The cricket - - - -
Just looked at an under 19, 50 over match video of an England batsman being given out for obstructing the field against Zimbabwe. All he did was pick up the ball that had stopped in the crease and threw it to the wicketkeeper standing next to him, who then appealed. Yes it’s out but what is cricket becoming if the umpires and teams give these ridiculous decisions.
Reply
(02-03-2024, 01:07 PM)wba13 Wrote: Just looked at an under 19, 50 over match video of an England batsman being given out for obstructing the field against Zimbabwe. All he did was pick up the ball that had stopped in the crease and threw it to the wicketkeeper standing next to him, who then appealed. Yes it’s out but what is cricket becoming if the umpires and teams give these ridiculous decisions.

This dismissal happened in the County Championship a few years back. It's a bizarre way to get out, but it's the rules. Why give the opponents the chance to appeal, and when they do so, the umpire has no choice but to give it out. 

Players should know the rules. I've no real sympathy.
Reply
(02-03-2024, 01:07 PM)wba13 Wrote: Just looked at an under 19, 50 over match video of an England batsman being given out for obstructing the field against Zimbabwe. All he did was pick up the ball that had stopped in the crease and threw it to the wicketkeeper standing next to him, who then appealed. Yes it’s out but what is cricket becoming if the umpires and teams give these ridiculous decisions.

Umpires have no choice - they’ve got to give it out if there’s an appeal.  All they can do is ask the fielding captain if they wish the appeal to stand.

The issue is with the fielding side.  Would you wish to claim a wicket like that?  I wouldn’t.  It’s 100 times worse than a Mankad in which the batter was trying to gain an illegal advantage. 

A fairly brainless thing for the England batter to do though.  I bet he won’t do that again!
Reply
(02-03-2024, 11:53 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Bumrah digs India out of a potential hole. At one point it looked like England would get 450 plus by lunch tomorrow.
No chase seems improbable in the 4th innings for England. India must not throw this advantage away as they did in the 1st test.

Unplayable spell after lunch, turned the test on its head

India will certainly want over 350 against this Stokes side but firmly in the box seats

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
England need 399 to win in 6 & a bit sessions every thing points to an Indian win however not with this England side!!!….50/50 in my books buckle up.
Reply
(02-04-2024, 10:16 AM)pindgill Wrote: England need 399 to win in 6 & a bit sessions every thing points to an Indian win however not with this England side!!!….50/50 in my books buckle up.

Sadly the wicket now has variable bounce.  Really difficult to bat on.  Can’t see England getting close.
Reply
399 to win in the 4th innings in India would be the best ever run chase. I just can't see it, sadly. (But if they get anywhere around half way I wouldn't bet against it!)
Reply
I'm not saying anything.

I want to write this chase off. I just can't.

Is anyone keeping an eye on the BBC Test Match love feed? There's some belting examples of sledging on there! Big Grin
Reply
Glorious or inglorious ? failure awaits, but the fact there is still ANY interest in the result is testament to Stokes (as a Captain if not as a batter).
Reply
50/50? Not a chance

I’d say 80/20 and it’s only 20 because of this history of the Stokes/McCullen era

Bumrah with the 30 over old ball is arguably more dangerous than the new ball and plenty of variable bounce on display which will only deteriorate

I’d be surprised personally if they get within 100, alas leaked too many runs in the first innings when one knock held up the rest for India

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: