Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
It's almost become an impossible situation to fix now. I'd be reforming the way it's run also but not in the way I'm guessing Proth would go for. I'd separate out the NHS and Private healthcare entirely, if someone is on an NHS waiting list then they get treated through the NHS and not by the NHS paying a private hospital to carry out the appointment. I'd also restrict doctors / surgeons from working both systems, they can choose which one but no more cake and eat it. And by the way I know that is very unlikely to work or even occur.
I always wanted to go to a preventative approach to medicine with regular checkups throughout a persons life. That would cause a two stream NHS for a period of time, probably decades, but ultimately would benefit the population.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
06-12-2024, 01:19 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-12-2024, 01:25 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
The problem with charging people for missed appointments is the inevitable backlash when appointments get cancelled by the GP, or hospitals, when they mess their own booking systems up. They also make it a nightmare for patients to attend when instead of putting two or three related appointments together they scatter them over a week at stupid times. This happens frequently in the disability sector and it’s hardly fair to charge them for the lack of joined up thinking any the medical admin/teams, if you happen to overlook one appointment out of four or five that week. I appreciate this is a niche situation relatively speaking but as ever with these things the devil is in the detail.
I worked with one older gentleman i(in his 80s) who was in a wheelchair and very vulnerable a few years ago who was forever been left by local Brum taxi firms without transport as they couldn’t or wouldn’t get him to his hospital appointments. They left him that day ten miles away from his home without any reason and no taxi that could take him for four hours in a heatwave. The only reason they came out at all was we threatened them with the press. The idea they should be fined for then not turning up to a hospital appointment is very Mel Stride.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
I agree with the regular integrated check ups. They could also work on a more fluent basis, in terms of location and way appointment times work
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(06-12-2024, 01:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It's almost become an impossible situation to fix now. I'd be reforming the way it's run also but not in the way I'm guessing Proth would go for. I'd separate out the NHS and Private healthcare entirely, if someone is on an NHS waiting list then they get treated through the NHS and not by the NHS paying a private hospital to carry out the appointment. I'd also restrict doctors / surgeons from working both systems, they can choose which one but no more cake and eat it. And by the way I know that is very unlikely to work or even occur.
I always wanted to go to a preventative approach to medicine with regular checkups throughout a persons life. That would cause a two stream NHS for a period of time, probably decades, but ultimately would benefit the population.
The NHS has always had private provision. Consultants have always had private work. In your scenario the NHS would be reduced to a residualised rump.
We need to reconnect the public with the concept that the NHS is paid for. It is not free. This means hypothecating at least part of an individuals personal taxation directly to the NHS. Only when individuals appreciate just how much they pay for "free" healthcare will they begin to make 21st Century demands on a 1950s institution. Holding the NHS's feet to the fire on service transformation is the only way it will survive in the long term.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
Your preferred system is a 19th century system that already failed.
I do not see how changing the funding model will make a lick of difference, it's not like NICs being on your paycheck (a holdover from when we had a social insurance system) makes a difference and the amount of public money spent on the NHS and on HSC in general is already publicly available. The two biggest chokepoints are two systems that are from when we only had the social insurance system.
Posts: 11,931
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
You're tougher on the NHS than you are fascists, you lad.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(06-12-2024, 01:26 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-12-2024, 01:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It's almost become an impossible situation to fix now. I'd be reforming the way it's run also but not in the way I'm guessing Proth would go for. I'd separate out the NHS and Private healthcare entirely, if someone is on an NHS waiting list then they get treated through the NHS and not by the NHS paying a private hospital to carry out the appointment. I'd also restrict doctors / surgeons from working both systems, they can choose which one but no more cake and eat it. And by the way I know that is very unlikely to work or even occur.
I always wanted to go to a preventative approach to medicine with regular checkups throughout a persons life. That would cause a two stream NHS for a period of time, probably decades, but ultimately would benefit the population.
The NHS has always had private provision. Consultants have always had private work. In your scenario the NHS would be reduced to a residualised rump.
We need to reconnect the public with the concept that the NHS is paid for. It is not free. This means hypothecating at least part of an individuals personal taxation directly to the NHS. Only when individuals appreciate just how much they pay for "free" healthcare will they begin to make 21st Century demands on a 1950s institution. Holding the NHS's feet to the fire on service transformation is the only way it will survive in the long term.
Long term the current model is not sustainable under any circumstances, but unfortunately there is no funding available to run a new model alongside until it becomes effective. I get what you say about private healthcare but it is far more patronised by specialists / surgeons now than it ever was. There needs to be some restrictions on what consultants are allowed to do if they are on an NHS salary; that has to be where they prioritise their focus.
And i really dislike the notion that the NHS should be paying for private care, this distorts the funding entirely and although I recognise the need to reduce waiting lists it's become a dependancy that needs to be broken.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(06-12-2024, 01:53 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (06-12-2024, 01:26 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-12-2024, 01:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It's almost become an impossible situation to fix now. I'd be reforming the way it's run also but not in the way I'm guessing Proth would go for. I'd separate out the NHS and Private healthcare entirely, if someone is on an NHS waiting list then they get treated through the NHS and not by the NHS paying a private hospital to carry out the appointment. I'd also restrict doctors / surgeons from working both systems, they can choose which one but no more cake and eat it. And by the way I know that is very unlikely to work or even occur.
I always wanted to go to a preventative approach to medicine with regular checkups throughout a persons life. That would cause a two stream NHS for a period of time, probably decades, but ultimately would benefit the population.
The NHS has always had private provision. Consultants have always had private work. In your scenario the NHS would be reduced to a residualised rump.
We need to reconnect the public with the concept that the NHS is paid for. It is not free. This means hypothecating at least part of an individuals personal taxation directly to the NHS. Only when individuals appreciate just how much they pay for "free" healthcare will they begin to make 21st Century demands on a 1950s institution. Holding the NHS's feet to the fire on service transformation is the only way it will survive in the long term.
Long term the current model is not sustainable under any circumstances, but unfortunately there is no funding available to run a new model alongside until it becomes effective. I get what you say about private healthcare but it is far more patronised by specialists / surgeons now than it ever was. There needs to be some restrictions on what consultants are allowed to do if they are on an NHS salary; that has to be where they prioritise their focus.
And i really dislike the notion that the NHS should be paying for private care, this distorts the funding entirely and although I recognise the need to reduce waiting lists it's become a dependancy that needs to be broken.
There is nothing in the Beveridge Model that stipulates that the hospitals need to be publicly owned, that was just a choice. There's publicly owned hospitals in Bismarck Model countries and our primary and social care is single payer funded but are privately owned and operated and the former worked fine until the Tory cuts on primary care funding.
Posts: 9,633
Threads: 518
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
06-12-2024, 02:25 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-12-2024, 02:26 PM by Lurker#3.)
(06-12-2024, 12:19 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (06-12-2024, 07:29 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The biggest challenge at this election is for the parties to show us how they are going to reform our welfare system and NHS to future proof it against an ageing population with hoarded wealth.
I would like to see state pension fall into a UC style model. Where it tops up income when you get to retirement age. So if you have a private pension/non earned income, annually of 40k, you frankly don't need that benefit.
Also, the NHS needs serious reform in the face of a growing, ageing and generally more unhealthy population. I never want to see the principle of "free at the point of use" taken away for those that need it, but I think some careful tax breaks for the middle classes if they have private medical insurance should be considered in line with salary sacrifice schemes that not everyone has access to.
As much as this sounds like sense there are a few holes - what are you calling non-earned income and how would you measure it? Are you talking about drawing down from savings and if that is the case then people will just stop saving and either give it to their kids or spend it. And I think you'd be surprised about how few people have pensions that give them £40k.
And as for the salary sacrifice schemes, private medical insurance route, you are mainly looking at employed people in that bracket and by definition probably under 65 which is exactly the demographic that tend not to use it that much. The ones that use it are the elderly who may not have access to PMI. Otherwise are you saying that people who have cancer treatment should be making sure they have adequate insurance - i have an example of a colleague that is terrified of losing her job because of the medical insurance that looks after her husband who is terminal, she has to travel away from her husband who needs very personal care a lot of the time because she feels pressured, that's not how the system should work.
Non-earned income; rent from second properties, dividends, capital gains, interest in savings etc.
Regarding your colleague; no, I am not afraid all saying they should bankrupt themselves for care. In fact that's the exact reason why "free at the point of use" is so important. But the more people you can incentivise to use PMI, the less general demand there is on the NHS. Meaning they can focus their funds care and attention in those who require the nationalised care.
You mention those 65+, but what about the millions of routine surgeries such at musculoskeletal and skin surgeries that could be hoovered up by people's PMI, releasing thousands of operating slots.
(06-12-2024, 12:48 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Means testing the state pension will merely result in a collapse in private pension savings.
The NHS needs root and branch reform, one aspect of which is to incentivise people not use it - instead of taxing PMI as a benefit if it's provided through an employer.
There should definitely be sanctions for failing to turn up to an appointment too.
Why's this, Proth?
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
06-12-2024, 04:19 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-12-2024, 04:21 PM by Protheroe.)
(06-12-2024, 01:46 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Your preferred system is a 19th century system that already failed.
I do not see how changing the funding model will make a lick of difference, it's not like NICs being on your paycheck (a holdover from when we had a social insurance system) makes a difference and the amount of public money spent on the NHS and on HSC in general is already publicly available. The two biggest chokepoints are two systems that are from when we only had the social insurance system.
It's the relationship between the individual and the state that needs to change, however you dress up the funding. Are there many other civilised European countries who'd put up with the shit we do? And then treat it as a national religion?
We're insanely deferential to an institution that's failed as much as the system it replaced. Just yesterday I found out a great friend of mine has been given a terminal diagnosis having been give the all clear after a scan 6 months ago.
(06-12-2024, 02:25 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Why's this, Proth?
If my State Penson was threatened by means testing of my other pension provision, then I would divert my investments elsewhere. Wouldn't everyone?
It would be the entirely rational response.
|