The cricket - - - -
(02-18-2024, 11:33 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(02-18-2024, 10:29 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: As some pundit on Talksport has just said, "This can't be fun, for the players or anyone watching. It has to make some sense".

I'm happy to accept that Bazball is about attitude and encouraging attacking play. There's surely no need for that attitude to morph into arrogance and complacency. Idle cronyism in team selection and poor decision-making by individual batters have obliterated the euphoria of the 1st Test win. Talking bullshit at press conferences doesn't help when you go out the next day and lose by a record margin.

TBF, In the past I've seen England attempt to bat out the sessions to scrape a draw, and fail miserably. It's the same result.

Exactly.
Reply
(02-18-2024, 02:28 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(02-18-2024, 02:09 PM)Cuzer Wrote: You're trying your hardes to get a rise RS with your blinkers, great win, well done, move on

Was the pitch good? Yes in the main, especially to some of the ones you see in the sub continent. Did some balls misbehave? massively, did we get some poor on field decisions? Yes, did it make a difference to the result, absolutely not

For me it's simple, as soon as Root was out the boys were booking their tee off times for tomorrow, you know how this Stokes team works, could we have taken it into Day 5, of course we could, would we have saved the test? Absolutely not, have a day off, some R&R and go again

With this Stokes/BM set up don't get too high on the wins or too down on the defeats, they play result cricket, they will always play result cricket

You've absolutely no chance of a rethink, they've been in all three tests and could have been better than 1-2, they will play the same way, for somebody that allegedly knows the sport why even suggest it? This is how this England team plays whether Australia away, India away or Zimbabwe at home

Cuzer

Clearly anything and everything I say is blinkered. 

The pitch was excellent as noted by experienced pundits. A good test pitch allows for bat and ball to excel. All 3 so far have done that. But that's something you will not commend due to your clear disregard and loathing for India. 

I have complimented and criticised both teams throughout. I will continue to voice my opinion. I don't need your validation as it's so one eyed. Why the vitriol? I mean Kohli is absent ffs.

As for ASKING IF this may result in a rethink to England's approach ... I'm not the only one who thinks that the inflexible approach may win matches but situations arise where a change maybe advisable.

But as I said before.. there's the Cuzer way of thinking (?) or there's the  ..... oh fuck there isn't an alternative. Clown.

It is blinkered, you are blinkered, you've been called out by many on here, I don't need to point it out

I'm not quite sure what tree you're barking up here, you tend to create things in your head as you go along

There is no alternative with this England team, they've created an enviroment where a fun and aggressive approach is how they play, they knew the game was gone so they took Day 5 off and will reboot, that's how they approach things
It's not for everybody but they're not going to change

As Rich said they will sit down, analyise and try to be better in the next test but this talk of reboot, rethink, change of strategy, not a chance

Winning in India is nigh on impossible at the best of times, chacnes are given our spinners are 2 kids and a first cap debutant with Leach now home, we have zero chance of getting a result out here before a ball has been bowled, sure this test was dissapointing but overall we've arguably competed better than expected, certainly better than I've excpected but they will play aggressive cricket, entertain and see where it gets us, I've no issue with that

Remember needing 340 to beat India in the delayed series, India thought the job was done and finally victory in England, we knocked them off in 4 sessions for the loss of 3, it's how they play if it doesn't come off they try harder next time, they way we took it back to Australia this summer and they couldn't live with it after being 2 down, it ain't changin anytime soon.....

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
(02-18-2024, 02:49 PM)richbaggie Wrote: Absolutely no chance there will be a change of approach. You'll get absolute stinkers like today but more highs than lows.

So far, Stokes has captained England in 22 Tests, winning 14 games, losing seven, and drawing one.

His win percentage of 63.63% (among those who have captained the side in at least 10 Tests) is the best in England's 147-year history in Test cricket.

We aren't suddenly going to rethink everything.

That's not to say things can't be tweaked. Root for example needs to go back to what he knows best. He was always free scoring playing conventionally anyway. I'd also drop Bairstow but fear he's too close to Stokes.

This all more than fair comment. And I wouldn't pay too much notice on today.

It's those key moments where we are in a fantastic position and fail to take advantage. Hard to see how you can go from 200 for 2, to all out for a little over 300.

Certainly playing abroad I think there needs to be a more realistic approach. Our bowlers get very little rest between innings, really hard in hot conditions, especially when one of your main bowlers is in their fifth decade.
Reply
(02-18-2024, 04:03 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(02-18-2024, 02:28 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(02-18-2024, 02:09 PM)Cuzer Wrote: You're trying your hardes to get a rise RS with your blinkers, great win, well done, move on

Was the pitch good? Yes in the main, especially to some of the ones you see in the sub continent. Did some balls misbehave? massively, did we get some poor on field decisions? Yes, did it make a difference to the result, absolutely not

For me it's simple, as soon as Root was out the boys were booking their tee off times for tomorrow, you know how this Stokes team works, could we have taken it into Day 5, of course we could, would we have saved the test? Absolutely not, have a day off, some R&R and go again

With this Stokes/BM set up don't get too high on the wins or too down on the defeats, they play result cricket, they will always play result cricket

You've absolutely no chance of a rethink, they've been in all three tests and could have been better than 1-2, they will play the same way, for somebody that allegedly knows the sport why even suggest it? This is how this England team plays whether Australia away, India away or Zimbabwe at home

Cuzer

Clearly anything and everything I say is blinkered. 

The pitch was excellent as noted by experienced pundits. A good test pitch allows for bat and ball to excel. All 3 so far have done that. But that's something you will not commend due to your clear disregard and loathing for India. 

I have complimented and criticised both teams throughout. I will continue to voice my opinion. I don't need your validation as it's so one eyed. Why the vitriol? I mean Kohli is absent ffs.

As for ASKING IF this may result in a rethink to England's approach ... I'm not the only one who thinks that the inflexible approach may win matches but situations arise where a change maybe advisable.

But as I said before.. there's the Cuzer way of thinking (?) or there's the  ..... oh fuck there isn't an alternative. Clown.

It is blinkered, you are blinkered, you've been called out by many on here, I don't need to point it out

I'm not quite sure what tree you're barking up here, you tend to create things in your head as you go along

There is no alternative with this England team, they've created an enviroment where a fun and aggressive approach is how they play, they knew the game was gone so they took Day 5 off and will reboot, that's how they approach things
It's not for everybody but they're not going to change

As Rich said they will sit down, analyise and try to be better in the next test but this talk of reboot, rethink, change of strategy, not a chance

Winning in India is nigh on impossible at the best of times, chacnes are given our spinners are 2 kids and a first cap debutant with Leach now home, we have zero chance of getting a result out here before a ball has been bowled, sure this test was dissapointing but overall we've arguably competed better than expected, certainly better than I've excpected but they will play aggressive cricket, entertain and see where it gets us, I've no issue with that

Remember needing 340 to beat India in the delayed series, India thought the job was done and finally victory in England, we knocked them off in 4 sessions for the loss of 3, it's how they play if it doesn't come off they try harder next time, they way we took it back to Australia this summer and they couldn't live with it after being 2 down, it ain't changin anytime soon.....

Cuzer

"It unravelled very quickly. It was extraordinary. This will reawaken all of the debate about so-called Bazball. It is great when it works but there seems an inability to go back to a more traditional way of playing.

"England threw a chance away on the third day. I hope there is honesty in the dressing room."


J Agnew

No we can't debate it. Be told.
Reply
Agnew has always been fairly luke warm to the approach.
Reply
Agnew is right. Game was lost yesterday morning when instead of digging in a bit and batting most of the day, we did what we always do. Said it throughout the past 18 months but Bazball isn't ruthless enough to adapt to the ebbs and flows of a game. When the going is good it's brutal, but it is extremely brittle under pressure.

I find some of the shit coming out of the changing room especially after the defeats confusing at best. Duckett's comments yesterday were at best completely arrogant and at worst plain deranged.
Reply
(02-18-2024, 04:49 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Agnew is right. Game was lost yesterday morning when instead of digging in a bit and batting most of the day, we did what we always do. Said it throughout the past 18 months but Bazball isn't ruthless enough to adapt to the ebbs and flows of a game. When the going is good it's brutal, but it is extremely brittle under pressure.

I find some of the shit coming out of the changing room especially after the defeats confusing at best. Duckett's comments yesterday were at best completely arrogant and at worst plain deranged.

You can't say that Ted! Big Grin

Stokes .. draw is not an option
Duckett ... the more to chase the better. That worked out well then eh?

Sport is about managing the situations..
Reply
(02-18-2024, 04:59 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(02-18-2024, 04:49 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Agnew is right. Game was lost yesterday morning when instead of digging in a bit and batting most of the day, we did what we always do. Said it throughout the past 18 months but Bazball isn't ruthless enough to adapt to the ebbs and flows of a game. When the going is good it's brutal, but it is extremely brittle under pressure.

I find some of the shit coming out of the changing room especially after the defeats confusing at best. Duckett's comments yesterday were at best completely arrogant and at worst plain deranged.

You can't say that Ted! Big Grin

Stokes .. draw is not an option
Duckett ... the more to chase the better. That worked out well then eh?

Sport is about managing the situations..

The Australian teams of the early 2000s was built on aggressive cricket, they actually did kick off the trend of increasing run rates in test cricket. There is not a chance in hell they'd have gone down swinging like we did yesterday morning. Dig in, play the situation and bat all day to restore parity. If we'd have done that India would have had a real job to win the game easily. 

Two years ago the Albion sacked a manager who had a one size fits all way of playing football. All sport is the same, there are times to attack and times to absorb pressure. Knowing when those times are is the key to being a great side and it is nothing short of arrogant to suggest your see yourselves as above having to do the dirty work.
Reply
(02-18-2024, 05:05 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-18-2024, 04:59 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(02-18-2024, 04:49 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Agnew is right. Game was lost yesterday morning when instead of digging in a bit and batting most of the day, we did what we always do. Said it throughout the past 18 months but Bazball isn't ruthless enough to adapt to the ebbs and flows of a game. When the going is good it's brutal, but it is extremely brittle under pressure.

I find some of the shit coming out of the changing room especially after the defeats confusing at best. Duckett's comments yesterday were at best completely arrogant and at worst plain deranged.

You can't say that Ted! Big Grin

Stokes .. draw is not an option
Duckett ... the more to chase the better. That worked out well then eh?

Sport is about managing the situations..

The Australian teams of the early 2000s was built on aggressive cricket, they actually did kick off the trend of increasing run rates in test cricket. There is not a chance in hell they'd have gone down swinging like we did yesterday morning. Dig in, play the situation and bat all day to restore parity. If we'd have done that India would have had a real job to win the game easily. 

Two years ago the Albion sacked a manager who had a one size fits all way of playing football. All sport is the same, there are times to attack and times to absorb pressure. Knowing when those times are is the key to being a great side and it is nothing short of arrogant to suggest your see yourselves as above having to do the dirty work.

C'rect.
Reply
(02-18-2024, 04:37 PM)richbaggie Wrote: Agnew has always been fairly luke warm to the approach.

Rightfully so.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)