Reform
#31
(07-05-2024, 08:34 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:12 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:00 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 07:33 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 07:25 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Would imagine the Reform vote would have been a lot higher had so many polling stations not been in primary schools.

Strong contender for post of the year.

The nazis rose to power by targeting genuine grievances and attributing them to 'foreigners'. 

The ruling class and the intelligentsia dismissed them and their supporters as idiots and fringe.

A world war later and everyone had learned. The ruling classes realised that they had to address real concerns and not let them get hijacked by extremists. Hence NHS and German reconstruction.

It seems the lesson has been forgotten. Everyone who votes Brexit is labelled as stupid, everyone who votes reform is a racist. But nobody is actually solving the very real problems that's pursuading them to vote  they way they are.

Most people are middle of the road, they just want a quiet, comfortable life and extremists are the antithesis of that. The only way they can be agitated is if they are ignored or feel insulted. Which is exactly what has been happening (especially with this government - both with the policies and the way they behaved).

The only saving grace for me is that unlike Hitler, I don't think BJ (he'll be back) or farage have any deep seated convictions. They just have a lust for power and they'l do what they can to get it. If they ever get it, they'll do fuck all with it. They don't have the talent or the agenda - they'll just do what they can to keep it. (Of course, they thought AH was talentless as well.)

I didn't say they were racist or stupid.

Aren't you doing exactly what Farage does when he dog-whistles and then denies it with a smug grin on his face?

It is a small joke. It's just a joke. Like when a Reform candidate referred to an autistic child as a "vegetable", or when a Reform candidate said that LGBTQ+ people were "paedophilles", or when a Reform candidate referred to black people as "jungle bunnies", or when a Reform candidate used the term "chinky" to describe a Chinese woman, or when a Reform candidate said that Nicola Sturgeon should be shot, or when the leader of Reform sang Hitler Youth songs. It's just a joke.
Reply
#32
Yup, definitely not stupid or racist.
In the form of his life.
Reply
#33
(07-05-2024, 08:46 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:34 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:12 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:00 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 07:33 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: Strong contender for post of the year.

The nazis rose to power by targeting genuine grievances and attributing them to 'foreigners'. 

The ruling class and the intelligentsia dismissed them and their supporters as idiots and fringe.

A world war later and everyone had learned. The ruling classes realised that they had to address real concerns and not let them get hijacked by extremists. Hence NHS and German reconstruction.

It seems the lesson has been forgotten. Everyone who votes Brexit is labelled as stupid, everyone who votes reform is a racist. But nobody is actually solving the very real problems that's pursuading them to vote  they way they are.

Most people are middle of the road, they just want a quiet, comfortable life and extremists are the antithesis of that. The only way they can be agitated is if they are ignored or feel insulted. Which is exactly what has been happening (especially with this government - both with the policies and the way they behaved).

The only saving grace for me is that unlike Hitler, I don't think BJ (he'll be back) or farage have any deep seated convictions. They just have a lust for power and they'l do what they can to get it. If they ever get it, they'll do fuck all with it. They don't have the talent or the agenda - they'll just do what they can to keep it. (Of course, they thought AH was talentless as well.)

I didn't say they were racist or stupid.

Aren't you doing exactly what Farage does when he dog-whistles and then denies it with a smug grin on his face?

It is a small joke. It's just a joke. Like when a Reform candidate referred to an autistic child as a "vegetable", or when a Reform candidate said that LGBTQ+ people were "paedophilles", or when a Reform candidate referred to black people as "jungle bunnies", or when a Reform candidate used the term "chinky" to describe a Chinese woman, or when a Reform candidate said that Nicola Sturgeon should be shot, or when the leader of Reform sang Hitler Youth songs. It's just a joke.

Their genuine concerns must be heard and appeased.
Reply
#34
(07-05-2024, 08:51 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:46 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:34 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:12 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:00 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: The nazis rose to power by targeting genuine grievances and attributing them to 'foreigners'. 

The ruling class and the intelligentsia dismissed them and their supporters as idiots and fringe.

A world war later and everyone had learned. The ruling classes realised that they had to address real concerns and not let them get hijacked by extremists. Hence NHS and German reconstruction.

It seems the lesson has been forgotten. Everyone who votes Brexit is labelled as stupid, everyone who votes reform is a racist. But nobody is actually solving the very real problems that's pursuading them to vote  they way they are.

Most people are middle of the road, they just want a quiet, comfortable life and extremists are the antithesis of that. The only way they can be agitated is if they are ignored or feel insulted. Which is exactly what has been happening (especially with this government - both with the policies and the way they behaved).

The only saving grace for me is that unlike Hitler, I don't think BJ (he'll be back) or farage have any deep seated convictions. They just have a lust for power and they'l do what they can to get it. If they ever get it, they'll do fuck all with it. They don't have the talent or the agenda - they'll just do what they can to keep it. (Of course, they thought AH was talentless as well.)

I didn't say they were racist or stupid.

Aren't you doing exactly what Farage does when he dog-whistles and then denies it with a smug grin on his face?

It is a small joke. It's just a joke. Like when a Reform candidate referred to an autistic child as a "vegetable", or when a Reform candidate said that LGBTQ+ people were "paedophilles", or when a Reform candidate referred to black people as "jungle bunnies", or when a Reform candidate used the term "chinky" to describe a Chinese woman, or when a Reform candidate said that Nicola Sturgeon should be shot, or when the leader of Reform sang Hitler Youth songs. It's just a joke.

