How do explain school is important to young people anymore?
#81
(01-11-2024, 04:01 PM)Fido Wrote:
(01-11-2024, 03:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-11-2024, 03:30 PM)Fido Wrote:
(01-11-2024, 02:10 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-11-2024, 01:45 PM)Pontificator Wrote: By and large our schools mirror our society. There have always been discipline problems, dreadful schools, fantastic schools and to use that most ridiculous of phrases bog standard comps. Educationalists have over the decades constantly tried to reinvent the wheel, but basically the process has always been the same. Get the little bastards to sit down and listen and do their sums and hard writing. To do that you need their consent and the consent of the parents for the rewards and consequences that follow. School uniform, personal presentation and organisation  (pens pencils, exercise books, pe kit etc) politeness and respect should be the expectation of every head teacher. When they are wearing grey socks you have their consent.

Maths is better taught in practical contexts rather than abstract contexts for most people. That is why most people are turned off from doing maths.

And maths skills have become so dire for school leavers in correlation with prioritising rote-learning methods for maths over practical development of skills - especially in relation to implementation with other subjects (even ones adjacent to maths like physics). Maths is a toolbox with lots of tools, you don't teach someone the skill to use any other tool using a textbook and worksheets. This obsession with 19th century methods for teaching maths needs to stop, you're better off having them play darts.

And rules about grey socks are nothing but a power trip by jobsworths, nobody in history has every said that conforming to rules about sock colour has helped their education. And it's a rule that nobody gives a shit about except head teachers several degrees removed from the classroom and school governors that don't have any teaching qualifications because it's pointless.

Agree on the lesson bit but think the point is being missed on the “socks”. This encompasses all school rules, use of language in the classroom, how many times you can go for a piss and disrupt a lesson, handing in work on time.

The point is that socks are a misnomer for discipline. The point of discipline in schools to ensure a steady and sensible learning environment, socks have nothing to do with that. It's overreach, used by people to stifle any expression of individuality no matter how banal.

There are much more salient issues with discipline and none of them have the root cause of wanting to wear colourful socks. It just smacks of an easy cop-out under "zero tolerance" for people with more power than sense instead of allocating appropriate resources to deal with in-class discipline and learning and dealing with poor parenting, as well as going for easy targets (good kids who might want to express a bit of individuality because they're teenagers) instead of the kids that have actual behavioural issues. And kids are being given stupid punishments or being sent home for stupid "uniform checks" that check socks (one of my mates used to teach at one of those schools until very recently, and he said it was stupid) under the guise of "zero tolerance" by a jobsworth head.

There are more salient issues with regards to discipline but the answer I’m gleaning from this thread, unless I’m completely wrong, is that kids are all individuals so they should be able to rock up to school in whatever they want and do whatever suits them. Scarce resources mean there some kind of median or benchmark or the whole thing falls apart.

Only one person has said they disagree with school uniforms in general (and even then they used Scandinavia which has a dress code for kids to follow), I don't really care about uniforms as I've not looked into finding evidence one way or another to suggest they influence outcomes but including sock colour in the uniform code and then being zero tolerance about it is stupid and does nothing to actually deal with problems relating to discipline. Purely about keeping up appearances.
Reply
#82
(01-11-2024, 04:09 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-11-2024, 04:01 PM)Fido Wrote:
(01-11-2024, 03:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-11-2024, 03:30 PM)Fido Wrote:
(01-11-2024, 02:10 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Maths is better taught in practical contexts rather than abstract contexts for most people. That is why most people are turned off from doing maths.

And maths skills have become so dire for school leavers in correlation with prioritising rote-learning methods for maths over practical development of skills - especially in relation to implementation with other subjects (even ones adjacent to maths like physics). Maths is a toolbox with lots of tools, you don't teach someone the skill to use any other tool using a textbook and worksheets. This obsession with 19th century methods for teaching maths needs to stop, you're better off having them play darts.

And rules about grey socks are nothing but a power trip by jobsworths, nobody in history has every said that conforming to rules about sock colour has helped their education. And it's a rule that nobody gives a shit about except head teachers several degrees removed from the classroom and school governors that don't have any teaching qualifications because it's pointless.

Agree on the lesson bit but think the point is being missed on the “socks”. This encompasses all school rules, use of language in the classroom, how many times you can go for a piss and disrupt a lesson, handing in work on time.

The point is that socks are a misnomer for discipline. The point of discipline in schools to ensure a steady and sensible learning environment, socks have nothing to do with that. It's overreach, used by people to stifle any expression of individuality no matter how banal.

There are much more salient issues with discipline and none of them have the root cause of wanting to wear colourful socks. It just smacks of an easy cop-out under "zero tolerance" for people with more power than sense instead of allocating appropriate resources to deal with in-class discipline and learning and dealing with poor parenting, as well as going for easy targets (good kids who might want to express a bit of individuality because they're teenagers) instead of the kids that have actual behavioural issues. And kids are being given stupid punishments or being sent home for stupid "uniform checks" that check socks (one of my mates used to teach at one of those schools until very recently, and he said it was stupid) under the guise of "zero tolerance" by a jobsworth head.

There are more salient issues with regards to discipline but the answer I’m gleaning from this thread, unless I’m completely wrong, is that kids are all individuals so they should be able to rock up to school in whatever they want and do whatever suits them. Scarce resources mean there some kind of median or benchmark or the whole thing falls apart.

Only one person has said they disagree with school uniforms in general (and even then they used Scandinavia which has a dress code for kids to follow), I don't really care about uniforms as I've not looked into finding evidence one way or another to suggest they influence outcomes but including sock colour in the uniform code and then being zero tolerance about it is stupid and does nothing to actually deal with problems relating to discipline. Purely about keeping up appearances.

More important than sock colour being relevant to the struggle of encouraging young people's aspirations in school might be the ever increasing living wage minimum they will get regardless of qualifications they gain or don't gain in school. I wonder how this affects older young people as they join the workforce and whether in the long term it dents people's aspirations to work hard at school or take on extra learning in their early twenties.
Reply
#83
We're debating socks now, are we lads?
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#84
If this had been enforced more rigorously from 2010 we wouldn’t be in the mess we are now in
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#85
The only people debating socks are the ones who want to avoid the wider issue.
Reply
#86
(01-11-2024, 05:18 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The only people debating socks are the ones who want to avoid the wider issue.

Which is?
Reply
#87
That schools weren’t open when they couldn’t be and Proth is angry about that but had no actual answers as to what was supposed to happen

No wonder we ended up on socks
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#88
This is why you have grey/black socks - Its called a uniform coz it's err...  a uniform and there's always a few truculent kids and parents who are more interested in challenging the system than getting the fuck on with life. I am surprised that the great minds pontificating on here don't get the "consent" thing. Once you lose the grip on the clients it is not easily regained. The focus is on the little things as it were!

   
Reply
#89
I think everyone understands what it’s for. It’s who that suits and whether it is the best way to achieve that that is on question.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#90
(01-15-2024, 08:29 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I think everyone understands what it’s for. It’s who that suits and whether it is the best way to achieve that that is on question.

Clearly there's a lot more than nit picking on uniform, Sir/madam/miss, stand up when a member of staff walks in the room, walking quietly in corridors, lining up outside the room. walking in standing behind chairs before being asked to sit down, standing behind chairs quietly at the end of the lesson, so many things. You give up on these things because people/teachers think they are trivial, coz they can't be arsed. When I was at school the head teacher ruled and the staff and kids were all shit scared of her. There was a limit to how much kids tried it on. I never felt unsafe at school. There are some truly shit schools in Birmingham so I gather
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: