England vs Slovenia
That was an awful performance, 3 in a row now, but we are still in it.
We won’t win it with Southgate though, is my opinion. He is weak and cannot motivate the players to win games. Hope I’m wrong and we win it.
Reply
(06-25-2024, 09:31 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I have to back Josh up a abit here. What he's, clumsily, trying to say is that are these players a product of the world class players and coaching that surround them again club level? Or are they, in themselves, stand out players.

As always. The reality is a bit of both. We lack a Rodrigo/Kroos to dominate and dictate the tempo. We lack a Left back. And we lack an Odegaard/Bernardo Silva to link play consistently.

This, thank you. 

Our so called class players look good at club level due to coaching (Southgate isn't ideal, but not the whole problem) and, more importantly, other players around them. 

What we lack is a player/leader who is truly world class and can change a game. Think Beckham v Greece.

Foden, Kane, Bellingham, whoever else you want to incorrectly label as world class aren't capable, unfortunately.
Reply
(06-25-2024, 09:31 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I have to back Josh up a abit here. What he's, clumsily, trying to say is that are these players a product of the world class players and coaching that surround them again club level? Or are they, in themselves, stand out players.

As always. The reality is a bit of both. We lack a Rodrigo/Kroos to dominate and dictate the tempo. We lack a Left back. And we lack an Odegaard/Bernardo Silva to link play consistently.

I'd agree with some element of this.

But other squads have weaknesses too, just as severe.
Reply
(06-25-2024, 09:34 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(06-25-2024, 09:31 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I have to back Josh up a abit here. What he's, clumsily, trying to say is that are these players a product of the world class players and coaching that surround them again club level? Or are they, in themselves, stand out players.

As always. The reality is a bit of both. We lack a Rodrigo/Kroos to dominate and dictate the tempo. We lack a Left back. And we lack an Odegaard/Bernardo Silva to link play consistently.

I'd agree with some element of this.

But other squads have weaknesses too, just as severe.

Those 2 'transition' positions, CM and #10 are vital for top teams who play against tough opposition's. 

And for all of our supposed attacking talent we lack that metronomic, efficient player who get us going. Like if or lump it Hendo did this.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(06-25-2024, 09:33 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(06-25-2024, 09:31 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I have to back Josh up a abit here. What he's, clumsily, trying to say is that are these players a product of the world class players and coaching that surround them again club level? Or are they, in themselves, stand out players.

As always. The reality is a bit of both. We lack a Rodrigo/Kroos to dominate and dictate the tempo. We lack a Left back. And we lack an Odegaard/Bernardo Silva to link play consistently.

This, thank you. 

Our so called class players look good at club level due to coaching (Southgate isn't ideal, but not the whole problem) and, more importantly, other players around them. 

What we lack is a player/leader who is truly world class and can change a game. Think Beckham v Greece.

Foden, Kane, Bellingham, whoever else you want to incorrectly label as world class aren't capable, unfortunately.

They are World Class though, find anyone who knows about football to say they aren't, Bellingham is favourite for the Balon D'or FFS, Kane is Europe's top scorer, Foden player of the season.

There are issues, tactical ones and some weak links in the squad I don't think Southgate have covered well enough. France have supposedly two world class squads, yet utterly reliant on Mbappe to score.
Reply
(06-25-2024, 09:37 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(06-25-2024, 09:34 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(06-25-2024, 09:31 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I have to back Josh up a abit here. What he's, clumsily, trying to say is that are these players a product of the world class players and coaching that surround them again club level? Or are they, in themselves, stand out players.

As always. The reality is a bit of both. We lack a Rodrigo/Kroos to dominate and dictate the tempo. We lack a Left back. And we lack an Odegaard/Bernardo Silva to link play consistently.

I'd agree with some element of this.

But other squads have weaknesses too, just as severe.

Those 2 'transition' positions, CM and #10 are vital for top teams who play against tough opposition's. 

And for all of our supposed attacking talent we lack that metronomic, efficient player who get us going. Like if or lump it Hendo did this.

Which is why I understood the idea for TAA, but he struggles facing towards his own defence and therefore wasn't capable. Mainoo seems more capable with Rice if covering that weakness.
Reply
(06-25-2024, 09:37 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(06-25-2024, 09:34 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(06-25-2024, 09:31 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I have to back Josh up a abit here. What he's, clumsily, trying to say is that are these players a product of the world class players and coaching that surround them again club level? Or are they, in themselves, stand out players.

As always. The reality is a bit of both. We lack a Rodrigo/Kroos to dominate and dictate the tempo. We lack a Left back. And we lack an Odegaard/Bernardo Silva to link play consistently.

I'd agree with some element of this.

But other squads have weaknesses too, just as severe.

Those 2 'transition' positions, CM and #10 are vital for top teams who play against tough opposition's. 

And for all of our supposed attacking talent we lack that metronomic, efficient player who get us going. Like if or lump it Hendo did this.

We lack a player who stands up and drags the players around him to another level. I just mentioned Beckham v Greece, but it's something Gerard did. 

Whilst I won't argue against anyone calling Kane, Bellingham or Foden world class for their respective clubs, because they are, bloody hell, I'm not that dense, but when they play for England you can almost sense those players nervous energy, they actually shirk and fear the challenge.
Reply
World class players don't automatically make a world class team.

We need to find balance. It might mean taking an attacking 'star' out to find it at some point.

Interesting idea to move Walker to LB and put Trent in as a RB/RCM hybrid.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
I'd agree on the mentality, I think the pressure of being one of the favourites is weighing heavily since it's not just bluster this time, for most people in the game, we were, and still are.
Reply
(06-25-2024, 09:38 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(06-25-2024, 09:33 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(06-25-2024, 09:31 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I have to back Josh up a abit here. What he's, clumsily, trying to say is that are these players a product of the world class players and coaching that surround them again club level? Or are they, in themselves, stand out players.

As always. The reality is a bit of both. We lack a Rodrigo/Kroos to dominate and dictate the tempo. We lack a Left back. And we lack an Odegaard/Bernardo Silva to link play consistently.

This, thank you. 

Our so called class players look good at club level due to coaching (Southgate isn't ideal, but not the whole problem) and, more importantly, other players around them. 

What we lack is a player/leader who is truly world class and can change a game. Think Beckham v Greece.

Foden, Kane, Bellingham, whoever else you want to incorrectly label as world class aren't capable, unfortunately.

They are World Class though, find anyone who knows about football to say they aren't, Bellingham is favourite for the Balon D'or FFS, Kane is Europe's top scorer, Foden player of the season.

There are issues, tactical ones and some weak links in the squad I don't think Southgate have covered well enough. France have supposedly two world class squads, yet utterly reliant on Mbappe to score.

Worryingly for you, I don't think we're that far apart in terms of opinions, I'm just expressing it completely wrong.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)