Boeing 737 Max
#11
I work for an Aerospace supplier and it is quite worrying the amount of counterfeit parts there are out there now.
Reply
#12
(01-06-2024, 02:15 PM)baggpuss Wrote: I work for an Aerospace supplier and it is quite worrying the amount of counterfeit parts there are out there now.

One of my clients is an aerospace supplier and it's quite worrying their general lack of competence.
Reply
#13
Boeing have a solid track record of using their muscle to bypass the usual testing and qualifying processes. The East Midlands crash in 1989 was ascribed to "pilot error" but the absence of high altitude testing for the uprated engines and the lack of simulator training to acquaint pilots with the new digital instrument panels in the 737-400 were huge contributing factors. 47 dead and 74 seriously injured.

It's pretty much universally acknowledged that Boeing should design a new "single-aisle" plane which is high enough off the ground to accommodate modern turbo-fan engines, instead of pissing about with the engine mountings and providing dodgy software to keep the flying characteristics as similar as possible to the older versions. Of course they would lose huge market share to Airbus and the new Chinese jets while they got their act together. So let's just keep the 60 year old design going. The fuselage is based on the venerable 707 and 727. Upgrades have been few and grudgingly delivered only when Airbus have got their noses ahead in the race for customers. I don't believe the rotten old 737 can ever be as safe or efficient as aircraft designed fully 25 years after it and continuously developed since.

As I said, I try very hard to avoid flying on these aircraft.
Reply
#14
(01-06-2024, 02:26 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-06-2024, 02:15 PM)baggpuss Wrote: I work for an Aerospace supplier and it is quite worrying the amount of counterfeit parts there are out there now.

One of my clients is an aerospace supplier and it's quite worrying their general lack of competence.

Maybe we know each other?  Big Grin
Reply
#15
(01-06-2024, 03:13 PM)baggpuss Wrote:
(01-06-2024, 02:26 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-06-2024, 02:15 PM)baggpuss Wrote: I work for an Aerospace supplier and it is quite worrying the amount of counterfeit parts there are out there now.

One of my clients is an aerospace supplier and it's quite worrying their general lack of competence.

Maybe we know each other?  Big Grin

Perhaps. My client wondered why their insurance had doubled in price, until I pointed out that an acquisition they'd recently made had massively increased their exposure...
Reply
#16
Video 
(01-06-2024, 11:58 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: The gift that keeps on giving. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-67899564

A window blowing out of an aeroplane is pretty unusual. Bearing in mind the 737 has been around for 55 years, with nearly 12,000 built, you'd hope they might by now know how to build, maintain and operate them safely.

Airbus every time, if I have the choice. Or maybe something from Brazil or Canada. In future I suppose Chinese planes will be competing strongly for sales. Beats me why airlines keep buying 737s.

You’ve forgotten about the airbus crashes I take it?

Such as this one

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I9gELPxPG8Q


Here's some more

https://www.1001crash.com/transport-page...story.html
Reply
#17
(01-06-2024, 03:48 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(01-06-2024, 11:58 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: The gift that keeps on giving. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-67899564

A window blowing out of an aeroplane is pretty unusual. Bearing in mind the 737 has been around for 55 years, with nearly 12,000 built, you'd hope they might by now know how to build, maintain and operate them safely.

Airbus every time, if I have the choice. Or maybe something from Brazil or Canada. In future I suppose Chinese planes will be competing strongly for sales. Beats me why airlines keep buying 737s.

You’ve forgotten about the airbus crashes I take it?

Such as this one

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I9gELPxPG8Q


Here's some more

https://www.1001crash.com/transport-page...story.html

You are a contrary fecker, though, aren't you? There are many reasons why planes crash. Boeing (in the modern era) have cornered the market in avoidable losses caused by their own greed/self-interest/over-confidence/sense of entitlement, however you want to describe it. That's FACT not opinion. We all love FACTs on this 'ere bored.
Reply
#18
(01-06-2024, 11:58 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: The gift that keeps on giving. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-67899564

A window blowing out of an aeroplane is pretty unusual. Bearing in mind the 737 has been around for 55 years, with nearly 12,000 built, you'd hope they might by now know how to build, maintain and operate them safely.

Airbus every time, if I have the choice. Or maybe something from Brazil or Canada. In future I suppose Chinese planes will be competing strongly for sales. Beats me why airlines keep buying 737s.

The 737 has been a hugely successful aircraft over the almost 60 years it has been in production. It built and expanded upon technology that was well-established in earlier 707 and 717 airframes, and Boeing quite-rightly trusted it. To date, I think over 11,000 have been sold, and it has even seen-off its own intended successor (the 757) in terms of longevity. 

Although I’m not an aerospace engineer (but like you a mechanical engineer nonetheless), I imagine it’s far easier to gain type-approval updating an existing airframe, than conceiving a new aircraft outright. Which - given the success and (it has to be said) relatively good safety record of the 737 - probably makes it a no-brainer to keep evolving what has been a brilliant cash-cow aircraft for Boeing. 

It is also a wonderful workhorse for short to mid-range journeys. It’s easy to maintain, and can be produced quickly to order; easily customisable to whatever sub-frame any particular airline wishes to procure. And very easy to fly.

Where I would agree with you is that (ironically, given its name) they have ‘maxed’ out the airframe. In trying to achieve greater efficiency for the MAX (as per industrial trends, and also their major rival doing it better with the 320-321), they needed to somehow fit CFM56 engines to the MAX; to give it the same efficiency gains and noise-reduction that Airbus were already achieving. This caused huge issues in its development as the 737 has VERY low ground clearance, and the CFM is a fat engine. They therefore had to mount the engines on pylons in front of the wing (rather than having them acircularly mounted beneath) which wasn’t an easy task. It was probably never designed for this and it was always a compromise. The MAX8 they lost two of a few years back probably weren’t helped by this, but overall that was down to extremely poor software engineering of the new anti-stall systems. But then, we don’t engineer product these days to achieve the best design; we are compelled to to achieve maximum shareholder gain. Modern life, eh. Smile

That being said, this failure seems purely down to rogue parts or poor maintenance; both perhaps even. It’s absolutely true what Bagpuss says in that the number of counterfeit (or non-compliant) parts in service is truly staggering. This is largely down to poor purchasing and QC however. Thank goodness for safety factors, or we would see this a lot more. 

Interestingly enough, though, regardless of your preference for flying in Airbus craft, Boeing planes will always ensure a smoother journey did you know. This is because the main structure of the wing remains a one-piece structure (very expensive to produce and mill to form), opposed to the typical Airbus wing which is largely fabricated. To offset this, Airbus airliners have to have a stiffer fuselage than Boeings, typically, which does make for a (slightly) bumpier ride. 

You can see it when you look out of the window (if it stays in place that is Smile ). But the Boeing - despite being yank - will always provide a smoother and softer flight.
Reply
#19
(01-06-2024, 05:19 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(01-06-2024, 03:48 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(01-06-2024, 11:58 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: The gift that keeps on giving. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-67899564

A window blowing out of an aeroplane is pretty unusual. Bearing in mind the 737 has been around for 55 years, with nearly 12,000 built, you'd hope they might by now know how to build, maintain and operate them safely.

Airbus every time, if I have the choice. Or maybe something from Brazil or Canada. In future I suppose Chinese planes will be competing strongly for sales. Beats me why airlines keep buying 737s.

You’ve forgotten about the airbus crashes I take it?

Such as this one

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I9gELPxPG8Q


Here's some more

https://www.1001crash.com/transport-page...story.html

You are a contrary fecker, though, aren't you? There are many reasons why planes crash. Boeing (in the modern era) have cornered the market in avoidable losses caused by their own greed/self-interest/over-confidence/sense of entitlement, however you want to describe it. That's FACT not opinion. We all love FACTs on this 'ere bored.

Nope. I just prefer to look at the whole picture, rather than focus on specifics. 

I guess for a true comparison, we should be looking at the average no of crashes for airbus & Boeing using the total number of planes.  Same again with av crashes per air miles flown.  I dare say that data on on the interweb somewhere.
Reply
#20
(01-06-2024, 07:37 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(01-06-2024, 11:58 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: The gift that keeps on giving. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-67899564

A window blowing out of an aeroplane is pretty unusual. Bearing in mind the 737 has been around for 55 years, with nearly 12,000 built, you'd hope they might by now know how to build, maintain and operate them safely.

Airbus every time, if I have the choice. Or maybe something from Brazil or Canada. In future I suppose Chinese planes will be competing strongly for sales. Beats me why airlines keep buying 737s.

The 737 has been a hugely successful aircraft over the almost 60 years it has been in production. It built and expanded upon technology that was well-established in earlier 707 and 717 airframes, and Boeing quite-rightly trusted it. To date, I think over 11,000 have been sold, and it has even seen-off its own intended successor (the 757) in terms of longevity. 

Although I’m not an aerospace engineer (but like you a mechanical engineer nonetheless), I imagine it’s far easier to gain type-approval updating an existing airframe, than conceiving a new aircraft outright. Which - given the success and (it has to be said) relatively good safety record of the 737 - probably makes it a no-brainer to keep evolving what has been a brilliant cash-cow aircraft for Boeing. 

It is also a wonderful workhorse for short to mid-range journeys. It’s easy to maintain, and can be produced quickly to order; easily customisable to whatever sub-frame any particular airline wishes to procure. And very easy to fly.

Where I would agree with you is that (ironically, given its name) they have ‘maxed’ out the airframe. In trying to achieve greater efficiency for the MAX (as per industrial trends, and also their major rival doing it better with the 320-321), they needed to somehow fit CFM56 engines to the MAX; to give it the same efficiency gains and noise-reduction that Airbus were already achieving. This caused huge issues in its development as the 737 has VERY low ground clearance, and the CFM is a fat engine. They therefore had to mount the engines on pylons in front of the wing (rather than having them acircularly mounted beneath) which wasn’t an easy task. It was probably never designed for this and it was always a compromise. The MAX8 they lost two of a few years back probably weren’t helped by this, but overall that was down to extremely poor software engineering of the new anti-stall systems. But then, we don’t engineer product these days to achieve the best design; we are compelled to to achieve maximum shareholder gain. Modern life, eh. Smile

That being said, this failure seems purely down to rogue parts or poor maintenance; both perhaps even. It’s absolutely true what Bagpuss says in that the number of counterfeit (or non-compliant) parts in service is truly staggering. This is largely down to poor purchasing and QC however. Thank goodness for safety factors, or we would see this a lot more. 

Interestingly enough, though, regardless of your preference for flying in Airbus craft, Boeing planes will always ensure a smoother journey did you know. This is because the main structure of the wing remains a one-piece structure (very expensive to produce and mill to form), opposed to the typical Airbus wing which is largely fabricated. To offset this, Airbus airliners have to have a stiffer fuselage than Boeings, typically, which does make for a (slightly) bumpier ride. 

You can see it when you look out of the window (if it stays in place that is Smile ). But the Boeing - despite being yank - will always provide a smoother and softer flight.

My one comment would be that this is a new aircraft therefore counterfeit parts would not be an issue. Repair and overall would be a different proposition and that falls under the airlines/owners responsibility.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: