Is any club in the Championship self sufficient?
#31
(01-05-2024, 09:12 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: There is an extra hurdle in the homegrown plan and that is the fact that the game itself allows bigger clubs to poach young players, from the lower leagues, with impunity.
If they had the integrity to plug this gap, then the sustainability complexion changes completely for the lower leagues, IMO. 
Sadly integrity and greed do not walk hand in hand so it won't happen.

Spot on.  A proper compensation structure with sell-on clauses is essential, although I’m not sure how it would stop foreign clubs being utilised to get around it.  It would need to be a UEFA and FIFA rule.
Reply
#32
(01-05-2024, 10:52 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(01-05-2024, 09:12 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: There is an extra hurdle in the homegrown plan and that is the fact that the game itself allows bigger clubs to poach young players, from the lower leagues, with impunity.
If they had the integrity to plug this gap, then the sustainability complexion changes completely for the lower leagues, IMO. 
Sadly integrity and greed do not walk hand in hand so it won't happen.

Spot on.  A proper compensation structure with sell-on clauses is essential, although I’m not sure how it would stop foreign clubs being utilised to get around it.  It would need to be a UEFA and FIFA rule.
Exactly right. The fact that any true football person or entity would want to "get around it" is what beggars belief.

There should be a minimum fee and a mandatory sell on clause. One decent deal could remove the spectre of extinction for a club in need, how can anyone not support that?
Reply
#33
(01-05-2024, 11:32 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-05-2024, 10:52 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(01-05-2024, 09:12 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: There is an extra hurdle in the homegrown plan and that is the fact that the game itself allows bigger clubs to poach young players, from the lower leagues, with impunity.
If they had the integrity to plug this gap, then the sustainability complexion changes completely for the lower leagues, IMO. 
Sadly integrity and greed do not walk hand in hand so it won't happen.

Spot on.  A proper compensation structure with sell-on clauses is essential, although I’m not sure how it would stop foreign clubs being utilised to get around it.  It would need to be a UEFA and FIFA rule.
Exactly right. The fact that any true football person or entity would want to "get around it" is what beggars belief.

There should be a minimum fee and a mandatory sell on clause. One decent deal could remove the spectre of extinction for a club in need, how can anyone not support that?

Well, there’s English clubs who can collude with a foreign club to take a youngster temporarily and buy them from the foreign club for a pre-arranged fee if the foreign clubs aren’t subject to the same rules, and there’s also foreign clubs who would buy youngsters for their own purposes if they could do so without paying the minimum fee or compensation. 

The only way to make this work is to make it something that applies to any player sold by an English club, regardless of where the buyer is, which might well be possible now that we are not part of the EU. 

There also needs to be protection built in for clubs poaching Academy players for no fee before they are old enough to sign a professional contract at 17.  This loophole completely shafts the club which has developed the young player, and I know for a fact that scouts from the big clubs “encourage” star players from clubs like ours who get into the England age group squads not to sign a pro contract at 17 as they can then move for nothing.  There had to be a way to properly tie an Under17 academy player into an appropriate contract.   Sadly there aren’t enough players and parents like Bellingham who insisted on signing a contract on his 17th birthday so that Blues would get £10m to recognise their contribution to his development. Many others would have pocketed that as a signing-on fee.
Reply
#34
The answer is probably not. Rotherham maybe but they don't stick around for long.

Coventry possibly but they've clearly gone to another level under King.

Cash Losses are key, moreso than Profit and Loss because the latter includes various Non Cash Items. For FFP it is the former ie P&L, for Solvency it is the latter.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: