The disquiet at Palace
#41
(02-09-2024, 11:47 AM)Squid Wrote:
(02-09-2024, 11:17 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-09-2024, 10:58 AM)Squid Wrote:
(02-09-2024, 10:51 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-09-2024, 08:34 AM)Peachy Wrote: Here's an interesting question. Who would rather get promoted and be offered 3 seasons worth of parachute money to stay in the championship or who would rather go up to the Prem, with VAR, and get pumped every week?

(Taking our obvious perilous financial position out of the equation)

It's a weird one.

Think for years we felt we had missed the boat and eventually got in the Prem and finally stayed there, but really aside of the Hodgson/Clarke seasons, just 3 of them, it was just making up the numbers, with the occasional big scalp to make us  feel good.

I want us though to be a club that can be a midtable decent club like that again and maybe become a Brighton, as they are now. All things considered they are not as big a club as us and it shows what is possible outside the established few.

As someone said in a post a couple of weeks ago, we settle for too little with Albion and this humility whilst gentle is our undoing. We complain the Seals and Dings have ideas above their stations. Well we should think more like that.

We've a 26,500 stadium, with the likes of the MK Dons having a bigger stadium than us. For a club with such a long history in one of the most densely populated areas of the country we could be doing so much more.

Much though is down to who buys us.

I give up.

It's been written many times on this thread alone: Brighton are only where they are because of the currently boundless wealth of their immensely wealthy owner. Unless we have a similarly wealthy and generous owner, neither us nor any other club will be doing a Brighton any time soon. The PL cartel is entirely set up for the interests of the Big 6. The other 14 clubs are just there to make up the numbers, not to ever seriously compete.

As I said, much(OK all) is down to who buys us. Unfortunately, the Peace years didn't move us on greatly.
I totally agree about the Prem cartel. Really there's those handful of clubs in pole position and just occasionally someone who has a go at joining them. Villa, I hate to say, do actually have a chance.
Your assessment of making up the numbers is the way it is. That is why the Prem became so soulless for us and maybe Palace are finding that now.
Over half the clubs are always a bad few months away from the disaster of relegation.

I've said it before, but the vast numbers of empty seats in the Sheff Utd section when they played Man City in the FA Cup semi final should have set massive alarm bells ringing. To not bother to see your team play in a semi-final speaks of massive apathy. That (and quite a few other reasons) are why Manchester City should face full punishment for all their FFP breaches.

And the perverse thing too is City fans can't be bothered either. I went to the Semi v Liverpool a couple of seasons ago as there were heaps of football tourists that day. It was only junior and his mates wanted to go.

The ridiculous level of wealth and corrupt way they have gone about growing the club is a disgrace and the recent Prem years has ruined the game, where it really is like being fed to Lions.

By the way, just you watch them reel off 12 wins in a row now or similar to tie up the league and are we all supposed to marvel at them?
Reply
#42
Er, no.
Reply
#43
(02-08-2024, 09:19 PM)Squid Wrote:
(02-08-2024, 09:04 PM)ElbowGrease1973 II Wrote:
(02-08-2024, 08:20 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: The Greed league is a boring sack of shit and fans just get frustrated by it, desperate for something exciting to happen, but it rarely does.
Promotion from the Championship is equivalent to winning a school race, getting a nice cheque and then getting a bucket of shit tipped on your head by the bullies while the teachers laugh and cheer.

You're bang on Bob. The Palace fans should really be protesting against the Premier League, as they've made the top division a soulless place to be, unless you're one of the big 6 or 7 clubs. Fighting to finish anywhere between 8th and 17th becomes tiresome. And yet, if you're to thrive as a club that's where you need to be.

This is exactly right. It's the massive problem with modern football and the elephant in the room for the Big Six obsessed media.

Brighton should not be included in this conversation. They are a sugar daddy's plaything. As soon as his money goes, the success will gradually ebb away too.

You can say this to you are blue in the face Squid but you will still have people argue we should emulate Brighton without ever acknowledging the money they have spent to get where they are. I’ve argued this for years but apparently it’s mostly don’t to great scouting, the DoF and just been great at what they do… of course it is ffs!
Reply
#44
The money helps, but you can still emulate the model, since it's our old model, without money and do well, maybe not quite as well of course. The part of it we never got right was selling high, we kept players too long. That's something I hope we'll repair of we get back to running well like that.
Reply
#45
(02-09-2024, 02:57 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: The money helps, but you can still emulate the model, since it's our old model, without money and do well, maybe not quite as well of course. The part of it we never got right was selling high, we kept players too long. That's something I hope we'll repair of we get back to running well like that.

Correct - essentially what we should aim to emulate from Brighton is their determination to do things differently, maximise leagues that other clubs aren't scouting heavily in, having feeder networks all over South America and Eastern Europe, link with clubs on the continent with less strict work permit regulations, and fundamentally have a plan behind the scenes which is reviewed and amended as circumstances arise.

Yes it helps that they have immense amounts of money, but they are now run in a more sustainable way - the amount of money they have generated in the last couple of years through player sales, and what they could potentially generate with the sales of Ferguson, Mitoma, Buonanotte etc would pay back the money Bloom has invested from day one and some. 

It is quite rightly unreasonable for us to aspire to be where they currently are as it requires half a billion quid of equity and a far more lenient set of rules than we now have in place. Thanks to Newcastle's new wealth the door to outlandish spending has been closed, hence why BHA are having to sell assets and modify their model, however we can learn a lot from their approach to the footballing operations side of the business.

Maybe it's a more fair approach to try and emulate the way Luton are run behind the scenes and the way Palace have operated with initiatives such as their youth development support which means they are more likely to get the best kids in a very competitive area.

Ultimately I hope the new owners have an understanding of what the club is, and how to be successful, and put the base organisation in place which allows that plan to be executed.
Reply
#46
Luton are a far better example SW4, Brighton’s ability to generate so much player sales and scouting network etc and only afforded by being bank rolled in the first place. To do that organically is almost impossible.
In the form of his life.
Reply
#47
(02-09-2024, 02:57 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: The money helps, but you can still emulate the model, since it's our old model, without money and do well, maybe not quite as well of course. The part of it we never got right was selling high, we kept players too long. That's something I hope we'll repair of we get back to running well like that.

This.

Even with Man City, undoubtedly the money helps, it turns them into contenders, what makes them winners is again, rather boringly, outstanding recruitment and coaching. Other clubs have spent similar amounts as City over the last 10 years, but not spent it as well. 

As for Brighton and Palace, similar size clubs, there is no doubt that the difference at the moment is player recruitment and to some extent coaching. I think Hidgson is a great coach. 
We could almost have afforded Caicedo...I think he was bought the same season as we bought Dike...they made over £100m profit on the player. But apparently player recruitment has nothing to do with their success.

And Birdman1811 is correct, our selling of players has been abysmal, particularly when we were in the premier league. We had good players and hung onto them until they were no longer good premier league players, and obtained minimal transfer fees or no fees for them and then wonder why we did not successfully replace them.
Reply
#48
(02-09-2024, 03:47 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: Luton are a far better example SW4, Brighton’s ability to generate so much player sales and scouting network etc and only afforded by being bank rolled in the first place. To do that organically is almost impossible.

Luton will be where Wigan are in a few seasons time again imo. Currently though they are the only exception to the rule with regards to relative success without rich owners.
Reply
#49
(02-09-2024, 03:57 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-09-2024, 03:47 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: Luton are a far better example SW4, Brighton’s ability to generate so much player sales and scouting network etc and only afforded by being bank rolled in the first place. To do that organically is almost impossible.

Luton will be where Wigan are in a few seasons time again imo. Currently though they are the only exception to the rule with regards to relative success without rich owners.

Most likely, maybe 5-10 years depending on how they use their eventual parachute payments. But they are right now the best example of being well run, and having a bit of good luck on their side.
In the form of his life.
Reply
#50
(02-09-2024, 03:54 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(02-09-2024, 02:57 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: The money helps, but you can still emulate the model, since it's our old model, without money and do well, maybe not quite as well of course. The part of it we never got right was selling high, we kept players too long. That's something I hope we'll repair of we get back to running well like that.

This.

Even with Man City, undoubtedly the money helps, it turns them into contenders, what makes them winners is again, rather boringly, outstanding recruitment and coaching. Other clubs have spent similar amounts as City over the last 10 years, but not spent it as well. 

As for Brighton and Palace, similar size clubs, there is no doubt that the difference at the moment is player recruitment and to some extent coaching. I think Hidgson is a great coach. 
We could almost have afforded Caicedo...I think he was bought the same season as we bought Dike...they made over £100m profit on the player. But apparently player recruitment has nothing to do with their success.

And Birdman1811 is correct, our selling of players has been abysmal, particularly when we were in the premier league. We had good players and hung onto them until they were no longer good premier league players, and obtained minimal transfer fees or no fees for them and then wonder why we did not successfully replace them.

We have owners who won’t put a penny into the club, in fact they’ve taken money out. The idea it’s down to our scouting and coaching that we aren’t where they are is wide of the mark.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: