Rotherham match fred
(12-13-2023, 10:39 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-13-2023, 10:23 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: You're looking for the exact thing we build around not providing Lurker. To you it's a problem, to me it's a huge asset.

Lots of respect for your posts by the way. Just don't agree with you here.

We are a solid 5th for a reason. If we get promoted, it will be because of the above, it won't have been a hindrance

No I am a massive advocate of a coach being flexible with his structure and approach. Pep and Arteta are masters at it, and CC is deffo cut from the same cloth, and its winning us games. 

I still want to see us be more consistent with our patterns and interchange within any set structure. We have, for quite a number of years had an issues with running power and ability to break lines, so i think, as Birdy rightly points out it is a squad balance issue. Not that the players we have are bad by the way. 

I think it shows with us not having Wallace and Phillips, both strong, direct runner's who stretch the game instinctively, we've struggled, and the other players don't naturally pick up that mantle as its not natural to them (lack of a set identity). This needs to be addressed both in training and as the squad evolves.

Squad balance holds some truth there. I thought he addressed all you have said there at half time last night to the maximum of what is at his disposal. I essentially think what you are right about here is just the reality of what we have to work with. Not much else.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
Corbs is playing the hand he's been dealt exceptionally well.

There are shades of Megson in that we aren't free flowing or fantastic to watch at times because we simply don't have to players to be, but we are organised, committed and capable of nicking a goal and that's often enough in this league.
Reply
(12-13-2023, 10:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Dabbling in football talk for once Wink

There is a clear style of play and tactics from CC. You will never get consistency of performance in this league, games come too frequently, injuries hamper and in our case seriously hamper our ability to be potent going forward as we are at nullifying teams defensively. Also a real bug bear of mine is when we fail to recognise that for everything we are trying to do, other teams are trying to stop us. We are a solid play-off position squad with a manager who is doing exceptionally well to navigate the serious injuries we are having and still turn out results.

Some games it take going to be a grind, some days it’s going to boring, some games it’s going to be exciting and some games you’re going to ride your luck… twas ever thus in the Championship and particularly when you cannot any longer like we have done previously bought the league/promotion.

Oh just to be inevitably and needlessly antagonistic XG is the new bullshit possession stat, another will come along shortly to replace it.

Not wrong.

Like all stats, it has it's place in analysis, but used by itself it means absolutely nothing, like possession.
Reply
(12-13-2023, 10:04 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-13-2023, 09:51 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Lurker it's rare, but honestly, I think you're talking absolute rubbish for once.

Stats only tell half the story, again, a game of football isn't one team Vs a bunch of NPC's like playing a game of FIFA. Rotherham were also playing football too. We are defensively solid, that is, and always has been CC's biggest concern. He tempered Bielsa by being like it, making his Leeds team exceptional. Huddersfield never looked great, but won, relentlessly.

I'll say it over, and over again. If you're defensively solid, it is almost impossible to not be at least moderately successful. We are, sometimes our attacking play lacks fluidity, being able to build a regular attack helps, as it did when we could.

I'm just not understanding the amount of criticism CC gets by fans, I genuinely think he is going to be second only to Gary Megson by the time he leaves here, no doubt. If he gets us up, he'll keep us up for sure.

Regarding our defense - I completely agree. We are fantastically drilled and it gives us a platform to get results. 

Regarding CC - yet again, I agree. He's doing a great job and as I said earlier in the thread, the thing that makes me have faith in him and his coaching is more often than not, when I hear his views on the game it is inline with mine. 

BUT - Just because we get a result(s), it doesn't mean the performance was good. Very often at the beginning of the season the performance has been much worse than the result, and we were getting lucky as our strike rate in terms of goals/xG was really high. Once this fell away we had to change the balance. This was when Mowatt/Grady came in and our all round play changed . we started carrying and passing the ball much more progressively, we played more key passes, we starting having more shot creating actions. But in the last few games, those metrics have fell away once more. And I think its down to the change in shape, Mowatt's stats have fell through the floor, as have Furlongs, both of whom were amongst our most progressive passers/receivers in those transitional areas.

But back to 'identity', I stick by we don't have one in possession. We are wining games through having good individuals and strong defense.

Our identity is being organised out of possession, pressing the opponent and then trying to hit teams on the break. When that's not on we try and hold possession and manoeuvre the opposition to try and create a chance. That doesn't always happen because we don't have the talent available. 

I genuinely can see an identity, a style, and a group of players that are well drilled and have bought into what the coach wants from them. No, it doesn't always work, but that's football. 

Also, we're not getting the basics right? I disagree, strongly. I'm not sure where that line of thought comes from! The basics of management, as a fan who knows little about this, is surely to build from the back, especially when your hands are tied with squad quality and injuries, make sure you're difficult to beat and to limit the opposition by being well drilled and organised. All of which we are currently doing.

In terms of attacking, we just don't have the players to attack, and being defensively solid (playing negatively and cautiously to some) is a must. If that means instructing our full backs not to aggressively overlap, and lose attacking momentum, so be it. We don't have the quality to consistently unlock opposition defences like we did under Mowbray or RDM promotion seasons. We just do not have the options. What we do have is a coach who knows how to drill a team so well we can go into a game with the attitude of 'knowing' we'll keep a clean sheet, so we only need to nick a goal. We don't have the luxury of having the likes of Super Kev, Dorrans, Koumas, Gera and so on, to drag us to a win by outscoring the opposition. 

However, we do try and play football. We try and be patient and carve open teams, but we do give the ball away cheaply, at times. Because we're not good enough to play like that - but at some point you have to try and make things happen. You have to try and play a risky pass that has a high chance of being intercepted but a high reward in terms of good attacking positions.

That's just where we are as a team. It's not exciting to watch. It's not entertaining on the eye, but I'm more than pleased with how we're cutting our cloth accordingly with the options we have.

We're a very good team as it stands (I genuinely believe our squad is average, (dare I say below average with the current injury list and threadbare options?) and we're in the position we are now because of CC's quality as an excellent coach), and once (touch wood) we get the like of Dike back to full fitness, I'm sure teams will not want to play us. If we're lucky enough to make the play offs, there's certainly teams that will want to avoid us.
Reply
(12-13-2023, 10:57 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(12-13-2023, 10:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Dabbling in football talk for once Wink

There is a clear style of play and tactics from CC. You will never get consistency of performance in this league, games come too frequently, injuries hamper and in our case seriously hamper our ability to be potent going forward as we are at nullifying teams defensively. Also a real bug bear of mine is when we fail to recognise that for everything we are trying to do, other teams are trying to stop us. We are a solid play-off position squad with a manager who is doing exceptionally well to navigate the serious injuries we are having and still turn out results.

Some games it take going to be a grind, some days it’s going to boring, some games it’s going to be exciting and some games you’re going to ride your luck… twas ever thus in the Championship and particularly when you cannot any longer like we have done previously bought the league/promotion.

Oh just to be inevitably and needlessly antagonistic XG is the new bullshit possession stat, another will come along shortly to replace it.

Not wrong.

Like all stats, it has it's place in analysis, but used by itself it means absolutely nothing, like possession.

Welcome to the footy chat Dekka, nice to have you  Big Grin You're completely rigth in what you are saying, I am not talking about "performance" as that is a combination of all aspects of the game. I am talking about our lack of consistency in our 'in possession' patterns of play and what we try and do. I love our ability to grind out results and defend like dogs, all for it. 

Regarding xG, its a fantastic stat. It shows if you are being clinical or not, and for the most part this year we have been. Excessively so in fact. Which again points towards us being efficient and earning our own bit of fortune. But that only goes so far, eventually you have to create better standards of chances, more consistently, through repeatable patterns of play, regardless of the formation or "tactics".  

FWIW, completely agree with it being used in isolation, as it doesn't give any context. That why I always try and bring in as many metric as possible.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
I think those that defend Carlos to the hilt and jump all over anyone who dares to criticise him, are completely missing his ethos. The bloke is incredibly self critical and laser focussed on continual improvement.
Therefore, I reckon anything said on here criticising his tactics, subs, team selection etc. pales into insignificance compared to the grilling he gives himself, especially after a poor performance or a defeat. That's why he's so good. It's also why he'll get better.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: