Bacuna racist abuse
(02-06-2024, 10:19 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 10:14 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 09:45 AM)Squid Wrote: I'm surprised nobody's mentioned the J-Rod case yet. That was eventually found to be a case where as Allan Nyom put it, the player definitely believed a racist remark had been said, but there was no evidence that such a comment had been made.

I alluded to this a few pages ago.

I don't think Bacuna is lying or making it up, I think in the heat of the moment he genuinely believed he heard something. Whether anything actually was or not is the question, but being mistaken and believing your own truth is not the same as lying.

I hate the idea of an incident like this not attracting a thorough investigation and I don't think such an investigation is a waste of police time.

However, based upon what I have heard, I think the balance - for me - has shifted.  He was evidently wound up.  This happens to him a lot more than most, it seems yet I don't think a case has been proven to date.  There have been some sensible posters (not the type that like to whitewash racism) who have reported nothing witnessed.  Based upon what I've heard, and if I was on a jury, I'd acquit.  We need to hear his side first though.  

But to assume that a case doesn't even need to be investigated?  That doesn't sit ok with me.

Completely agree.
Reply
(02-06-2024, 10:07 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 10:01 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: The Bacuna case isn’t taking up coppers time that could be used more wisely elsewhere because of bad prioritising. It’s taking up time that acts in opposition to what else it could be used for because of a pitifully underfunded and overstretched public resource.

Leaving us with an argument about it that doesn’t even need to exist and misses the point

Let's be honest, Spandex saying racism isn't important (or overstated in importance) is the equivalent of the cuddly toy on the Generation Game.  He just doesn't find it as important as the plight of the working class/burglary/bollocks being grabbed/trans issues and you're just trying to cancel him because of his views.
Not really. I haven't said racism isn't important and this is where the whole grown up debates finishes as we (as a society) can't hold honest open discussions as it's a them or us camp with no nuance.
Context is everything and the complexities of tribalism, prejudice against others etc is in all of us and needs to be recognised in a more grown up way. 
As I said it's a debate that is laden with trip wire, no matter how well intentioned anyone is, which I am.
It is a climate that has pigeon holed this debate into a very uncomfortable place as both me and Hughie Reed have already said, hence my initial misgivings about opening the debate into something wider.
It's complex and uncomfortable times.
Reply
I think it’s a decent debate to be honest. But there is often also a very “nuanced “ line in situations I see where people pull out the old “you can’t say certain things” nowadays line when in fact what they mean is I’ve been called out and made transparent for what I really mean.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
(02-06-2024, 10:25 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I think it’s a decent debate to be honest. But there is often also a very “nuanced “ line in situations I see where people pull out the old “you can’t say certain things” nowadays line when in fact what they mean is I’ve been called out and made transparent for what I really mean.
To be honest Captain, I think by and large we can have more intelligent debate on here and there seems to be a core of bright posters, of which you are one. Of course the finance wizards sit at the top table.
In wider society though I'm not so sure.
I don't engage on Facebook, but have an account and get some snippets from grouops I find useful. I left the Action For Albion group as it was the equivalent of being in a social club full of hairy arsed morons from the Smethwick End arguing with liberal university students. 
Sadly that group and some of the shit on Twitter is more where we are and there are certain trigger words that are flammable. Racism is one of those.
Reply
(02-06-2024, 10:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 10:25 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I think it’s a decent debate to be honest. But there is often also a very “nuanced “ line in situations I see where people pull out the old “you can’t say certain things” nowadays line when in fact what they mean is I’ve been called out and made transparent for what I really mean.
To be honest Captain, I think by and large we can have more intelligent debate on here and there seems to be a core of bright posters, of which you are one.
In wider society though I'm not so sure.
I don't engage on Facebook, but have an account and get some snippets from grouops I find useful. I left the Action For Albion group as it was the equivalent of being in a social club full of morons arguing with liberal univesity students. 
Sadly that group and some of the shit on Twitter is more where we are and there are certain trigger words that are flammable. Racism is one of those.

Yep I agree with that it’s why this place is the only place I bother debating things. For all our differences Proth said similar a few weeks back. You can have a wider range of views on here and in the main and broader willingness to accept some stick without it all descending into cuntivity. By and large it’s always been a good space for that, this place.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
(02-06-2024, 10:36 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 10:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 10:25 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I think it’s a decent debate to be honest. But there is often also a very “nuanced “ line in situations I see where people pull out the old “you can’t say certain things” nowadays line when in fact what they mean is I’ve been called out and made transparent for what I really mean.
To be honest Captain, I think by and large we can have more intelligent debate on here and there seems to be a core of bright posters, of which you are one.
In wider society though I'm not so sure.
I don't engage on Facebook, but have an account and get some snippets from grouops I find useful. I left the Action For Albion group as it was the equivalent of being in a social club full of morons arguing with liberal univesity students. 
Sadly that group and some of the shit on Twitter is more where we are and there are certain trigger words that are flammable. Racism is one of those.

Yep I agree with that it’s why this place is the only place I bother debating things. For all our differences Proth said similar a few weeks back. You can have a wider range of views on here and in the main and broader willingness to accept some stick without it all descending into cuntivity. By and large it’s always been a good space for that, this place.

It's also pretty good for cuntivity at times, too.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
(02-06-2024, 10:47 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 10:36 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 10:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 10:25 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I think it’s a decent debate to be honest. But there is often also a very “nuanced “ line in situations I see where people pull out the old “you can’t say certain things” nowadays line when in fact what they mean is I’ve been called out and made transparent for what I really mean.
To be honest Captain, I think by and large we can have more intelligent debate on here and there seems to be a core of bright posters, of which you are one.
In wider society though I'm not so sure.
I don't engage on Facebook, but have an account and get some snippets from grouops I find useful. I left the Action For Albion group as it was the equivalent of being in a social club full of morons arguing with liberal univesity students. 
Sadly that group and some of the shit on Twitter is more where we are and there are certain trigger words that are flammable. Racism is one of those.

Yep I agree with that it’s why this place is the only place I bother debating things. For all our differences Proth said similar a few weeks back. You can have a wider range of views on here and in the main and broader willingness to accept some stick without it all descending into cuntivity. By and large it’s always been a good space for that, this place.

It's also pretty good for cuntivity at times, too.

I think cuntivity is an early runner for the oed word of the year  Big Grin
Reply
(02-06-2024, 10:49 AM)garryowensneck Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 10:47 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 10:36 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 10:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 10:25 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I think it’s a decent debate to be honest. But there is often also a very “nuanced “ line in situations I see where people pull out the old “you can’t say certain things” nowadays line when in fact what they mean is I’ve been called out and made transparent for what I really mean.
To be honest Captain, I think by and large we can have more intelligent debate on here and there seems to be a core of bright posters, of which you are one.
In wider society though I'm not so sure.
I don't engage on Facebook, but have an account and get some snippets from grouops I find useful. I left the Action For Albion group as it was the equivalent of being in a social club full of morons arguing with liberal univesity students. 
Sadly that group and some of the shit on Twitter is more where we are and there are certain trigger words that are flammable. Racism is one of those.

Yep I agree with that it’s why this place is the only place I bother debating things. For all our differences Proth said similar a few weeks back. You can have a wider range of views on here and in the main and broader willingness to accept some stick without it all descending into cuntivity. By and large it’s always been a good space for that, this place.

It's also pretty good for cuntivity at times, too.

I think cuntivity is an early runner for the oed word of the year  Big Grin

It hasn't actual came up as needing a spell check, which is intriguing!
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
If Bacuna has said he was racially abused, you have to investigate and take his claims seriously.

Hearsay from people who were sat near to the alleged culprit should be put to one side until the police and the club have conducted their investigation. If proven the person will be permanently banned from the Hawthorns. If not proven, the club will say so and life goes on.

It is not representative of all Albion fans, just as it's not representative of society as a whole. The oneupmanship of football fans over things like this is one of the most pointless and regressive things about modern fan culture, it helps no one.

It's not that fucking difficult.
Reply
(02-06-2024, 10:58 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: If Bacuna has said he was racially abused, you have to investigate and take his claims seriously.

Hearsay from people who were sat near to the alleged culprit should be put to one side until the police and the club have conducted their investigation. If proven the person will be permanently banned from the Hawthorns. If not proven, the club will say so and life goes on.

It is not representative of all Albion fans, just as it's not representative of society as a whole. The oneupmanship of football fans over things like this is one of the most pointless and regressive things about modern fan culture, it helps no one.

It's not that fucking difficult.

Indeed.

It was exactly the same after the trouble against Wolves. Straight away there were people wailing about how it was a disagrace to everything and people should hanged, etc but at the same time there were apologists popping up saying we hadn't done anything wrong (despite clear evidence to the contrary), it was the Wolves fans' fault, etc...

It's very difficult to take a balanced view when it's your club.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)