Squad 2024/2025
#71
Corberán has already said there will be a lot of changes in the summer. They will do everything they can to re-sign Kipre and Mowatt, but all the others will be released (and so they should imo). Phillips, Bartley, Reach, Pieters, Chalobah, M'Vila and Pipa.

We are in a position of strength at goalkeeper so I think they will tout Palmer around for between £10 and £15 million and give Griffiths his head next season.

We're already linked with the young midfielder released by Huddersfield - Diarra - who would cost a nominal fee possibly set by tribunal if agreement can't be reached.
Reply
#72
(05-20-2024, 08:26 PM)Jacko Wrote: Corberán has already said there will be a lot of changes in the summer. They will do everything they can to re-sign Kipre and Mowatt, but all the others will be released (and so they should imo). Phillips, Bartley, Reach, Pieters, Chalobah, M'Vila and Pipa.

We are in a position of strength at goalkeeper so I think they will tout Palmer around for between £10 and £15 million and give Griffiths his head next season.

We're already linked with the young midfielder released by Huddersfield - Diarra - who would cost a nominal fee possibly set by tribunal if agreement can't be reached.

Palmer sadly won’t go for any more than about £5m.  As a result I’d be more inclined to sell Griffiths
Reply
#73
An awful lot of opinion being passed off as fact here.
In the form of his life.
Reply
#74
If we can get rid of Townsend ut will be a blessing for us ......he just doesn't do enough for me ....furlong has improved under CC . I thing CT has gone backwards .
Reply
#75
(05-20-2024, 11:56 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(05-20-2024, 11:33 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-20-2024, 08:31 AM)Squid Wrote:
(05-20-2024, 07:34 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Last season Fellows came through, the season before Palmer

Next season Faal, Griffiths, Taylor, Ingram, Heard or Whitall could, if given the chance

I would estimate about 20 of our apprentices/academy graduates played in the four tiers of the football league, among them
Wood, O'Shea, Aziz, TGH and Field. For a club outside the Premier league that is good.

Our problem is we insist on giving contracts to old players past their best (Barry, Snodgrass, Kelly, Wieman etc) rather than giving our young players a go. I suspect that will not change and we will see a few more M'Villas next season.

Most agree on here we need somebody savvy to handle recruitment, I hope CC stays but his record on signing players is not that good, we need someone who knows the lower leagues and European leagues, another Ashworth.

It's not about where they play, but if we get money for them when they go. We got 0 for Aziz. 

IIRC, the only Academy players we have received money for in the post-PL era are Morgan Rogers, Sam Field, Nathan Ferguson, TGH and Dara O'Shea. Only for O'Shea did we get north of £2 million. 

While any money against FFP is a good thing, those sums are quite some way less than the £10 million a year some are hoping for. 

There's also the issue of players needing to play in order to build their value and how much that should be countered against picking the best team and if fans are really as patient about developing young talent as they claim to be.

I agree with you Squid, but what I would say is that we are at least producing the players.

In the last 5 years we have Rodgers, O'Shea, Irobegum and Ferguson all now at PL clubs (and had we made smarter selling decisions, all could have fetched £10m+ fees) and we have Palmer, Griffiths, Fellows who will command a decent fee in the squad. Add to that the additional players we've generated and seen leave at young ages to the bigger clubs and the likes of Azaz who we failed to make the most of. 

If we'd been savvier, we could have made very generous profits from these players, and I'd say it's much easier for us to improve our selling strategy than it is to suddenly start producing players capable of delivering decent fees.

Unfortunately, we've had no long term plan as a club under Lai, it has always been short term "survive in the PL this year" or "get back to the PL this year" and this lack of a plan has led to short term thinking across the board, hence signings like Martin Kelly instead of giving younger players game time.

Whoever is in charge next season and ongoing needs to buy into the fact our academy needs to be used - we need to see 3-4 players getting game time every season and hope one of them can have the kind of impact Fellows has had. 

In our last 5 seasons in the Championship we've had: Harper break through under Big Dave and look like he would command a decent fee, O'Shea and Ferguson looking excellent under Billic, TGH the only bright point under Val, and then Palmer and Fellows in the last 2 - That's all we need, we just have to keep giving players the opportunity instead of pursuing older stop gap signings.

This...

We need to look at three pillars in terms of the squad. And it should be as close to 1/3 each as possible. 

1 - Home grown talent from the academy

2 - 20-25 year old, low fee signings, such as BTA who have the potential to fetch a decent sell on but are equally as likely to have a long stay at the club and develop in our senior pros.

3 - Experienced pros - Whether that be the ones we keep who develop into the senior pros such as; Townsend, Furlong, Palmer. Or low risk, short term deals like Pieters/M'Vila.
There is a 4th category: loans.

