Rotherham match fred
(12-13-2023, 08:53 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-13-2023, 08:21 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(12-13-2023, 08:14 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Two things spring to mind reading this:
Molumby, how about giving him time to get up to speed, he hasn't been a regular in this team for months.
Swift, had an absolute stinker last Saturday and maybe Carlos was right to drop him.
Here's another, it was a great away win at a tricky place to go. So what if the first half was dull when we nullified any threat and put two goals away in the 2nd. Bradford (under SGM) was one of the best away days in memory but for 90 minutes it was like watching paint dry. 46 games, they won't all be classics.

Spot on, this. 

For me, between this and the Cardiff away win, is as close to the perfect blue print to play away from home as you can reasonably expect. We were well organised, defensively solid, gave no clear cut chances to the opposition and took our chances when they came. 

Do people really expect us to go away from home and play free flowing gung ho football, and win every game 5-0? I suspect no one is that deluded, but the way folk carry on, that's how they come across.
Don't think anyone truly expects that, but the match thread is about observation, not expectation, anyway. The match thread was negative and dull because the match was, that's perfectly natural to me.
Once we scored, the relief kicked in and the mood changed, which is, I can pretty much guarantee, having been to dozens of away games like this, was what happened in the ground. Big Grin
It's all about opinions. I think a lot of us see the games in different eyes. I thought BTA did OK for one. Held the ball up pretty well for a lot of the time, was given very little to feed on, and, despite not being 100% fit, worked his knackers off again. Also, when Jed came ,immediately he showed us why he is so important to us. Sometimes we only realise a players importance when they are not playing, which applies to OK too.
Reply
(12-13-2023, 08:21 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(12-13-2023, 08:14 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Two things spring to mind reading this:
Molumby, how about giving him time to get up to speed, he hasn't been a regular in this team for months.
Swift, had an absolute stinker last Saturday and maybe Carlos was right to drop him.
Here's another, it was a great away win at a tricky place to go. So what if the first half was dull when we nullified any threat and put two goals away in the 2nd. Bradford (under SGM) was one of the best away days in memory but for 90 minutes it was like watching paint dry. 46 games, they won't all be classics.

Spot on, this. 

For me, between this and the Cardiff away win, is as close to the perfect blue print to play away from home as you can reasonably expect. We were well organised, defensively solid, gave no clear cut chances to the opposition and took our chances when they came. 

Do people really expect us to go away from home and play free flowing gung ho football, and win every game 5-0? I suspect no one is that deluded, but the way folk carry on, that's how they come across.

Josh - No I don't expect all those things mate, because football isn't that simple. But, I do expect the basics to be done correctly more often than not, and this is where we let ourselves down. regardless of tactics and/or formations, parts of the game are just standard. Defensive discipline, communication, movement off the ball, creating overloads; these are entry level things, and for some reason, all too often, we don't do them, and it takes half time or a break in play and CC getting hold of them for us to start.

I always harp on about identity, and that's what we are still lacking. Even though we are doing very well.

(12-13-2023, 08:25 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Was driving home from Reading last night. And reading through this thread is just depressing. I honestly thought we'd lost (checked this before the score).

An away win, a clean sheet against a team that scored in every home game, a team with a new manager fighting for survival while we have an injury crisis, unable to field a settled team. That can only be good, no other way to spin it.


Birdy - Result wise? Absolutely. No doubt it was a well fought win in challenging circumstances, but its doesn't mean we should ignore the poor performance and lack of identity. The stats support how poor a display it was given our relative domination. I will do a "Stats and Ratings" fred later. Lets put it this way, we scored 2 on an xG of 0.5, one was a poor shot and deflection and one was a screamer. If those low odds outcomes hadn't materialised the mood would be very different.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
We clearly looked to slow the game down after the first, to be fair, so not sure using a low xG as a stick to beat the team with last night is particularly fair.
Reply
BTA did well considering he was doubled up on a lot of the time. The stats may well show how poor we were first half, but you have to credit the opposition for their efforts too. They didn’t fall into our trap and wouldn’t press in the way we wanted them to, also made endless tackles. But they were toothless up top, thankfully.
In the form of his life.
Reply
(12-13-2023, 09:24 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-13-2023, 08:21 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(12-13-2023, 08:14 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Two things spring to mind reading this:
Molumby, how about giving him time to get up to speed, he hasn't been a regular in this team for months.
Swift, had an absolute stinker last Saturday and maybe Carlos was right to drop him.
Here's another, it was a great away win at a tricky place to go. So what if the first half was dull when we nullified any threat and put two goals away in the 2nd. Bradford (under SGM) was one of the best away days in memory but for 90 minutes it was like watching paint dry. 46 games, they won't all be classics.

Spot on, this. 

For me, between this and the Cardiff away win, is as close to the perfect blue print to play away from home as you can reasonably expect. We were well organised, defensively solid, gave no clear cut chances to the opposition and took our chances when they came. 

Do people really expect us to go away from home and play free flowing gung ho football, and win every game 5-0? I suspect no one is that deluded, but the way folk carry on, that's how they come across.

