Forest
#41
(04-23-2024, 06:30 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 06:25 PM)Duffers Wrote: Josh, after a stellar few months you’re not covering yourself in glory here.

I really couldn't care less. 

I don't claim to be an expert, I'm just joining in a debate. It's funny how people shoot you down, tell you you're wrong but don't actually explain why. 

My question to Prag, is; Explain Libal law, then? He's clearly someone with vast experience in the subject matter (I assume given the nature of his responses) I've asserted that although Atwell may have a claim in principle, it won't be a claim worth pursuing as I can't see where the financial loss is coming from? He's not lost his officiating role, infact he's even been selected for a prestigious role in the Euros today!

Forest have embarrassed themselves. But have they really damaged Atwell's reputation to the extent his reputation will suffer?

Is my understanding that you have to suffer financial loss as a result of libelous comments incorrect? If so, then what would the basis of his case be? 

It's all well and good getting arsey with my posts, but at least respond in an adult manner and carry on the debate.

No you do not need to suffer any financial loss to claim for libel.

Forest have basically claimed that Atwell has deliberately abused his position to cheat in favour of the club he supports. If they cannot prove it then it’s libel.
Reply
#42
(04-23-2024, 06:14 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 06:09 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 05:42 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 10:58 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: What financial loss has Atwell suffered as a consequence of Forest' Tweet? Anyone with half a brain will know it's sour grapes but with a hint of accuracy. I'm not so sure there's anything liable in what has been said to the point where it'd stand up in court.

Totally disagree.  Blatant defamation of character to accuse him of cheating/corruption - unisss they have evidence.

(04-23-2024, 12:14 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 11:00 AM)Duffers Wrote: That's literally the bit that would need proving in court.

Quite. To say there's corruption in the EPL and with VAR is one thing, and I think we can all pretty much say with confidence it's there to benefit the top clubs, but to actually prove it is another. 

This is my point, most people will suspect corruption so how can reputation be damaged when that's the majority of people's default mentality? 

I think what Forest Tweeted out was laughable and not what you should be seeing from a professional sports club. But I'm not so sure there's enough there to even begin a court case, let alone persue it.

You might wish to properly research libel law

(04-23-2024, 12:23 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 12:18 PM)Duffers Wrote: Will they?

I'm not sure you fully understand the legal process.

Just look at the comments on any VAR Fred here. Most people already suspect some form of corruption in letting the so called big 6 get away with decision after decision. Even before VAR it was widely accepted referees were extremely biased towards those same Big 6 clubs.

In terms of the legal aspect, and I'm more than willing to be corrected here, but in order to have a claim of defamation you have to prove you have suffered financial loss and/or damage of reputation as a result of that defamation. My point is that in order for reputation to be damaged then the default mentality is that there's no corruption in VAR or the Prem. I'm not so sure that that's the case. Unless I'm completely misinterpreting the tone of posts on here and making unreasonable assumptions that those tones can be assumed to be the same thoughts as most football fans. 

Can you honestly say that Atwell's reputation has been so damaged by the Tweet he has suffered any form of financial loss?


Rest assured he has a very strong case

It doesn’t matter what people THINK.  It’s what they SAY that counts.

(04-23-2024, 12:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Josh has a point. The obvious defence for Forest if this ever makes it into court is "how can you damage a reputation that is already lower than a snakes belly?"

Wrong.  It’s only the reputation of Attwell that counts here. It’s he who has been defamed

(04-23-2024, 12:33 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 12:27 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: A "general sense of corruption" about the system of VAR vs openly saying Atwell was corrupt/biased and made deliberately wrong decisions because of that are not the same thing.

Surely damage to reputation would be fairly easy to prove? His ability to referee any game will now be called in to question because of the tweet by Forest, which affects his career/earnings etc.

That won't happen, though. He won't be forced to step aside, won't stop officiating, and therefore won't suffer any financial loss?