Their genuine concerns must be heard and appeased.

In fairness they're true to their word and deal with problems as and when they arise. For example, one of Farage's volunteers George Jones was told last week that he would have no further involvement with the party after referring to the pride flag as "degenerate" and referring to LGBTQ+ people as "paedophiles" - you'll be surprised to hear he was pictured enjoying himself at the Reform campaign party last night.
Reply
#35
(07-05-2024, 08:46 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: It is a small joke. It's just a joke. Like when a Reform candidate referred to an autistic child as a "vegetable", or when a Reform candidate said that LGBTQ+ people were "paedophilles", or when a Reform candidate referred to black people as "jungle bunnies", or when a Reform candidate used the term "chinky" to describe a Chinese woman, or when a Reform candidate said that Nicola Sturgeon should be shot, or when the leader of Reform sang Hitler Youth songs. It's just a joke.

I wasn't trying to say there was anything wrong with making a joke, and in all fairness, it did make me smile. I was just saying that it has a bit part part in the rise of populism. Personally insulting the opposition just entrenches opinions. There's plenty of evidence for that. But you're entitled to say whatever you like.

FWIW, I also think a reform candidate calling someone a jungle bunny is exactly what drives people away from the reform party! Now that really did make me smile.

On a personal note, I'd prefer junglebunny over being told I wasn't allowed near a primary school and all that hints at. But honestly, I wouldn't take either personally so I wouldn't be that insulted by either!

Just to be clear, the leaders of reform are fair game, as is exposing the activities of their members. It's the insulting of their supporters I have concerns about.
Reply
#36
Lots garbage being posted again.
My POV is.
1. The Tory party messed up big time, again and again.
2. People wanted change.
3. Reform got votes simply because people didn't want to vote Tory or Labour.
4. Farage connected with the public, saying what they wanted to hear.
5. All parties have members who have personal agendas and forget they are to represent the people not themselves.
Reply
#37
Agree with your analysis

What about the independent winners, there are some interesting characters there.
Reply
#38
(07-05-2024, 09:15 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Lots garbage being posted again.
My POV is.
1. The Tory party messed up big time, again and again.
2. People wanted change.
3. Reform got votes simply because people didn't want to vote Tory or Labour.
4. Farage connected with the public, saying what they wanted to hear.
5. All parties have members who have personal agendas and forget they are to represent the people not themselves.

I can understand all those points. But point 3, couldn't they have spoilt their paper if they wanted to make a protest vote? Or just not even voted. They (or you?) didn't have to vote Reform. There were lots of independents, Greens, liberals...
But point 4 - whether people want to see it or not, Farage gets the votes for a reason. That's the 'problem' and it needs to be addressed. Just dismissing it as a protest vote means it will continue to fester.
Reply
#39
(07-05-2024, 09:09 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 08:46 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: It is a small joke. It's just a joke. Like when a Reform candidate referred to an autistic child as a "vegetable", or when a Reform candidate said that LGBTQ+ people were "paedophilles", or when a Reform candidate referred to black people as "jungle bunnies", or when a Reform candidate used the term "chinky" to describe a Chinese woman, or when a Reform candidate said that Nicola Sturgeon should be shot, or when the leader of Reform sang Hitler Youth songs. It's just a joke.

I wasn't trying to say there was anything wrong with making a joke, and in all fairness, it did make me smile. I was just saying that it has a bit part part in the rise of populism. Personally insulting the opposition just entrenches opinions. There's plenty of evidence for that. But you're entitled to say whatever you like.

FWIW, I also think a reform candidate calling someone a jungle bunny is exactly what drives people away from the reform party! Now that really did make me smile.

On a personal note, I'd prefer junglebunny over being told I wasn't allowed near a primary school and all that hints at. But honestly, I wouldn't take either personally so I wouldn't be that insulted by either!

Just to be clear, the leaders of reform are fair game, as is exposing the activities of their members. It's the insulting of their supporters I have concerns about.

Conversely, I am far more concerned about the people who vote for them who hold far more worrying beliefs than the party members themselves. Been to Clacton recently? It’s a worrying place.
In the form of his life.
Reply
#40
(07-05-2024, 09:27 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 09:15 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Lots garbage being posted again.
My POV is.
1. The Tory party messed up big time, again and again.
2. People wanted change.
3. Reform got votes simply because people didn't want to vote Tory or Labour.
4. Farage connected with the public, saying what they wanted to hear.
5. All parties have members who have personal agendas and forget they are to represent the people not themselves.

I can understand that point of view, especially point 4. But point 3, couldn't they have spoilt their paper if they wanted to make a protest vote? Or just not even voted. They didn't have to vote Reform.
Whether people want to see it or not, Farage gets the votes for a reason.

Farage is much savvier than many give him credit for. To be honest, just as much as we are talking about the Tories and Labour having a big few years ahead in terms of the people they fill their parties full of and the direction they travel. 
So does reform. The last minute defectors from Reform to Tory refer to the candidates being the racist, homophobic and all the other 'ists, where the leadership wasn't. I will keep an eye on them very carefully over the next few years. If they manage to distance themselves from the dangerous far right and focus on political and constitutional changes they could hoover up a lot of moderate voters who want that big change. 

Farage was consistently distancing himself from the far, far right and kept talking about he was the reason the BNP folded. 

Interesting, and challenging times ahead politically.
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: