Just thinking, If Jimmy Shan
#1
Had been manager from day one, where would we be now.
I just think he can organise things better than Moore n Jones, and that's all that was lacking really. We have 2 strikers who have got 40plus goals between em, and we aint finished top two. Tells a story in itself.
Reply
#2
Similar position.
His lack of experience told on Saturday. Still believe a more experienced manager would have hooked Gayle, it was obvious what Villas game was.

He's done a decent job, as did Big Dave before him but IMO a good experienced boss would have got this squad up automatically. For all the talk the squad isn't as good as we make out its still a pretty strong squad for this division.
Reply
#3
(05-13-2019, 01:41 PM)baggie93 Wrote: Had been manager from day one, where would we be now.
I just think he can organise things better than Moore n Jones, and that's all that was lacking really. We have 2 strikers who have got 40plus goals between em, and we aint finished top two. Tells a story in itself.

Good question mon. 

He’s done a very decent job in the circs - and I suspect we would have finished closer to the top 2. Still POs mind

But at the end of it all and as we stand - he has lost all 3 of our games against teams in the top 8.
Reply
#4
I'm fast coming to the thinking it's only partially down to the managers and largely down to the loan players you can get your hands on. If we'd have kept Harvey Barnes we would have been automatic, if Villa hadn't have got hold of Mings they'd have been dead and buried gaes ago. I think Shan (and Morre) have a lot to learn and this isn't the right environment for them to do that.
Reply
#5
(05-13-2019, 01:44 PM)boingingbaggie Wrote: Similar position.
His lack of experience told on Saturday. Still believe a more experienced manager would have hooked Gayle, it was obvious what Villas game was.

He's done a decent job, as did Big Dave before him but IMO a good experienced boss would have got this squad up automatically. For all the talk the squad isn't as good as we make out its still a pretty strong squad for this division.
Agree 100% with all that

(05-13-2019, 01:44 PM)boingingbaggie Wrote: Similar position.
His lack of experience told on Saturday. Still believe a more experienced manager would have hooked Gayle, it was obvious what Villas game was.

He's done a decent job, as did Big Dave before him but IMO a good experienced boss would have got this squad up automatically. For all the talk the squad isn't as good as we make out its still a pretty strong squad for this division.
Perhaps Appy shudda stepped in re hooking Gayle. We've bought him in to help. He's managed 250 games
Reply
#6
(05-13-2019, 02:05 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I'm fast coming to the thinking it's only partially down to the managers and largely down to the loan players you can get your hands on. If we'd have kept Harvey Barnes we would have been automatic, if Villa hadn't have got hold of Mings they'd have been dead and buried gaes ago. I think Shan (and Morre) have a lot to learn and this isn't the right environment for them to do that.

Spot on, this squad is decent on paper but inconsistent and I really doubt whether enough of them really want to go up. This squad has got far to many mangers the sack with many different styles of football played with them.

Barnes was a massive loss, the club should have been looking at a replacement/alternative far earlier.
Reply
#7
(05-13-2019, 02:05 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I'm fast coming to the thinking it's only partially down to the managers and largely down to the loan players you can get your hands on. If we'd have kept Harvey Barnes we would have been automatic, if Villa hadn't have got hold of Mings they'd have been dead and buried gaes ago. I think Shan (and Morre) have a lot to learn and this isn't the right environment for them to do that.

In my opinion the mistake was giving it Moore in the first place. Wrong situation for him.
Reply
#8
(05-13-2019, 02:07 PM)baggie93 Wrote:
(05-13-2019, 01:44 PM)boingingbaggie Wrote: Similar position.
His lack of experience told on Saturday. Still believe a more experienced manager would have hooked Gayle, it was obvious what Villas game was.

He's done a decent job, as did Big Dave before him but IMO a good experienced boss would have got this squad up automatically. For all the talk the squad isn't as good as we make out its still a pretty strong squad for this division.
Agree 100% with all that

(05-13-2019, 01:44 PM)boingingbaggie Wrote: Similar position.
His lack of experience told on Saturday. Still believe a more experienced manager would have hooked Gayle, it was obvious what Villas game was.

He's done a decent job, as did Big Dave before him but IMO a good experienced boss would have got this squad up automatically. For all the talk the squad isn't as good as we make out its still a pretty strong squad for this division.
Perhaps Appy shudda stepped in re hooking Gayle. We've bought him in to help. He's managed 250 games
 
Appy wanted to bring Giles Barnes on
Reply
#9
We definitely need an experienced manager with all the changes that’s needed to the squad regardless of which division we are in next season ,I would have Mowbray back in a shot
Reply
#10
Moore earned his chance. Come what may, I will not regret the club giving him a go. What I will regret is them allowing him to chose Jones as his assistant. That outcome was entirely predictable.

As for hooking Gayle - possibly, but Gayle was keeping them busy. What if we hooked him and they then scored a third. Easy to say in hindsight. I don't like criticising Shan for the failure the ref.

Looking at how the league has panned out, with more pragmatic management, auto was easily within grasp.

However, we mustn't forget what a shambles the club was in during summer. Moore was key to securing Gayle and Barnes.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)