The teams that have been promoted in the last few seasons have relied heavily on loans and we are still underutilising them. 

Depending on the player, the parent club may subsidise the wages and the risk is much lower as you are committing to a season tops.
Reply
#76
(05-20-2024, 10:03 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(05-20-2024, 11:56 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(05-20-2024, 11:33 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-20-2024, 08:31 AM)Squid Wrote:
(05-20-2024, 07:34 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Last season Fellows came through, the season before Palmer

Next season Faal, Griffiths, Taylor, Ingram, Heard or Whitall could, if given the chance

I would estimate about 20 of our apprentices/academy graduates played in the four tiers of the football league, among them
Wood, O'Shea, Aziz, TGH and Field. For a club outside the Premier league that is good.

Our problem is we insist on giving contracts to old players past their best (Barry, Snodgrass, Kelly, Wieman etc) rather than giving our young players a go. I suspect that will not change and we will see a few more M'Villas next season.

Most agree on here we need somebody savvy to handle recruitment, I hope CC stays but his record on signing players is not that good, we need someone who knows the lower leagues and European leagues, another Ashworth.

It's not about where they play, but if we get money for them when they go. We got 0 for Aziz. 

IIRC, the only Academy players we have received money for in the post-PL era are Morgan Rogers, Sam Field, Nathan Ferguson, TGH and Dara O'Shea. Only for O'Shea did we get north of £2 million. 

While any money against FFP is a good thing, those sums are quite some way less than the £10 million a year some are hoping for. 

There's also the issue of players needing to play in order to build their value and how much that should be countered against picking the best team and if fans are really as patient about developing young talent as they claim to be.

I agree with you Squid, but what I would say is that we are at least producing the players.

In the last 5 years we have Rodgers, O'Shea, Irobegum and Ferguson all now at PL clubs (and had we made smarter selling decisions, all could have fetched £10m+ fees) and we have Palmer, Griffiths, Fellows who will command a decent fee in the squad. Add to that the additional players we've generated and seen leave at young ages to the bigger clubs and the likes of Azaz who we failed to make the most of. 

If we'd been savvier, we could have made very generous profits from these players, and I'd say it's much easier for us to improve our selling strategy than it is to suddenly start producing players capable of delivering decent fees.

Unfortunately, we've had no long term plan as a club under Lai, it has always been short term "survive in the PL this year" or "get back to the PL this year" and this lack of a plan has led to short term thinking across the board, hence signings like Martin Kelly instead of giving younger players game time.

Whoever is in charge next season and ongoing needs to buy into the fact our academy needs to be used - we need to see 3-4 players getting game time every season and hope one of them can have the kind of impact Fellows has had. 

In our last 5 seasons in the Championship we've had: Harper break through under Big Dave and look like he would command a decent fee, O'Shea and Ferguson looking excellent under Billic, TGH the only bright point under Val, and then Palmer and Fellows in the last 2 - That's all we need, we just have to keep giving players the opportunity instead of pursuing older stop gap signings.

This...

We need to look at three pillars in terms of the squad. And it should be as close to 1/3 each as possible. 

1 - Home grown talent from the academy

2 - 20-25 year old, low fee signings, such as BTA who have the potential to fetch a decent sell on but are equally as likely to have a long stay at the club and develop in our senior pros.

3 - Experienced pros - Whether that be the ones we keep who develop into the senior pros such as; Townsend, Furlong, Palmer. Or low risk, short term deals like Pieters/M'Vila.
There is a 4th category: loans.

The teams that have been promoted in the last few seasons have relied heavily on loans and we are still underutilising them. 

Depending on the player, the parent club may subsidise the wages and the risk is much lower as you are committing to a season tops.

Completely agree. It's no coincidence that the two times in the past 15 or so seasons that we've successfully utilised the loan market we've finished 8th in the Prem (under Clarke) and gotten promoted (under Bilic). It's massively important
Reply
#77
Chalobah seemingly saying goodbye on his socials yesterday so I expect we aren't far away from announcing who is off.

Really do hope its only Kipre and Mowatt we try and keep, time to do a good sweep to get the wage bill down and reduce the age of the squad. Arguably second half of the season only Bartley is the other one CC has used. Most others have been bit part players, Phillips included when he came back
Reply
#78
(05-21-2024, 07:34 AM)baggiedave85 Wrote: Chalobah seemingly saying goodbye on his socials yesterday so I expect we aren't far away from announcing who is off.

Really do  hope its only Kipre and Mowatt we try and keep, time to do a good sweep to get the wage bill down and reduce the age of the squad. Arguably second half of the season only Bartley is the other one CC has used. Most others have been bit part players, Phillips included when he came back

Apparently Saturday was the deadline for informing the players & the EFL who was being offered new contracts, & who was being released.


https://uk.news.yahoo.com/every-champion...14372.html
Reply
#79
(05-20-2024, 01:23 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: For me I would be looking at this as our squad for next year to look like:

* EP = Experienced Pro (27 - Retirement), YP = Young Pro (22-26), HGP = Home Grown Prospect (<21) 

GK: 
1) Palmer (EP) / Griffiths (YP)
2) Cann (YP)
3) Cisse/Hollingshead (HGP)

LB: 
1) Townsend (EP)
2) New - YP

RB: 
1) Furlong (EP)
2) New - YP

CB:
1) Kipre (EP)
2) New - YP
3) Ajayi (EP)
4) Pieters (EP)
5) Taylor (HGP)

CM:
1) Okay (EP)
2) Mowatt (EP)
3) Molumby (YP)
4) New - YP
5) Mufamba/Whitwell/Deeming (HGP)

AM/W:
1) Wallace (EP)
2) Fellows (HGP)
3) Grady (YP)
4) Swift (EP)
5) New - YP (Dynamic left sided wide player)
6) Heard/Higgins (HGP)

ST:
1) BTA (YP)
2) Maja (YP)
3) Dike (YP)
4) New - EP/youth loan/free

Summary: 

GK - One of Palmer or Griffiths to be sold to balance FFP, Cann to be reserve and the 2 youngsters available on rotation as #3 with one always out on loan. 

CB - We need to move Bartley on as he's such a high earner sadly, we need to try and keep Kipre because he is coming into his prime, and against all my expectations has turned into our best CB. Pieters is worth another 12 months as he's cheap as chips and a good, solid, fit pro ad zero risk. Then we need to get another player to challenge Kipre/Ajayi, the senior pros and to compete with Taylor for a starting berth.

RB/LB - We need 2 young, athletic, fast, young prospects who can develop and challenge the 2 older heads at fullback. We have needed them for a few years, but now it is a must. I guess its also last chance saloon for Ethan Ingram who is highly thought of still. There is a good episode on "One Up Front" podcast by Salford FC fan with his dad, well worth a listen.   

CM - As above. We need a real powerhouse, running, aggressive young midfielder. We need to balance off against the sensible, important but ploddy contributions from Okay and Mowatt. 

AM/W - There is a theme with what we need. We need explosive, fast, dynamic and unpredictable. This player can be a bit of a wild card as we have so many reliable, predictable players in this area of the pitch.

ST - We need a target man in Dike's absence. Probably an older head/young player on loan or a free given the financial situation.

All together that's a 23 man squad with a handful of youngsters in CM and AM/W positions to try and break through. The most important thing is the profile of incoming players. We need to pace, aggression and dynamism.

So where are now? 


GK:
1) Palmer - EP 
2) Wildsmith - EP
3) Cann - YP

LB:
1) New - YP
2) New - EP

RB:
1) Furlong - EP
2) New - YP

CB:
1) Bartley - EP
2) Heggem - YP
3) Ajayi - EP
4) McNair - EP
5) Taylor - HGP

CM:
1) Mowatt - EP
2) Molumby - YP
3) Diakite - YP
4) New - EP (Ball winning - Sitter)
5) Mfuamba/Deeming/Whitwell - HGP

AM/W:
1) Wallace (EP)
2) Fellows (HGP)
3) Grady (YP)
4) Swift (EP)
5) New - YP (Dynamic left sided wide player)
6) Heard/Bostock/Higgins (HGP)

ST:
1) Maja - YP
2) Cole - EP
3) Dike - YP
4) New - YP (Poacher, quick, runs in behind - Cameron Archer on loan would be ideal)
5) Cleary/Faal - HGP


So the situation has shifted somewhat, but the needs and very similar. 

We are sorted in goal, with a surprising outcome of us holding onto our best young prospect and getting a senior night watchman in. 

Fullback has become a big priority given the impending departure of Townsend. We need a Young prospect to challenge Furlong and both a first choice left back, I would like to see us go younger, with an Eric Pieters type coming in as back up at both fullback and LB which would allow Heggem to be completion at LB too. 

Midfield - The departure of Okay means we need a straight replacement. Somebody like Choudhury from Leicester would be ideal. Does the dirty work, but has the legs to do it alone in there. Needs to be someone with some experience too ideally. I think this is why McNair has been brought in short term to help see us through if we can't get somebody till Jan.

Further forward we still need that pacy, goal threat on the left to replace MJs contributions. We have sorted the short term target man, but we now need to replace BTAs pace and threat in behind. Ideally with somebody who can be a little more clinical. As I said above Cameron Archer on loan would be ideal. Or the lad from Leicester? 

So I am counting 6 players needed to come in still. That would give us a first team of 25, with McNair to depart at Xmas, and that includes Cann who's not really first team squad. So let's say 23. 
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#80
There are some on here are going to be massively disappointed.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)