Josh - No I don't expect all those things mate, because football isn't that simple. But, I do expect the basics to be done correctly more often than not, and this is where we let ourselves down. regardless of tactics and/or formations, parts of the game are just standard. Defensive discipline, communication, movement off the ball, creating overloads; these are entry level things, and for some reason, all too often, we don't do them, and it takes half time or a break in play and CC getting hold of them for us to start.

I always harp on about identity, and that's what we are still lacking. Even though we are doing very well.

(12-13-2023, 08:25 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Was driving home from Reading last night. And reading through this thread is just depressing. I honestly thought we'd lost (checked this before the score).

An away win, a clean sheet against a team that scored in every home game, a team with a new manager fighting for survival while we have an injury crisis, unable to field a settled team. That can only be good, no other way to spin it.


Birdy - Result wise? Absolutely. No doubt it was a well fought win in challenging circumstances, but its doesn't mean we should ignore the poor performance and lack of identity. The stats support how poor a display it was given our relative domination. I will do a "Stats and Ratings" fred later. Let’s put it this way, we scored 2 on an xG of 0.5, one was a poor shot and deflection and one was a screamer. If those low odds outcomes hadn't materialised the mood would be very different.

Come on. I think we have a very clear identity under Carlos. We’ve kept the most clean sheets in the division and sit comfortably in the play off places.
Reply
Lurker it's rare, but honestly, I think you're talking absolute rubbish for once.

Stats only tell half the story, again, a game of football isn't one team Vs a bunch of NPC's like playing a game of FIFA. Rotherham were also playing football too. We are defensively solid, that is, and always has been CC's biggest concern. He tempered Bielsa by being like it, making his Leeds team exceptional. Huddersfield never looked great, but won, relentlessly.

I'll say it over, and over again. If you're defensively solid, it is almost impossible to not be at least moderately successful. We are, sometimes our attacking play lacks fluidity, being able to build a regular attack helps, as it did when we could.

I'm just not understanding the amount of criticism CC gets by fans, I genuinely think he is going to be second only to Gary Megson by the time he leaves here, no doubt. If he gets us up, he'll keep us up for sure.
Reply
(12-13-2023, 09:32 AM)Dumbo Wrote: Come on. I think we have a very clear identity under Carlos. We’ve kept the most clean sheets in the division and sit comfortably in the play off places.

Defensively maybe, not in possession.

We are not an effective possession based team as we don't have the technical ability in tight areas.

We set up to be a counter attacking team, and more often than not when we play well its when this clicks, but as said, far too often our players are too static, don't break lines or the press and our player on the ball has no out ball.

We are not a direct team as we don't (currently) have a target man or real, devastating pace.

But this is in itself testament to the job CC and some of the more reliable members of the squad have/are doing that we drag our selves through games. I am sure, and I hope he sees this issue and each window tries to move us towards a style of play, in possession which underpins his various tactical approaches.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
That post makes more sense Lurker.

However, you've pointed out why we're like it. I said before a lot, this squad has no set style, nothing blends properly, it's tantamount to his coaching and tactical skill CC has got them to be pretty successful as a team. And it is a bit of a inconsistent mess, but so is the squad as a whole.

We defend well, that to me means very little criticism.

Someone call me Tony Pulis at your convenience.
Reply
(12-13-2023, 09:51 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Lurker it's rare, but honestly, I think you're talking absolute rubbish for once.

Stats only tell half the story, again, a game of football isn't one team Vs a bunch of NPC's like playing a game of FIFA. Rotherham were also playing football too. We are defensively solid, that is, and always has been CC's biggest concern. He tempered Bielsa by being like it, making his Leeds team exceptional. Huddersfield never looked great, but won, relentlessly.

I'll say it over, and over again. If you're defensively solid, it is almost impossible to not be at least moderately successful. We are, sometimes our attacking play lacks fluidity, being able to build a regular attack helps, as it did when we could.

I'm just not understanding the amount of criticism CC gets by fans, I genuinely think he is going to be second only to Gary Megson by the time he leaves here, no doubt. If he gets us up, he'll keep us up for sure.

Regarding our defense - I completely agree. We are fantastically drilled and it gives us a platform to get results. 

Regarding CC - yet again, I agree. He's doing a great job and as I said earlier in the thread, the thing that makes me have faith in him and his coaching is more often than not, when I hear his views on the game it is inline with mine. 

BUT - Just because we get a result(s), it doesn't mean the performance was good. Very often at the beginning of the season the performance has been much worse than the result, and we were getting lucky as our strike rate in terms of goals/xG was really high. Once this fell away we had to change the balance. This was when Mowatt/Grady came in and our all round play changed . we started carrying and passing the ball much more progressively, we played more key passes, we starting having more shot creating actions. But in the last few games, those metrics have fell away once more. And I think its down to the change in shape, Mowatt's stats have fell through the floor, as have Furlongs, both of whom were amongst our most progressive passers/receivers in those transitional areas.

But back to 'identity', I stick by we don't have one in possession. We are wining games through having good individuals and strong defense.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
Agree with Birdman on this one. Was at the game and whilst it might not have been easy on the eye, it was exactly the performance you need at Rotherham on a Tuesday night in December. How often do you ever watch Albion away and feel relaxed more or less throughout as to where the 3 points are headed?
Someone could have been killed
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: