Takeover
(12-22-2023, 08:59 AM)Mr vertical Wrote:
(12-22-2023, 08:47 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(12-21-2023, 11:17 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-21-2023, 10:47 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: All these financial problems are directly the fault of Lai.
We should always be a buying / selling club, remembering most championship clubs lose £25m a season we are no different. But we don't have an owner to support us, just a bunch of thieves.
We have not sold players when their value has increased for years. Bar Pereira (which was a suspect sale) and Dara who was more of a forced sale
All in all we have been in mess since the day we were sold.
We have to accept players coming and going to balance the books is normal.
Investment in good management and scouting in our situation has to be the priority.

This was the problem for 3 years before Lai and his 999 investors come along. They just kept the status quo, then tipped their grubby mitts in the pot when the world got tough. 

I struggle to get too mad. I would have probably done the same if I owned a business I know nothing about, have no feelings for, or allegiance too. 

Sooner they are away from the club the better, let's just hope we get good 'ens next time.
Those 2 (underpriced) sales are an example of what is wrong with our club. They are a symptom but not the cause. I don't think Lai intended to plunder the coffers. He was simply sold a dud. JP did nothing pro-active in the years before the sale, he simply tried to keep the value of the club as high as he could without further investment. Lai was advised by Peace to bring in the incompetent Williams and his mate.  Probably told Pulis does not get anyone relegated, ever. Then Lai watched as Pulis burned through the cash on the likes of Greg and Burke. Our new owners are a disaster for a club of our size but they are not the entire problem. We have been drifting aimlessly for a good few years.

I'm inclined to agree with this. The money wasted on just those two could have been to much better use. Hopefully we'll be able to look back on this decade of decline from a better standpoint soon.

The single biggest factor in our demise was the failure to replace Ashworth adequately. We were riding high and had excellent people in all the key positions. The cheap route of Burton and Garlick destabilised everything and we lost our competitive advantage. Allowing McDonut free rein to destroy everything and then needing the Pulis sticking plaster brought everything crashing down.

Who knows how motivated to sell Peace would have become had Ashworth remained and we continued to progress, who knows what a higher league position instead of scrapping our way to 15th under Pulis would have attracted as a buyer. The day we decided Garlick could step up started the ball rolling for our decline. Sure we had plenty of chances to course correct along the way, but we seemingly decided to ignore red flag after red flag until we finally just got used to them.
Reply
(12-22-2023, 01:18 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-22-2023, 08:59 AM)Mr vertical Wrote:
(12-22-2023, 08:47 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(12-21-2023, 11:17 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-21-2023, 10:47 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: All these financial problems are directly the fault of Lai.
We should always be a buying / selling club, remembering most championship clubs lose £25m a season we are no different. But we don't have an owner to support us, just a bunch of thieves.
We have not sold players when their value has increased for years. Bar Pereira (which was a suspect sale) and Dara who was more of a forced sale
All in all we have been in mess since the day we were sold.
We have to accept players coming and going to balance the books is normal.
Investment in good management and scouting in our situation has to be the priority.

This was the problem for 3 years before Lai and his 999 investors come along. They just kept the status quo, then tipped their grubby mitts in the pot when the world got tough. 

I struggle to get too mad. I would have probably done the same if I owned a business I know nothing about, have no feelings for, or allegiance too. 

Sooner they are away from the club the better, let's just hope we get good 'ens next time.
Those 2 (underpriced) sales are an example of what is wrong with our club. They are a symptom but not the cause. I don't think Lai intended to plunder the coffers. He was simply sold a dud. JP did nothing pro-active in the years before the sale, he simply tried to keep the value of the club as high as he could without further investment. Lai was advised by Peace to bring in the incompetent Williams and his mate.  Probably told Pulis does not get anyone relegated, ever. Then Lai watched as Pulis burned through the cash on the likes of Greg and Burke. Our new owners are a disaster for a club of our size but they are not the entire problem. We have been drifting aimlessly for a good few years.

I'm inclined to agree with this. The money wasted on just those two could have been to much better use. Hopefully we'll be able to look back on this decade of decline from a better standpoint soon.

The single biggest factor in our demise was the failure to replace Ashworth adequately. We were riding high and had excellent people in all the key positions. The cheap route of Burton and Garlick destabilised everything and we lost our competitive advantage. Allowing McDonut free rein to destroy everything and then needing the Pulis sticking plaster brought everything crashing down.

Who knows how motivated to sell Peace would have become had Ashworth remained and we continued to progress, who knows what a higher league position instead of scrapping our way to 15th under Pulis would have attracted as a buyer. The day we decided Garlick could step up started the ball rolling for our decline. Sure we had plenty of chances to course correct along the way, but we seemingly decided to ignore red flag after red flag until we finally just got used to them.

JRP knew we were over-achieving. He saw us as a mid-table Champ club (or words to that effect) and rebuilding the Halfords was financial suicide. I think he identified our value, which he achieved in the sale to Lai. To go to the "next level" would have required massive investment, which he wouldn't have seen in his financial return.
Reply
As Fulham keeps kindly pointing out, with no hint of condescension or arrogance, a lot of this is beyond plebs like me but, what I glean from his expert analysis is that, even if our new owner is the richest bloke on the planet, it is irrelevant, as FFP is going to screw us anyway and the fire sale is inevitable. We may as well, therefore, end this thread and come back in February.

What's everybody having for tea.
Reply
(12-22-2023, 03:47 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: As Fulham keeps kindly pointing out, with no hint of condescension or arrogance, a lot of this is beyond plebs like me but, what I glean from his expert analysis is that, even if our new owner is the richest bloke on the planet, it is irrelevant, as FFP is going to screw us anyway and the fire sale is inevitable. We may as well, therefore, end this thread and come back in February.

What's everybody having for tea.

Sausage, beans and chips.  The sausage knows as much as the financial spurts on here about FFP worries.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
(12-22-2023, 03:47 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: As Fulham keeps kindly pointing out, with no hint of condescension or arrogance, a lot of this is beyond plebs like me but, what I glean from his expert analysis is that, even if our new owner is the richest bloke on the planet, it is irrelevant, as FFP is going to screw us anyway and the fire sale is inevitable. We may as well, therefore, end this thread and come back in February.

What's everybody having for tea.

Using applied Reminomics.
We just need to get money coming in before we spend.
Renaming the ground, New sponsorship, etc
This shuffling of funds methods have been used in the past by others to offset FFP rules.
Merry Christmas
Reply
(12-22-2023, 03:47 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: As Fulham keeps kindly pointing out, with no hint of condescension or arrogance, a lot of this is beyond plebs like me but, what I glean from his expert analysis is that, even if our new owner is the richest bloke on the planet, it is irrelevant, as FFP is going to screw us anyway and the fire sale is inevitable. We may as well, therefore, end this thread and come back in February.

What's everybody having for tea.

Chicken drumsticks with corn on the cob.
Reply
(12-22-2023, 03:47 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: As Fulham keeps kindly pointing out, with no hint of condescension or arrogance, a lot of this is beyond plebs like me but, what I glean from his expert analysis is that, even if our new owner is the richest bloke on the planet, it is irrelevant, as FFP is going to screw us anyway and the fire sale is inevitable. We may as well, therefore, end this thread and come back in February.

What's everybody having for tea.

So if you're a financially stable club in this division is there any advantage in having a mega rich owner?  I guess they can spend in other areas like training facilities,  the ground etc
Reply
(12-22-2023, 08:05 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(12-22-2023, 03:47 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: As Fulham keeps kindly pointing out, with no hint of condescension or arrogance, a lot of this is beyond plebs like me but, what I glean from his expert analysis is that, even if our new owner is the richest bloke on the planet, it is irrelevant, as FFP is going to screw us anyway and the fire sale is inevitable. We may as well, therefore, end this thread and come back in February.

What's everybody having for tea.

So if you're a financially stable club in this division is there any advantage in having a mega rich owner?  I guess they can spend in other areas like training facilities,  the ground etc

You can buy promotion at the risk of huge FFP sanctions (see FOSUN/Mendes/Wo1ve5 in 2017/18). Do often find it surprising Coates family at Sjoke haven't gone down this route last couple of years.
Reply
(12-22-2023, 08:45 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(12-22-2023, 08:05 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(12-22-2023, 03:47 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: As Fulham keeps kindly pointing out, with no hint of condescension or arrogance, a lot of this is beyond plebs like me but, what I glean from his expert analysis is that, even if our new owner is the richest bloke on the planet, it is irrelevant, as FFP is going to screw us anyway and the fire sale is inevitable. We may as well, therefore, end this thread and come back in February.

What's everybody having for tea.

So if you're a financially stable club in this division is there any advantage in having a mega rich owner?  I guess they can spend in other areas like training facilities,  the ground etc

You can buy promotion at the risk of huge FFP sanctions (see FOSUN/Mendes/Wo1ve5 in 2017/18). Do often find it surprising Coates family at Sjoke haven't gone down this route last couple of years.

How did the dings get away with it? Was it investigated at all?
Reply
(12-22-2023, 08:56 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(12-22-2023, 08:45 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(12-22-2023, 08:05 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(12-22-2023, 03:47 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: As Fulham keeps kindly pointing out, with no hint of condescension or arrogance, a lot of this is beyond plebs like me but, what I glean from his expert analysis is that, even if our new owner is the richest bloke on the planet, it is irrelevant, as FFP is going to screw us anyway and the fire sale is inevitable. We may as well, therefore, end this thread and come back in February.

What's everybody having for tea.

So if you're a financially stable club in this division is there any advantage in having a mega rich owner?  I guess they can spend in other areas like training facilities,  the ground etc

You can buy promotion at the risk of huge FFP sanctions (see FOSUN/Mendes/Wo1ve5 in 2017/18). Do often find it surprising Coates family at Sjoke haven't gone down this route last couple of years.

How did the dings get away with it? Was it investigated at all?

They won the league so they were no longer under the jurisdiction of the EFL.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 9 Guest(s)