That’s a very unlikely outcome

I'll look forward to reading Atwell's winning judgement in due course. Please feel free to post on here once he's won the case. I'd be generally interested to read the jlfull judgement after he's sued Forest for all their worth.

Or will the judgement be found in the same place as our pending letters of administration and fire sale documents?

Do you mean the “pending letters of administration and fire sale documents” which would be in play imminently if the club hadn’t been sold when it was?

Some just won't admit it we were that close to not being able to pay the wages .....clueless beyond words
Reply
#43
(04-23-2024, 06:39 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 06:30 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 06:25 PM)Duffers Wrote: Josh, after a stellar few months you’re not covering yourself in glory here.

I really couldn't care less. 

I don't claim to be an expert, I'm just joining in a debate. It's funny how people shoot you down, tell you you're wrong but don't actually explain why. 

My question to Prag, is; Explain Libal law, then? He's clearly someone with vast experience in the subject matter (I assume given the nature of his responses) I've asserted that although Atwell may have a claim in principle, it won't be a claim worth pursuing as I can't see where the financial loss is coming from? He's not lost his officiating role, infact he's even been selected for a prestigious role in the Euros today!

Forest have embarrassed themselves. But have they really damaged Atwell's reputation to the extent his reputation will suffer?

Is my understanding that you have to suffer financial loss as a result of libelous comments incorrect? If so, then what would the basis of his case be? 

It's all well and good getting arsey with my posts, but at least respond in an adult manner and carry on the debate.

No you do not need to suffer any financial loss to claim for libel.

Forest have basically claimed that Atwell has deliberately abused his position to cheat in favour of the club he supports. If they cannot prove it then it’s libel.

Well, that's all that was needed to be said, then. So, on what basis would damages be valued at, then? I'm genuinely curious. Prag hinted at a big law case. How is that valued? 

Like I've said previously, Forest Tweet is laughable. It's unprofessional. You read fans say similar weekly, but for an official club account to come out with it is embarrassing on their part.
Reply
#44
(04-23-2024, 06:30 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 06:25 PM)Duffers Wrote: Josh, after a stellar few months you’re not covering yourself in glory here.

I really couldn't care less. 

I don't claim to be an expert, I'm just joining in a debate. It's funny how people shoot you down, tell you you're wrong but don't actually explain why. 

My question to Prag, is; Explain Libal law, then? He's clearly someone with vast experience in the subject matter (I assume given the nature of his responses) I've asserted that although Atwell may have a claim in principle, it won't be a claim worth pursuing as I can't see where the financial loss is coming from? He's not lost his officiating role, infact he's even been selected for a prestigious role in the Euros today!

Forest have embarrassed themselves. But have they really damaged Atwell's reputation to the extent his reputation will suffer?

Is my understanding that you have to suffer financial loss as a result of libelous comments incorrect? If so, then what would the basis of his case be? 

It's all well and good getting arsey with my posts, but at least respond in an adult manner and carry on the debate.

Well I certainly didn’t mean to offend.

He could quit due to the defamatory comments and claim that it has made it impossible for him to continue, sue for loss of earnings for the rest of his (likely) refereeing career and also sue for pecuniary damages for the stress, hurt and general damage to his reputation.  Unless Forest have clear evidence he would almost certainly win. 

Libel quickly summarised is the making of untrue statements to third parties, causing them loss or damage to their reputation.  If there is no evidence to prove that the comments are true - and it up to the person making them to prove that they are true - then the defamed person will win. 

The quantum of damages not only relates to actual loss suffered, but also “pain and suffering”.  An untrue statement read by 27 million people worldwide within 2-3 hours (and many more subsequently) is a lot of global damage to his character and reputation.  Mention the name “Stuart Attwell” and a huge number of people will know that name in a negative manner specifically because of Forest’s allegations.  Thats a lot of “pain and suffering”.  A jury awarding damages would hammer a Premier League club with the vast riches involved.
Reply
#45
(04-23-2024, 10:50 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 09:47 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: They are not far wrong on how he preformed

Incompetence? Absolutely, he was atrocious. But as Prag says, they've made libellous claims about corruption. They have to have evidence to support that, more than just "his family are Luton fans", otherwise they're fucked.

He should be sacked on the spot for being incompetence 1 ok 2 shocking 3 not one excuse ......if that was any of us at work you would be out of the door what makes them so fireproof ?
Reply
#46
(04-23-2024, 06:45 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 06:30 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 06:25 PM)Duffers Wrote: Josh, after a stellar few months you’re not covering yourself in glory here.

I really couldn't care less. 

I don't claim to be an expert, I'm just joining in a debate. It's funny how people shoot you down, tell you you're wrong but don't actually explain why. 

My question to Prag, is; Explain Libal law, then? He's clearly someone with vast experience in the subject matter (I assume given the nature of his responses) I've asserted that although Atwell may have a claim in principle, it won't be a claim worth pursuing as I can't see where the financial loss is coming from? He's not lost his officiating role, infact he's even been selected for a prestigious role in the Euros today!

Forest have embarrassed themselves. But have they really damaged Atwell's reputation to the extent his reputation will suffer?

Is my understanding that you have to suffer financial loss as a result of libelous comments incorrect? If so, then what would the basis of his case be? 

It's all well and good getting arsey with my posts, but at least respond in an adult manner and carry on the debate.

Well I certainly didn’t mean to offend.

He could quit due to the defamatory comments and claim that it has made it impossible for him to continue, sue for loss of earnings for the rest of his (likely) refereeing career and also sue for pecuniary damages for the stress, hurt and general damage to his reputation.  Unless Forest have clear evidence he would almost certainly win. 

Libel quickly summarised is the making of untrue statements to third parties, causing them loss or damage to their reputation.  If there is no evidence to prove that the comments are true - and it up to the person making them to prove that they are true - then the defamed person will win. 

The quantum of damages not only relates to actual loss suffered, but also “pain and suffering”.  An untrue statement read by 27 million people worldwide within 2-3 hours (and many more subsequently) is a lot of global damage to his character and reputation.  Mention the name “Stuart Attwell” and a huge number of people will know that name in a negative manner specifically because of Forest’s allegations.  Thats a lot of “pain and suffering”.  A jury awarding damages would hammer a Premier League club with the vast riches involved.

That's actually helpful and interesting, thanks! 

I know this is probably of little relevance, but Atwell, as does every other official, has 20,000 plus, fans shouting 'you're a wanker' or 'where's your shirt you bias cunt' every single week, they probably see Tweets from fans about their performance, and have no doubt been accused hundreds, if not thousands, of times of being corrupt. OK, not by a club, with so many followers and with such a big reach, but what Forest have said, shouldn't be new to him and I'd be surprised if has any pain and suffering (although, it's impossible to truly say without being out into that position). 

I genuinely understand the logic you've just posted, and the legal side you mentioned makes sense, but I just don't understand the practical side, i.e why he'd quit now and then go down the legal route. I'm probably wrong, but I just don't see that happening.

Alternatively Forest haven't said anything libelous, and we're arguing over nothing. But that's extremely unlikely, I'd have thought!
Reply
#47
(04-23-2024, 06:22 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 06:17 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: I would love to see a statement from the var  team on why they didn't send the ref to the screen.

Apparently PMGOL are forwarding the audio evidence to Forest. Quite why officials don't have their conversations aired at the time, per Rugby Union with TMO, and Cricket with DRS, I'll never know. That doesn't help matters in terms of people suspecting corruption, does it. How difficult would it be to air those discussions in real time?

(04-23-2024, 06:14 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 06:09 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 05:42 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 10:58 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: What financial loss has Atwell suffered as a consequence of Forest' Tweet? Anyone with half a brain will know it's sour grapes but with a hint of accuracy. I'm not so sure there's anything liable in what has been said to the point where it'd stand up in court.

Totally disagree.  Blatant defamation of character to accuse him of cheating/corruption - unisss they have evidence.

(04-23-2024, 12:14 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: Quite. To say there's corruption in the EPL and with VAR is one thing, and I think we can all pretty much say with confidence it's there to benefit the top clubs, but to actually prove it is another. 

This is my point, most people will suspect corruption so how can reputation be damaged when that's the majority of people's default mentality? 

I think what Forest Tweeted out was laughable and not what you should be seeing from a professional sports club. But I'm not so sure there's enough there to even begin a court case, let alone persue it.

You might wish to properly research libel law

(04-23-2024, 12:23 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: Just look at the comments on any VAR Fred here. Most people already suspect some form of corruption in letting the so called big 6 get away with decision after decision. Even before VAR it was widely accepted referees were extremely biased towards those same Big 6 clubs.

In terms of the legal aspect, and I'm more than willing to be corrected here, but in order to have a claim of defamation you have to prove you have suffered financial loss and/or damage of reputation as a result of that defamation. My point is that in order for reputation to be damaged then the default mentality is that there's no corruption in VAR or the Prem. I'm not so sure that that's the case. Unless I'm completely misinterpreting the tone of posts on here and making unreasonable assumptions that those tones can be assumed to be the same thoughts as most football fans. 

Can you honestly say that Atwell's reputation has been so damaged by the Tweet he has suffered any form of financial loss?


Rest assured he has a very strong case

It doesn’t matter what people THINK.  It’s what they SAY that counts.

(04-23-2024, 12:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Josh has a point. The obvious defence for Forest if this ever makes it into court is "how can you damage a reputation that is already lower than a snakes belly?"

Wrong.  It’s only the reputation of Attwell that counts here. It’s he who has been defamed

(04-23-2024, 12:33 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: That won't happen, though. He won't be forced to step aside, won't stop officiating, and therefore won't suffer any financial loss?

That’s a very unlikely outcome

I'll look forward to reading Atwell's winning judgement in due course. Please feel free to post on here once he's won the case. I'd be generally interested to read the jlfull judgement after he's sued Forest for all their worth.

Or will the judgement be found in the same place as our pending letters of administration and fire sale documents?

Do you mean the “pending letters of administration and fire sale documents” which would be in play imminently if the club hadn’t been sold when it was?
Maybe. Maybe not. No one really knows, do they. It's all guesswork.

There’s no “maybe not” about it.  We were in deep trouble.
Reply
#48
Forest should sue themselves for defamation, they've done far more harm to their own reputation than that of the incompetent VAR official.
Reply
#49
(04-23-2024, 09:01 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 06:22 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 06:17 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: I would love to see a statement from the var  team on why they didn't send the ref to the screen.

Apparently PMGOL are forwarding the audio evidence to Forest. Quite why officials don't have their conversations aired at the time, per Rugby Union with TMO, and Cricket with DRS, I'll never know. That doesn't help matters in terms of people suspecting corruption, does it. How difficult would it be to air those discussions in real time?

(04-23-2024, 06:14 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 06:09 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(04-23-2024, 05:42 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: Totally disagree.  Blatant defamation of character to accuse him of cheating/corruption - unisss they have evidence.


You might wish to properly research libel law



Rest assured he has a very strong case

It doesn’t matter what people THINK.  It’s what they SAY that counts.


Wrong.  It’s only the reputation of Attwell that counts here. It’s he who has been defamed


That’s a very unlikely outcome

I'll look forward to reading Atwell's winning judgement in due course. Please feel free to post on here once he's won the case. I'd be generally interested to read the jlfull judgement after he's sued Forest for all their worth.

Or will the judgement be found in the same place as our pending letters of administration and fire sale documents?

Do you mean the “pending letters of administration and fire sale documents” which would be in play imminently if the club hadn’t been sold when it was?
Maybe. Maybe not. No one really knows, do they. It's all guesswork.

There’s no “maybe not” about it.  We were in deep trouble.
It's like banging your head against the wall nothing g like ostrich putting their heads in the sand
Reply
#50
I haven't read all posts, but the phrase "unconscious bias" might be worth considering?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: