Posts: 987
Threads: 13
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(07-09-2024, 07:32 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (07-08-2024, 07:04 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: If you fine the firms, and the people have bought a product which wasn’t what was advertised, shouldn’t the money be distributed among the people that were the customers? Surely it would be more absurd for the fine or recompense to be in the coffers of state structures?
The behaviour was a regulatory breach. Hence a regulatory fine.
Like I say, no consumer has suffered a consequential loss.
If the car was advertised at 60mpg but only does 50mpg the customer uses more fuel that they have to pay for. Why isn't that a loss?
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(07-09-2024, 07:48 AM)Morley Wrote: If the car was advertised at 60mpg but only does 50mpg the customer uses more fuel that they have to pay for. Why isn't that a loss?
MPG is not the basis for the claim.
Posts: 11,922
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
Think of the boost to the economy if everyone who had a car of a certain age suddenly had some wedge? #FinancialExpert
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 4,668
Threads: 183
Joined: Nov 2022
Reputation:
14
It's not even been a week under Labour government and already people are clamouring to get something for nothing!
Posts: 527
Threads: 5
Joined: Dec 2019
Reputation:
7
(07-09-2024, 08:35 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: It's not even been a week under Labour government and already people are clamouring to get something for nothing!
Clever use of irony about a thread that started in Nov 2022 at the height of Boris’s grab anything you can get culture
Posts: 665
Threads: 28
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
(07-08-2024, 06:24 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (07-08-2024, 02:55 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: You have previously stated that it is a moral obligation to reduce one’s tax liability as far as is legally possible to maximise income, which I wouldn’t disagree with.
However, why the outrage when people look to maximise their income with a payout from multinational corporations, off the back of these corporations’ outright criminality?
It's not outrage, it's simply that there's no merit to the case for an individual as no individual has suffered any consequential loss.
By all means fine the firms for cheating, but don't pretend that anyone decided to buy an oil burner on environmental grounds.
But many many people did because the government narrative of the time was based on reducing Co2 emissions and company car / road tax was adjusted to follow suit. Choosing a lower c02 emitting vehicle was better for the environment (and still is) when you consider that particular pollutant in isolation.
As scientific and govt understanding of micro particles and the more significant Nox improved and battery technology improved, the govt road tax narrative changed to support electric vehicle purchases and company cars in the same way.
Unfortunately in the height of the diesel boom, the super fuel efficient low Co2 emitting and arguably most popular diesels of the time from VAG were hiding their true NoX emissions for the EU and other testing regimes and then happily pumping out multiple times the amount of Nox that they had been certified as producing to us poor souls in the general public.
There is ample research of Nox emissions on human lung health, preventable deaths, increased asthma rates in children and so on so the consequential loss is right there. We know it's happening but the UK government and legal system is not able to deliver true justice which IMHO would be 10 years of tariffs added on to the purchase price of new VAG vehicles of which monies would then be put straight into NHS coffers.
The class actions are not perfect, but they are merely an accessible form of resolution which will put some level of financial hardship the way of motor manufacturers who yet again put profit before truth, before people. The main consequential loss is to society and health. The secondary consequential losses are for those that purchased vehicles for market values based on the vehicles advertised and tested performance and emissions that they could then not deliver in real life and therefore not worth the purchase price paid - a loss for each consumer whether they were aware of it or not.
Posts: 11,922
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(07-09-2024, 08:47 AM)Bristolbion Wrote: (07-09-2024, 08:35 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: It's not even been a week under Labour government and already people are clamouring to get something for nothing!
Clever use of irony about a thread that started in Nov 2022 at the height of Boris’s grab anything you can get culture
It's Starmer's fault the M5 isn't finished.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 988
Threads: 43
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation:
0
07-09-2024, 08:55 AM
(This post was last modified: 07-09-2024, 09:08 AM by 1952.)
(07-09-2024, 08:52 AM)lemon Wrote: (07-08-2024, 06:24 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (07-08-2024, 02:55 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: You have previously stated that it is a moral obligation to reduce one’s tax liability as far as is legally possible to maximise income, which I wouldn’t disagree with.
However, why the outrage when people look to maximise their income with a payout from multinational corporations, off the back of these corporations’ outright criminality?
It's not outrage, it's simply that there's no merit to the case for an individual as no individual has suffered any consequential loss.
By all means fine the firms for cheating, but don't pretend that anyone decided to buy an oil burner on environmental grounds.
But many many people did because the government narrative of the time was based on reducing Co2 emissions and company car / road tax was adjusted to follow suit. Choosing a lower c02 emitting vehicle was better for the environment (and still is) when you consider that particular pollutant in isolation.
