that literally stinks.

You could say something similar about prisons - the the criminal justice canary has been dead in its cage for some time.
Reply
#17
There is absolutely no need to have supply of a human essential managed on a way that profits from it working properly and being delivered and managed in a manner befitting that. The very fact that you acknowledge that it needs State intervention regardless tells you everything you need to know.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#18
Ofwat is the issue, Labour need to bin it off and absorb it's powers into a new body adjacent to the Environment Agency with better legal powers - putting it adjacent to the EA will hopefully resist the regulatory capture that has resulted in Ofwat being so tepid.
Reply
#19
(07-12-2024, 03:02 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Ofwat is the issue, Labour need to bin it off and absorb it's powers into a new body adjacent to the Environment Agency with better legal powers - putting it adjacent to the EA will hopefully resist the regulatory capture that has resulted in Ofwat being so tepid.

Indeed.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: