ICJ
#71
(06-01-2024, 08:48 AM)Baggybenny Wrote: It is surprising how much the land area of Palestine has shrunk since 1948, through 1967 to the present day.
Who are the occupants of that disappeared land.

The First Aliyah began in 1881. Just imagine, if nineteenth and early twentieth century Europe had been a more welcoming place maybe there wouldn't have been a need for a Jewish homeland. The Arabs didn't much like Jews returning either (or the British Mandate). By the end of WWII about a third of the occupants of Mandated Palestine were Jewish. In 1948 the UN granted an Israeli state 55% of Mandated Palestine.

So many of the descendants of the occupants (including Israeli Palestinians) of that "disappeared land" are actually still there. 

The day after the UN Mandated the Jewish State, eight Arab countries launched the Arab-Israeli war in an attempt to strangle the state at birth. At the ceasefire Jordan annexed the West Bank (not Israel) and Egypt annexed the Gaza Strip (not Israel). About 700,000 Palestinian Arabs fled or were expelled in the Nakba. Over the first 3 years after the establishment of the state the Jewish population doubled largely made up of Holocaust survivors and Jews expelled or fleeing from extremely repressive Arab and North African regimes who weren't too happy about losing the war.

Add in another couple of failed Arab attempts to drive the Jews into the sea and I think it's bleeding obvious why Arabs have either left or been turfed out of that 55%. 

And lets not forget that the Arabs haven't exactly got a clean slate when it comes to the invasion of the Maghreb. No tears for Byzantium on this board I see.

So those "shrinking maps" might make for a good meme. But that's about it Ben.
Reply
#72
(06-01-2024, 01:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-01-2024, 08:48 AM)Baggybenny Wrote: It is surprising how much the land area of Palestine has shrunk since 1948, through 1967 to the present day.
Who are the occupants of that disappeared land.

The First Aliyah began in 1881. Just imagine, if nineteenth and early twentieth century Europe had been a more welcoming place maybe there wouldn't have been a need for a Jewish homeland. The Arabs didn't much like Jews returning either (or the British Mandate). By the end of WWII about a third of the occupants of Mandated Palestine were Jewish. In 1948 the UN granted an Israeli state 55% of Mandated Palestine.

So many of the descendants of the occupants (including Israeli Palestinians) of that "disappeared land" are actually still there. 

The day after the UN Mandated the Jewish State, eight Arab countries launched the Arab-Israeli war in an attempt to strangle the state at birth. At the ceasefire Jordan annexed the West Bank (not Israel) and Egypt annexed the Gaza Strip (not Israel). About 700,000 Palestinian Arabs fled or were expelled in the Nakba. Over the first 3 years after the establishment of the state the Jewish population doubled largely made up of Holocaust survivors and Jews expelled or fleeing from extremely repressive Arab and North African regimes who weren't too happy about losing the war.

Add in another couple of failed Arab attempts to drive the Jews into the sea and I think it's bleeding obvious why Arabs have either left or been turfed out of that 55%. 

And lets not forget that the Arabs haven't exactly got a clean slate when it comes to the invasion of the Maghreb. No tears for Byzantium on this board I see.

So those "shrinking maps" might make for a good meme. But that's about it Ben.

I've heard people using the vote to elect Hamas 20 years ago for a reason why it's OK to kill children in Gaza. But using the Byzantine times really takes the cake. 

The rest of your history seems to ignore actual events in favour of a pro-Israeli skew.
Reply
#73
More of the finest whataboutery
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#74
Well done Squid, you just concentrate on the pisstake bit rather than the substance of the post. Like shooting fish in a barrel here sometimes, just like house prices eh CF?
Reply
#75
(06-01-2024, 07:20 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Well done Squid, you just concentrate on the pisstake bit rather than the substance of the post. Like shooting fish in a barrel here sometimes, just like house prices eh CF?

If you get provided with links to evidence, you just ignore/deny/start saying "Whatabout".
Reply
#76
(06-01-2024, 01:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-01-2024, 08:48 AM)Baggybenny Wrote: It is surprising how much the land area of Palestine has shrunk since 1948, through 1967 to the present day.
Who are the occupants of that disappeared land.

The First Aliyah began in 1881. Just imagine, if nineteenth and early twentieth century Europe had been a more welcoming place maybe there wouldn't have been a need for a Jewish homeland. The Arabs didn't much like Jews returning either (or the British Mandate). By the end of WWII about a third of the occupants of Mandated Palestine were Jewish. In 1948 the UN granted an Israeli state 55% of Mandated Palestine.

So many of the descendants of the occupants (including Israeli Palestinians) of that "disappeared land" are actually still there. 

The day after the UN Mandated the Jewish State, eight Arab countries launched the Arab-Israeli war in an attempt to strangle the state at birth. At the ceasefire Jordan annexed the West Bank (not Israel) and Egypt annexed the Gaza Strip (not Israel). About 700,000 Palestinian Arabs fled or were expelled in the Nakba. Over the first 3 years after the establishment of the state the Jewish population doubled largely made up of Holocaust survivors and Jews expelled or fleeing from extremely repressive Arab and North African regimes who weren't too happy about losing the war.

Add in another couple of failed Arab attempts to drive the Jews into the sea and I think it's bleeding obvious why Arabs have either left or been turfed out of that 55%. 

And lets not forget that the Arabs haven't exactly got a clean slate when it comes to the invasion of the Maghreb. No tears for Byzantium on this board I see.

So those "shrinking maps" might make for a good meme. But that's about it Ben.

There were no tears for the Byzantine Empire at the time.

The Christian and the Jewish communities were glad to see the back of them.
Reply
#77
Lots of people were happy to see the back of Jeremy Peace Shabba.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)