As scientific and govt understanding of micro particles and the more significant Nox improved and battery technology improved, the govt road tax narrative changed to support electric vehicle purchases and company cars in the same way.
Unfortunately in the height of the diesel boom, the super fuel efficient low Co2 emitting and arguably most popular diesels of the time from VAG were hiding their true NoX emissions for the EU and other testing regimes and then happily pumping out multiple times the amount of Nox that they had been certified as producing to us poor souls in the general public.
There is ample research of Nox emissions on human lung health, preventable deaths, increased asthma rates in children and so on so the consequential loss is right there. We know it's happening but the UK government and legal system is not able to deliver true justice which IMHO would be 10 years of tariffs added on to the purchase price of new VAG vehicles of which monies would then be put straight into NHS coffers.
The class actions are not perfect, but they are merely an accessible form of resolution which will put some level of financial hardship the way of motor manufacturers who yet again put profit before truth, before people. The main consequential loss is to society and health. The secondary consequential losses are for those that purchased vehicles for market values based on the vehicles advertised and tested performance and emissions that they could then not deliver in real life and therefore not worth the purchase price paid - a loss for each consumer whether they were aware of it or not.
Excellent post
Scanning back through previous posts I saw a few posters who qualified but decided not to claim.
I know a few guys with Audi's that had the same engine. Each got the same payout.
Asuming there's a pot of money somewhere to cover claims for all the cars sold that could qualify what happens to the monies not claimed? Where does it sit, who benefits from it?
Posts: 4,668
Threads: 183
Joined: Nov 2022
Reputation:
14
07-09-2024, 09:20 AM
(This post was last modified: 07-09-2024, 09:23 AM by SuperBob2002.)
(07-09-2024, 08:47 AM)Bristolbion Wrote: (07-09-2024, 08:35 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: It's not even been a week under Labour government and already people are clamouring to get something for nothing!
Clever use of irony about a thread that started in Nov 2022 at the height of Boris’s grab anything you can get culture
It's a frilly tongue in cheek post!
But I'll tak a whoosh as I hadn't noticed the date of the original Fred!
Actually, we're still under (technically) a Tory government, so whether it was posted today or when ten years ago, shouldn't make a difference!
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(07-09-2024, 08:52 AM)lemon Wrote: (07-08-2024, 06:24 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (07-08-2024, 02:55 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: You have previously stated that it is a moral obligation to reduce one’s tax liability as far as is legally possible to maximise income, which I wouldn’t disagree with.
However, why the outrage when people look to maximise their income with a payout from multinational corporations, off the back of these corporations’ outright criminality?
It's not outrage, it's simply that there's no merit to the case for an individual as no individual has suffered any consequential loss.
By all means fine the firms for cheating, but don't pretend that anyone decided to buy an oil burner on environmental grounds.
But many many people did because the government narrative of the time was based on reducing Co2 emissions and company car / road tax was adjusted to follow suit. Choosing a lower c02 emitting vehicle was better for the environment (and still is) when you consider that particular pollutant in isolation.
As scientific and govt understanding of micro particles and the more significant Nox improved and battery technology improved, the govt road tax narrative changed to support electric vehicle purchases and company cars in the same way.
Unfortunately in the height of the diesel boom, the super fuel efficient low Co2 emitting and arguably most popular diesels of the time from VAG were hiding their true NoX emissions for the EU and other testing regimes and then happily pumping out multiple times the amount of Nox that they had been certified as producing to us poor souls in the general public.
There is ample research of Nox emissions on human lung health, preventable deaths, increased asthma rates in children and so on so the consequential loss is right there. We know it's happening but the UK government and legal system is not able to deliver true justice which IMHO would be 10 years of tariffs added on to the purchase price of new VAG vehicles of which monies would then be put straight into NHS coffers.
The class actions are not perfect, but they are merely an accessible form of resolution which will put some level of financial hardship the way of motor manufacturers who yet again put profit before truth, before people. The main consequential loss is to society and health. The secondary consequential losses are for those that purchased vehicles for market values based on the vehicles advertised and tested performance and emissions that they could then not deliver in real life and therefore not worth the purchase price paid - a loss for each consumer whether they were aware of it or not.
Exactly. So regulatory breaches = regulatory fines.
Good luck with proving any diminution in market value of those cars. There is no consequential loss to the individual.
I can promise you that class action like this is only to the benefit of law firms. No one else. It's exactly the same for the huge class action on Visa / Mastercard interchange fees - the only people who will make any money will be law firms and their funders.
|