The cricket - - - -
#31
It should be mandatory that any televised cricket coverage should feature Isa Guha and/or Mayanti Langar in their commentary team.
Reply
#32
(01-24-2024, 10:27 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: No, I won't be getting up at 4.00am to listen, but I will tune in halfway through the first day.

I've been a stern critic of Rob Key and his off-the-wall selections for England. Will he prove me wrong starting tomorrow? Mark Wood is the only seamer in the line-up. Hardly a stock bowler though. If the Indian batters take a liking to one or more of the spinners we'll see a lot of overs bowled by part-timers like Root and - - - well who else? We desperately needed a seam bowling all-rounder, but that would have meant leaving out Bairstow or Foakes. Can't leave out Jonny, he's one of the gang.

What jars with me is the fact that the proven best spin bowler in England, Liam Dawson, has been left out because "he is probably not someone who wants to go around India as a 15th or 16th man. I don't think it's high on his agenda to be a replacement bowler". Yet we've picked Leach who hasn't played at all since injury and two blokes with barely two seasons of first class cricket behind them. Rob Key has essentially said "You don't have an England future, Liam Dawson".

Remember one of England's better players in the woeful World Cup finals? David Willey, informed halfway through the tournament that he wouldn't be offered a new central contract and responded by announcing his retirement from international cricket immediately afterwards. Wonderful motivation from the management there.

Rob Key is all about cliques, cronies, old pals' acts, keeping the band together. All the stuff that prevents English cricket from staying at the top for long. I'll be delighted when he's gone. This tour will either provide some shreds of evidence that his methods can work or (more likely IMO) be another well-deserved nail in the coffin of his career.

Now I have read what you have written a couple of times now some of the points you raise are valid
Especially the comments about Mark Wood also good foresight considering what’s happened to Hartley today, but I have to give Key credit for his appointments McCullum as test coach and Ben Stokes as captain were bold moves which I think as paid off so far, everyone wants to watch England play now
Also let’s not forget not many teams go to India and win.
Reply
#33
(01-25-2024, 02:06 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Whilst I laud Stokes for his brash and flamboyant innings that gave England a respectable (in the circumstances) total, I must call him on his reckless captaincy in the field. Playing Hartley as an opening bowler was a worthwhile tactic/risk but then to persist in keeping him on beyond his first couple lends a shade of arrogance to it. Is he looking for plaudits on his ''inspired'' choice in the hope that the bowler would get a prize scalp and we can all say what a genius piece of thinking that was?

As it is, he has handed a significant advantage to India by allowing Jaiswal to flourish. Sometimes it pays to go the tried and trusted route and let experience take the lead. Not expose a debutant to a 7 an over lashing.

True enough. I suppose you could be accused of using hindsight but it was entirely predictable. The team selection (England's), is looking rash. Using all the appeals is likely to be very costly.   It ain't over till it's over but I think we'll have an idea of the result by lunch tomorrow.
Reply
#34
It's a strange line-up that we've selected. One bowler that isn't a recognised spinner. I appreciate it's a typical Indian wicket, but I still think that's a huge gamble. Has there ever been an eleven with just one quickie / medium pacer?
Reply
#35
Was out most of today so only seen bit's but looking at the scorecard and reading this thread, snippets online well shock horror we seem undercooked

Most the batsmen get in, then get out in the 30's 40's, nobody stuck around and went big, then the bowlers are rusty letting India get off to a flyer

Probably played out as most of us feared/predicted in all honesty, hell of a place to go and try to get a result

Surprised by your comments Chesh on Key, for me he's done and conitnues to do a sterling job, no issues in the slightest from me about his leadership to date

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#36
Early days in this game at the moment. Far from done yet.
Reply
#37
I’ll be very surprised if India don’t win by an innings.
Reply
#38
Quite obvious Leach can only bowl in 4 over spells max and is still having some injury issues leaving Root to bowl the long spells.
Indians will love seeing Root getting knackered before batting not joined up thinking here by captain coach & Key’s!!..
Reply
#39
This will be over tomorrow. England won't get past 150 in their second innings.
Reply
#40
(01-26-2024, 12:06 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: This will be over tomorrow. England won't get past 150 in their second innings.

I did giggle the other day when someone on here was talking about how the pitch would play on day 5, I thought doubt we'll get to see.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: