Corberan - messiah or overrated or somewhere in between?
#31
(05-21-2024, 10:50 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: He has a good mentality and possibilities Big Grin

Joking aside, he’s done a fantastic job whilst having g his hands tied re transfers and all the off field shenanigans selling the club. 

Yes, he’s made some team selections and and substitutions that have baffled us at times, especially seeing as he was a master at substitutions early on.   But anyone who criticises him is a deluded idiot as we won’t get anyone better.
Reply
#32
(05-21-2024, 10:59 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(05-21-2024, 10:58 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-21-2024, 10:53 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Not sure how you can set up to be more attacking on a consistent basis without any strikers.

Doesn't help the one time he really let the brakes.off against Leicester when they looked there for the taking and we were on top, we lost. Hardly fills him or the squad with confidence to go out and attack teams to death.

We do the same by trying to stay in the game and we lose

We dont though. We were 5th in the league since November. We are consistent and predictable. All thing CC likes.

What we need now is to sprinkle a little unpredictability into the squad to try and find us that edge in tight games.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#33
(05-21-2024, 10:57 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(05-21-2024, 10:53 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Not sure how you can set up to be more attacking on a consistent basis without any strikers.

Setting up just to try and stay in the game and nick it ain't the way forward rich ....

I really don't enjoy it I've not just said it on this post I've told you privately how I feel ......especially away no wonder I've walked out long before the end and gone back to the pub .

It is when you can't score goals consistently. And we've seen too many games where we've had so much pressure applied to the opposition and barely created a chance, let alone scored.

We need that clinical, reliable striker up front, but they aren't there in January, be interesting to see what happens this summer, Maja isn't a goalscorer, and we have to accept Dike may not play for us again.
Reply
#34
I wouldn't go as far as to say messiah, but he's closer to that than being overrated. He shouldn't be immune to criticism, he has made mistakes. Like all managers - even at the elite level.

Anyone questioning whether he's the right coach to manage us next season and beyond should give their head a vigorous wobble.

To achieve 5th and be a Grady finish (1st leg) and a Grady fuck up away* from Wembley with this squad, and with only one striker for the majority of the season, is some achievement.

*I've no doubt we'd have gone on to win the first leg had he put that gilt edged chance away, and who knows how the second leg would have panned out had he not made a costly error that gifted Saints their first.
Reply
#35
He's done a great job with us. Not sure he could have done better, especially considering the injuries to the forwards this season.

It will be interesting to see what he can do next season, the squad will inevitably be smaller, but should be more his, rather than one he inherited.
Reply
#36
He's done a very good job. Only questions marks from me, which I think are fair is the away form and our ability to gain points from losing positions. Occasionally I have questioned his subs and I think too many times he made 3 or 4 changes at once which rarely has a positive impact.

I'm not too worried about how many players we lose, as he has improved pretty much all of them from a position where we wanted a total clear out, so I would trust him to do the same with any replacements.
Reply
#37
There is room for improvement on playing style do I want to watch a rigid style again this season....100% no
Reply
#38
(05-21-2024, 11:13 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: There is room for improvement on playing style do I want to watch a rigid style again this season....100% no

He was the one who gave rigidity to Bielsas Leeds, so he will always have a strong, tactically strict shape, but as we showed at times, he does let players express themselves for periods of games too.
Reply
#39
(05-21-2024, 11:09 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: He's done a great job with us. Not sure he could have done better, especially considering the injuries to the forwards this season.

It will be interesting to see what he can do next season, the squad will inevitably be smaller, but should be more his, rather than one he inherited.

Smaller, but hopefully better balanced with more versatility in attacking options (more than one forward). 

Through no one's fault, Dike's injury is what ultimately cost us this year.
Reply
#40
He is doing a really good job to date and just needs another 2 years for a comprehensive judgement to be made on all aspects of his performance.

The guy is a workaholic and I have no doubt that he already has dossiers prepared to improve and extract the extra performance from the squad next season along with appropriate additions and departures to achieve this under P&S.

Between Carlos and Shilen, I could see us generally on a trend of improving our league position by 1-3 places every season for a longer period of time, possibly wjth a PL relegation thrown in somewhere.

Keep going Carlos. Thanks for turning the oil tanker around . Don't burn yourself out and keep working with the club to develop the support and infrastructure around you to be successful.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)